Link

Social

Embed

Disable autoplay on embedded content?

Download

Download
Download Transcript

[Call to Order: Board President ]

[00:00:15]

WELCOME, EVERYONE. AT THIS TIME, I ASK THAT. EVERYONE, PLEASE MUTE YOUR DEVICE UNTIL CALLED UPON TO AVOID INTERRUPTIONS. I CALL TO ORDER THIS BOARD OF BUSINESS MEETING OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION OF HARFORD COUNTY ON JULY 15TH, 2024 AT 6:03 P.M. THIS BUSINESS MEETING WILL BE CONDUCTED IN A HYBRID FASHION. MISS ROLLO, PLEASE TAKE A ROLL CALL. MISS ALVAREZ. PRESENT.

MISS BRUCE. HERE. MISS COKER. HERE. DOCTOR. MUELLER. PRESENT. MISS KEY HERE. MISS PERRY. HERE.

MR. SEWELL. HERE. MISS STRAUSS HERE. VICE PRESIDENT. HAHN VICE PRESIDENT IS ABSENT THIS EVENING. PRESIDENT CLINTON HERE. SUPERINTENDENT WILSON. HERE. THIS COMPLETES THE ROLL CALL.

THANK YOU, MISS HAHN IS CURRENTLY ABSENT. SHE SAID THAT SHE MAY PHONE IN, SO IF SHE DOES, COULD YOU PLEASE LET THE BOARD KNOW? AND WITH MISS HAHN ABSENT, I HAVE ASKED OUR BRAND NEW STUDENT BOARD MEMBER TO FILL IN ON SOME OF THE RESPONSIBILITIES AS VICE PRESIDENT TONIGHT. SO JUST THROWING HER RIGHT IN THE MIX, MISS, COULD COULD YOU PLEASE READ THE STATEMENT THAT IN THE PROCESS WHICH WE WILL FOLLOW, THIS EVENING, THE FOLLOWING PROCESS WILL BE USED THIS EVENING. BOARD MEMBERS AND STAFF WILL MUTE THEIR DEVICE UNTIL CALLED UPON. BOARD MEMBERS, PLEASE HOLD ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS UNTIL THE END OF EACH PRESENTATION. FOLLOWING THE PRESENTATION, DOCTOR BOYNTON WILL CALL ON EACH BOARD MEMBER FOR COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS. BOARD MEMBERS AND STAFF MEMBERS SHOULD RESTATE THEIR NAME BEFORE SPEAKING. DOCTOR BOLTON WILL RESPOND TO QUESTIONS OR CALL ON APPROPRIATE STAFF MEMBERS TO DO SO. WHEN A ROLL CALL IS TAKEN FOR A MOTION, I ASK THAT YOU PLEASE REPLY WITH A YES OR A NO.

[Adoption of Agenda ]

BOARD MEMBERS, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. BOARD MEMBERS, YOU HAVE THE AGENDA BEFORE YOU, IN JUST A MOMENT, I'M GOING TO ASK FOR A MOTION AND A SECOND TO ADOPT THE AGENDA. BUT GIVEN THE FACT THAT WE HAVE SO MANY PUBLIC SPEAKERS, THIS EVENING. YES, MA'AM. I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION THAT WE TABLE THE PRESENTATION ON THE 2026 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU.

THAT'S EXACTLY WHERE I WAS GOING. SO WITH THAT IN MIND, IS THERE A SECOND? I SECOND THE MOTION. THANK YOU. ALL IN FAVOR, PLEASE SAY YES. YES YES, YES. THANK YOU. THE MOTION IS PASSED.

SO BOARD MEMBERS, YOU HAVE THE REVISED AGENDA BEFORE YOU DO. I HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND TO ADOPT THE REVISED AGENDA. I MOVE TO ADOPT THE REVISED AGENDA. THANK YOU ALL. AND I'LL SECOND.

THANK YOU ALL IN FAVOR, PLEASE SAY YES. YES, YES, YES. IF THERE ARE ANY OPPOSED, PLEASE SAY NO.

THANK YOU. THE MOTION PASSES. PLEASE LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS. ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. ALL RIGHT. WE'RE GOING TO START THIS

[A. Swearing In Ceremony: 2024-2025 Student Board Member, Sasha Pazoki, Aberdeen High School]

EVENING WITH SOMETHING VERY SPECIAL. AS I MENTIONED, OUR NEW STUDENT MEMBER IS JOINING US FOR THE FIRST TIME FOR A ONE YEAR TERM. AND I'D LIKE TO WELCOME, DOCTOR BALSON AND OUR NEW STUDENT MEMBER, SASHA PASZKOWSKI, TO THE FRONT FOR HER SWEARING IN. OH, I'M SORRY. AND CINDY MUMBY. ONE MINUTE. BEGINS THE SWEARING IN PART, AND WE'LL BRING YOU UP TO. ALL RIGHT. WELL YOU HAVE A GREAT CROWD THAT TURNED OUT TO SEE FANTASTIC. ALL RIGHT, SO I'M GOING TO SAY A LITTLE BIT ABOUT YOU. FIRST WE HAVE SOME SOME TALKING POINTS HERE. AND THEN WE'LL GET INTO THE SWEARING IN. SO I'D LIKE TO INTRODUCE SASHA. MANY OF YOU HAVE SEEN HER BEFORE. SHE'S A SENIOR AT THE SCIENCE AND MATHEMATICS ACADEMY AT ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL. SHE WILL SERVE AS A 2024 2025 STUDENT MEMBER OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION. SHE IS CURRENTLY INVOLVED IN YOUTH AND GOVERNMENT AND PARTICIPATES IN MULTIPLE SCHOOL CLUBS, ALONG WITH BEING THE VICE PRESIDENT OF HER SCHOOL STUDENT COUNCIL, IN ADDITION TO A REGENT STUDENT. MAKE SURE I GOT IT RIGHT.

STUDENT COUNCIL. SHE HOLDS THE POSITION AS AN OFFICER FOR MEDICAL CLUB GLAMOR GALS, SPEECH AND DEBATE, AND GENDER, SEXUALITIES AND ALLIANCES CLUB. ADDITIONALLY SASHA HAS SERVED ON THE EXECUTIVE BOARD OF THE MARYLAND ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT COUNCILS FOR TWO YEARS. OUTSIDE

[00:05:03]

OF SCHOOL, SHE'S PLAYED CLUB SOCCER FOR TEN YEARS AND HAS PLAYED FOR HER HIGH SCHOOL VARSITY SOCCER TEAM FOR ALL FOUR YEARS. SHE ENJOYS BEING AN ACTIVE MEMBER OF HER COMMUNITY, AND ACTIVELY TUTORS STUDENTS FROM GRADES SIX THROUGH 12. ON OCCASION, SASHA LIKES TO PERFORM TRADITIONAL PERSIAN DANCING RACKS AND I SAY THAT RIGHT. WITH HER DANCE GROUP, SHE ACTIVELY EXPRESSES HER LOVE FOR STEM AS SHE HAS CONTINUED HER LAB RESEARCH AT ABERDEEN PROVING GROUND THROUGH AN APPRENTICESHIP FOR THREE CONSECUTIVE YEARS. SHE PLANS TO USE THE KNOWLEDGE SHE HAS ACQUIRED TO ATTEND A FOUR YEAR UNIVERSITY, STUDYING BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES AND POLITICAL SCIENCE. TO FURTHER CONTINUE HER EDUCATION AT MEDICAL SCHOOL, FOLLOWED BY LAW SCHOOL. THAT'S A LOT. AND ALL THAT. SOMEHOW YOU'RE GOING TO FIND TIME TO BE OUR STUDENT MEMBER OF THE BOARD, WHICH IS NO SMALL TASK. OKAY. ARE YOU READY? YES. PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. DO YOU SWEAR THAT YOU WILL SUPPORT THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, AND THAT YOU WILL BE FAITHFUL AND BEAR JUST ALLEGIANCE TO THE STATE OF MARYLAND AND SUPPORT THE CONSTITUTION AND LAWS THEREOF? AND THAT YOU WILL, TO THE BEST OF YOUR SKILL AND JUDGMENT, DILIGENTLY AND FAITHFULLY, WITHOUT PARTIALITY OR PREJUDICE. EXECUTE THE OFFICE OF STUDENT MEMBER TO THE BOARD OF EDUCATION OF HARFORD COUNTY. ACCORDING TO THE CONSTITUTION AND LAWS OF THIS STATE, AS WELL AS THE GUIDELINES OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION OF HARFORD COUNTY.

I DO OUTSTANDING CONGRATULATIONS AND WELCOME. SO I HAVE A PIN FOR YOU, BUT NOW WE'D LIKE MISS MUMBI TO COME UP. SHE IS HERE FROM THE COUNTY EXECUTIVE'S OFFICE, AND I'LL HAPPILY GIVE YOU THE MICROPHONE TO DO THIS LITTLE THING FIRST. ALL RIGHT, GO TAKE THAT. SASHA, ON BEHALF OF COUNTY EXECUTIVE BOB CASSILLY, I'M GOING TO CONGRATULATE YOU FOR BEING THE NEWEST MEMBER OF THE STUDENT MEMBER OF THE BOARD. I PROBABLY SHOULDN'T ADMIT THIS, BUT I'VE BEEN TO EVERY SCHOOL BOARD MEETING FOR 20 YEARS, AND I CAN PROMISE YOU THAT THE STUDENT VOICE MATTERS, AND IT MAKES A DIFFERENCE. SO THANK YOU FOR COMMITTING YOUR TIME TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE IN HARFORD COUNTY. THANK YOU. THANK. ALL RIGHT. SO WE HAVE A NEW BOARD. NOW. LET'S GET ONE WITH JUST YOU GUYS. AND THEN SINCE WE HAVE A NEW BOARD LET'S GET THE WHOLE BOARD UP THERE TO GET THE NEW BOARD. MAKE SURE WHO'S DOING PICTURES ARE WE PUTTING YOU ON TAP? OKAY.

ACTUALLY THANK YOU. VICE. ALL RIGHT. IF WE CAN GET THE BOARD UP FRONT. AND YOU WANT TO POINT OUT YOUR PARENTS AND EMBARRASS THEM WHERE THEY ARE, MAYBE.

20 YEARS. YOUR HONOR. WELCOME.

TO. ONE MORE ROUND.

[Special Message]

OKAY, BEFORE WE MOVE ON WITH PUBLIC COMMENT, I DO HAVE A SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT THAT I'D LIKE TO MAKE. GOOD EVENING. BEFORE WE PROCEED WITH PUBLIC COMMENT AND BOARD MEMBER REMARKS, I WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT TO ADDRESS SOMETHING DEEPLY IMPORTANT. IN RECENT YEARS, OUR NATION HAS SEEN A RISE IN POLARIZATION AND DIVISION AFFECTING EVEN OUR SCHOOL BOARD DISCUSSIONS. THESE ISSUES ARE OFTEN COMPLEX AND EVOKE STRONG EMOTIONS BECAUSE THEY TOUCH ON

[00:10:05]

WHAT WE HOLD MOST DEAR. OUR CHILDREN. AS WE NAVIGATE THESE CHALLENGES, IT'S VITAL THAT WE DO SO WITH RESPECT AND MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING. THE TRAGIC ASSASSINATION ATTEMPT THIS WEEKEND SERVES AS A STARK REMINDER OF THE CONSEQUENCES OF OUR DIVISION. AS PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN SAID LAST NIGHT, WE ARE NOT ENEMIES. WE'RE NEIGHBORS HERE IN HARFORD COUNTY. WE'RE ALL NEIGHBORS, LIVING SIDE BY SIDE AND STRIVING TO DO WHAT IS BEST FOR OUR COMMUNITY.

DISAGREEMENTS ARE NATURAL, BUT LET'S SEEK COMMON GROUND AND APPROACH EACH OTHER WITH CIVILITY. I STAND FIRM ON UPHOLDING THE FIRST AMENDMENT, SO SPEAK YOUR MIND. BUT REMEMBER, IT'S ESSENTIAL TO CONSIDER NOT JUST WHAT WE SAY, BUT HOW WE SAY IT AND HOW WE TREAT OUR FELLOW NEIGHBORS. LET'S REMEMBER THAT DESPITE OUR DIFFERENCES, WE ARE ALL CHILDREN OF GOD AND DESERVE TO BE TREATED WITH THE SAME CONSIDERATION WE WISH FOR OURSELVES. I URGE YOU TO PLEASE FOLLOW MY LEAD AND KEEP THIS SPIRIT OF UNDERSTANDING AND RESPECT IN MIND DURING TONIGHT'S COMMENTS AND IN ALL FUTURE DISCUSSIONS, BECAUSE TOGETHER WE CAN CREATE A

[Public Comments ]

COMMUNITY WHERE EVERYONE FEELS VALUE VALUED AND HEARD. THANK YOU. OKAY, SO WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON WITH PUBLIC COMMENT. MISS ROLLO, HOW MANY PUBLIC SPEAKERS DO WE HAVE THIS EVENING, I'M STILL COUNTING, BUT WE HAVE. MORE THAN THE ROOM CAN HOLD. YES 60. I'LL GIVE YOU A FINAL COUNT IN A MINUTE. OKAY, SO THIS EVENING, TO HELP MOVE THINGS ALONG, WE WILL CALL NOT ONLY THE SPEAKER, BUT WE WILL ALSO CALL THE FOLLOWING SPEAKER. SO IF YOU HEAR YOURSELF AS THE NEXT SPEAKER, IF YOU COULD JUST MAKE YOUR WAY TO THE AISLE OVER THERE AND JUST STAND MAYBE A FEW FEET BEHIND THE SPEAKER WHO'S AT THE PODIUM JUST TO PREPARE YOURSELF TO COME UP NEXT. ALL RIGHT. CAN I SAY SOMETHING? YES. SO I JUST GOT NOTIFIED BY SOMEONE WHO IS OUTSIDE OF THE BUILDING THAT EVEN THOUGH THEY'RE PRE-REGISTERED TO SPEAK, THEY ARE NOT BEING ALLOWED TO COME INTO THE BUILDING. WE HAD A CAPACITY ISSUE. YES SIR. OKAY. SO HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE OUT THER? 40 OR SO. ABOUT 40. THEY WERE TOLD THAT NO MATTER HOW MANY PEOPLE LEAVE, THEY WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO COME IN. YEAH, WE NEED TO FIX THAT. WE DO. SO WE CAN WE CAN DO THIS. IS THERE A PROCESS TO WHERE IF SOMEONE LEAVES AFTER THEIR COMMENT, WE CAN LET SOMEONE IN? OKAY. HAVE I THINK IT'S A YEAH, WE NEED A BIGGER BOARD ROOM NEXT TIME. OKAY. SO IS THERE A PROCESS THEN. SO HAS ANYONE OUTSIDE REGISTERED OR HAVE THEY NOT REGISTERED? THEY HAVE REGISTERED OKAY. SO PLEASE BEAR WITH US. THIS IS A LITTLE UNPRECEDENTED, BUT WE'RE GOING TO TRY TO GET EVERYONE OUTSIDE THAT'S IN HERE SOMEHOW AND NEED TO KNOW THOUGH. YEAH. IF SO, IF WE CAN SEND SOMEONE OUT THERE AND JUST HAVE THEM BEAR WITH US WHILE WE WORK THROUGH THIS, IT MIGHT BE A LITTLE BIT OF TIME BECAUSE IT MIGHT BE A LONG NIGHT. I'LL HAVE THAT WOULD BE GREAT. OKAY. AND THEN WE'LL SEE ONCE WE GET THROUGH HOW MANY FOLKS THAT WE CAN ACTUALLY GET IN HERE. IF NOT, WE'LL HAVE TO FIGURE SOMETHING OUT AT THAT POINT. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. SO PLEASE READ THIS EVENING'S RULES OF ORDER. GOOD EVENING. I'M DJ RAVAGE, REGIONAL COORDINATOR FOR THE OFFICE OF SAFETY AND SECURITY. THANK YOU FOR ATTENDING TONIGHT'S BOARD OF EDUCATION BUSINESS MEETING. IN KEEPING WITH THE BUSINESS PURPOSE OF THE MEETING, I WOULD LIKE TO SHARE UPDATED PRACTICES THAT WILL BE ENFORCED THIS EVENING. AND FOR ALL FUTURE BOARD MEETINGS.

DURING THE BUSINESS MEETING, ALL ATTENDEES ARE REMINDED TO CONDUCT THEMSELVES IN A RESPECTFUL MANNER. GRANDSTANDING WHICH INCLUDES APPLAUSE, AUDIBLE COMMENTARY, EXCESSIVE GESTURES, STANDING OVATIONS, AND SIMILAR DISTRACTING BEHAVIORS IS NOT PERMITTED. LIKEWISE, THREATENING WORDS, GESTURES, OR BEHAVIORS ARE NOT PERMITTED. WE ASK THE COMET CORRECTION. WE ASK THE COMMENTERS REFRAIN FROM IDENTIFYING INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC AND DO NOT SIT ON THE BOARD. WHILE IT IS ACCEPTABLE TO ADDRESS BOARD MEMBERS DIRECTLY, IT IS PREFERRED THAT INDIVIDUALS DO NOT IDENTIFY OTHERS, AS THIS COULD BE CONSTRUED AS A PERSONAL ATTACK, WHICH IS PROHIBITED. WE APPRECIATE YOUR UNDERSTANDING AND ARE COMMITTED TO ENSURING A RESPECTFUL AND CONSTRUCTIVE DIALOG IN OUR MEETINGS. PLEASE FEEL FREE TO REACH OUT IF YOU HAVE ANY FURTHER CONCERNS OR NEED ADDITIONAL SUPPORT. SHOULD AN ATTENDEE ENGAGE IN ONE OF THE PROHIBITED BEHAVIORS, THUS DETRACTING FROM THE BUSINESS PURPOSE OF THIS MEETING, THE ATTENDEE WILL RECEIVE A WARNING TO IMMEDIATELY CEASE THE PROHIBITED BEHAVIOR. IF THE ATTENDEE DOES NOT CEASE TO PROHIBIT A BEHAVIOR, THE ATTENDEE WILL BE ESCORTED FROM THE BUSINESS MEETING BY SECURITY. WE APPRECIATE YOUR RESPECTFUL ATTENDANCE AND

[00:15:02]

PARTICIPATION, AND LOOK FORWARD TO A PRODUCTIVE MEETING. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'VE ALREADY REMOVED ONE ITEM, ONE BUSINESS ITEM, TO ALLOW FURTHER PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY, BUT WE STILL DO HAVE TO VOTE AND HAVE DISCUSSIONS AND HAVE PRESENTATIONS ON THE CURRICULUM.

SO WE DO HAVE BUSINESS TO DO AFTER THIS, SO IN-PERSON SPEAKERS WILL BE CALLED BY THE BOARD SECRETARY. ALL SPEAKERS WILL RECEIVE TWO MINUTES TO SPEAK THIS EVENING. AND THAT'S WHETHER YOU'RE AN INDIVIDUAL OR WHETHER YOU'RE A GROUP. SPEAKERS MAY BE INTERRUPTED AND MAY BE GIVEN NOTICE WHEN THEY HAVE 30S LEFT. WHEN SPEAKERS REACH THEIR TWO MINUTE MARK, THEIR TIME WILL EXPIRE. MISS ROLLO, PLEASE BEGIN WITH IN PERSON SPEAKERS THIS EVENING. WE WILL BEGIN WITH MR. CHRISTOPHER PROVIDENCE, FOLLOWED BY KAREEM WALLACE. MISS KAREEM WALLACE IS HERE. CAN YOU PLEASE WAIT BEHIND THIS FIRST SPEAKER? KAREEM WALLACE IS THERE A CURRENT? HE'S OUTSIDE. JUST PUT A CHECK NEXT TO THAT AND THEN WE'LL COME BACK TO THAT PERSON AND THEN MOVE ON TO THE NEXT ONE FOR THE NEXT SPEAKER. SO THE NEXT SPEAKER WOULD BE JOAQUIM RISING JOAQUIM RISING. MICHAEL ECKERT SARAH MICHAEL ECKERT. ALISON NEWBERGER. SOME PEOPLE MAY HAVE SIGNED UP AT ADVANCE AS WELL. MAY NOT BE HERE, I DON'T KNOW. OKAY. AMBER MILLS. IS SHE. IS THAT HER? OKAY. ALL RIGHT.

YES, SIR. THANK YOU. YOU MAY PROCEED. GOOD EVENING, SUPERINTENDENT PAULSEN AND MEMBERS OF THE BOARD. MY NAME IS CHRISTOPHER PROVIDENCE. I'M A RETIRED EDUCATOR, AND I LIVE IN HARBOR DEGREES. FOR TOO LONG, HISTORY HAS BEEN TAUGHT ONLY FROM A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE, INCLUSIVE HISTORY IS IMPORTANT BECAUSE IT TEACHES US ABOUT THE CONTRIBUTIONS, ACHIEVEMENTS, AND STRUGGLES OF ALL AMERICANS, AND IT GIVES US THE OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN FROM DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES. SOMETIMES THAT HISTORY IS PAINFUL AND UNCOMFORTABLE, BUT IT REFLECTS THE TRUTH OF OUR HISTORY, BOTH GOOD AND BAD. PART OF THAT TRUTH IS UNDERSTANDING HOW THE LEGACY OF ENSLAVEMENT AND JIM CROW CONTINUES TO IMPACT US TODAY. IN 2024, DURING THE PREVIOUS BOARD MEETING, FIVE OF YOU VOTED TO REJECT THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES ELECTIVE COURSE AGAINST THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE SUPERINTENDENT. AND DESPITE THE FACT THAT THE COURSE WAS SUCCESSFULLY IMPLEMENTED, HAS RECEIVED OVERWHELMINGLY POSITIVE FEEDBACK. MORE THAN 100 STUDENTS HAVE ALREADY REGISTERED TO TAKE THE COURSE, AND ADDITIONAL SCHOOLS HAVE EXPRESSED INTEREST IN THE COURSE. PLUS, IF WE DROP THE COURSE, WE'LL LOSE A LOT OF MONEY AND FUNDING. AND WHY DID YOU VOTE? NO, THE REASONS WE HEARD NO ACCESS TO THE PROPOSED CURRICULUM, CONCERNS ABOUT THE CONTENT, THE QUALITY OF THE CURRICULUM. IT'S TOO POLITICAL. IT PROMOTED TERRORISM AS A FORM OF ACTIVISM. IT REFLECTED A SEVERE PROGRESSIVE AGENDA. INFORMATION WAS BIASED AND DIVISIVE, DIVISIVE. IT PITS AMERICANS AGAINST AMERICANS, AND YOU SAID YOU WANTED TO SEE MORE BALANCE AND MORE POSITIVE MESSAGES. WHAT'S DISTURBING ABOUT YOUR OBJECTIONS IS THAT THEY'RE HIGHLY SUBJECTIVE, AND THEY APPEAR TO BE BASED NOT ON OBJECTIVE DATA, BUT ON PERSONAL OPINIONS AND GRIEVANCES, BIAS, DISCOMFORT WITH IDEAS AND PERSPECTIVES DIFFERENT FROM YOUR OWN AND YOUR RELIGIOUS AND POLITICAL BELIEFS. I SAW THIS GREAT QUOTE LAST NIGHT. MOST PEOPLE DON'T USE FACTS TO FORM THEIR OPINIONS. THEY USE THEIR OPINIONS TO FORM THEIR FACTS.

AND TO BE FRANK, I DON'T THINK YOU HAVE THE QUALIFICATIONS, BACKGROUNDS, OR CULTURAL SENSITIVITY TO TELL THE AFRICAN AMERICAN COMMUNITY WHICH PARTS OF OUR HISTORY SHOULD AND SHOULD NOT BE TAUGHT. THANK YOU SIR. WE'RE I URGE YOU, THANK YOU SIR, THANK YOU, THANK YOU. PERMANENT COLLECTION NUMBER. THANK YOU. GOOD OKAY. WHO'S NEXT? HEY, JUST A COUPLE OF HOUSEKEEPING THINGS.

WE DO HAVE TO STICK TO THE TWO MINUTE TIME LIMIT. SO IF YOU COULD JUST ADJUST YOUR. IF YOU PREPARED A THREE MINUTE SPEECH, IT'S GOING TO HAVE TO BE TWO MINUTES. I'M SORRY, AND ALSO THERE'S NO GRANDSTANDING, WHICH INCLUDES CLAPPING OR THINGS LIKE THAT. SO THE PRESENTERS ARE ALSO TO SPEAK TO THE BOARD. WHO'S NEXT? MISS AMBER MILNE? GOOD EVENING. I AM AMBER MILNE'S

[00:20:04]

PROUD TEACHER AT ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL. I AM HERE TO SPEAK ON THE RECENT VOTE TO BLOCK THE OFFERING OF AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. WHILE I APPRECIATE THAT THE BOARD HAS TAKEN A MORE ACTIVE POSITION IN THEIR ROLE, I URGE YOU TO RECALL THE VOTE AND TABLE IT UNTIL YOU CAN PROVIDE ACTUAL, CONCRETE EVIDENCE BASED OBSERVATIONS ON HOW EXACTLY THE COURSE DOES NOT MEET UNIVERSAL STANDARDS. HAVING A STANDARD REQUIRES YOU TO HAVE EXPERIENCED PROFESSIONAL AND PERSONAL IN THE CONTENT OR SUBJECT AREA, WHICH THOSE OF YOU THAT VOTED AGAINST IT LACK. BLACK HISTORY IS AMERICAN HISTORY, PERIOD. BLACK AMERICANS HAVE BEEN JUST AS INTEGRAL IN THE FORMATION OF AMERICAN OUR DEMOCRACY. BUT THROUGH FORCED MEANS LIKE TRAFFICKING AND SLAVERY, AMERICAN HISTORY IS ONE THAT IS FULL OF UNSAVORY AND UNPLEASANT ACTIONS. BY OUR COLLECTIVE ANCESTORS. SLAVERY. THE 3/5 COMPROMISE, MANIFEST DESTINY. TRAIL OF TEARS. RESERVATIONS.

JIM CROW, EMMETT TILL, JAPANESE INTERNMENT CAMPS, THE TRUMAN DOCTRINE, AND THE MARSHALL PLAN, THE LITTLE ROCK NINE THEY ALL HAPPENED. SHOULD WE REMOVE ALL TEACHING OF THESE EVENTS TO MAKE WHITE AMERICA LOOK BETTER? THIS COUNTRY HAS A LONG HISTORY OF HATRED AND MARGINALIZATION, ALONGSIDE DEMOCRACY THAT CLAIMS TO BE FOR LIFE, LIBERTY, AND THE PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS. EVEN BLACK AMERICANS WERE ABLE, LIKE WENTWORTH CHESWELL, HE USED HIS LIGHTER SKIN TONE AND TOOK THAT ADVANTAGE TO IDENTIFY AS WHITE ON A CENSUS SO HE COULD SERVE AS THE FIRST BLACK AMERICAN IN OUR GOVERNMENT. IN THE 1700S. WHEN YOU WERE ELECTED OR APPOINTED TO THIS BOARD, YOU REPEATEDLY SAID YOU WANTED TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF EDUCATION, IMPROVE ACADEMIC SUCCESS, AND ALLOW FOR PARENTAL CHOICE. TO DATE, FIVE OF YOU HAVE CONSISTENTLY VOTED IN A MANNER THAT IS IN DIRECT CONFLICT OF YOUR WORDS SINCE YOUR ARRIVAL. YOU'VE VOTED FOR A LATER START DATE, WHICH REDUCES INSTRUCTIONAL DAYS BEFORE HIGH STAKES TESTING CONVENED, A BOOK COMMITTEE ATTEMPTED TO FORCE A FLAG POLICY, VOTED AGAINST AN ELECTIVE AP COURSE NOT BASED ON ACTUAL EVIDENCE, BUT TALKING POINTS PLAGIARIZED FROM RON DESANTIS AND THE STATE OF FLORIDA'S HANDBOOK. THANK YOU.

NEXT WE HAVE DEVIN DEFORD, FOLLOWED BY DEREK MAUL. WHO'S NEXT? DEREK DEFORD IS FIRST. OKAY. I MEAN, I'M SORRY, DEVIN. OKAY YOU CAN BEGIN. OKAY. COOL.

SO AS A FORMER ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT WHO'S TAKEN AP, US HISTORY AND AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, SHOUT OUT TO, MR. MOBLEY IF HE STILL TEACHES AT ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL. I KNOW THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN AMERICAN HISTORY FROM THE WHITE PERSPECTIVE AND FROM THE AFRICAN AMERICAN PERSPECTIVE. AND I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO POINT OUT, TO ONE OF THE BOARD OF COMMITTEE MEMBERS WHO CALLED AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORIES, STRAUSS WHO SAID IT'S DIVISIVE. I DON'T KNOW HOW BLACK HISTORY IS DIVISIVE WHEN IT'S A PART OF THE HISTORY AS A WHOLE. I LIKE TO THINK THAT, TRYING TO FIND A COMMON SOLUTION BASED ON WHAT YOU GUYS DEEM AS LIKE, APPROPRIATE TEACHING IS BASED ON YOUR POLITICAL IDEOLOGY. IT'S NOT BASED IN FACTS. AND I ALSO LIKE TO TALK TO THE POINT THAT, SIR, THAT YOU GUYS REALLY JUST DIDN'T PUT AN EFFORT INTO ACTUALLY TRYING TO LOOK AT THE CURRICULUM. YOU GUYS BASED THIS ON DISINGENUOUS POINT OF VIEW BY SAYING, AND I QUOTE FROM TERRY COQUARD, THAT THE COURSE FAILS TO ILLUSTRATE THE HEADWAY THAT'S BEEN MADE. YOU SAID IT PAINTS AN ACTIVIST AND A POINT THAT PERPETUATES VICTIM MENTALITY.

AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS NOT VICTIM MENTALITY. FIRST OF ALL, I FIND IT VERY OFFENSIVE AS A BLACK PERSON. SO FOR YOU TO SAY THAT THAT MEANS YOU DIDN'T TAKE ENOUGH CONSIDERATION TO THINKING WHAT THE COURSE ACTUALLY TEACHES, BECAUSE IF YOU WOULD, YOU WOULD HAVE THOUGHT THERE WAS NO WAY POSSIBLE FOR YOU TO COME TO THAT CONCLUSION AND JUST THE DEROGATORY COMMENTS YOU MADE THAT WE HAVE TOWARDS THE POLICE. THAT WAS A STATEMENT YOU MADE IN AN INTERVIEW. SO, JUST THE BOARD MEMBERS WHO CLAIM TO LIKE, LOOK, THE CURRICULUM, THEIR STATEMENTS SAY OTHERWISE, YOU HAVE THE PRESIDENT OF THE BOARD WHO SAYS, LIKE THE CURRICULUM REFERS TO IT AS TERRORISM. AND I CHALLENGE YOU TO FIND WHERE IN THE CURRICULUM IT SAYS THAT BECAUSE IT ONLY REFERS TO THE KKK AS A TERRORIST GROUP. SO YOU'RE PERPETUATING RIGHT WING TALKING POINTS. AND I DON'T THINK YOU HAVE THE BEST INTEREST IN HARFORD COUNTY STUDENTS. AND FOR YOU TO SIT HERE AND SAY, WE NEED TO BE UNIFIED WHEN YOU ALREADY CHOSEN ASIDE, BECAUSE IF THE MOMS FOR LIBERTY GROUP IS ON YOUR SIDE, SUPPORTING THE AFRICAN AMERICAN LIKE HISTORY DROP, THEN YOU'RE ON THE WRONG SIDE OF HISTORY AND TIME WILL TELL THAT. THANK YOU. YEAH ALL RIGHT. WE GOT TO STICK BY THE RULES OF, NO CLAPPING, NO GRANDSTANDING. THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS DEREK MAUL.

I'M A RETIRED UNITED STATES ARMY VETERAN OF 26 YEARS AND A RETIRED UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT

[00:25:04]

CIVILIAN. I HAVE WORKED IN THE HARFORD COUNTY COMMUNITY SINCE 2003 AND LIVED IN THE HARFORD COUNTY SINCE 2014. I RECENTLY LEARNED OF THE DECISION BY THE HARFORD COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION TO REMOVE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY FROM THE CURRICULUM OF THE HARFORD COUNTY SCHOOL SYSTEM, UP UNTIL NOW, I HAVE NOT BEEN INVOLVED IN ANY ASPECT OF A LOCAL GOVERNMENT BUSINESS ANYWHERE I'VE LIVED OR WORKED. THE RECENT DECISION BY THE HARFORD COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION HAS PROMPTED AND IGNITED A SINCERE DESIRE TO BE MORE INVOLVED, DUE TO THE SEVERITY OF THE DECISION TO REMOVE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY FROM THE CURRICULUM AND THE COMMENTS MADE BY SEVERAL BOARD MEMBERS, THE REASONING QUOTED BY SEVERAL BOARD MEMBERS DOES NOT REPRESENT PAST, PRESENT OR FUTURE REALITIES IN OUR LIVES. AS AMERICANS, NOT JUST AFRICAN AMERICANS. BOARD MEMBER MISS TERRY CROCKER IS QUOTED BY SEVERAL LOCAL NEWS ORGANIZATIONS STATING OF AP AMERICAN HISTORY, AND I QUOTE THE TOPICS ARE HEAVILY POLITICALLY ORIENTED, PERPETUATE THE MESSAGE OF OPPRESSED VERSUS OPPRESSOR. I DIDN'T FIND POSITIVE MESSAGES THAT WEREN'T OVERWHELMED BY NEGATIVE MESSAGES. ADDITIONALLY, MISS COKER IS QUOTED STATING STATING, I THINK WE'RE MISSING AN OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT POSITIVE MESSAGES OF UNITY AND GREAT AMERICAN CONTRIBUTIONS. MISS COKER, YOU ARE CORRECT IN SOME OF YOUR STATEMENTS, THE HISTORY OF AFRICAN AMERICANS IS ONE OF OPPRESSED VERSUS THE OPPRESSOR. AS SAD AS IT MAY SEEM, THIS IS REALITY. HISTORY SHOULD BE AND IS A LESSON OF PAST MISTAKES AND GIVES US THE ABILITY TO PRESENT SOLUTIONS FOR FUTURE PROGRESS. THE POSITIVE MESSAGE YOU ARE SEEKING IS FOUND NOT IN REMOVING THE CURRICULUM. THE POSITIVE MESSAGE IS FOUND IN EDUCATING FUTURE GENERATIONS OF SAME MISTAKES AND ATROCITIES. THANK YOU SIR. LET ME GO TO THE END. I SOLEMN REQUEST OF THIS BODY IS TO RESTORE THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN CURRICULUM. THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION AND TIME. THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE JIM THORNTON, FOLLOWED BY DAVID MARSHALL. IS DAVID MARSHALL HERE? YOU CAN GO AHEAD, SIR. GOOD EVENING TO ALL PRESENT THE DECISION NOT TO OFFER THE COURSE. THE AP BLACK HISTORY COURSE NEXT YEAR IS OF GREAT DISDAIN TO ME. I WANT TO QUOTE A FEW BOARD MEMBERS, BOARD MEMBER TERRY COCKER VOTED AGAINST THE COURSE, SAYING WE NEED AN AP AFRICAN AMERICAN COURSE, BUT THIS IS NOT IT. I DIDN'T FIND POSITIVE MESSAGES THAT WEREN'T OVERWHELMED BY THE NEGATIVE MESSAGES. SO I THINK WE'RE MISSING AN OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT POSITIVE MESSAGES OF UNITY AND GREAT AMERICAN CONTRIBUTIONS. LAUREN PAGE STRAUSS THEN SAID ANOTHER, ANOTHER BOARD MEMBER STATED, I SPENT A LOT OF TIME REVIEWING THIS CURRICULUM. I THINK THERE'S A LOT OF GOOD, SOLID EDUCATION COMPONENTS, BUT I AM STRUGGLING OVER THE DIVISIVENESS AND SOME OF THIS CONTENT THAT SOME OF THIS CONTENT COULD CAUSE. THEN WE HAD SOME ON THE OTHER SIDE. THANK GOD FOR THAT, CAROL BRUCE VOTING TO KEEP THE CLASS, SAYING FOR US TO KEEP SAYING WE DON'T WANT IT BECAUSE IT'S POLITICAL, I THINK IS UNFAIR AND SHORTSIGHTED. IT'S PITTING AFRICAN AMERICANS AGAINST NON-AFRICAN AMERICANS BECAUSE WE WANT TO SPEAK UP, TO SAY WE WANT HISTORY TAUGHT. I WANT TO FIRST ADDRESS ALL OF THOSE WHO HAVE EXPRESSED THEIR LACK OF INTEREST IN THIS COURSE. BOTH OF YOU, ALL OF YOU INTIMATED THAT THE COURSE IS IN SOME WAY NEGATIVE AND DIVISIVE. WELL, THE REALITY OF THE HISTORY OF BLACKS IN AMERICA IS UNFORTUNATELY QUITE NEGATIVE. AND DIVISIVE. LET ME GIVE YOU A LITTLE HISTORICAL CONTEXT TO SUPPORT THIS MANY. CONSIDER A SIGNIFICANT STARTING POINT TO SLAVERY IN AMERICA TO BE IN 1619, WHEN THE WHITE LION BROUGHT 20 ENSLAVED AFRICANS ASHORE TO THEN BRITISH, TO THEN BRITISH COLONY OF JAMESTOWN, VIRGINIA, SLAVERY WAS CONSIDERED ONE OF THE GREATEST ADDRESS ATROCITIES IN HISTORY. THIS WAS A FORCED MOVEMENT THAT WENT ON FOR OVER 200 YEARS. ACCORDING TO DIGITAL HISTORY, 10 TO 15% OF THE 10 TO 15 MILLION AFRICANS TRANSPORTED ACROSS THE ATLANTIC DIED DURING THE MIDDLE PASSAGE. SLAVES WERE PUNISHED FOR NOT WORKING FAST ENOUGH FOR BEING LATE. OH, THERE'S SO MUCH MORE TO BE SAID, BUT THANK YOU. TO GIVE, TO KEEP ON GIVING, I WILL, I WILL, I'M SORRY. CALL THE NEXT PERSON AND I'LL GIVE HIM JIM THORNTON IN. NOW OR IS HE STILL UP? OKAY SO OUR NEXT TWO ARE CASSANDRA BEVERLY, FOLLOWED BY CHERYL LOVE. I WILL SAY THAT IF YOU CANNOT GET EVERYTHING THROUGH IN TWO MINUTES, YOU'RE ALSO WELCOME TO EMAIL YOUR

[00:30:04]

ENTIRE STATEMENT TO THE BOARD. I CERTAINLY CAN'T, WE I, I REPRESENT A GROUP. I WAS TOLD IT WAS GOING TO BE FIVE MINUTES AND NOW I'VE GOT TO MASH IT DOWN. YOU SHOULD HAVE PUT THAT ON THE WEBSITE SO I COULD HAVE HAD AN ALTERNATIVE SPEECH, GOOD EVENING, SUPERINTENDENT BOARD, CHAIR, BOYNTON AND MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION. MY NAME IS CASSANDRA BEVERLY. I'M CHAIR OF THE HARFORD COUNTY CAUCUS OF AFRICAN AMERICAN LEADERS, I'M ALSO ONE OF THE FIRST, PRIOR ELECTED MEMBERS OF THIS BOARD. WE ARE A GROUP OF COMMUNITY LEADERS THAT INCLUDES CLERGY, BUSINESS OWNERS AND OTHERS WHO SHARE A COMMITMENT TO ADVOCATING FOR EQUITY, FAIRNESS AND INCLUSION FOR AFRICAN AMERICANS IN THIS COUNTY. I'M HERE TO EXPRESS OUR PROFOUND DISAPPOINTMENT OVER YOUR DECISION NOT TO GIVE THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY COURSE REGULAR STATUS FOR THE UPCOMING YEAR, AND TO URGE YOU TO REVOTE ON THIS MATTER. HARFORD COUNTY HAS A WELL-DOCUMENTED HISTORY OF DRAGGING ITS FEET WHEN IT COMES TO THE EDUCATION OF STUDENTS OF COLOR. IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT APPROXIMATELY 100 STUDENTS HAD EXPRESSED AN INTEREST IN TAKING THE COURSE. I IMAGINE THAT A MAJORITY OF THOSE STUDENTS ARE STUDENTS OF COLOR.

NOW, ONCE AGAIN, HARFORD COUNTY IS AT THE FOREFRONT OF DENYING THOSE STUDENTS THE OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE THEIR KNOWLEDGE OF THE HISTORY OF AFRICAN AMERICANS. IN THIS COUNTRY AND TO DEVELOP CRITICAL THINKING SKILLS, BECAUSE SOME OF YOU BELIEVE THAT THERE WERE NOT ENOUGH POSITIVE MESSAGES IN THE CURRICULUM, I FIND IT ASTONISHING THAT SOMEONE CAN BELIEVE THAT THERE IS A POSITIVE WAY TO TELL THE TRUTH ABOUT SLAVERY, JIM CROW, SEGREGATION, AND DECADES OF DISCRIMINATORY PRACTICES. YOU PROPOSE THAT THE CURRICULUM BE REVISED TO PROVIDE MORE POSITIVE MESSAGES AND TO BE LESS DIVISIVE. THIS APPEARS TO BE A REQUEST TO WHITEWASH THE TRUTH AND PAINT A PICTURE THAT I CALL HAPPY NEGROES AND BENEVOLENT WHITE FOLKS. NOW, BECAUSE I HAVE TO SHORTEN THIS, I OPPOSE YOUR APPOINTMENT TO THIS BOARD. DOCTOR BOYNTON, ONCE WE LEARNED AT THE CAUCUS OF YOUR CONNECTIONS WITH RON DESANTIS, WE BELIEVE THAT YOU AND OTHERS ON THIS BOARD WERE GOING TO IMPORT THE PRACTICES FROM FLORIDA. WE OPPOSE THEM. AND WE URGE YOU TO REVOTE ON THIS ISSU. CHERYL, LOVE. SO WE HAVE A SUSIE SCOTT. I'M SORRY, SUSIE. SUSIE.

SCOTT. OKAY FOLLOWED BY EMIL CROMWELL. OKAY. OKAY. THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE THAT WAS DENIED AT THE LAST BOARD MEETING HAS BECOME A LIGHTNING ROD OF CONTENTION FOR CERTAIN MEMBERS OF THIS COMMUNITY BY UTILIZING THE ACTIVIST TACTICS LAID OUT IN THAT COURSE, THESE DISGRUNTLED PEOPLE HAVE TAKEN ACTIONS THAT WILL ONLY FURTHER INFLAME THE SITUATION. INSTEAD OF WORKING AS A GROUP OF DEDICATED PROFESSIONALS AND ADULTS, I'M SEEING ANGRY SOCIAL MEDIA POSTS FULL OF MISINFORMATION, THREATENING LETTERS DEMANDING ACTION AND DENIGRATING SCHOOL BOARD OFFICIALS FOR DOING THEIR JOB. ONE SIDED MEDIA ARTICLES AND ZOOM CALLS MEANT TO AGITATE AND KINDLE AN EMOTIONAL RESPONSE FROM OUR STUDENTS. THE FIVE MEMBERS THAT VOTED NO TO THAT AP COURSE GAVE SPECIFIC AND VALID REASONS FOR THEIR CONCERNS. THE HIGHLY POLITICIZED NATURE OF THAT COURSE IS NOT APPROPRIATE CONTENT FOR HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS. PLEASE NOTE THAT THIS SPECIFIC COURSE HAS BEEN REJECTED BY NUMEROUS STATES AND SCHOOL BOARDS ACROSS THE NATION BECAUSE OF ITS SKEWED AND POLITICALLY BIASED CONTENT. THE FALSE NARRATIVE THAT'S BEING PERPETRATED ON OUR STUDENTS IS THAT WE ARE. EVERYTHING HAS TO BE VIEWED THROUGH AN EQUITY LENS, AND IT ASSERTS AN IDEOLOGICAL NARRATIVE THAT AMERICA IS A FUNDAMENTALLY RACIST COUNTRY. THIS IS CAUSING REAL HARM. LOOK AT THE RESULTS.

A DIVIDED NATION, A GENERATION OF YOUTH WITH CRIPPLING MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES AND A HOSTILE SCHOOL ENVIRONMENT. THIS IS NOT WHAT THE CITIZENS OF THIS COUNTY OR OUR COUNTRY VOTED FOR. SO WHAT SHOULD BE THE PROPER COURSE OF ACTION? HOW DO WE SOLVE THIS PROBLEM BEFORE US? LIKE CIVILIZED ADULTS, CPS EMPLOYS A COTERIE OF CURRICULUM SPECIALISTS AND NATIONAL BOARD CERTIFIED TEACHERS. DO YOU NOT? ARE THEY NOT CAPABLE OF CRAFTING AN AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY COURSE THAT WOULD STEER CLEAR OF THE RADICAL POLITICS OF THIS HIGHLY CONTROVERSIAL AP COURSE? DID NOT THE BOARD MEMBERS WHO REJECTED THIS SPECIFICALLY FLAWED CURRICULUM SAY SEVERAL TIMES AT THE LAST MEETING THAT THEY WANT TO SEE AN AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE IN CPS? YES, THEY DID. LET'S MAKE THAT HAPPEN. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS MR. EMIL CROMWELL. I WAS BORN AND RAISED IN HAVRE DE GRACE, MARYLAND. I'M A 1961 GRADUATE OF HAVE DE GRACE CONSOLIDATED SCHOOL, SINCE RENAMED ROY WILLIAMS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL. I AM

[00:35:03]

AN ADVOCATE FOR THE RECONSIDERATION TO OFFER THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE WITHIN ALL HIGH SCHOOLS IN HARFORD COUNTY. PUBLIC SCHOOLS, AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS A VALUE TO ALL STUDENTS FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS. NUMBER ONE, THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE OR ASSIST IN NEGATING HARMFUL NARRATIVES THAT ARE PERPETRATED, GIVING STUDENTS AN UNENHANCED UNDERSTANDING OF THE PAIN AND SUFFERING IN AMERICAN RACIAL HISTORY. NUMBER TWO, THE PARTICIPANTS EXPLORE PERTINENT TOPICS THAT EXTEND FROM EARLY AFRICAN KINGDOMS TO ONGOING CHALLENGES AND ACHIEVEMENTS TO THE PRESENT TIME. NUMBER THREE, IT EXAMINES THE DIVERSITY OF AFRICAN AMERICAN EXPERIENCES THROUGH DIRECT ENCOUNTERS WITH RICH AND VARIED SOURCES. NUMBER FOUR. FINALLY, AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES IS MEANT FOR EVERYONE. DOCTOR JOHN HENRY CLARK, RENOWNED AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORIAN, IS QUOTED AS SAYING, HISTORY IS NOT EVERYTHING, BUT IT IS A STARTING POINT. HISTORY IS A CLOCK THAT PEOPLE USE TO TELL THEIR POLITICAL AND CULTURAL TIME OF DAY. IT IS A COMPASS THAT THEY USE TO FIND THEMSELVES ON THE MAP OF HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. THANK YOU. NEXT, NEXT. WE HAVE ERICA RICHARDSON, FOLLOWED BY LISA STONEHAM. IS ERICA RICHARDSON HERE? LISA STONEHAM. LISA LUCAS. SHALL BE FOLLOWED BY DAVID BAUER. IS OUTSIDE. GOOD EVENING, BOARD MEMBERS. MY NAME IS LISA LUCAS, AND I'M A RISING SENIOR IN CURRENT STUDENT GOVERNMENT PRESIDENT FOR ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL. I'VE COME TODAY TO ELEVATE THE VOICES OF MY PEERS, CLASSMATES AND FRIENDS REGARDING AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE APPROVAL. HONESTLY I NEVER THOUGHT THAT THIS TOPIC WOULD REQUIRE ADVOCACY DUE TO ALL THE AUTHENTIC POSITIVE FEEDBACK AND INTEREST I'VE PERSONALLY HEARD. LAST YEAR, THE TEACHER OF MY US HISTORY CLASS ALSO TAUGHT AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES LAST YEAR AND HE WAS FANTASTIC. WE AS A CLASS WERE ABLE TO HAVE VERY MEANINGFUL CONVERSATIONS THAT GENUINELY HELPED ME UNDERSTAND AND LEARN ABOUT THE UNITED STATES HISTORY. WHEN I REACHED OUT TO STUDENTS WHO TOOK THE COURSE LAST YEAR, MANY OF THEM RISING FIRST YEAR COLLEGE STUDENTS ARE PLANNING TO JOIN THE US ARMED SERVICES. I DID NOT HEAR A SINGLE NEGATIVE ASPECT ABOUT THE COURSE.

CONVERSELY, THE STUDENTS EXPRESSED THEIR APPRECIATION FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN ABOUT LEADERS MORE IN DEPTH WHO PREVIOUSLY WERE ONLY BRIEFLY MENTIONED IN THEIR REQUIRED COURSES. IN FACT, MANY OF THE STUDENTS TOLD ME THAT THE COURSE TAUGHT THEM ABOUT THEIR ROOTS, IDENTITY, AND WHO THEY WANT TO BE AS A PERSON AND WAYS THAT OTHER HISTORY CLASSES COULD NOT.

EVEN THOUGH THE BOARD ASSUMES THAT THIS CURRICULUM WILL INTRODUCE UNCOMFORTABLE CONVERSATIONS, THESE ARE THE CONVERSATIONS THAT ARE BENEFICIAL FOR THE STUDENT BODY TO HAVE, AND A SAFE AND CREDIBLE ENVIRONMENT. WITHOUT THIS REPUTABLE SOURCE OF INFORMATION, STUDENTS WILL HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO TURN TO THEIR OWN RESOURCES. LIKE TIKTOK, YOU HAVE HIRED AND TRAINED TEACHERS IN THIS COUNTY. NOW IT'S TIME FOR YOU TO TRUST THEM. I FELT THE NEED TO SPEAK UP TODAY BECAUSE I WOULD PRAY THAT SHE WOULD REALIZE THAT THIS COURSE IS WAY MORE THAN JUST A CURRICULUM. IT'S THE OPPORTUNITY FOR STUDENTS OF HARFORD COUNTY TO ADVANCE IN THEIR EDUCATION AS AN AP COURSE. IT INCREASES THE CHANCES OF EARNING SCHOLARSHIPS, COLLEGE ACCEPTANCE, AND GPA.

ADDITIONALLY, IF THE STUDENTS TRANSFER THIS CREDIT, THEY WILL BE DIRECTLY LOWERING THE COST FOR THEIR COLLEGE. FURTHERMORE, THIS RIGOR OF THIS COURSE WILL HELP THE STUDENTS BE MORE COLLEGE AND CAREER READY. WITHHOLDING THIS RESOURCE ROBS OUR STUDENTS, ROBS OUR FAMILIES, AND ROBS OUR COMMUNITY OF HELPING PEOPLE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. NEXT WE HAVE WILLIAM MARTINO, FOLLOWED BY TIMOTHY MANNING. GOOD EVENING. SEVERAL YEARS AGO, I HAD A FAMILY MEMBER WHO COMPLETED A CHILD PSYCHOLOGY COURSE AT A UNIVERSITY. HE APPROVED TEXTBOOK FOR THE COURS, STATED THAT 5% OF ISSUES IMPACTING CHILDREN ARE LGBT RELATED. THE INSTRUCTOR CHOSE TO FOCUS THE ENTIRE SEMESTER ON THAT 5, IGNORING ALL OTHER

[00:40:04]

FACTORS AFFECTING MINORS SUCH AS PHYSICAL ABUSE, SEXUAL ASSAULT, POVERTY, NEGLECT, AND OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS. THIS WAS CLEARLY DONE TO CULTIVATE A RADICAL LGBT PHILOSOPHY IN THE STUDENTS. THE AP COURSE MATERIAL ON TONIGHT'S AGENDA IS DESIGNED TO DO THE SAME THING TEACHING AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY AND WOMEN'S STUDIES IS NECESSARY TO GIVE OUR PAST HISTORICAL PATRIOTS CIVIL RIGHTS ICONS, SCIENTISTS AND POLITICAL LEADERS. THE CREDIT THEY ARE DUE. HOWEVER, THE COURSE IS PUSHED BY TODAY'S UNIVERSITIES ARE FILLED WITH RADICAL ACTIVIST IDEOLOGY THAT ZOOMS IN ON THE WORST PARTS OF OUR HISTORY ONLY TO FOSTER DANGEROUS WORLDVIEWS.

WHEN THE STUDENTS DON'T HAVE A SOLID FOUNDATION ON ALL THE HISTORICAL FACTS, THEY BECOME EASY PREY FOR ACTIVIST PROFESSORS. US HISTORY IS COMPLEX AND HAS HAD ITS SHARE OF RIGHTEOUS AND UNRIGHTEOUS MOMENTS. THIS CURRICULUM CHERRY PICKS THE BAD TO PROMOTE A PHILOSOPHY OF HATRED, DIVISION AND ENTITLEMENT. THIS IS A ONE SIDED VIEW OF OUR PAST. WE KEEP HEARING THAT THE AP COURSE WAS PUT TOGETHER BY EXPERT EXPERTS AT THE COLLEGE LEVEL, AND WE MUST SUPPORT THEIR CURRICULUM. THE SAME UNIVERSITIES TODAY HAVE DISGRACEFUL ANTI-SEMITIC DEMONSTRATIONS GOING ON ALL OVER THE COUNTRY. THIS RADICAL MATERIAL IS DESTROYING OUR ONCE PRESTIGIOUS UNIVERSITIES AND HAVE TURNED THEM INTO GREEN AND WHITE TENT CITIES FULL OF RADICAL KEFFIYAH WEARING ACTIVISTS THAT HATE AMERICA AND HATE THE JEWISH PEOPLE. HE DOES NOT NEED TO BE A PARTICIPANT IN THIS PROCESS. STAY FIRM IN YOUR DUTIES TO TEACH ACADEMIC EDUCATION AND REFUSE PARTICIPATION. THANK YOU. TIMOTHY MANNING. HELLO, MY NAME IS TIM MANNING, AKA ONE OF THESE PEOPLE, AND I LIVE IN ABINGDON AS OF MAY. I NO LONGER HAVE ANY CHILDREN ATTENDING PUBLIC SCHOOL IN HARTFORD COUNTY, BUT I STILL CARE DEEPLY ABOUT THE QUALITY OF EDUCATION AND EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES MADE AVAILABLE TO OUR STUDENT POPULATION.

THEREFORE, I'M HERE TO SUPPORT AND PERSONALLY DEMAND THE BOARD REVERSE THEIR DECISION AND REJECT AN AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. I FIND YOUR REJECTION AS DISMISSIVE, DISAPPOINTING AND DIVISIVE IN ITS OWN RIGHT. YOUR EXCUSES THAT THE TOPICS ARE POLITICALLY ORIENTED PERPETRATE THE MESSAGE OF THE OPPRESSED VERSUS THE OPPRESSOR, AND THAT THE POSITIVE MESSAGES ARE OVERWHELMED BY NEGATIVE MESSAGES, ARE EXTREMELY WEAK AND PERSONALLY OPINIONATED. LET ME SHARE SOMETHING WITH YOU. IT HAS BEEN, AND IT STILL IS EXTREMELY HARD TO GROW UP IN AMERICA AS AN AFRICAN AMERICAN. WHEN VOTES SUCH AS THIS CONTINUE TO TRY TO UNDERMINE THE TRUTH AND ELIMINATE REPRESENTATIVE EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES. LET'S KEEP IN MIND, FOLKS, THIS IS NOT A BLACK COURSE. THIS IS NOT A RADICAL COURSE OR A COURSE WITH A HIDDEN AGENDA. I DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU FIVE ARE SO AFRAID OF. PEOPLE OF ALL BACKGROUNDS WANT TO TAKE THIS COURSE AND THEY WILL BENEFIT GREATLY. I TOOK A SIMILAR COURSE DURING MY COLLEGE JOURNEY, WHERE I SERVED AS ACTIVE DUTY FOR 24 YEARS IN THE AIR FORCE, AS DID A WHITE COLLEAGUE OF MINE WITH DIFFERING OPINIONS AND BACKGROUNDS. I LEARNED SO MUCH ABOUT MYSELF FROM MY PEOPLE, AS DID HE. IT DIDN'T MAKE ME HATE. IT ALLOWED ME TO LEARN MORE ABOUT THE STRUGGLES AND CONTRIBUTIONS OF MY PEOPLE IN AMERICA. HE HAD MORE QUESTIONS THAN EXCUSES NOW. I DEVELOPED EVEN MORE SELF PRIDE AND TO CONTINUE TO MAKE ME A BETTER HUMAN BEING. IT WAS REWARDING BECAUSE IT REPRESENTED ME, AND IT MADE ME WANT TO LEARN EVEN MORE AS A COLLEGE STUDENT. IT MADE ME MORE ACCOUNTABLE TO MY OWN CONTRIBUTIONS AS AN AFRICAN AMERICAN, AND I WISH I HAD ACCESS TO THIS COURSE EARLIER IN MY OWN PUBLIC SCHOOLS. ALTHOUGH IT HURTS TO LEARN OF THE OFTEN UNTAUGHT AND UNSPEAKABLE HORRORS OF THE PAST, AND ABOUT THE COUNTLESS ACCOMPLISHMENTS, CONTRIBUTIONS AND INVENTIONS THAT HAVE BEEN DISCREDITED AS SOMEONE ELSE'S WERE NOT RECOGNIZED AT ALL. THE FACTS ARE, AND THE WHYS MUST BE ADDRESSED, ACKNOWLEDGED, AND ANALYZED BY OUR YOUNG MINDS.

I'LL LEAVE YOU WITH THIS. THOSE WHO DON'T LEARN FROM HISTORY ARE DOOMED TO REPEAT IT. THOSE WHO PREVENT HISTORY FROM BEING TAUGHT FULLY INTEND TO. NEXT WE HAVE ERICA RICHARDSON, FOLLOWED BY DAVID BAUER. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS ERICA RICHARDSON AND I AM THE PROUD 2024 TEACHER OF THE YEAR FOR HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS. I TAKE PRIDE IN BEING A WOMAN AND I TAKE PRIDE IN BEING AN AFRICAN AMERICAN WOMAN. I UNDERSTAND THAT MY PERSPECTIVES MAY DIFFER FROM OTHERS BECAUSE OF MY PAST EXPERIENCES. I THINK ABOUT EXPERIENCES THAT MY MOTHER, MY GRANDMOTHER, AND OLDER RELATIVES HAVE ENDURED AND EXPERIENCED, ESPECIALLY MY GRANDMOTHER, WHO WAS BORN AND RAISED IN CHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA. HER AND MY GRANDFATHER HAD TEN CHILDREN, 32 GRANDCHILDREN, AND MANY, MANY GREAT GRANDCHILDREN. MY GRANDFATHER PASSED AWAY SOME YEARS AGO, BUT MY GRANDMOTHER IS VERY MUCH ALIVE. SHE IS 104 YEARS OLD. I CAN'T IMAGINE THE

[00:45:05]

STORIES THAT SHE COULD TELL. I CAN'T IMAGINE THE EXPERIENCES AND THE THINGS THAT SHE HAD TO ENDURE. I THINK ABOUT HER EVERY DAY. EVERY DECISION THAT I MAKE, EVERY TIME I WANT TO IMPROVE OR LOOK TO HAVE SOME KIND OF INPUT IN MY DECISION MAKING. SHE IS MY MOTIVATION. I CANNOT EXPRESS TO YOU THE IMPORTANCE OF HAVING THIS COURSE AT OUR SCHOOLS. JOPPATOWNE HIGH SCHOOL, WHICH IS A SCHOOL I'M FROM, IS A SCHOOL. ONE OF THE SCHOOLS THAT HAD THAT PILOT PROGRAM, MY FORMER PRINCIPAL, MISS PAMELA ZIEGLER, AND I DISCUSSED IT, DECIDED THAT IT WOULD BE A GREAT IDEA TO HAVE THIS EXPERIENCE FOR OUR MARINERS. WE HAVE A VERY EXPERIENCED VETERAN TEACHER TO PROVIDE THIS INFORMATION TO OUR STUDENTS, AND WE ALSO HAVE THE RESOURCES TO ALLOW OUR STUDENTS TO BE SUCCESSFUL. PLEASE GIVE OUR STUDENTS THE OPPORTUNITY TO ACHIEVE THIS SUCCESS. THIS COURSE PROVIDES FACTS. THIS COURSE ALLOWS FOR BOTH SIDES TO BE HEARD. MANY PERSPECTIVES. IT ALSO ALLOWS OUR STUDENTS TO CONTINUE TO BE BRILLIANT AS THEY ARE. PLEASE DO NOT STAND IN THE WAY OF EDUCATION. PLEASE WORK WITH US TO HELP IT BE SUCCESSFUL. THANK YOU.

GOOD EVENING, I'M DAVID BAUER, AND THIS EVENING I'M GOING TO BE SPEAKING EXTEMPORANEOUSLY. I'LL EMAIL YOU MY PREPARED REMARKS. BUT THEY DON'T FIT IN THIS TIME LIMIT. PREVIOUSLY, I COMMENTED THAT SOME OF YOU CAME INTO THIS OFFICE SEEMINGLY WITH THE MISSION TO CONQUER THE SCHOOL DISTRICT AND NOT TO UNDERSTAND IT. YOU'VE AGAIN DEMONSTRATED THAT YOU CAME IN. SOME OF YOU APPOINTED, SOME ELECTED, AND YOU SEEM TO HAVE COME IN WITH THIS PREJUDICE ABOUT WHAT THE SCHOOL SYSTEM WAS LIKE. AND AS YOU'VE DISCUSSED, CURRICULUM OVER THE PAST YEAR, WE'VE ACTUALLY SEEN KIND OF A MOVING OF THE GOALPOSTS. YOU'RE COMPLAINING ABOUT THINGS LIKE WHAT LINKS OR, WHAT RESOURCES ARE LINKED TO IN THE SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL. YOU'RE COMPLAINING ABOUT THINGS LIKE TALKING ABOUT HUMAN CAUSED GLOBAL WARMING. I'VE GOT NEWS FOR YOU THAT IS REALITY. THAT HAS BEEN THE POSITION OF THE US AND THE VAST MAJORITY OF THE COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD SINCE BEFORE YOUR STUDENTS WERE BORN. THAT IS THE WORLD WE LIVE IN. HISTORY IS NOT ALWAYS PRETTY.

IT'S NOT ALWAYS UPLIFTING. THAT IS THE WORLD WE LIVE IN. SO TO THE FIVE OF YOU WHO CAUSED THIS GREAT CROWD THIS EVENING, YOU MESSED UP AGAIN. THIS ISN'T THE FIRST TIME, SO I HOPE THAT YOU WILL TAKE A STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION THIS EVENING TO CORRECT IT. THANK YOU ALL. NEXT, I HAVE CELESTE HARRIS, FOLLOWED BY EVA FITZGERALD. IS SARAH EVA FITZGERALD. WE CREATED A HOLDING ROOM UPSTAIRS SO THEY'LL HOPEFULLY BE ABLE TO COME DOWN WHEN WE ARE NO LONGER AT CAPACITY. BUT JUST KEEP GOING AND TAKE A MARK FOR NOW. GENESIS SCOTT. FOLLOWED BY MELISSA WILLIAMS. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS GENESIS SCOTT, AND I'M ACTUALLY A SCHOLAR, A LEGAL SCHOLAR OF ONE OF THE NATION'S TOP IVY LEAGUE INSTITUTIONS OF CORNELL LAW SCHOOL. AND I'M ALSO, I HAD A MINOR IN AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES AND I JUST WANTED TO SAY I WENT TO ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL AND THERE WAS AN AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, BUT THERE WAS AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, AND IT WAS ONE OF MY FAVORITE CLASSES. I MEAN, EVERYBODY WHO VOTED AGAINST THE CURRICULUM ARE ALL WHITE PEOPLE, AND I DON'T THINK WHITE PEOPLE COULD FATHOM THE PSYCHOLOGICAL TOLL THAT BLACK STUDENTS FACE BEING IN A WORLD WHERE FACES RARELY RESEMBLE THEIR OWN, OR WHERE THE SCHOOL LESSONS ARE OFTEN PAINTING SOMEONE ELSE'S, SOMEONE ELSE AS A HERO, OR YOU'RE LEARNING ABOUT THE HISTORIC MILESTONES OF SOMEONE ELSE'S HISTORY. BUT YOURS IS MARGINALIZED. THE FACT THAT THIS IS EVEN AN ISSUE IS GOING TO HAVE AN EFFECT ON PEOPLE, BECAUSE WE HAVE TO CONSIDER THE MESSAGE THAT WE'RE TRYING TO CONVEY, IT FEELS THIS INFERIORITY COMPLEX. WHY IS IT THAT AP EUROPEAN HISTORY PERSISTS? WHY IS IT THAT US

[00:50:04]

GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS, WHICH IS A VERY CONTENTIOUS COURSE THAT GETS TO STAY, AND THEY TALK ABOUT REVOLUTIONS, WARS AND CIVIL DISTRESS, BUT YOU DON'T SEEM TO HAVE AN ISSUE WITH THAT.

SO IF THE ISSUE IS THAT IT'S TOO DIVISIVE, WE HAVE TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE ESSENCE OF THAT ARGUMENT, BECAUSE RIGHT NOW, WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE IS THAT AFRICANS, AFRICAN AMERICANS ARE SO SUBPAR, THEY'RE NOT EVEN THEIR HISTORY IS WORTH TEACHING OR LEARNING ABOUT, AND IT'S UPHOLDING WHITE SUPREMACY. SO I WANT YOU ALL TO RECONSIDER. AND FOR ALL THE WHITE PEOPLE, BECAUSE IT WAS ONLY WHITE PEOPLE WHO VOTED AGAINST IT. I WANT YOU TO SEE THINGS FROM A DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE AND ENHANCE YOUR CULTURAL COMPETENCE, WHICH IS WHAT THIS COURSE CAN OFFER.

THANK YOU. YES, THIS IS ME. BE ONE FINAL REMINDER ACCORDING TO THE RULES OF THE BOARD, THERE ARE NO CLAPPING, THERE ARE NO GRANDSTANDING. AND THE SPEAKERS ARE TO SPEAK TO THE BOARD. THANK YOU. KAREEM WALLACE IS HERE TOO NOW AS WELL. SOMEONE CALLED EARLIER. WELL, I WAS TROUBLED BY MANY OF THE BOARD'S COMMENTS AT THE LAST MEETING. I WAS MOST WHAT I FOUND MOST TROUBLING AND DISHEARTENING WERE YOUR COMMENTS ABOUT THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE BEING DIVISIVE, NEEDING A FEW TWEAKS, AND NOT MEETING YOUR STANDARDS. YOUR VOTES AND COMMENTS LEFT ME WONDERING WHAT WOULD MAKE FIVE WHITE BOARD MEMBERS BELIEVE THAT THEY KNOW BETTER WHAT SHOULD BE INCLUDED IN THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE. THEN THE LEADERS IN THE FIELD OF BLACK STUDIES WHO WORKED WITH THE COLLEGE BOARD TO DEVELOP AND VET THE COURSE, OR THE 355 COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES WHO HAVE ALREADY SIGNED ON TO PROVIDE COLLEGE CREDIT. I WONDERED WHAT WOULD MAKE THESE FIVE WHITE BOARD MEMBERS WHO HAVE NO BACKGROUND IN CURRICULU, ASSESSMENT OR DEVELOPMENT, THINK THAT THEY KNOW BETTER HOW TO DEVELOP A CURRICULUM THAT ENCOURAGES CRITICAL THINKING. THEN THEIR FELLOW BOARD MEMBER, WHO HOLDS A PHD IN CURRICULUM INSTRUCTION. EVEN MORE, I WONDERED WHAT WOULD MAKE THESE FIVE WHITE BOARD MEMBERS BELIEVE THAT THEY COULD BETTER TELL THE STORY OF THE REALITY OF THE AFRICAN AMERICAN EXPERIENCE THAN THEIR FELLOW AFRICAN AMERICAN BOARD MEMBERS WHO VOTED IN FAVOR OF THE CURRICULUM AND WHOSE DAILY LIVED EXPERIENCES HAVE GIVEN THEM INSIGHT AND QUALIFICATION THAT YOU WILL NEVER HAVE EVEN IF YOU WERE COMMITTED TO DOING THE WORK OF UNDERSTANDING YOUR OWN PRIVILEGE AND BIAS, WHAT, OTHER THAN WHITE PRIVILEGE AND SUPREMACIST THINKING, COULD POSSIBLY MAKE YOU BELIEVE THAT YOU KNOW BEST WHEN ALL OF THE EVIDENCE SHOWS THAT THIS IS A SOLID, MULTIDISCIPLINARY, TRUTHFUL CURRICULUM THAT ENGAGES STUDENTS IN CRITICAL THINKING, PLEASE SPARE US AND PLEASE YOU. SPARE YOUR STUDENTS ANY ADDITIONS THAT WOULD LIKELY LEAD TO THE CONTINUED DEFLECTION OF OUR NATION'S RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE ENSLAVEMENT AND ONGOING OPPRESSION OF AFRICAN AMERICANS IN THE UNITED STATES AND PERPETUATE HARMFUL NARRATIVES THAT THE EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE HAS SO FAR, NOW MORE THAN EVER, WE MUST STRIVE FOR UNITY. IN THE WORDS OF BERNICE KING, SINCERE, LOVE CENTERED CALLS FOR UNITY MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY WORK FOR TRUE PEACE, WHICH INCLUDES JUSTICE, CORRECTING SYSTEMS, CORRECTING EDUCATION, CORRECTING THINKING. I URGE YOU TO TAKE THE CURRICULUM BY APPROVAL. SOCIAL SCIENCE CURRICULA. NEXT, WE HAVE EVA FITZGERALD OR EVANGELINE FITZGERALD AND MEGAN FITZGERALD. THIS IS WORKING ALL RIGHT. I AM EVA FITZGERALD. I WILL BE GOING INTO THE IB PROGRAM NEXT YEAR. GOOD EVENING. MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION. I'M HERE TO TALK TONIGHT ABOUT THE RECENTLY VOTED UPON ELECTIVE CLASS FOR ADVANCED PLACEMENT COURSE FOR AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. WITH WHAT I HAVE SEEN AND HEARD, I HAVE TAKEN MY OWN INTERPRETATION OF THIS. AND WHILE IT'S CERTAINLY NOT EVERY INTERPRETATION, I NEED TO STATE SOME CONCERNS I HAVE. FIRST OF ALL, CONSIDERING THIS CLASS IS AN ELECTIVE, STUDENTS CAN CHOOSE WHETHER THEY SIGN UP FOR THIS. THIS DOES NOT MEAN THE BOARD OF EDUCATION NEEDS TO CHOOSE FOR ALL STUDENTS. SECOND OF ALL, YOUR REASONING DOES SEEM TO HAVE QUITE A FEW FLAWS. FOR ONE, THE BALANCE ASPECT. WHILE THE NEGATIVITY OF THE PAST CAN BE OFF PUTTING, THAT'S JUST HOW HISTORY CAN BE. YOU CAN'T REWRITE IT TO YOUR IDEALS, HISTORY WAS BRUTAL AND BLOODY. YES, IT SEEMS THAT ACHIEVEMENTS ARE HEAVILY OUTWEIGHED BY STRUGGLE. THAT'S BECAUSE THAT'S HOW HISTORY WAS. IT'S NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH. BY FORCEFULLY SILENCING THE PAST, YOU WILL STIFLE THE KNOWLEDGE THAT OTHERS GAIN. AND BASED ON THE TOPIC OF IT BEING HISTORY, THIS ISN'T SOMETHING THAT SHOULD BE STIFLED. THE PEOPLE WHO SIGNED UP FOR THIS WANTED TO LEARN ABOUT THIS, AND LACK OF EDUCATION IS A KEY INPUT TO

[00:55:02]

FEEDING PREJUDICE AND MISCONCEPTIONS. AND CONSIDERING 7,575% OF STUDENTS WHO SIGNED UP FOR THIS CLASS ARE OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HERITAGE, THEY WOULD NOT GET TO LEARN OF THEIR OWN HISTORY. THEY WOULD BE UNSEEN, UNHEARD. ONE OF THE THINGS YOU WERE GOING AGAINST WAS THE CONCEPT OF THE OPPRESSOR VERSUS THE OPPRESSED FOR BEING TOO DIVISIVE, BUT I JUST WANT TO ASK HOW. HOW WOULD TEACHING SOMETHING THAT HAPPENED DIVIDE OTHERS? I WANT AN HONEST ANSWER TO THAT. DO YOU EXPECT STUDENTS TO TAKE AFTER WHAT THEY HEAR? IF THE STUDENT WAS ABLE TO CHOOSE WHETHER THEY SIGNED UP FOR THIS CLASS, THEY WILL ALSO CHOOSE WHAT THEY LEARN FROM IT. AND I'D RECKON THAT IN THIS CONTEXT, THEY HAVE THE COMMON SENSE TO KNOW NOT TO OPPRESS OTHERS. IT'S NOT A MANDATORY CLASS. IF A PARENT DOESN'T WANT A STUDENT TAKING SAID CLASS FOR ANY REASON, OR IF THE STUDENT DOES NOT WANT TO ELECT FOR THIS CLASS, AND THEY CAN CHOOSE NOT TO ELECT FOR IT AGAIN. THANK YO. IT'S MEGAN FITZGERALD HERE. GOOD EVENING, DOCTOR OLSON AND DISTINGUISHED MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION. MY NAME IS MEGAN FITZGERALD. I WANT TO THANK EACH OF YOU FOR THE EFFORT AND THOUGHT THAT YOU BRING TO THE SERVICE YOU PROVIDE. IT IS EVIDENT THAT YOU ARE ALL PASSIONATE ABOUT BEING PART OF THE EDUCATION PROCESS FOR HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENTS. TO THAT END, I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT YOU REVISIT AND PERHAPS RECONSIDER YOUR DECISION REGARDING THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE, REMOVING THE SELECTIVE COURSE DIRECTLY CONFLICTS WITH THE BOARD'S MISSION TO PROVIDE A SAFE AND CARING ENVIRONMENT THAT HONORS THE DIVERSITY OF OUR STUDENTS AND STAFF. BASED ON HOW WELL THE COURSE WAS RECEIVED LAST YEAR AND THE 90 STUDENTS WHO SIGNED UP FOR IT THIS YEAR, THIS DECISION DOES NOT STRIKE ME AS CARING, AND IT'S OBVIOUS THAT REMOVING AN ELECTIVE COURSE ON AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES DOES NOT HONOR THE DIVERSITY OF THE STUDENTS AND STAFF IN OUR SCHOOL SYSTEM. THE VISION OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION IS TO INSPIRE AND PREPARE EACH STUDENT TO ACHIEVE SUCCESS IN COLLEGE AND CAREER. BECAUSE THIS AP ELECTIVE IS NOVEL AND UNIQUE, I AM CERTAIN THAT THERE ARE STUDENTS WHO PLAN TO TAKE THIS COURSE THAT WOULD NOT HAVE OTHERWISE CHOSEN AN ADVANCED PLACEMENT COURSE. REMOVING THIS COURSE HAS TAKEN AWAY THEIR OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE A COLLEGE LEVEL COURSE. I SPENT SOME TIME THIS WEEKEND REFLECTING ON THE LONG TERM GOALS OF THE PUBLIC OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION, AND ONE OF THEM IS TO PROVIDE LEARNING ENVIRONMENTS THAT ARE CONDUCIVE TO EFFECTIVE TEACHING AND LEARNING, CREATIVITY AND INNOVATION. IT IS OBVIOUS TO ME THAT TAKING AWAY A COLLEGE LEVEL COURSE DOES NOT PROVIDE EFFECTIVE LEARNING, CREATIVITY OR INNOVATION. THIS WHOLE DECISION WAS POORLY HANDLED BEFORE TAKING THIS VOTE.

THERE COULD HAVE BEEN SMALL GROUP DISCUSSIONS THAT INCLUDED STUDENTS, CAREGIVERS, HIGH SCHOOL COUNSELORS, AND TEACHERS. FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO VOTED TO REMOVE THIS COURSE, I CHALLENGE YOU TO THOUGHTFULLY AND CRITICALLY CONSIDER THE WHOLE OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. IF TAUGHT HONESTLY AND CORRECTLY, THE CONTENT REFLECTS SIGNIFICANTLY MORE STRIFE AND HARDSHIP THAN SUCCESS AND ADVANCEMENTS. LEARNING UNCOMFORTABLE TRUTHS ABOUT US HISTORY PROVIDES EVERYONE OPPORTUNITIES FOR GROWTH. BUT THE RESULTING. MISS CHRISTINE BOWERS, FOLLOWED BY DEREK NOISE. IT SAID THAT ONE BAD APPLE. I'M SORRY. ONE BAD APPLE SPOILS THE BARREL. THEREFORE I APPLAUD THOSE OF YOU WHO DUG DEEP INTO THE TWO CURRICULA THAT WERE PRESENTED AT THE LAST MEETING AND FINDING A FEW BAD APPLES, SAID NO TO A SPOILED PRODUCT.

SPEAKING OF BAD APPLES, I ASK YOU TO CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING QUOTES. NO WOMAN SHALL HAVE THE LEGAL RIGHT TO BEAR A CHILD, AND NO MAN SHALL HAVE THE RIGHT TO BECOME A FATHER WITHOUT A PERMIT FOR PARENTHOOD. A MARRIAGE LICENSE SHALL, IN ITSELF GIVE HUSBAND AND WIFE ONLY THE RIGHT TO A COMMON HOUSEHOLD, AND NOT THE RIGHT TO PARENTHOOD. NO PERMIT FOR PARENTHOOD SHOULD BE VALID FOR MORE THAN ONE BIRTH. I WANT TO THANK YOU, MRS. ALVAREZ, FOR SNIFFING OUT THIS BAD APPLE.

MARGARET SANGER, WHO WAS INCLUDED IN THE WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE CURRICULUM. MARGARET SANGER WAS NO FRIEND OF WOMEN NOR AN ADVOCATE FOR CHOICE. SHE IN MANY WAYS ACTIVELY WORKED AGAINST THE WOMAN'S CHOICE TO BEAR CHILDREN. SANGER SUPPORTED BUCK VERSUS BELL DECISION, WHICH PERMITTED THE STERILIZATION OF PEOPLE DEEMED UNFIT WITHOUT THEIR CONSENT. SHE ALSO SUPPORTED EXPERIMENTAL BIRTH CONTROL PILLS, TRIALS ON PUERTO RICAN WOMEN WITHOUT GIVING THEM FULL INFORMED CONSENT. MANY OF THESE WOMEN SUFFERED FROM STERILIZATION AS A RESULT OF

[01:00:04]

THESE TRIALS. SHE WAS AN ELITIST WHO SAID THAT ALL OF OUR PROBLEMS ARE THE RESULT OF THE OVERBREEDING AMONG THE WORKING CLASS, FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION, I WOULD PROPOSE A WOMAN WHO I THINK IS A GREAT AMERICAN HERO AND A MUCH SWEETER CHOICE DOCTOR MILDRED FAY JACKSON, THE FIRST AFRICAN AMERICAN GRADUATE OF HARVARD MEDICAL LAW SCHOOL, SAID OF HERSELF, I BECAME A PHYSICIAN IN ORDER TO HELP SAVE LIVES. I AM AT ONCE A PHYSICIAN, A CITIZEN AND A WOMAN, AND I AM NOT WILLING TO STAND ASIDE AND ALLOW THE CONCEPT OF EXPENDABLE HUMAN LIVES TO TURN THIS GREAT LAND OF OURS INTO JUST ANOTHER EXCLUSIVE RESERVATION WHERE ONLY THE PERFECT, THE PRIVILEGED, AND THE PLANNED HAVE THE RIGHT TO LIVE. I HOPE THIS LEAVES A SWEET TASTE IN YOUR MOUTH AS IT DOES MINE. IS THERE A DEREK NOLAN? OKAY, NEXT WE HAVE CELESTE HARRIS, FOLLOWED BY PATRICK OWENS. PROBABLY STILL OUTSIDE. YOU BEGIN. THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING, PRESIDENT PONTON.

EXCUSE ME. PONTON POINTON. THANK YOU, VICE PRESIDENT. HAHN SUPERINTENDENT OLSON AND MEMBERS OF THE BOARD, I AM HERE TO SPEAK TO YOU TODAY REGARDING YOUR CURRICULAR DECISIONS FACING BOARD OF EDUCATION AS HARFORD COUNTY PARENT, CONSTITUENT AND FORMER EDUCATOR, I HAVE GREAT CONCERN WITH THE MOST RECENT EXCLUSIONARY DECISION THAT YOU MADE AND WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT IT IS REVERSED IN FUTURE DECISIONS, SUPPORT THE BOARD'S VISION AND MISSION. I AM AWARE THAT AT THE LAST MEETING, THE BOARD VOTED TO REMOVE THE OPPORTUNITY FOR STUDENTS TO RECEIVE A COMPLETE SOCIAL STUDIES EDUCATION. I AM HERE TODAY TO ENCOURAGE YOU TO REEVALUATE THE TYPE OF EDUCATION THAT YOU ARE PROVIDING TO THE STUDENTS OF HARFORD COUNTY, HARFORD COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION'S MISSION IS THAT EACH STUDENT IS TO ATTAIN ACADEMIC AND PERSONAL SUCCESS IN A SAFE AND CARING ENVIRONMENT THAT HONORS DIVERSITY FOR ALL STUDENTS AND STAFF. HOW ARE YOU HONORING THE DIVERSITY FOR THE STAFF AND THE STUDENTS? IF YOU REFUSE TO TEACH IT OR WHITEWASH IT? IN SHORT, YOU ARE NOT. YOU CANNOT CHANGE HISTORY AND IMPACT OR THE IMPACT ON ANY SOCIAL GROUP. THE VISION OF THE HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS IS THAT WE WILL INSPIRE STUDENTS TO ACHIEVE SUCCESS AND HONOR, TO BE IN COLLEGE AND BE SUCCESSFUL, COLLEGE AND CAREER READY. HOW ARE YOU PREPARING STUDENTS TO DO THAT? IF YOU ARE OMITTING KEY ASPECTS IN AMERICAN HISTORY, YOU AREN'T. TODAY, I CHALLENGE YOU TO HONOR THE OATH THAT YOU TOOK FOR THE STUDENTS OF HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS. WE SEE IF WE CAN FIX THAT STAIN. IT'S REALLY OLD. IT'S PROBABLY FROM THE BUDGET CUTS. THANK YOU. OKAY GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS PATRICK OWENS, AND I'M BOTH A TEACHER AT HARFORD TECH AND A PARENT OF FUTURE STUDENTS. I'M HERE TO ADVOCATE FOR THE ADOPTION OF THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES SCORES. I'M FAMILIAR WITH THE COURSES I'VE SPENT HOURS PLANNING AND PREPARING TO TEACH IT IN THE FALL. I FIRMLY BELIEVE THAT THIS COURSE IS AN IMPORTANT OPTION FOR OUR STUDENTS, AS IT FULFILLS THE VALUES OUR SCHOOL DISTRICT HAS PUT FORTH FOR THE SOCIAL SCIENCES, WHERE THE VISION IS THAT EVERY STUDENT CAN SEE THEMSELVES IN THEIR LEARNING AND CAN CELEBRATE WHAT THEY SEE. WITH RESPECT TO THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES, THIS OBVIOUSLY SPEAKS TO OUR AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDENTS FIRST AND FOREMOST.

HOWEVER, I HAVE HAD STUDENTS AT TECH OF ALL RACES EXCITED FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE THIS COURSE. I UNDERSTAND THAT SOME OF THE BOARD HAS EXPRESSED CONCERNS WITH THE TOPICS ADDRESSED IN THE COURSE. FIRST, YOU ARE CORRECT, THE COURSE DOES COVER SUCH TOPICS AS CONFLICTS WITH POLICE AND HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUES. HOWEVER, DENYING OUR STUDENTS THE OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE THIS COURSE WILL NOT ERASE THE FACT THAT THESE ISSUES HAPPENED AND THAT OUR STUDENTS WILL LEARN ABOUT THEM. DON'T WE WANT TO GIVE THEM THE OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN ABOUT THEM IN A SPACE WHERE THEY CAN BE SUPPORTED AND GUIDED? OVER THE LAST FIVE YEARS, I'VE BEEN TEACHING US AND AP US HISTORY. IN THAT TIME, I'VE SEEN STUDENTS HANDLE MANY DIFFICULT TOPICS WITH MATURITY AND GRACE. UNFORTUNATELY, WHETHER WE ARE DISCUSSING AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY SPECIFICALLY OR AMERICA'S HISTORY AND OUR EXISTING US CLASSES, THE REALITY IS THAT WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO COVER SOME DIFFICULT TOPICS. THIS CLASS IS NOT COVERING ANYTHING MORE VIOLENT OR DIVISIVE THAN WHAT'S ALREADY COVERED IN THE AP AND NINTH GRADE US HISTORY

[01:05:03]

CURRICULA, AND THAT INCLUDES TOPICS SUCH AS CONFLICTS BETWEEN CIVIL RIGHTS ACTIVISTS AND POLICE. TULSA MASSACRE AND RED SUMMER STUDENTS WILL STILL LEARN ABOUT THESE TOPICS, AS HISTORY AND ITS MANY VIEWPOINTS ARE THERE TO BE STUDIED. BOARD MEMBERS ALSO EXPRESSED CONCERN THAT THE COURSE DOES NOT PROVIDE POSITIVE MESSAGES WELL. PARTS OF THE CURRICULUM CERTAINLY COVER SOME OF THE DARKER PARTS OF HISTORY IN AMERICA. A LARGE AMOUNT OF THE FOCUS IN THEIR CURRICULUM IS ON POSITIVE ASPECTS, MOVEMENTS AND CONTRIBUTIONS OF AFRICAN AMERICANS AND CULTURE, RELIGION, EDUCATION, ART, MUSIC, THEATER, FILM, SPORTS, MEDICINE. THE ARMED FORCES ARE ALL DEDICATED TIME AND SPACE ON THE COURSE. THESE ARE IMPORTANT THINGS FOR STUDENTS OF ALL BACKGROUNDS TO KNOW AND UNDERSTAND ABOUT. STUDENTS DESERVE TO SEE THEMSELVES IN EDUCATION. LET THEM TAKE THIS COURSE. I HAVE JIM THORNTON, FOLLOWED BY CHERYL LOVE. VERY NICE MODELS. MR. CLOCK START. THANK YOU TO PRESIDENT BOYNTON, BOARD MEMBERS, SUPERINTENDENT BOSE AND A MEMBER OF THE BOARD OF ED. I'M JIM THORNTON, FORMER BOARD OF EDUCATION MEMBER, A MEMBER OF THE HARTFORD COUNTY CAUCUS OF AFRICAN AMERICAN LEADERS. I'M HERE THIS EVENING BECAUSE I'M OUTRAGED ABOUT THE RECENT DECISION TAKEN BY THIS BOARD OF EDUCATION. AT YOUR MEETING ON MONDAY, JUNE 24TH. YOUR ACTIONS TO DENY THE ADVANCED PLACEMENT, AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, REGULAR STATUS IS AN AFFRONT TO THE COMMUNITY THAT DEEPLY CARES ABOUT THE EDUCATION OF ALL STUDENTS IN HARTFORD COUNTY. I WILL NOT TAKE ANY OF MY LIMITED TIME TO LAY OUT THE MERITS OF THE COURSE. INSTEAD, MY COMMENTS THIS EVENING WILL FOCUS ON TWO THINGS. THE ROOT CAUSE OF THIS MISGUIDED ACTION IS TAKEN PRIMARILY BECAUSE OF THE ACTION TAKEN BY THE HARTFORD COUNTY GOVERNMENT. OUR DELEGATION, WHICH PASSED THE BILL, HOUSE BILL 603, WHICH WAS IN LIGHT AND ENACTED IN MAY OF 19 2022, SHOULD HAVE NEVER BEEN INTRODUCED BY THE HARTFORD COUNTY DELEGATION. I TESTIFIED AGAINST THAT LEGISLATION AT THE TIME IT WAS MAKING ITS WAY THROUGH THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY. THE LEGISLATION EFFECTIVELY EFFECTIVELY GAVE THE COUNTY EXECUTIVE AND COUNTY COUNCIL THE AUTHORITY TO APPOINT THREE MEMBERS TO THAT BOARD, AND IN FACT, IT TOOK THE APPOINTMENT FROM THE GOVERNOR, WHICH, BY THE WAY, HAD BEEN THE PROCESS FOR MANY YEARS DURING PERIODS OF TIME WITH BOTH REPUBLICAN AND DEMOCRATIC GOVERNORS, THAT LEGISLATION IN EFFECT, WAS SUPPOSED TO BE IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITIZENS OF HARTFORD COUNTY. THAT ASSUMPTION IS INHERENTLY FLAWED. WHAT WE NOW HAVE IS A BOE DOMINATED BY IDEOLOGUES WEDDED TO AN IDEOLOGY SUPPORTED BY SUCH INDIVIDUALS AS RON DESANTIS, GOVERNOR OF FLORIDA, AND SEVERAL OTHER HIGH PROFILE ELECTED LEADERS ACROSS THE COUNTRY THAT SUBSCRIBE TO A RIGHT WING PUBLIC EDUCATION AGENDA. FURTHERMORE, WE HAVE A BROKEN PROCESS WE'RE IN. AN APPOINTED MEMBER OF THE BOARD CAN BECOME THE PRESIDENT. THIS IS ABSURD. FROM A GOVERNANCE PROCESS, THIS IS A POLICY THAT MUST CHANGE TO WHOM IS HE ACCOUNTABLE? THERE WAS A LOUD CRY SEVERAL YEARS AGO TO MOVE TO AN ELECTED BOARD, BUT WE NOW HAVE AN APPOINTED PERSON. THANK YOU SIR. THANK YOU. AS CHERYL LOVE HERE. CHERYL WILL BE FOLLOWED BY LISA STONEHAM. TO START. OKAY THERE'S NOTHING THEORETICAL ABOUT BEING LYNCHED IN FACT, IN HARTFORD COUNTY, NOT MORE THAN A FEW MILES FROM THIS LOCATION, SEVERAL BLACK MEN WERE LYNCHED IN THE 1860S AND 1900S. THERE IS NOTHING THEORETICAL, AND IT IS AN OVERWHELMINGLY HORRIFIC EXPERIENCE TO BE BEAT AND SPAT UPON BECAUSE YOU ARE TRYING TO DESEGREGATE SCHOOLS, DEPARTMENT STORES, TRAINS AND BUSSES, AS WAS THE CASE THROUGHOUT THE 50S AND THE 60S WHEN FREEDOM RIDERS THERE IS NOTHING THEORETICAL BUT CAN BE OVERWHELMINGLY DEMORALIZING.

EXPERIENCE BECAUSE OF JIM AND JIM CROW LAWS TO BE THE HEADLINING MARQUEE ACT OF AN ENTERTAINMENT VENUE WHERE YOU HAVE TO ENTER FROM THE REAR AND ARE FORBIDDEN TO EAT AND USE THE BATHROOM ON THE PREMISES. THE WHOLE MOTOWN ROSTER OF MUSICIANS PERFORMING DURING THE 50S AND THE 60S, WHOSE MUSIC WE JAM TO TODAY, WAS SUBJECTED TO THIS DISCRIMINATION. THIS GIVES MEANING TO YOU WANT MY RHYTHM BUT NOT MY BLUES. THERE ARE. THESE ARE THE LIVED EXPERIENCE AND TRUTHS OF MILLIONS MORE OF AFRICAN AMERICANS THAT SPAN CENTURIES. IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE FIND BOARD MEMBERS NOT WANTING TO ACCEPT THE FULLNESS OF THE AMERICAN EXPERIENCE. THIS COUNTRY HAS FOR TOO LONG ERASED, IGNORED, AND DIMINISHED THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF BLACK PEOPLE.

THIS IS THE VERY REASON WHY DOCTOR CARTER, G. WOODSON, AND OTHERS ESTABLISHED HISTORY MONTH AND SUBSEQUENTLY AFRICAN AMERICAN AFRICAN AMERICAN MONTH, HERITAGE MONTH. WHAT IS POSITIVE

[01:10:06]

IS THE TENACITY AND THE PERSEVERANCE EXHIBITED BY A PEOPLE BOLSTERED BY THEIR FAITH TO MAKE A WAY SEEMINGLY OUT OF NO WAY. WHAT IS POSITIVE IS THE FACT THAT THROUGHOUT THE HISTORY AND EVEN TODAY, THERE ARE ALLIES WHO SEE OUR HUMANITY AND RAISE THEIR VOICES TO SPEAK OUT AGAINST THE INHUMANE AND UNETHICAL TREATMENT. WHAT IS POSITIVE IS TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE COUNTRY'S COLLECTIVE PAIN AND GLORY, TRIBULATIONS AND TRIUMPHS, OUR SHAMEFUL AND PRIDEFUL MOMENTS. THE TRUTH IS WELL DOCUMENTED. CONTINUING TO IGNORE IT, REFUSING TO ACCEPT AND ACKNOWLEDGE IT, SENDS A MESSAGE ABOUT WHOSE HISTORY IS IMPORTANT AND WHOSE IS NOT.

GOOD EVENING, BOARD MEMBERS. MY NAME IS LISA. I DON'T NORMALLY SIGN UP TO SPEAK FOR THESE MEETINGS. FRANKLY, I DON'T FEEL COMFORTABLE BEING UP HERE. BUT I FEEL LIKE I NEED NEED YOU FOR MY GRANDDAUGHTER AND ALL OF THE STUDENTS. THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM IS FAILING OUR CHILDREN. I HAVE A LOT OF CONCERNS WITH SOME OF THE AGENDAS THAT I'VE LISTENED TO AT THESE MEETINGS. IT SEEMS LIKE WE'RE SPENDING MONEY ON SOCIAL ISSUES, MORE MONEY ON SOCIAL ISSUES, AND TELLING OUR STUDENTS WHAT TO WHAT TO THINK INSTEAD OF TEACHING THEM HOW TO THINK ON THEIR OWN. NEXT, WE HAVE KAREEM WALLACE, FOLLOWED B. MARY BROWN. AS KAREEM WALLACE HERE. OKAY. OKAY. CUT BACK TO KAREEM. I AM HAPPY TO BE HERE TODAY. BUT I'M REALLY, REALLY DISTURBED. I READ IN THE SOME PAPERS THE OTHER DAY THAT BELLAIRE IS ONE OF THE BEST PLACES TO LIVE. AND THEN I GO BACK AND I TAKE A LOOK AT ALL OF THE ARTICLES THAT CAME OUT OF THE SUN PAPER WITHIN THE LAST COUPLE OF WEEKS. HARTFORD SCHOOL BOARD IS ERASING BLACK HISTORY FOR FEAR OF DIVISION AP AMERICAN HISTORY CLASS A BLOW TO HARFORD COUNTY. NOW, THIS SHOULD NOT ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO WANT TO COME TO LIVE HERE. BUT LET ME GO ON AS A CITIZEN AND RETIRED EDUCATOR, A 40 YEAR RESIDENT, I AM DISAPPOINTED, APPALLED AT YET ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF BLATANT, DIVISIVE POLITICAL WHITEWASHING OF AMERICAN HISTORY TAKEN FROM THE PLAYBOOK OF PROJECT 2025 TO DENY OUR AP STUDENTS TRUE AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY MUST BE THE GOAL OF THIS BOARD. YOU INDICATE AS YOUR POSITION OUR STUDENTS OF HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS DESERVE BETTER. TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO RECONSIDER. EXAMINE THE CHOICE TO ELIMINATE THIS COURSE SHOULD YOU NOT REINSTATE THIS COURSE, I ASSURE YOU, AND I WILL ENCOURAGE PARENTS, CITIZENS, RETIRED PARENT TEACHERS, CHURCH MEMBERS, OTHER BOARD MEMBERS, SOCIAL ORGANIZATIONS TO ENGAGE BAND TOGETHER TO TEACH THE TRUTH AND THE TRUTH IS NOT ALWAYS GOOD. SOMETIMES IT'S BAD AND UGLY IN OUR HOMES AND IN OUR COMMUNITY CENTERS AND IN OUR CHURCHES. WE WILL GO FORWARD TO TEACH THE HISTORY NEEDED. DIDN'T KNOW HISTORY. DIDN'T KNOW BETTER. NO HISTORY, NO BETTER. THANK YOU. MY NAME IS KAREEM WALLACE. I'M I'M A JUNIOR AT EDGEWOOD HIGH SCHOOL. I'M HERE TO ADDRESS THE REJECTION OF THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE AND THE IGNORANCE. BONDI. FIRSTLY, HISTORY, BY ITS VERY NATURE SHOULD BE UNCOMFORTABLE AND UNSETTLING. THIS DISCOMFORT IS WHAT GIVES HISTORY VALUE TO UNDERSTAND, INFLUENCE AND USE KNOWLEDGE TO SCULPT A BETTER FUTURE THROUGH INSIGHT AND AWARENESS. AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES IS, OF COURSE, A CHOSEN COURSE THAT DOES JUST THIS.

QUOTE. THE TOPICS ARE HEAVILY POLITICAL ORIENTED AND PERPETUATE THE MESSAGE OF OPPRESSED VERSUS OPPRESSOR. I DIDN'T FIND POSITIVE MESSAGES THAT WEREN'T OVERWHELMED BY THE NEGATIVE MESSAGES. UNDERSTAND THAT IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO SEPARATE AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY FROM POLITICS AS IT IS DEEPLY ROOTED IN POLITICAL STRUGGLE AND POLITICAL RESILIENCE. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THIS COURSE IS TO URGE STUDENTS TO DIG DEEPER. AND UNFORTUNATELY, THE MORE YOU DIG IN AMERICAN HISTORY, THE UGLIER IT GETS. STOP TAKING OUR CIVIL. I'VE LISTENED TO YOUR STATEMENTS AND IDENTIFIED A SHARED CONCERN. THE PORTRAYAL AND VILLAINIZATION OF THE

[01:15:03]

POLICE. AND NO WAY DOES THIS CURRICULUM DICTATE OR TELL STUDENTS HOW TO FEEL ABOUT THE POLICE. THE COURSE ONLY PRESENTS RAW MATERIAL FROM HISTORICAL RECORD OF THE UNDENIABLE INEQUITIES TOWARDS THE AFRICAN AMERICANS BY THE POLICE FORCE. THE QUESTION IS NOT IF THE COURSE VILLAINIZES THE POLICE, BUT IF THE POLICE HAVE COMMITTED VILLAINOUS ACTS TOWARDS THE BLACK COMMUNITY FOR DECADES IN WHICH THIS IMAGE IS ESTABLISHED, THERE ARE SO MANY. QUOTE. THERE ARE SO MANY ASSIGNMENTS AND PICTURES OF POLICE CONFLICTS, HUMAN RIGHTS CONFLICTS, SOCIAL JUSTICE CONFLICTS, PEOPLE AGAINST THE POLICE. INSTEAD OF THE FOCUS ON GREAT PEOPLE IN HISTORY. WE ARE NO LONGER LITTLE KIDS. AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS MUCH DEEPER THAN MLK AND ROSA PARKS. THE CONFLICT MENTIONED ARE NOT ONLY MAJORITY OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, BUT INTEGRAL IN UNDERSTANDING THE MOTIVATIONS OF THESE GREAT PEOPLE. LASTLY, A BOARD MEMBER SAID, I THINK WE'RE MISSING AN OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT POSITIVE MESSAGES OF UNITY AND GREAT AMERICAN CONTRIBUTIONS WHEN WE LOOSELY USE THE WORD UNITY AND GREAT AMERICAN CONTRIBUTIONS. LET'S REMEMBER HOLIDAYS LIKE THANKSGIVING AND COLUMBUS DAY, WHICH OFTEN MISREPRESENT HISTORICAL TRUTH, WITH THE REALITY BENEFITING THE NARRATIVE OF THIS COUNTRY. AND NOT UNDERSTANDING. THANK YOU. NEXT, WE HAVE VICTORIA HARVEY, FOLLOWED BY KRISTY CRAWFORD SMITH. IS VICTORIA HARVEY HERE? IT'S KRISTY CRAWFORD SMITH. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS KRISTY CRAWFORD SMITH, AND I'M THE PROUD PRESIDENT OF THE HARFORD COUNTY EDUCATION ASSOCIATION. I CAME PREPARED TONIGHT SO YOU WILL BE RECEIVING MY ORIGINAL COMMENTS VIA EMAIL. I'D LIKE TO THANK MRS. BRUCE. DOCTOR MUELLE, MR. SEWELL, MRS. PERRY FOR VOTING TO RETAIN THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE. THANK YOU FOR STANDING UP AGAINST THE POLITICAL AGENDA THAT WANTS TO PRETEND THAT THERE IS A POSITIVE SIDE TO THE HORRORS OF SLAVERY AND JIM CROW. YOUR UNWAVERING SUPPORT FOR EDUCATORS AND OUR STUDENTS IS APPRECIATED. FIVE OF YOU VOTED TO DENY STUDENTS THE OPPORTUNITY TO EARN AP CREDIT AND ROB THEM OF A ROBUST EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCE, BECAUSE THERE AREN'T ENOUGH POSITIVE MESSAGES OF UNITY, OR THERE ARE TOO MANY MENTIONS OF ACTIVISM OR SOCIAL JUSTICE. THE FIVE OF YOU WHO ALL HAPPEN TO BE WHITE ARE ALSO DENYING THE RIGHTS OF STUDENTS TO LEARN ABOUT AMERICAN HISTORY THROUGH THE EYES OF AFRICAN AMERICANS, WHICH EXPOSES YOUR HYPOCRISY, YOUR INTENTIONAL PROHIBITION OF THIS COURSE IS THE SAME INDOCTRINATION YOU SO FREQUENTLY PREACH AGAINST. YOU ARE CHOOSING TO IGNORE AND DISREGARD THE EXPERIENCES OF THE ONLY PEOPLE OF COLOR ON THIS BOARD. ON JULY 1ST, ALL THE UNION PRESIDENTS SENT THE BOARD A JOINT LETTER THAT EXPRESSED OUR DISAPPOINTMENT IN THE BOARD VOTE AND COMMENTS BY BOARD MEMBERS THAT VERY CLEAR THAT THERE'S A SEGMENT OF THE BOARD THAT IS PRIORITIZING THEIR OWN COMFORT OVER TEACHING. THE FACTUAL HISTORY OF THIS NATION. WE LEARN AND GROW BEST WHEN OUR COMFORT IS TESTED, AND THAT IS HOW STUDENTS LEARN CRITICAL THINKING SKILLS. IN DOCTOR BOYNTON'S RESPONSE TO OUR LETTER, HE STATED THAT THE BOARD'S RESPONSIBILITY IS TO DEVELOP CURRICULUM. I RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE. THE BOARD IS CHARGED WITH THE RESPONSIBILITY OF APPROVING CURRICULUM, BUT YOU FIRST NEED TO UNDERSTAND WHAT THAT MEANS.

CURRICULUM IS A FRAMEWORK THAT EDUCATORS USE TO CRAFT THEIR LESSONS. IT'S THE TEACHER'S JOB TO DECIDE HOW THEY GUIDE THEIR STUDENTS TO MEET EACH OUTCOME. IN THE LAST 24 YEARS AS AN EDUCATOR, I HAVE WITNESSED A LOT OF CHANGE, TURMOIL, AND GROWTH OVER THE YEARS AND ALL OF THOSE YEARS, I'VE NEVER WITNESSED A GROUP OF PEOPLE WHO CLAIM TO SUPPORT PUBLIC EDUCATION TRY SO HARD TO DISMANTLE IT. EVERY BOARD HAS THEIR LEGACY, AND IF THIS CONTINUES, THIS BOARD'S LEGACY WILL BE ONE OF SHAME THAT TOOK THIS DISTRICT RUNNING BACKWARDS DUE TO YOUR BIGOTRY AND UNNECESSARY DRAMA. REMEMBER, EDUCATORS ARE WATCHING AND WE WILL REPLACE. WHAT WE HAVE CHARLENE HAUPT, FOLLOWED BY MARLENE TILLMAN. IF THERE ARE CHARLENE HAUPT. MARLENE TILLMAN, OTHERS CHARLENE. THANK YOU TO EVERYONE THAT'S HERE AND MANAGED TO GET HERE AND THOSE THAT ARE UPSTAIRS WAITING TO HEAR WHAT HAPPENS. AND PEOPLE IN THE CHURCH DOWN THE STREET WHO ARE ALREADY HERE LISTENING TO US. I'M SORRY, I'M SORRY. GOOD EVENING. I'M CHARLENE HAUPT, AND AS I SAID, THANK YOU FOR BRINGING US HERE. THOSE OF US THAT COULD MANAGE TO GET IN. AND MY ONE OBJECTION IS THAT I STRONGLY OBJECT TO ANY VOTE BEING HELD TONIGHT, WHEN DOZENS AND HUNDREDS OF PEOPLE ALL OVER THE PLACE ARE NOT ABLE TO EXPRESS THEIR OPINIONS OR EVEN THEIR ATTITUDES, OR BE HEARD. SO THAT'S ONE THING THAT I HAD TO SAY EVEN BEFORE I START SPEAKING. SO FAR. SORRY. SO FAR, OPPONENTS OF DEI HAVE BEEN SUCCESSFUL AND HAVE MANAGED

[01:20:05]

THROUGH THE HIGHEST COURT TO HAVE YOU BELIEVE THAT AFFIRMATIVE ACTION IS UNFAIR TO THEM. AFFIRMATIVE ACTION THAT BY AND LARGE BENEFITED WHITE WOMEN MORE THAN ANYONE ELSE. THE OPPONENTS DENIAL OF FAIRNESS FURTHERS THEIR ATTITUDE TOWARDS SUPERIORITY OVER WOMEN, AND MANY WOMEN BELIEVE IN THIS SUPERIORITY. GO FIGURE. THE REMOVAL OF A WOMAN'S RIGHT TO CHOOSE BEING JUST ONE EXAMPLE OF THE FEDERALIST SOCIETY'S PLANS TO DISH OUT. IN THEIR ARROGANCE, THEY HAVE DISCLOSED A MORE DETAILED PLAN IN THEIR PROJECT 2025. TWO VERY SALIENT PLANS ARE TO ABOLISH THE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT AND AMPLIFY PARENTS RIGHTS REGARDING CONTROL OF OUR SCHOOLS. THESE TWO SUBJECTS GO HAND IN HAND, AND THAT'S ONLY THE BEGINNING OF THEIR PLANS.

THE COORS FAMILY BEER, THE WALTON FAMILY, WALMART AND EXXONMOBIL HAVE CONTRIBUTED TO THE HERITAGE FOUNDATION PROJECT 2025. WHAT DOES BIG BUSINESS AND THEIR MONEY INTERJECTED INTO OUR SCHOOLS? DO FOR OUR CHILDREN? THE EXCUSES DON'T RING TRUE, AND EVERY STUDENT BEYOND THE AGE OF FIFTH GRADERS KNOW IT. WHICH OF YOU ARE IN FAVOR OF PROJECT 2025? THE PLAN IS EXTREME ON WOMEN'S RIGHTS, DIVERSITY, EQUITY AND INCLUSION PROGRAMS, AND IT'S VERY FIRST PREMISE IS TO TARGET LOW INCOME AND LOW RESOURCE COMMUNITIES EDUCATION THAT CAN HALT AND OR REVERSE ALL THE INROADS WE HAVE MADE, COMBATING DISCRIMINATION OF THOSE WHOSE COLOR OR CULTURE.

THANK YOU MA'AM. NEXT, WE HAVE ZERLINA GILES. NEXT WE HAVE ZERLINA GILES, FOLLOWED BY LILLIAN MOSS. GOOD EVENING. I'M HERE AS A PARENT, AND I'M HERE TO EXPRESS MY PROFOUND DISAPPOINTMENT AND DEEP CONCERN REGARDING YOUR DECISION TO DENY AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES REGULAR STATUS. THIS DECISION NOT ONLY PERPETUATES THE HARMFUL NOTION THAT THE HISTORIES CRUCIAL TO DEVICE DIVERSE, POPULATIONS IN OUR COUNTY SHOULD BE OVERLOOKED, BUT IT ALSO BLATANTLY DISREGARDS THE LIVED EXPERIENCES OF BLACK AND BROWN COMMUNITY MEMBERS, EDUCATORS, AND STUDENTS WHO CHERISH AND BENEFIT FROM THIS COURSE. THE INTEGRATION OF DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES IN EDUCATION IS INDISPENSABLE FOR EQUIPPING STUDENTS TO THRIVE IN OUR INCREASINGLY INTERCONNECTED WORLD. IT IS DEEPLY TROUBLING THAT THE BOARD OF EDUCATION CLAIMS TO PRIORITIZE BALANCE IN OUR SCHOOLS. YET CONSISTENTLY OBSTRUCTS THE INCLUSION OF DIVERSE AND RIGOROUS MATERIALS. EDUCATION SHOULD EMPOWER OUR OUR STUDENTS, OUR CHILDREN TO ENGAGE WITH AND LEARN FROM AND CRITICALLY ANALYZE COMPLEX SUBJECTS WITHIN A SUPPORTIVE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT. TRUE EDUCATIONAL QUALITY CANNOT BE ACHIEVED BY LIMITING THE NARRATIVES TAUGHT TO OUR STUDENTS. THIS CURRICULUM HAS UNDERGONE THOROUGH REVISION.

SUCCESSFUL PILOTING, AS WE'VE HEARD AND HAS RECEIVED PRAISE FROM EDUCATIONAL EXPERTS AND STUDENTS ALIKE IN OUR COMMUNITY. AND THE KEY WORD THERE IS EDUCATIONAL EXPERTS. YOUR DECISION TO REJECT THIS COURSE UNDER THE GUISE OF QUALITY CONTROL OVER BALANCE LACKS JUSTIFICATION AND UNDERMINES THE INTEGRITY OF OUR EDUCATIONAL MISSION. IT IS IMPERATIVE THAT HISTORY BE TAUGHT IN ITS ENTIRETY, WITHOUT OMISSION TO PREVENT THE REPETITION OF PAST INJUSTICES. I URGE YOU TO RECONSIDER YOUR DECISION. IT'S OKAY. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS LILLIAN MOSS. I'M 14 YEARS OLD, AND I'M HERE TO SPEAK AGAINST THE REMOVAL OF THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM DURING THE FIRST DEI MEETING OF MY EIGHTH GRADE YEAR, MY CLASS WAS ASKED HOW WE FELT ABOUT THE RACIAL DYNAMICS WITHIN OUR GRADE. ONE THING I WILL NEVER FORGET FROM THAT CONVERSATION IS WHEN A CLASSMATE WHO WAS WHITE STATED THAT SHE FELT THAT ANY STUDENT WHO HAD EXPERIENCED A MICROAGGRESSION OR FELT UNCOMFORTABLE AT ANY POINT AS A PERSON OF COLOR SHOULD SIMPLY JUST DEAL WITH IT. AS A BLACK GIRL, THIS ONLY SHOWED THE LACK OF UNDERSTANDING AND THE TRUE HISTORY AND STRUCTURES OF AMERICA THAT IN SOME PLACES, STILL REMAIN TODAY. THIS IS WHY IT IS SO IMPORTANT TO INCLUDE CLASSES LIKE THESE AS AN OPPORTUNITY TO GAIN THE SKILLS, TO GRASP A DEEPER UNDERSTANDING AND ANALYZE EVENTS, ELIMINATING THE CHANCE TO RECEIVE THIS LEVEL OF EDUCATION SIMPLY BECAUSE IT IS UNCOMFORTABLE TO HEAR IS

[01:25:06]

OUTRAGEOUS. WHY SHOULD THE TRUTH BE WATERED DOWN TO THE POINT WHERE YOU'RE COMFORTABLE HEARING IT? I'M CONFIDENT THAT STUDENTS WHO INTENDED ON TAKING THIS COURSE DIDN'T WANT TO WORRY ABOUT HOW SOMEONE FELT AWKWARD OR TARGETED WHILE THEY WERE LEARNING. WHICH BRINGS ME TO MY SECOND POINT MAKING STUDENTS AWARE OF MODERN DAY ISSUES SUCH AS POLICE BRUTALITY IS NOT VILLAINIZING THE POLICE IN ANY WAY OR TARGETING A CERTAIN RACE. THE CONSTANTLY SHIFTING CLIMATE OF AMERICA IS IMPORTANT TO KEEP UP WITH, ESPECIALLY FOR YOUNG ADULTS. SO LEARNING ABOUT CURRENT EVENTS AND WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO YOUNG AFRICAN AMERICANS FOR SIMPLY WALKING DOWN THE STREET IS A GREAT WAY TO INCORPORATE TODAY'S WORLD INTO LESSONS ABOUT THE PAST.

FROM INSENSITIVE COMMENTS TO ANOTHER BLACK PERSON UNJUSTLY LOSING THEIR LIVES. THIS TOPIC HAS CONTINUED TO BE SOMETHING I CARE ABOUT DEEPLY. I AM TIRED OF MY HISTORY BEING REDUCED TO A BRIEF MENTION OF SLAVERY IN A HISTORY CLASS, BECAUSE WE ARE SO MUCH MORE THAN THAT. OUR HISTORY CERTAINLY DID NOT BEGIN IN BONDAGE AND SURELY WILL NOT END IN IT. OUR HISTORY IS A RESILIENT ONE AND DESERVES TO BE TAUGHT AND WELL KNOWN. THANK YO. NEXT WE HAVE CHRISTIAN HAWK FOLLOWED BY TANYA TAYO. GOOD EVENING EVERYBODY, MY NAME IS CHRISTIAN HAWK. I'M A FORMER STUDENT AT HARTFORD TECHNICAL HIGH SCHOOL, AND MY LITTLE SISTER, CAMERON, IS A CURRENTLY RISING SENIOR AT HARTFORD TECHNICAL HIGH SCHOOL. SHE WAS DEVASTATED WHEN SHE HEARD OF THE BOARD'S REJECTION OF AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES, AND EVEN MORE DEVASTATED WHEN SHE REALIZED THAT SHE WOULD BE OUT OF THE COUNTRY AND UNABLE TO PRESENT HER THOUGHTS AND SHARE THEM WITH YOU ALL, THIS WILL BE ME RAPIDLY SHARING HER OWN WORDS WITH YOU ALL. MY LAST DAY OF SCHOOL, I SPENT TIME LOOKING OVER THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE IN MY HISTORY TEACHERS ROOM. HE HAS STEPPED UP TO TEACH THE CLASS NEXT YEAR AND HE, AN ADULT, HAD EXPRESSED HIS EXCITEMENT TO LEARN ABOUT PARTS OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY THAT HE DIDN'T HAVE A VAST KNOWLEDGE OF, DESPITE A DEGREE IN HISTORY. I MYSELF WAS ALSO GREATLY INTERESTED IN LEARNING MORE ABOUT MY ANCESTRY IN DEPTH. SINCE SO LITTLE TIME IS OFTEN SPENT ON IT. IN SCHOOLS, WE LEARN OF SLAVERY, OF CIVIL RIGHTS, AND OF VERY LITTLE IN BETWEEN. ALL THIS TO SAY, IT WAS A GENUINE SHOCK TO LEARN THE BOARD HAD REJECTED IT FOR NEXT YEAR. DISREGARDING THIS COURSE HAS TAKEN AWAY AN OPTION FOR LEARNING, NOT A REQUIREMENT, BUT AN OPTION. AN OPTION FOR STUDENTS TO SEE THEMSELVES IN WHAT IS TAUGHT IN CLASSES AND OPTIONS FOR STUDENTS TO LEARN MORE ABOUT THEIR PEERS. IF IT IS OFTEN IGNORANCE THAT LEADS TO HATE, WHAT BETTER WAY TO COMBAT IT THAN TO EDUCATE? CONCERNS EXPRESSED BY THE BOARD STATED THAT THIS COURSE IS TOO DEPRESSING TO FOCUS ON THE BAD TOO LACKING IN POSITIVITY, THE VIEW THAT AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY CAN BE TOO STEEPED IN NEGATIVITY AS A SMALL MINDED OUTLOOK THAT HARMS AFRICAN AMERICANS TO THIS DAY, IT IS AN INJUSTICE TO AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY ITSELF TO TRY TO TEACH A WATERED DOWN, GENTLE, PALATABLE VERSION. IF YOU WISH TO CELEBRATE THE ADVANCES WE HAVE MADE AS A SOCIETY, YOU MUST ACKNOWLEDGE THE DESPAIR THAT WE WENT THROUGH. THE TRUTH THAT AFRICAN AMERICANS WALK WITH TODAY. IF YOU DO NOT, IF YOU ONLY ALLOW HISTORY TO BE TAUGHT WHEN IT IS WRAPPED WITH A BOW AND PLACED IN A NEAT LITTLE BOX, TO ONLY BE TAUGHT WHEN IT HAS BEEN CHANGED TO YOUR PERSONAL DISCRETION, THEN YOU ARE DOING THE GREATEST INJUSTICE TO THE STUDENTS YOU SERVE. PLEASE DO NOT TAKE AWAY THE OPPORTUNITY FOR EDUCATION. THE EDUCATED MIND IS OUR GREATEST DEFENSE AGAINST THE PREJUDICES OF TODAY. PLEASE GIVE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES REGULAR STATUS FOR THE SCHOOL YEAR. TANYA TEO. I JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT THERE'S SOMEBODY BACK THERE THAT WASN'T CALLED YET. SO AFTER ME, IF YOU GUYS WANT TO GO BACK TO HER. I MEAN, SHE WAS CALLED, BUT, LIKE, SHE WAS NOT INSIDE. I HEARD YOU GUYS CALL HER NAME, I JUST WANTED TO SAY, I COMPLETELY STAND FOR AND SUPPORT BOARD MEMBERS THAT ARE PROPERLY ADVOCATING FOR EVERY SINGLE STUDENT. I GIVE CREDIT TO DIANE ALVAREZ, MELISSA HAHN, AARON POINTON, LAUREN STRAUSS, AND TERRI KOCHER. WELL DONE WITH THE LAST MEETING AND STANDING YOUR GROUND, I APPRECIATE IT AND I'M VERY PROUD OF YOU. OUR TEST SCORES ARE TERRIBLE. SO I MEAN, THE THING IS, WE GOT TO FOCUS ON THAT. FOR THE REST OF YOU BOARD MEMBERS THAT STOOD UP JUST TO GO AHEAD AND VOTE FOR IT BECAUSE THE EXPERT SAID SO, OR THE CURRICULUM IS ALL WE HAVE. I'M JUST KIND OF LIKE, SHAME ON YOU.

LIKE, REALLY DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH. YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT THE HISTORY THAT'S THE PROBLEM. IT'S LIKE THE WAY THAT IT'S BEING, CONSTRUED OR SLANTED, YOU KNOW, CERTAIN WAYS, AND I KNOW THIS FOR A FACT. MY KIDS ARE GRADUATED NOW, SO THEY'RE OUT. BUT I'M CONCERNED. I HAVE NIECES AND NEPHEWS, AND I KNOW A LOT OF PEOPLE, AND I AM A MEMBER OF THE COMMUNITY CURRICULUM. SO IF YOU.

[01:30:03]

IF YOU IF YOU. IF YOU DON'T KNOW EVERYTHING THAT YOU'RE VOTING FOR, YOU SHOULDN'T BE VOTING FOR IT TONIGHT, PERIOD. I HOPE ALL YOU GUYS HAD A CHANCE TO LOOK EVERYTHING OVER. AND YOU KNOW WHAT YOU'RE DOING HERE, AND I JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT MY OWN KIDS PERSONALLY HAD TO WITNESS THE CRITICAL RACE THEORY. I KNOW A LOT OF PEOPLE THINK THERE'S NO AGENDA GOING ON LIKE THAT, BUT THERE IS. OKAY. LIKE A COUPLE YEARS AGO, THE HARTFORD TECH PRINCIPAL GOT ONE THE ANNOUNCEMENTS AND WAS APOLOGIZING FOR BEING WHITE. SO MY KIDS COME HOME AND THEY'RE LIKE, DUDE, WE HAVE TO FEEL BAD THAT WE'RE WHITE. LIKE, OF COURSE NOT. AND I PERSONALLY DON'T LIKE THAT AT ALL BECAUSE MY HUSBAND AND I WORKED VERY HARD FOR EVERYTHING WE HAVE. AND I'LL JUST END WITH THAT BECAUSE I'M SO MAD. THANK YOU. BRENDA. TERRENCE FOLLOWED BY JEREMIAH PETTIJOHN. IS THERE A BRENDA TARRANT? OKAY THANK YOU. SO I THINK WE CALLED VICTORIA, BUT WE MISSED HER. OH, YOU WERE IN THE BATHROOM. YOU PICKED THE WORST. TIME TO GO. WELCOME BACK. SO IT WAS AWFUL. CAN WE. AND THERE WAS NO OTHER LADIES IN THE RESTROOM. IT WAS VERY STRESSFUL. I'M SORRY. WHAT IS YOUR NAME, VICTORIA. HARVEY. OKAY. THANK YOU. WE COULD HAVE. QUIET, PLEASE. WE'LL CONTINUE. WELCOME. OKAY I AM HERE TO EXPRESS APPRECIATION TO THOSE BOARD MEMBERS THAT VOTED AGAINST ROLLING OUT THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES FOR REGULAR STATUS AS A MOM AND A MULTI-ETHNIC FAMILY. IT IS DISHEARTENING TO SEE THE CONTINUED ATTEMPT AT CREATING THE NEXT GENERATION OF ACTIVISTS BY DIVIDING US ALL BY COLOR AND GENDER. I'M SICK OF THE DIVISION, I LOVE EVERYBODY, I DON'T CARE, YOU BE PURPLE, I DON'T CARE. ONE OF THE STUDENTS IN THE PILOT PROGRAM SAID, EXERCISING MY RIGHTS HAS BECOME MY UTMOST PRIORITY. I HOPE THAT ALL SOCIAL STUDIES CLASSES HAVE AN EMPHASIS ON THE RIGHTS THAT THE CONSTITUTION PROVIDES. EACH AND EVERY ONE OF US VIEWING HISTORY THROUGH THE LENS OF TODAY LEADS TO REVISIONIST HISTORY, WHICH WE'VE EXPERIENCED WITH THE VANDALISM AND DESTRUCTION OF MEMORIALS THROUGHOUT THE NATION. THERE IS AN AGENDA BEING PUSHED FORWARD FROM THE UPPER ECHELONS OF GOVERNMENT DOWN TO THE UNIONS, TO CREATE GENERATIONS OF SOCIAL JUSTICE WARRIORS. AND THAT'S NOT A COMPLIMENT. THE IRONY IS THAT THE HCA SENT OUT A LETTER TO THE BOARD OF EDUCATION, DATED JULY 1ST, THAT STATES EDUCATION DOES NOT HAVE PARTY LINES YET. THE HCA SENT A LETTER TO THE HARFORD COUNTY COUNCIL JUST SEVEN DAYS LATER THAT THAT INCLUDES A SENTENCE THAT SAYS, AS ASSOCIATION PRESIDENTS REPRESENTING 5000 HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS, WE ARE URGING YOU TO VOTE IN FAVOR OF BILL 20 4-016 TO OVERRIDE THE COUNTY EXECUTIVE'S VETO. THAT IS DEFINITELY ON PARTY LINES WITH A FAMILY MEMBER. THAT WAS A FOUNDING DELEGATE OF THE STEELWORKERS UNION. THIS IS A REMINDER TO THE BOARD AS TO WHAT THE ROLE OF THE UNION IS. THE UNION IS IN PLACE TO PROTECT WORKER SAFETY, PROTECT WORKING CONDITIONS, AND NEGOTIATE WAGES. THERE SHOULD BE NO ATTEMPT TO DICTATE THE BUSINESS MODEL OR IN THIS CASE, CURRICULUM. THE MAJORITY OF PARENTS IN A GROWING NUMBER OF EDUCATORS FIND THE HCA IRRELEVANT. THANK YOU TO THE BOARD MEMBERS THAT HAD THE BACKBONE TO VOTE IN THE BEST INTEREST OF HARFORD COUNTY'S FAMILIES. THANK YOU. IS THERE A BRENDA TARRANCE? YES, I'M GIVING YOU A LITTLE BIT OF LATITUDE HERE, BUT I'M REALLY LOSING MY PATIENCE. OKAY, SO MOVING FORWARD, PLEASE, WE WILL FOLLOW THE RULES THAT HAVE BEEN ESTABLISHED BY THIS BOARD. NO CLAPPING, NO GRANDSTANDING, NO MATTER HOW GOOD THE SPEECH IS. THANK YOU. PLEASE CONTINUE. GOOD EVENING. I'M BRENDA TARRANT, AND I'M AN EDUCATOR, AND I'M A SCIENCE EDUCATOR. I'M NOT A SOCIAL STUDIES TEACHER OR A HISTORY TEACHER. HOWEVER, I AM A TEACHER WHO'S HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE A TRIP TO THE SOUTH ON A CIVIL RIGHTS TRIP FOR OVER A WEEK LONG TRIP ON A CIVIL RIGHTS TRIP WITH OTHER TEACHERS. THIS TRIP HAS LET ME KNOW HOW IMPORTANT AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS IN THIS COUNTRY, HOW MANY HOLES THERE ARE. I'VE BEEN ON THE TRIP FOUR TIMES. THIS IS THE FIRST TIME THAT I WENT WITH ALL TEACHERS AND ALL OF THEM WERE STUNNED BY HOW MUCH INFORMATION THEY DID NOT HAVE ABOUT THE HISTORY OF THIS COUNTRY. I'M EXTREMELY SENSITIVE TO WHAT OUR STUDENTS ARE MISSING AND HOW POPULAR THIS PARTICULAR COURSE IS. NOBODY'S INVESTIGATING AP CHEM, NOBODY'S INVESTIGATING AP LIT, NOBODY'S INVESTIGATING ANYTHING IN THIS COUNTRY EXCEPT AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. YOU ARE REALLY, REALLY TAKING A DEEP DIVE INTO THIS PARTICULAR COURSE. IT IS UGLY. OUR HISTORY IS UGLY. BUT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE UNDERSTAND IT. WE KNOW THAT THIS COURSE IS RIGOROUS. IT REQUIRES THAT STUDENTS ANALYZE,

[01:35:01]

COMPARE AND CONTRAST, EXTRAPOLATE COMPARED TO SOME OTHER HISTORICAL EVENT. IT IS VERY RIGOROUS. BUT BECAUSE IT'S UNCOMFORTABLE, MAYBE IF STUDENTS SEE HOW UNCOMFORTABLE THIS IS, THEY WON'T REVISIT THE CONDITIONS THAT LED THEM TO THAT UGLY PAST. MAYBE OUR FUTURE WILL BE BRIGHTER BECAUSE THEY UNDERSTAND THAT HISTORY, EVEN BETTER. THEY HAVE THE INFORMATION TO CHANGE HISTORY, TO MAKE IT BETTER. SO PLEASE, OF ALL THE CLASSES THAT YOU ALL ARE LOOKING AT, WHY THIS ONE, ASK YOURSELF AND I IMPLORE YOU, PLEASE, ONE MUSEUM. IF YOU GO TO ANY, GO TO THE LEGACY MUSEUM IN MONTGOMERY, ALABAMA AND LEARN YOUR US HISTORY. YES NEXT WE HAVE JEREMIAH PETTIJOHN FOLLOWED BY K FLOW. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS JEREMIAH PETTIJOHN, I'M A STUDENT AT HAVRE DE GRACE HIGH SCHOOL, WHERE I'M SERVING AS THE VICE PRESIDENT OF STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION, I'M THE DRUM MAJOR OF OUR MARCHING BAND, AND I'M THE MEMBER OF SEVERAL OTHER ORGANIZATIONS I HAVE ENJOYED OVER THE YEARS, TAKING AP CLASSES SINCE THE NINTH GRADE, AND I WAS ALSO RECOMMENDED TO TAKE THIS CLASS.

BUT OF COURSE, NOW I CAN'T, THROUGHOUT MY YEARS I HAVE, THAT I'VE BEEN ENROLLED HERE, I HAVE WITNESSED SIGNIFICANT NEGLECT REGARDING DIVERSITY. GROWING UP IN MARYLAND, I HAVE IT HAS SHOWN ME THE IMPORTANCE OF INCORPORATING CLASSES THAT FOSTER A COMMUNITY OF LOVE, COMPASSION, AND KINDNESS TOWARDS ALL. WE ARE ALL GATHERED HERE TODAY TO EXPRESS OUR OPINIONS ON THE RECENT DECISION TO REMOVE AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES FROM OUR SCHOOLS. THIS DECISION DEEPLY CONCERNS ME AS IT UNDERMINES THE PROGRESS WE HAVE TOWARDS CREATING AN INCLUSIVE AND RESPECTFUL EDUCATION ENVIRONMENT. MY QUESTION IS WHY? WHY ARE WE TAKING STEPS BACKWARD INSTEAD OF MOVING FORWARD? WHY IS THE WELL-BEING OF OUR STUDENTS NOT THE PRIMARY FOCUS? WHY IS DIVERSITY SEEN AS AN OPPONENT? RATHER THAN RECOGNIZING THAT THE TRUE ISSUE IS THE LACK OF DIVERSITY, WILL THERE EVER BE A MOMENT IN TIME WHEN OUR MAIN FOCUS IS ON THE WELL-BEING OF THE STUDENTS? WILL THERE EVER BE A TIME WHEN DIVERSITY IS AN OPPONENT? BUT THE LACK OF DIVERSITY? LIKE I SAID, WILL IT EVER BE? IT IS TIME FOR US TO TAKE A STAND AND ADVOCATE FOR AN EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM THAT WILL EMBRACE AND CELEBRATE ALL HISTORIES AND ALL CULTURES. THIS IS NOT JUST ABOUT ADDING A SUBJECT TO THE CURRICULUM, IT'S ABOUT ACKNOWLEDGING AND RESPECTING THE EXPERIENCES AND CONTRIBUTIONS OF AFRICAN AFRICAN AMERICANS AND ENSURING THAT ALL STUDENTS RECEIVE A WELL-ROUNDED AND INCLUSIVE EDUCATION. LET'S WORK TOGETHER TO CREATE A FUTURE WHERE DIVERSITY IS CELEBRATED AND NOT FEARED. THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING, MY NAME IS KEITH LOW. I AM HERE ON BEHALF OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE HARFORD COUNTY NAACP. AND I AM GOING TO GO AHEAD AND START AT THE END BECAUSE OUR TIMELINE HAS CHANGED. TO, TO BEGIN TO RECTIFY THE HARM THAT HAS BEEN DONE BY THIS DECISION THAT YOU'VE OBVIOUSLY HEARD TONIGHT, WE'RE ASKING THE NAACP IS ASKING THAT THERE IS AN IMMEDIATE RECONSIDERATION OF YOUR DECISION AND A FULL APPROVAL OF THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM FOR IMPLEMENTATION AS AN OPTIONAL, OPTIONAL ELECTIVE COURSE AT ALL PLANNED HARFORD COUNTY SCHOOLS. LET ME JUST SAY, MR. BOYNTON, I APPRECIATED YOUR STATEMENT AT THE BEGINNING OF THIS SESSION, AND I, I, TOO, WISH FOR US TO HAVE MUTUAL RESPECT AS WE LOOK AT THIS ISSUE. AS YOU CAN SEE BY THE DIVERSITY OF THE NAACP AND THE ROOM, THIS ALL THAT HAS SHOWN UP IN THIS ROOM TO ASK THAT OUR YOUTH HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN IN A GUIDED MANNER. I HAVE RECEIVED THE CURRICULUM IN THREE DIFFERENT SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM. THAT MEANS OUR YOUTH ALREADY HAVE ACCESS TO IT. WE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE EDUCATORS WALK OUR YOUNG PEOPLE THROUGH THIS, AND AS YOU CAN SEE AND AS YOU'VE HEARD TONIGHT, OUR YOUNG PEOPLE ARE WAY MORE ADVANCED THAN WE ARE. THEY ARE ALREADY DISCUSSING THINGS ON A LEVEL THAT WE SHOULD BE PROUD OF. THEM BEING ABLE TO DISCUSS, RECONSIDER WHAT HAS BEEN DONE. HISTORY IS LOOKING AT US RIGHT NOW. THIS DECISION IS BEING MARKED IN HISTORY AS DIVISIVE. MAKE A DECISION THAT WILL BRING OUR COMMUNITY TOGETHER. THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE FRED HAMEL, FOLLOWED BY ANNIE BEESON. FRED

[01:40:08]

HAMEL OR ANNIE BEESON. HI. GOOD EVENING AND THANK YOU TO THE BOARD FOR ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK TONIGHT. I AM A MOM OF TWO STUDENTS WHO ATTEND EMERSON ELEMENTARY SCHOOL AS A MEMBER OF THE PTA AND A ROOM PARENT. MOST KIDS KNOW ME AS MISS OWEN'S MOM OR MRS. AARON'S MOMMY. LET ME BE CLEAR. I AM NOT HERE REPRESENTING THE SCHOOL, BUT RATHER AS ONE OF ITS BIGGEST FANS. I AM NOT AN EXPERT IN EDUCATION. I DON'T HAVE A HISTORY OR LITERATURE DEGREE, BUT I HAVE LEARNED SOME THINGS DURING OUR TIME AT EMERSON AND I DO HAVE SOME COMMON SENSE. THE EAGLES HAVE SORT OF A SCHOOL SLOGAN, AND IT SAYS WITH OPEN MINDS, OPEN HEARTS AND OPEN HANDS WILL SOAR. I AM HERE TO RESPECTFULLY ASK THIS BOARD OF EDUCATION TO REFLECT UPON THE WAYS IN WHICH YOU ARE HELPING OUR COMMUNITY TO SOAR. WILL YOU IGNORE? WILL YOU IGNORE THE UPDATED SOCIAL STUDIES CURRICULUM PROPOSAL, THEREBY RISKING A LOSS OF STATE FUNDING FOR OUR ENTIRE DISTRICT? WILL YOU FILL IN THE GAPS WHEN UNSUPPORTED TEACHERS AND STAFF INEVITABLY WALK AWAY FROM THEIR CLASSROOMS IN THIS DISTRICT, SOME PACKED WITH 30 OR MORE EIGHT AND NINE YEAR OLDS? WILL YOU IGNORE YOUR COMMUNITY OF GATHERED EXPERTS, EDUCATORS, STUDENTS AND SCHOLARS THAT ARE GATHERED HERE TODAY? OR WILL YOU APPROACH THESE VOTES WITH OPEN HEARTS AND OPEN MINDS IN MUCH THE SAME WAY THAT WE ASK OUR SIX, EIGHT, AND TEN YEAR OLD FRIENDS TO DO IN THEIR CLASSROOMS EVERY DAY? THANK YOU, NEXT, DO WE HAVE JASON KING AND RYAN BURBY? GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS JASON KING, AND I'M A SOCIAL STUDIES TEACHER AT JOPPATOWNE HIGH SCHOOL, AS WELL AS A MEMBER OF THE HCA BOARD OF DIRECTORS. I COME BEFORE YOU TONIGHT TO ASK A SIMPLE QUESTION. WHAT ARE YOU DOING? I'VE BEEN ATTENDING MEETINGS REGULARLY FOR THE PAST YEAR AND VOICED MY OPINION, MOSTLY AGAINST THE POLICIES THAT THE BOARD OF ED IS TRYING TO IMPLEMENT BECAUSE AS A TEACHER AND A PARENT, I FEEL THAT THEY ARE RESTRICTING STUDENT LEARNING AND TONIGHT IS NO DIFFERENT. AS I WATCHED THE LAST BOARD MEETING AND HEARD ADULTS COMMENTS ABOUT HOW THERE WAS NOT ENOUGH POSITIVE IMAGERY OR HOW CERTAIN CURRICULUM DID NOT MEET THE STANDARDS OF CERTAIN BOARD MEMBERS. A THOUGHT CROSSED MY MIND. WHERE WERE THE STUDENTS WHO OPPOSE THESE CLASSES? IF THE CONTENT BEING TAUGHT IN THESE CLASSES WERE TRULY AN ISSUE, THEN I WOULD HAVE EXPECTED HUNDREDS OF STUDENTS TO SPEAK OUT AGAINST THESE CLASSES. MOST OF THE OPPOSITION HAS COME FROM A HANDFUL OF BOARD MEMBERS.

SINCE I TEACH AT A SCHOOL THAT OFFERS BOTH CLASSES, I'VE HAD THE CHANCE TO TALK TO NUMEROUS STUDENTS WHO ARE ENROLLED IN ONE OR BOTH CLASSES, AND I CAN TELL YOU THAT THERE HAS BEEN A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF POSITIVE FEEDBACK FROM STUDENTS. THESE CLASSES ALLOW STUDENTS TO SEE HISTORY THROUGH A DIFFERENT LEN, AND ALLOW STUDENTS TO LEARN ABOUT EVENTS THAT ARE NOT TAUGHT IN THE TRADITIONAL US HISTORY CLASS. ANOTHER POINT I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE IS THAT THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY AND WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE CLASSES ARE ELECTIVES. THIS MEANS THAT STUDENTS HAVE A CHOICE. THESE CLASSES ARE NOT PART OF GRADUATION REQUIREMENTS. IF A STUDENT HAS A PROBLEM WITH THE CONTENT OR MATERIAL, THE STUDENT CAN CHOOSE NOT TO TAKE IT. SO I ASK YOU AGAIN, WHAT ARE YOU DOING? WERE YOU ELECTED OR APPOINTED TO SERVE YOUR OWN POLITICAL AGENDA OR TO DO WHAT IS BEST FOR THE STUDENTS OF HARFORD COUNTY? YOUR VOTE TONIGHT WILL ANSWER THOSE QUESTIONS. THANK YOU. HEAR, HEA. NEXT WE HAVE NOAH MYERS, FOLLOWED BY DIANE CHRISTIE. ALL RIGHT. MEMBERS OF THE BOARD. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS NOAH MYERS, AND I'M HERE TO SHOW MY SUPPORT FOR THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY COURSE, GETTING REGULAR STATUS AS IS. MEMBERS OF THIS BOARD HAVE DENIED THIS CLASS REGULAR STATUS WITH FALSE APPEALS TO BALANCE OR DECENCY, AND HAVE RAISED OBJECTIONS THAT THE COURSE PROMOTES ACTIVISM AND PROTEST, WHICH IS INHERENTLY CONTRADICTORY BECAUSE THESE ARE IDEALS THAT THIS COUNTRY WAS FOUNDED ON. IT IS AMAZING WHEN PEOPLE BECOME COMFORTABLE OR SORRY, MY BAD. IT IS AMAZING HOW WHEN PEOPLE BECOME COMFORTABLE IN THEIR PRIVILEGE, THEY WANT TO FORGET THE PAST AND HOW WHEN PEOPLE WHO ARE COMFORTABLE WITH THEIR PRIVILEGE GAIN POWER, THEY THEN WANT TO DENY OTHER GROUPS THE OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN ABOUT SAID PAST. THERE HAVE BEEN NUMEROUS STUDENTS WHO HAVE TAKEN THIS CLASS AND SPEAK HIGHLY OF IT, AND WHO HAVE HAD AN OFFENSIVE THAT THIS BOARD BELIEVES THEY ARE NOT CAPABLE OF TAKING IN THIS MATERIAL. DOES THIS MEAN THE MEMBERS OF THE

[01:45:01]

BOARD BELIEVE THEY HAVE FAILED STUDENTS TO TEACH, FAIL TO TEACH STUDENTS TO BE ABLE TO THINK CRITICALLY? THE MEMBERS OF THIS BOARD OF EDUCATION AND THE GROUPS THEY ARE A PART OF HAVE SHOUTED LOUDLY ABOUT SUPPRESSING AND CENSORING HISTORY. IF YOU WERE ACTUALLY AGAINST THAT, YOU WOULDN'T BE CENSORING THIS AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY CLASS. SARAH, DIANE, CHRISTY. GRETCHEN LINDSEY FOLLOWED BY ANN PAIGE GARDNER. SORRY. CAN YOU HEAR ME? OKAY.

GOOD EVENING, DOCTOR BOLSON, BOARD MEMBERS AND GUESTS. MY NAME IS GRETCHEN LINDSEY, A PROUD READING TEACHER AT SOUTHAMPTON MIDDLE SCHOOL. I HOPE THAT THOSE ON THE BOARD THAT DID NOT APPROVE THE GRADE SIX HUMAN GEOGRAPHY CURRICULUM AND THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE WILL RECONSIDER AND APPROVE THESE COURSES FOR HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS.

TEACHING HISTORY FROM DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES IS ESSENTIAL AND NECESSARY FOR ALL GRADE LEVELS, AS WELL AS THE GENERAL PUBLIC. HOW CAN WE LEARN FROM OUR PAST IF WE DO NOT SEE THE PAST FROM DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES? WHY ARE WE SO SCARED? AND I WILL END WITH ONE OF MY FAVORITE QUOTES FEAR LEADS TO ANGER. ANGER LEADS TO HATE, AND HATE LEADS TO SUFFERING. THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO VOICE MY OPINION. AND PAIGE GARDNER FOLLOWED BY HEATHER TOCCI. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS ANN PAIGE GARDNER. I'M A RETIRED EDUCATOR FROM HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND THE PROUD GREAT GRANDMOTHER OF SIX CHILDREN WHO ARE CURRENTLY ENROLLED IN HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS. IT HAS BEEN SUGGESTED THAT WE STUDY HISTORY TO HELP US UNDERSTAND HOW EVENTS IN THE PAST MADE THINGS THE WAY THEY ARE TODAY. UNDERSTANDING THE PRESENT AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT PROVIDES INFORMATION SO THAT WE NOT ONLY LEARN ABOUT OURSELVES AND HOW WE CAME TO BE, BUT TO ALSO DEVELOP THE ABILITY TO AVOID MISTAKES AND CREATE BETTER PATHS FOR OUR SOCIETY.

BUT WE CAN ONLY AC IF WE ARE WIO PRESENT THE TOTAL PICTURE. THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY. SOME OF THAT PICTURE IS DEFINITELY GOOD, SOME IS BAD, AND SOME IS JUST PLAIN UGLY. BUT BY PRESENTING ALL THE FACTS, WE ENABLE OUR STUDENTS TO THOUGHTFULLY EXAMINE AND DISCUSS HOW EVENTS FROM THOSE CATEGORIES CONTRIBUTED TO THE WORLD. IN OUR COUNTRY AS WE KNOW IT TODAY.

THAT EXAMINATION WILL SURELY RESULT IN IDENTIFYING EVENTS TO CELEBRATE. IT WILL ALSO RESULT IN THE RECOGNITION OF PAINFUL MOMENTS, WHICH IS NOT MEANT TO PLACE BLAME OR TO MAKE STUDENTS FEEL RESPONSIBLE FOR ACTIONS BEYOND THEIR CONTROL, BUT TO EXPAND THEIR UNDERSTANDINGS OF THE TRUTH OF THOSE UGLY EVENTS. SO THAT WE WILL MOVE FORWARD, NOT REPEAT OUR ANCESTORS MISTAKES. I RESPECTFULLY ASK THE BOARD MEMBERS TO RECONSIDER THEIR VOTE. OUR STUDENTS AND OUR COUNTRY DESERVE AND NEED ALL THE FACTS IN ORDER TO CREATE BETTER PATHS FOR OUR DEMOCRACY. I URGE YOU TO VOTE IN FAVOR OF GRANTING AP AFRICAN AMERICAN REGULAR STATUS. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.

GOOD EVENING. I COME TO YOU. SPEAK. OOPS. THERE GOES MY MINUTES. SORRY, SORRY. OH, MY TIME IS TICKING TO. OH, JEEZ, I COME TO YOU SPEAK ABOUT THE CURRICULAR ISSUES ON THE AGENDA TONIGHT. MY COMMENTS CAN BE DRILLED DOWN TO THREE WORDS HYPOCRISY, PROJECTION AND IGNORANCE. THE HYPOCRISY OF THE BOARD'S COMMENTS TO THE MEDIA IS ALMOST LAUGHABLE. OUT OF ONE SIDE OF YOUR MOUTH, YOU SPEAK ABOUT PARENTAL CHOICE WHEN SPEAKING ABOUT THE SIXTH GRADE CURRICULUM, AND WHY YOU DON'T WANT TO IMPLEMENT THAT. WHERE'S THE PARENTAL CHOICE WHEN IT COMES TO AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES OR WOMEN HISTORY? NOTHING SAYS MORE ABOUT CHOICE THAN ELECTIVES IN A PUBLIC HIGH SCHOOL ARENA. HOWEVER, YOU WANT TO TAKE THE PARENTAL AND STUDENT CHOICE AWAY, IT IS CLEARLY YOUR CHOICE AS A PARENT TO STEAL YOUR STUDENT AWAY FROM THAT CLASS OF ANY ELECTED CLASSES OFFERED IN HIGH SCHOOLS, IT IS SIMPLE. REGISTER FOR ANOTHER CLASS. STOP TRYING TO IMPART YOUR IGNORANCE ON ALL OF US. PROJECT PROJECTION STOP BLAMING EDUCATORS FOR INDOCTRINATING. INDOCTRINATING THE STUDENTS OF CPS. AS A TAXPAYER WITH NO CHILDREN IN

[01:50:03]

CPS, IT CLEARLY LOOKS LIKE THE INDOCTRINATION IS COMING FROM YOU. MY DAUGHTER IS LOOKING FOR HER FOREVER HOME IN HARFORD COUNTY. WE HAVE HAD MANY CONVERSATIONS ABOUT THE DIRECTION OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION IS TRYING TO MOVE THE EDUCATION IN HARFORD COUNTY TOWARDS. I WOULD MUCH RATHER THAT MY GRANDDAUGHTER BE EDUCATED IN A FORWARD THINKING, INCLUSIVE ENVIRONMENT AND MY DAUGHTER AGREES. HOW MANY OTHER INFORMED PARENTS ARE GOING TO CHOOSE ANOTHER COUNTY? HOW WILL YOUR RADICAL BOARD? HOW MUCH WILL YOUR RADICAL BOARD COST? MR. CASLEY AND THE COUNTY AND TAXES IGNORANCE? I READ IN THE MEDIA THAT A BOARD MEMBER SAID THAT THEY WANTED TO NOT OFFER AMERICAN STUDIES BECAUSE IT WAS NOT POSITIVE ENOUGH AND TOO DIVISIVE. SO UNDER THIS STATEMENT, THE SCHOOL SYSTEM, IT WILL NOT TEACH ANY HISTORY THAT IS NOT POSITIVE OR. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, THANK YOU. NOW I'M SORRY, MA'AM. WE SHOULD NOT BE PRAYING FOR THE WORLD OUTSIDE THE PARK COUNTY HISTORY IS DIVISIVE SHORTHAND THAT GOES WAY BACK. TO. DAVID ELTRINGHAM. IS THERE A DAVID ELTRINGHAM? YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO SPEAK UP. WE HAVE. QUIET, PLEASE. NEXT WE HAVE DAVID ELTRINGHAM, FOLLOWED BY CHRISTINA LANCIA. I FIND THAT VERY RUDE. I'M HERE THIS EVENING TO LEND MY VOICE ON BEHALF OF THE STUDENTS. IT IS MY DESIRE TO SHARE MY EARNEST BELIEFS REGARDING THESE PROPOSED AP COURSES. I AM A BELIEVER IN EDUCATION AND WANT OUR STUDENTS TO HAVE EVERY LEARNING OPPORTUNITY POSSIBLE. BUT WHAT THEY ARE TAUGHT IN THIS PUBLIC ARENA MAY BE BASED ON MAY BE BASED ON HISTORICAL FACTS. A DISTORTION, A DISTORTION OF HISTORY AND FACTS TO CREATE A NARRATIVE THAT IS ULTIMATELY TEARING DOWN OUR SOCIETY AND IS INTENTIONAL. THE AGENDA IS USING YOUNG, IMPRESSIONABLE MINDS TO ACCOMPLISH THIS. MY HEART ACHES FOR THESE STUDENTS WHO ARE BEING LED TO BELIEVE THIS CURRICULUM, AN AGENDA THAT HAS ITS ROOTS IN MARXISM. SHE PROVES IT TRUE HISTORY TEACHES THOSE WHO ARE TEACHABLE, AND MARXISM ULTIMATELY DESTROYS, DESTROYS BODY, MIND, AND SPIRIT. WE SEE THE AGENDA IN MANY AREAS OF OUR LIVES TODAY, AND IT'S DISHEARTENING TO SAY THE LEAST. THE BOARD DID RIGHT NOT TO APPROVE THESE AP COURSES, AND I MUST, I MUST DO RIGHT AS A TAXPAYER IN HARFORD COUNTY TO SPEAK, ABOUT THESE COURSES. ALSO HOWEVER, IT'S NOT ABOUT TAXES. THIS IS ABOUT THE EROSION OF OUR PUBLIC EDUCATION. AND MY DESIRE TO DO WHAT I CAN DO TO PROTECT THE MINDS OF OPERATIONAL STUDENTS. IDENTITY POLITICS HAS NO PLACE IN OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS. GOOD LORD, THERE'S SO MUCH WE CAN LEARN ABOUT OUR HISTORY. WHY IS THIS STUCK IN ONE SPOT? CITIZENS OF THE FORMER SOVIET UNION BLOC HAVE WARNED THE THAT AMERICA IS SHOWING TELLTALE SIGNS OF VERY OF THE VERY EVILS THAT PLAGUE THEM, AND THESE EVILS ARE ALL ALL BEGAN WITH PSYCHOLOGICAL MANIPULATION. THESE COURSES ARE JUST THAT. WE MUST RESIST THE AGENDA. ALEXANDER SOLZHENITSYN GAVE US A QUOTE. HE SAID, LIVE NOT BY LIES. SO THIS IS WHAT WE MUST D. GET TO THE TRUTH, FOLKS. WE CAN ALL GO TOGETHER THERE. ALRIGHT.

GOOD EVENING. THANK YOU. YES, WE DO NEED GOD BACK IN OUR SCHOOLS. JESUS SAID, I AM THE WAY THE TRUTH AND THE LIFE. NO ONE COMES TO THE FATHER EXCEPT THROUGH ME. WE DO NEED TO TELL OUR CHILDREN THE WHOLE TRUTH ABOUT OUR HISTORY, NOT MINIMIZING THE POSITIVE CHANGES THAT HAVE BEEN MADE AND NOT SUGARCOATING THE HORRIBLE PARTS OF OUR HISTORY. I DO AGREE WITH THAT. THAT, FOR EXAMPLE, IN THE WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE CURRICULUM RESOURCES, MARGARET SANGER IS GLORIFIED RATHER THAN BEING PRESENTED IN FULL TRUTH REGARDING HER BEING A EUGENICIST AND A RACIST. THE FOLLOWING IS A QUOTE FROM MARGARET SANGER SAID IN A DECEMBER 1939 LETTER TO DOCTOR C.J. GAMBLE, WE DO NOT WANT WORD TO GO OUT THAT WE WANT TO EXTERMINATE THE POPULATION.

AND THE MINISTER IS THE MAN WHO CAN STRAIGHTEN OUT THAT IDEA. IF IT EVER OCCURS TO ANY OF THEIR

[01:55:02]

MORE REBELLIOUS MEMBERS. THE SAME 1939 LETTER SHOWS SANGER SAYING, I KNOW THAT YOU DOUBT IT WORTHWHILE TO EMPLOY A FULL TIME PHYSICIAN. IT SEEMS TO ME FROM MY EXPERIENCE ALL I HAVE BEEN IN NORTH CAROLINA, GEORGIA, TENNESSEE AND TEXAS THAT WHILE THE COLORED NEGROES HAVE GREAT RESPECT FOR WHITE DOCTORS, THEY CAN GET CLOSER TO THEIR OWN MEMBERS AND MORE OR LESS LAY THEIR CARDS ON THE TABLE, WHICH MEANS THEIR IGNORANT SUPERSTITIONS AND DOUBTS. MORE OF SANGER'S WORDS ARE FROM AN ARTICLE TITLED A BETTER RACE THROUGH BIRTH CONTROL. SHE SAYS GIVING BIRTH CONTROL THE UNFIT WILL VOLUNTARILY ELIMINATE THEIR KIND. BIRTH CONTROL DOES NOT MEAN CONTRACEPTION IS INDISCRIMINATELY PRACTICED, SHE WROTE. IT MEANS THE RELEASE AND CULTIVATION OF THE BETTER ELEMENTS IN OUR SOCIETY. MARGARET SANGER IS NOT SOMEONE WE WANT TO LOOK AT AS A HERO. MARGARET SANGER PROACTIVELY MOVED TO ELIMINATE THOSE SHE DEEMED UNFIT, INCLUDING THE AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION. I ADVOCATE FOR TELLING THE UNVARNISHED TRUTH ABOUT HER AND HER VIEWS ON THE AFRICAN AMERICAN POPULATION. MAY GOD BLESS YOU WITH WISDOM AND GUIDANCE IN ALL YOUR DECISION MAKING. NEXT WE HAVE JORDAN COOK FOLLOWED BY REVEREND C HUNTER. HELLO. OKAY. HI, MY NAME IS JORDAN COOK. I'M A STUDENT AT TOWSON UNIVERSITY, AND I'M SPEAKING HERE TODAY ABOUT THE CONCERNS I HAVE REGARDING THE CANCELLATION OF THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM. SO AP SO THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM WAS IMPLEMENTED IN SCHOOL RIGHT AFTER I GRADUATED HIGH SCHOOL, SO I MISSED OUT ON IT. UNFORTUNATELY BUT GROWING UP IN HARFORD COUNTY, I DID NOT WITNESS A LOT OF DIVERSITY IN THE SCHOOL CURRICULUM. IT WAS ONLY IN FEBRUARY WHERE I WITNESSED A LITTLE BIT OF DIVERSITY AND REPRESENTATION, BUT STILL IT WAS THE SAME HISTORICAL FIGURES ROSA PARKS, DOCTOR MARTIN LUTHER KING AND HARRIET TUBMAN. OF COURSE, THOUGH, THESE FIGURES ARE AMAZING TO LEARN ABOUT, THERE ARE MORE POWERFUL BLACK PEOPLE WHO EXISTED IN HISTORY THAT MEAN OTHER STUDENTS COULD HAVE LEARNED ABOUT. AND I WISH THAT WE DID LEARN ABOUT OUTSIDE OF SCHOOL. I SPENT A LOT OF TIME READING, RESEARCHING, AND LEARNING, AND THEN RELEARNING ABOUT THE RICHNESS OF AFRICAN CULTURE. I HAD TO TEACH MYSELF THAT MY ANCESTORS HISTORY DIDN'T START WITH ENSLAVEMENT, EVEN THOUGH THAT'S WHAT I FELT MY HIGH SCHOOL WAS TEACHING ME, TEACHING ME. AND TO BEGIN WITH, BECAUSE THE NEGATIVE IMPACTS I ENDURED AS A RESULT OF NOT SEEING DIVERSITY AND REPRESENTATION AS IT PERTAINED TO AFRICAN CULTURE, I CREATED MY OWN CURRICULUM THAT I'M TEACHING MIDDLE SCHOOL STUDENTS, AND IT'S TITLED HEALING CULTURES OF COLO. THE TOPICS I TEACH IN MY STUDENTS ABOUT ONE OF THEM. ONE OF THEM HAPPENS TO BE AFRICAN AMERICAN CULTURE. AND THESE STUDENTS WHO ARE MIDDLE SCHOOLERS ABSOLUTELY, ABSOLUTELY ADORE IT. THEY ARE REALLY INTERESTED IN IT. THEY'RE INTERESTED IN DOING THE HANDS, HANDS ON ARTWORK INSPIRED BY AFRICAN CULTURE. AND THEY ARE ALWAYS APPRECIATIVE OF IT. SO IF THIS CHOICE IS MADE TO REMOVE THE AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM, IT COULD BE ONE OF THE BIGGEST DISADVANTAGES. WE GIVE OUR STUDENTS FOR YOUNG BLACK STUDENTS AND THE AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THEM TO FEEL REPRESENTED AND EMPOWERED. SO I'M GOING TO ASK THIS SINCE THERE IS SO MUCH POSITIVE AND IMPACTFUL MODERN MATERIAL WE CAN CONTINUE TO EMBED INTO THE AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM. WHY WOULD WE EVER THINK ABOUT TAKING THE COURSE AWAY TO BEGIN WITH? WE WILL REAP MORE NEGATIVE REPERCUSSIONS FROM THIS THAN POSITIVE ONES, AND THIS COULD. MEAN ALL I'M MOST A RESIDENT OF THIS ILLUSTRIOUS COUNTY FOR THE MOST PART, I COME TO SUPPORT, THE INCLUSION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY APPROACH AND LEARNING EXPERIENCES IN THIS PARTICULAR COUNTY. AS AN EDUCATOR OF MORE THAN 50 YEARS, WE FOUND OUT THAT WE PRACTICE INCLUSION, AND WE WANT TO PROVIDE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR STUDENTS TO DO CRITICAL THINKING, TO DO ANALYSIS, AND NOT DO THOSE THINGS BY WHICH THEY CAN THINK AND THEY CAN MAKE DECISIONS BASED UPON ACCURATE, AND COMPLETED AND COMPREHENSIVE, INFORMATION. WE ALSO WANT TO SHARE AN ABSENCE OF THE OVERRIDING OPPORTUNITIES OF EXCELLENT LEARNING EXPERIENCE FOR ALL STUDENTS, ESPECIALLY BLACK AND BROWN ASPIRANTS COULD BE VIEWED AS THE FOLLOWING.

NUMBER ONE, LACKING A VISION FOR STUDENT AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT. NUMBER TWO INEFFECTIVE SCHOOL POLICIES AND PROCEDURES. NUMBER THREE MARGINALIZE THE CLIMATE FOR LEARNING UNDER DIMENSIONS OF LEARNING. ONE, TWO, AND THREE AND LEADERSHIP THAT FAILS TO MODEL FOR ANTICIPATED STUDENT EXCELLENCE RATHER THAN MEDIOCRITY. IT ALSO, YOUR

[02:00:05]

DECISION IS AN INDICATION OF THE INSENSITIVITY TO DIE, THEREBY PERPETUATING THE STATUS QUO OF INTENTIONAL INTENSIVE AND SYSTEMATIC RACISM. IT ALSO SHOWS THERE'S AN INDICATION IN TERMS OF THAT THE WHITE SUPREMACY IS THE ORDER OF THE DAY, AND WHEREAS IT'S THE INCLUSION OF THIS OF THIS, OF THIS PROGRAM WOULD PROVIDE AN OPPORTUNITY BY WHICH STUDENTS WOULD LEARN ABOUT THEMSELVES. AND AS THEY LEARN ABOUT THEMSELVES, THEY LEARN ABOUT OTHERS. WAS THERE A JORDAN COOK? JORDAN COOK OKAY, OKAY. AMBER HOPKINS FOLLOWED BY FELICIA HOPKINS. HELLO MY NAME IS AMBER HOPKINS. I'M A SENIOR AT MORGAN STATE UNIVERSITY, AND I HAVE A COMMENT TO MAKE ABOUT THE REMOVAL OF THE AFRICAN AMERICAN AP STUDIES. SO I WANT TO EMPHASIZE, FIRST OF ALL, THE IMPORTANCE OF HISTORICAL INTEGRITY. IT DOESN'T MATTER HOW DIVISIVE YOU FEEL THAT THE CURRICULUM IS. HOW MANY PEOPLE DO YOU TRUST THAT HAVE LIED TO YOU OR SUGAR COATED THE TRUTH TO YOU? HOW MANY PEOPLE IN YOUR LIFE DO YOU FEEL COMFORTABLE LISTENING TO? FORMULATING YOUR OPINIONS AROUND AND THEY HAVE LIED TO YOU. NOT MANY OR ANY AT ALL, ESPECIALLY AS A BLACK AMERICAN STUDENT. WHEN I LEARNED THE TRUTH OF HOW GRUESOME SLAVERY WAS, ENSLAVED PEOPLE BEING, THEIR SKIN BEING MADE INTO A FURNITURE, I FROM THAT POINT ON, I COULDN'T EVEN TRUST.

LOOK AT THE GOVERNMENT. LOOK AT THE PEOPLE WHO WERE TEACHING ME THESE THINGS, THE SAME WAY I HAVE. I WENT TO AN ELEMENTARY. I WENT TO PATTERSON MILL. I GRADUATED IN 2019. SO I HAVE NOT TAKEN THIS COURSE. BUT ONCE THE STUDENTS LEARN THE TRUTH ABOUT HISTORY, WHAT DO YOU THINK THAT THEY'RE GOING TO FEEL ABOUT THE GOVERNMENT? THAT'S MORE DIVISIVE, LYING? IT'S GOING TO BE IT'S GOING TO DIVIDE THEM MORE IF YOU LIE TO THEM RATHER THAN TELLING THEM THE TRUTH.

EVERYTHING ABOUT AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS NOT PEACHES AND CREAM. AND TO THIS DAY, I'M STILL LEARNING ABOUT THE WHOLE AFRICAN DIASPORA. I'M STILL LEARNING ABOUT MYSELF AND MY CULTURAL BACKGROUND. AND IT'S IMPORTANT NOT JUST TO AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDENTS, BUT STUDENTS OF ALL RACES. SO THEY DON'T HAVE ANY UNCONSCIOUS BIASES AGAINST THEIR PEERS. AND HOPEFULLY THIS OPENS A CONVERSATION AND ALLOWS OTHER CURRICULUMS TO BE MADE FOR OTHER.

GOOD EVENING. MEMBERS OF THE HARFORD COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION. MY NAME IS FELICIA HOPKINS AND I REPRESENT THE YOUTH ENRICHMENT SOCIETY OF HARFORD COUNTY, A NONPROFIT THAT SUPPORTS YOUTH THROUGH COMMUNITY SERVICE, LEADERSHIP, COLLEGE SCHOLARSHIPS, AND ADMISSION FEES. I'M HERE TODAY TO ADVOCATE FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM IN ALL HIGH SCHOOLS IN HARFORD COUNTY IN THE INTEREST OF TIME, I'M GOING TO CUT MY SPEECH DOWN. UNDERSTANDING AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS CRUCIAL BECAUSE IT PROVIDES A COMPREHENSIVE AND ACCURATE REPRESENTATION OF THE UNITED STATES PAST. AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS AMERICAN HISTORY. IT ENCOMPASSES THE STRUGGLES, ACHIEVEMENTS, AND CONTRIBUTIONS OF AFRICAN AMERICANS WHO HAVE HELPED SHAPE OUR NATION FROM THE INJUSTICES OF SLAVERY AND SEGREGATION, TO THE TRIUMPHS OF THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT AND BEYOND. THESE STORIES ARE VITAL TO UNDERSTANDING THE COMPLEXITIES AND PROGRESS OF OUR COUNTRY.

MOREOVER, MUTUAL LIBERATION OF ALL RACES ARE INTERTWINED WITH THE ACCURATE REPRESENTATION OF HISTORY. BY ACKNOWLEDGING AND TEACHING THE REALITIES OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY AND EXPERIENCES, WE PAVED THE WAY FOR GREATER UNITY AND SOLIDARITY AMONG DIFFERENT RACIAL AND ETHNIC GROUPS TO ADDRESS DIRECTLY THE BOARD OF EDUCATION MEMBER WHO STATED THAT PRESENTING AN AP AFRICAN AMERICAN COURSE IN ITS PRESENT STATE WOULD, AND I QUOTE, PERPETUATE THE STIGMA OF VICTIMHOOD. I HAD TO PAUSE AT THE ASSESSMENT AND LOOK UP AT THE ACTUAL MEANING OF THAT IN THE WEBSTER'S DICTIONARY. VICTIMHOOD IS A CONDITION OF HAVING BEEN HURT, DAMAGED, OR MADE TO SUFFER, ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU WANT PEOPLE TO FEEL SORRY

[02:05:05]

FOR YOU. BECAUSE OF THIS USE OF EXCUSE OF SOMETHING. MY RESPONSE TO THIS IS AS FOLLOWS. WE DO NOT WANT PEOPLE TO FEEL SORRY FOR US BECAUSE WE CELEBRATE HOW WE FEEL OR TALK ABOUT THE DARKER SIDES OF HISTORY. WE SEEK TO UNDERSTAND WHAT MADE AMERICA THE WAY IT IS TODAY. THE TERM VICTIMHOOD CAN BE A SUPPLE FROM FORM OF DISRESPECT TO AN ENTIRE RACE, AND IT IMPLIES THAT OUR LIVED EXPERIENCES WERE NOT REAL AND SHOULD NOT BE DOWNPLAYED OR ONLY DISCUSSED PAST. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE JESSICA FENDRICK, FOLLOWED BY BONNIE KNUTSEN. SARAH JESSICA FENDRICK.

I'M BONNIE KNUTSON. I'LL GO FIRST SINCE JESS IS ON HER WAY DOWN. I'M GOING TO KEEP IT REALLY, REALLY BRIEF TONIGHT. MY COMMENTS ARE TO THE FIVE OF YOU. YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE BY NOW. I DON'T MEAN TO SAY YOUR NAMES. THE AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CLASS IS AN ELECTIVE. I THINK A FEW OTHER PEOPLE BROUGHT THAT UP TONIGHT, BUT NOT APPROVING THIS CLASS. YOU'RE TAKING AWAY PARENTAL RIGHTS, WHICH YOU LIKED SO MUCH TO RAVE ABOUT. SO I JUST WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR THAT DOCTOR POINT. YOU SAID YOURSELF, WRITING CURRICULUM IS A MONUMENTAL TASK THAT RELIES ON EXPERTS. RESPECTFULLY, I HAVE READ ALL OF YOUR BIOS ON THE HSPS WEBSITE. NONE OF THE FIVE OF YOU HAVE ANY EXPERIENCE OR EDUCATION IN EDUCATION AND ARE THEREFORE NOT QUALIFIED TO WRITE CURRICULUM. I'M ASKING YOU TO APPROVE THIS COURSE AS IT WAS. I WOULD LIKE TO SEE IT IN ALL HIGH SCHOOLS. TO BE HONEST WITH YOU. THANK YOU. AS JESSICA FENDRICK HERE. OKAY, RONALD WOODEN, FOLLOWED BY MIKE PARKER. GOOD EVENING, RON WOODEN, PROUD PRINCIPAL OF POST ROAD ELEMENTARY SCHOOL AND THE 24 HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS TEACHER OF THE YEAR. TONIGHT I COME AS ONE, BUT STAND FOR 10,000, REPRESENTING ALL OF THOSE WHOSE NAMES WE KNOW MADE THE HISTORY BOOKS. SOJOURNER TRUTH, HARRIET TUBMAN, DOCTOR KING AND THE MILLIONS WHO DIDN'T, FOR THOSE WHO MARCHED, FOR THOSE WHO PRAYED FOR THOSE WHO SANG, FOR THOSE WHO BLED, FOR THOSE WHO BELIEVED, AND FOR THOSE WHO DIED. I COME AS ONE BUT STAND FOR 10,000 TO THE 10TH POWER. THIS EVENING I AM REPRESENTING THOSE WHO WERE CRESTFALLEN BY THE VOTE THAT TOOK PLACE BY THE BOARD REGARDING THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY COURSE. PERHAPS SOME OF YOU WOULD NEVER UNDERSTAND OR CARE TO UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU DID LAST MONTH, AND THE MESSAGE THAT I BELIEVE WAS MADE CLEAR AS AN AFRICAN AMERICAN, LET ME TELL YOU WHAT I BELIEVE WAS MADE CLEAR. I FEEL THAT YOU DON'T WANT ME HERE. I FEEL THAT YOU DON'T VALUE THE TRUTH ABOUT MY STRUGGLES AND WAYS THAT I, OR PEOPLE THAT LOOK LIKE ME, HAD TO FIGHT TO OVERCOME. I FEEL THAT YOU DON'T WANT THE TRUTH TO BE SHARED WITH OUR STUDENTS. IT IS THE TRUTH THAT I WAS PROVIDED THAT PUSHED ME AND PUSHES ME TO BE THE PROUD CHRISTIAN, AMERICAN, AFRICAN AMERICAN EDUCATOR AND HUMAN BEING THAT I AM TODAY. THIS WAS ALL BECAUSE OF LEARNING THE TRUTH OF THE AFRICAN AMERICAN EXPERIENCE THAT I LEARNED IN THE PHILADELPHIA PUBLIC SCHOOLS, AND WHILE A STUDENT AT THE LINCOLN UNIVERSITY, COURSES REGARDING THE AFRICAN AMERICAN EXPERIENCE SHOULD NOT ONLY BE TAUGHT IN THE INNER CITIES AND HISTORICAL BLACK COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES, AT THIS POINT IN HISTORY, WE SHOULD BE IN A BETTER PLACE WITH EDUCATION SO THAT OUR CHILDREN CAN LEARN THE TRUTH IN ALL SCHOOLS. THE TRUTH DIDN'T CAUSE ME TO HATE PEOPLE OR OTHERS WHO ARE DIFFERENT FROM ME. THE TRUTH CAUSED ME TO LOVE EVEN HARDER. REVEREND DOCTOR MARLIN TILLMAN STATED, THE MORE YOU KNOW ABOUT YOUR HISTORY, THE MORE LIKELY YOU ARE TO MAKE CHANGES FOR THE FUTURE. AND BY DENYING AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, YOU ARE DENYING THE POTENTIAL OF A FUTURE OF A FUTURE. WHEN YOU DENY SOMEONE THE POSSIBILITY OF A FUTURE BY KNOWING THEIR HISTORY, YOU ARE ALSO DENYING. HOW STRUGGLE PRODUCES PERSEVERANCE AND PERSEVERANCE GIVES US HOPE. AND THANK YOU TO THE AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY COURSE AS A GUIDE IS ONE WAY THAT I BELIEVE THE BOARD SUPPORTED THE POLITICAL AGENDA. THANK YOU SIR. PROJECT 2025, WHICH ELIMINATES AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDY AT ALL LEVELS OF EDUCATION. I HEAR GOING FORWARD THAT WE MUST ELIMINATE POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES. HOWEVER, GOING DOWN THIS COURSE IS IMPORTANT EVEN THOUGH OUR. GOOD EVENING, I'M MIKE PARKER. I'D LIKE TO SUGGEST THE BOARD, TAKE A STEP BACK AND RECONSIDER YOUR POSITION ON THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES PROGRAM. THIS NATIONALLY

[02:10:01]

CERTIFIED PROGRAM BY THE COLLEGE BOARD WAS GENERATED BY THE ACADEMIC LEADERS IN THIS FIELD.

IT IS FACT BASED. I READ ALL 411 PAGES OF THIS CURRICULUM, INCLUDING FACT CHECKING, THE HUNDREDS OF REFERENCES IN THE DOCUMENT. WHAT I FOUND IN MY OPINION, THERE'S NO IDEOLOGICAL IDEOLOGY. EXCUSE ME, IDEOLOGICAL BENT OR MOTIVATION OR THRUST IN THIS DOCUMENT. IT IS BALANCED, FACTUAL PRESENTATION. MANY OF THE FACTS ARE VERY, VERY DISTRESSING, BUT THERE ARE NONETHELESS THEY ARE THE FACTS. AND THE CURRICULUM REQUIRES THE STUDENT TO TAKE THOSE FACTS, APPLY CRITICAL THINKING AND REACH THEIR OWN CONCLUSION. AND TO DENY THIS OPPORTUNITY TO STUDENTS OF HARFORD COUNTY IS SOMETHING THAT OUGHT TO BE TAKEN WITH, WITH GREAT, CONSIDERATION.

ADDITIONALLY, YOU KNOW, IT IS AN ELECTIVE COURSE AND PARENTS ARE CAPABLE OF MAKING THAT JUDGMENT OF HOW THEIR STUDENT AND THEIR LEVEL OF MATURITY AND THEIR LEVEL OF CRITICAL THINKING, AND WHETHER OR NOT THEY'RE SUITABLE FOR THIS TYPE COURSE. THANK YOU. YOU'RE HERE. NEXT, WE HAVE RITA SHERMAN, FOLLOWED BY JENNA TILLERY. OKAY. NEXT WE HAVE JOYCE BOYD. I'M RITA SHERMAN, AND I'M HERE TONIGHT TO SAY I'M DEEPLY TROUBLED BY THE RECENT DECISION TO CANCEL THE AP.

AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE. THIS DECISION IMPACTS THE HIGH EDUCATIONAL STANDARDS THAT THIS COMMUNITY HAS COME TO EXPECT. THIS COURSE OFFERS STUDENTS THE OPPORTUNITY TO EXPLORE THE RICH AND COMPLEX HISTORY, CULTURE, AND CONTRIBUTIONS OF AFRICAN AMERICANS, WHICH ARE ALSO AN IMPORTANT PART TO OUR NATION OF OUR NATION. THESE ARE THINGS THAT ARE MISSING. WHEN I WAS IN HIGH SCHOOL HERE, I WENT TO HIGH SCHOOL HERE. SO I KNOW EDUCATION IS A POWERFUL TOOL FOR FOSTERING EMPATHY, UNDERSTANDING AND UNITY. IT EQUIPS OUR YOUNG PEOPLE WITH KNOWLEDGE AND SKILLS TO NAVIGATE AN INCREASINGLY DIVERSE WORLD. WHEN WE LIMIT THEIR ACCESS TO COURSES THAT REFLECT THIS DIVERSITY, WE DO THEM A GREAT DISSERVICE. WE ARE ESSENTIALLY TELLING THEM THAT SOME HISTORIES AND EXPERIENCES ARE LESS IMPORTANT THAN OTHERS, WHICH CONTRIBUTES, CONTRADICTS THE VERY PRINCIPLES OF EQUALITY THAT ALL OUR EDUCATIONAL SYSTEMS SHOULD UPHOLD. MOREOVER, THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE PROVIDES STUDENTS WITH RIGOROUS ACADEMIC CHALLENGES THAT PREPARE THEM FOR HIGHER EDUCATION AND BEYOND. IT ENCOURAGES CRITICAL THINKING, ANALYTICAL SKILLS, AND A DEEPER ENGAGEMENT WITH HISTORY AND LITERATURE. THESE ARE INDIVIDUAL, INVALUABLE SKILLS THAT BENEFIT STUDENTS REGARDLESS OF WHAT THEY DO LATER IN LIFE. I URGE YOU TO RECONSIDER THIS DECISION. I DON'T KNOW WHY YOU DID IT. WHAT IS YOUR EXPERTISE ON THE SUBJECT? AND EVERYBODY HAS SAID THIS. WHAT IS MANY PARENTS WANT THIS. I'VE HEARD THE BOARDS MEMBERS SAY THEY WANT PARENTS TO BE ABLE TO DECIDE, WELL, PARENTS WANT THIS. AND SO THEY SHOULD BE ABLE TO DECIDE WHY THIS ONE. DO YOU NOT WANT THAT? I WILL END WITH A QUOTE FROM HELEN KELLER. THE HIGHEST RESULT OF EDUCATION IS TOLERANCE. AND TOLERANCE LEADS TO UNITY. AND THAT'S SOMETHING THAT YOUR PRESIDENT OF THE BOARD ASKED FOR. LET'S HAVE IT. GINA TILLERY. MY NAME IS JOYCE BOYD.

I TAUGHT MATHEMATICS AT ABERDEEN MIDDLE SCHOOL AND ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL FOR A TOTAL OF 32 YEARS, RETIRING IN 2023. WHEN I WAS IN SECOND GRADE, PERRYSVILLE ELEMENTARY FINALLY BECAME INTEGRATED. THERE WERE ONLY THREE AFRICAN AMERICAN FAMILIES IN TOWN AT THAT TIME. I COULD SEE THEIR HOUSES FROM MY CLASSROOM WINDOW. THEY LIVED IN A LITTLE ROW ON THE STREET.

ORIGINALLY, THOSE CHILDREN WERE BUSED 15 MILES TO THE SCHOOL IN ELKTON. BUT I REMEMBER THE DAY LARRY AND JULIUS WERE ALLOWED TO JOIN MY CLASS. LOOKING BACK, IT STILL FEELS SAD THAT IT TOOK SO LONG. I SPENT MUCH OF MY GROWING UP YEARS AT PORT DEPOSIT, SWIMMING IN THE POOL PORT DEPOSIT AT THAT TIME, AND STILL DOES, HAD MANY AFRICAN AMERICAN FAMILIES AND THEIR CHILDREN WERE NOT ALLOWED TO SWIM IN THAT POO. IMAGINE HOT DAYS WATCHING A BUNCH OF WHITE KIDS SPLASHING

[02:15:04]

AND PLAYING WHILE YOU WERE LEFT STANDING ON THE SIDEWALK. I DON'T SHARE THESE EXPERIENCES TO FURTHER DIVISION, BUT RATHER TO ENLIGHTEN. UNFORTUNATELY, THOSE CHILDREN WERE VICTIMS OF A RACIST SOCIETY IN THE 60S AND 70S. THERE WAS NOT MUCH ENLIGHTENED BLACK HISTORY. I LEARNED ABOUT THE CIVIL WAR, BUT NOT WHAT SLAVERY REALLY WAS. I HEARD NOTHING ABOUT THE TULSA RACE MASSACRE, WHERE 40 PEOPLE WERE KILLED, 800 HOSPITALIZED, 35 BLOCKS OF A NEIGHBORHOOD DESTROYED. NOT A WORD WAS IN A TEXTBOOK. THIS BRINGS ME TO THE MOST PRESSING CONCERN WHERE ARE OUR CHILDREN GOING TO LEARN ABOUT THEIR HERITAGE? GOOD AND BAD. IF WE ARE NOT TEACHING IT IN OUR SCHOOLS, THEY NEED TO LEARN THE TRUTH AND LEARN HOW TO THINK IN WAYS THAT ARE PRODUCTIVE FOR ALL SOCIETY. I SEE THIS DIVISION. I SEE THIS CANCELING OF THE COURSE AS A HUGE STEP BACKWARDS IN OUR EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM. AS ELEANOR ROOSEVELT SAID, LEARNING. MORGAN WRITES, FOLLOWED BY REVEREND WILLIAM FISHER. IN THE NATIONAL SOCIALIST PARTY OF GERMANY CAME TO POWER IN 1933, THEY BEGAN TO DO SOMETHING THAT MANY AUTHORITARIAN REGIMES DO. THEY TRY TO REWRITE HISTORY. THEY BANNED AND CENSORED MANY TOPICS. THE MAIN BLACKLIST INCLUDED IMPRESSIONIST ARTWORK, CLASSICAL MUSIC COMPOSED BY JEWISH COMPOSERS SUCH AS MAHLER AND MENDELSSOHN. THEY ALSO BANNED THE WORKS OF FAMOUS AUTHOR WAR OF THE WORLDS, AUTHOR WAR OF THE WORLDS AUTHOR H.G. WELLS, AND FOR WHOM THE BELL TOLLS AUTHOR ERNEST HEMINGWAY.

THEY SUPPRESSED THE WORKS OF ALBERT EINSTEIN, PHYSICIST NIELS BOHR, FREDERICH FREUD, AND SEX AND GENDER SCIENTIST MAGNUS HIRSCHFELD. TODAY, MANY OF THE ABOVE CREATORS AND SCIENTISTS ARE LOOKED AT. SOME OF THEM ARE LOOKED AT AS LEGENDS OF THEIR FIELDS. LOOKING AT THESE NAMES IS HARD TO UNDERSTAND WHY THE PARTY WOULD CENTER SUCH IMPORTANT WORKS AND THEIR AUTHORS. WELL, WITH THE POWER OF HINDSIGHT, WE CAN SEE THAT IT WAS A PLOY FOR POWER AND CONTROL. IT WAS AUTHORITARIANIS. BUT AT THE TIME, I'M SURE MANY OF THE EXCUSES THAT THEY HAD WERE EASY TO UNDERSTAND. THEY MAKE GERMANY LOOK BAD. THEY'RE NOT PEOPLE WE WANT TEACHING OUR CHILDREN. IT'S DIVISIVE AND IT'S TOO POLITICAL. SO NOW THAT I'VE TALKED QUITE A BIT ABOUT WHERE YOU GOT YOUR PLAYBOOK, I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT EXACTLY WHAT YOU'RE BANNING. SO WHAT IS CRITICAL RACE THEORY TO SOME OF YOU, IT'S A WEAPON TO USE AGAINST YOU TO MAKE YOU FEEL GUILTY FOR PURPORTED ABUSES COMMITTED BY YOU AND SOME OF YOUR LOVED ONES. TO THE REST OF US WHO THOUGHT CRITICALLY ABOUT IT, IT'S A IT'S A TOOL TO UNDERSTAND OUR HISTORY THROUGH A DIFFERENT LENS, TO BETTER UNDERSTAND OUR PRESENT. AND IT'S A TOOL TO RECOGNIZE HOW WE ALL HAVE OUR OWN BIASES AND HOW THOSE BIASES AFFECT HOW WE SEE AND TREAT THE PEOPLE AROUND US.

AND MAYBE THAT WE CAN DISMANTLE THOSE NEGATIVE BIASES AND FREE OURSELVES AND EACH OTHER FROM DISCRIMINATION. IN CHARLES R LAWRENCE'S ESSAY THE ID, THE EGO, AND EQUAL PROTECTION RECKONING WITH UNCONSCIOUS RACISM, HE RELATES THE STORY OF EXCLUSION AND DETACHMENT DURING AN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL STORY TIME. AS THE ONLY BLACK STUDENT THAT IS NOT LAUGHING AT THE MAIN CHARACTER OF THE STORY. THE STORY IS A LITTLE BLACK SAMBO. HE GOES ON TO SAY THAT EVEN AS A CHILD, HE COULD RECOGNIZE THAT HIS TEACHER WAS NOT TRYING TO ISOLATE HIM OR ALIENATE HIM, AND THAT'S. WHY. GOOD EVENING. BOARD MEMBERS. MY NAME IS REVEREND WILLIAM FISHER.

I'M THE PASTOR OF HOSANNA AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH, IF YOU'RE NOT FAMILIAR WHERE IT IS, IT'S ON CASTLETON ROAD AND DARLINGTON, MARYLAND. I'VE BEEN IN HARFORD COUNTY FOR, ALMOST COMING UP TO TWO YEARS, AND IT'S NOT ABOUT HARFORD COUNTY AS FAR AS WHAT I'M GOING TO SAY. I AM GOING TO LIMIT MY CONVERSATION TO MY TESTIMONY AS AN AFRICAN AMERICAN. MALE IN THE INNER CITY, LIVING IN THE INNER CITY, I WAS THE VALEDICTORIAN OF MY CLASS AT CARVER VOCATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL IN BALTIMORE, MARYLAND. THAT AFFORDED ME A GREAT EDUCATION. I EVEN HAD FUN.

HOWEVER, THE ONE THING THAT CAME OUT OF THAT EDUCATION WAS A DISAPPOINTMENT TO THE FACT THAT THAT I DID NOT GET MY AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, AND IT MADE ME ANGRY. AND HOW MANY AFRICAN AMERICAN MEN DO YOU THINK ARE ANGRY IN BALTIMORE CITY? COME ON, THINK ABOUT IT. SOME OF THE

[02:20:01]

SHOOTINGS ARE BASED ON THEY DON'T KNOW. THEY JUST DON'T KNOW. HERE IT IS. MY TESTIMONY IS I GOT ANGRY. I GOT TIRED OF AFRICA. I GOT TIRED OF WHITE MALES, FEMALES TRYING TO TELL ME WHO I AM. SO WHAT I DO, I JUMP INTO MORGAN STATE UNIVERSITY. THAT WAS AFTER 24 YEARS OF BEING OUT OF HIGH SCHOOL. SO WHEN I GOT THERE, I WAS JUST FLOORED FOR THE SIMPLE FACT. I DID NOT KNOW THAT THEY WENT TO ANCIENT AFRICA TO 1500. I DIDN'T DO HISTORY TWO. HOWEVER, I AM GOING TO GO BACK. BUT I GOT WHAT I NEEDED AND I CAME OUT KNOWING THAT I WAS SET FREE. I WAS SET FREE. I GOT WHAT I NEEDED SO I DON'T NEED TO GO AROUND BEING ANGRY ANYMORE. APPROVE THIS, DON'T STAND IN THE WAY OF PROGRESS. THANK YOU FOR THE OVERWHELMING EVIDENCE, PLEASE.

THANK YOU SIR. THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE EMMA PELLER FOLLOWED BY DOCTOR. SIR. I'M SO SORRY, SIR.

HARRIS. GOOD EVENING, SUPERINTENDENT BOLSON. MEMBERS OF THE BOARD, AND THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH YOU THIS EVENING, I'M HERE TO ECHO THE VOICES OF MANY OF MY NEIGHBORS WHO ARE HERE TO ASK YOU TO APPROVE THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM.

WHILE I DIDN'T HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE THIS SPECIFIC COURSE WHILE I WAS IN CPS, I DID TAKE MANY OTHER AP CLASSES, WHICH AFTER TAKING THE AP EXAM AFFORDED ME COLLEGE CREDIT, WHICH ALLOWED ME TO SKIP A SEMESTER OF COLLEGE, SAVE LOTS OF MONEY, AND GRADUATE EARLY.

THIS SPECIFIC COURSE ALLOWS FOR STUDENTS TO GAIN MORE THAN COLLEGE CREDIT, SO AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY HAS BEEN AND CONTINUES TO BE OVERLOOKED WITHIN HISTORY CURRICULUM NATIONALLY AND WITHIN CPS. WITHIN MY OWN CLASS. THAT'S NOT A DISCREDIT TO ANY OF THE TEACHERS IN HC, BUT THAT'S THE REALITY. THE HISTORY, AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY ALLOWS OUR STUDENTS SPECIFIC CONTEXT ABOUT HISTORICAL EVENTS THAT PLAY DIRECTLY INTO THE, REALITY OF DAILY LIFE IN AMERICA FOR SO MANY PEOPLE, IT PLAYS DIRECTLY INTO THE POLARIZATION THAT WE'RE SEEING THAT DOCTOR THAT, MR. POINTON BROUGHT UP AT THE BEGINNING OF THIS MEETING, AND I WANT TO ECHO WHAT WAS HAS BEEN SAID BY OTHERS THAT THOSE WHO DO NOT LEARN HISTORY ARE DOOMED TO REPEAT IT. I ASK YOU TONIGHT THAT YOU LISTEN TO THE VOICES OF SO MANY IN THIS COMMUNITY OF SO MANY OF YOUR STUDENTS WHO HAVE BEEN BRAVE ENOUGH TO SPEND A MONDAY NIGHT IN THE SUMMER AND GET UP AND TALK IN FRONT OF ALL THESE PEOPLE ABOUT HOW THEY FEEL SO STRONGLY ABOUT THIS. AND I URGE YOU TO RECONSIDER YOUR DECISION. THANK YOU. I'M DOCTOR SYLVIA HARRIS. I HEARD IN THE OPENING REMARKS I HEARD THAT WE ARE ALL EQUAL. SOMEONE ON THE BOARD MENTIONED THAT AND SHOULD BE TOLERANT AND TOLERANT OF EACH OTHER. AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS A VITAL PART OF OUR AMERICAN HISTORY, AND SHOULD BE A PART OF OUR EQUAL EDUCATION. THE EDUCATION OF AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. IS A BIASED AGAINST THE COMMUNITY. THAT IS TO EXCLUDE IT WOULD BE BIAS AGAINST THIS COMMUNITY THAT HAS SPOKEN OUT TO INCLUDE IT. THIS SEEMS TO BE THE BEGINNING OF THE WHITE NATIONAL MOVEMENT THAT IS PROPOSED IN THE PROJECT 2025 AND BEING EXECUTED HERE IN HERTFORD COUNTY. THERE IS NO DISCUSSION ABOUT THE WHITE NATIONALIST TEXT CURRENTLY IN OUR SCHOOLS. THESE DECISIONS ARE BIASED AND UNACCEPTABLE IN AMERICAN SOCIETY. PERHAPS YOU DIDN'T HAVE ALL THE FACTS BE BUT BEFORE. BUT TODAY, TODAY WE HAVE ENLIGHTENED YOU AND I ENCOURAGE YOU TO REVERSE YOUR DECISION AND APPROVE THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN COURSE. THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE JACOB BENNETT, FOLLOWED BY JASON

[02:25:08]

KING.

GOOD EVENING. JACOB BENNETT, HARTFORD COUNTY COUNCILMAN AND KINDERGARTEN TEACHER. PROUD TO WORK FOR THE BEST PRINCIPAL IN HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS, YOU KNOW, MY NUMBER ONE ISSUE IS READING INSTRUCTION, FOR THOSE WHO DON'T KNOW, WE HAVE THE THIRD LARGEST RACIAL ACHIEVEMENT GAP IN THE STATE OF MARYLAND WE HAD THE YEAR BEFORE. WE HAVE THIS YEAR WITHOUT MAJOR WORK.

WE'LL HAVE IT AGAIN NEXT YEAR. THE SIMPLE VIEW OF READING SAYS DECODING TIMES. KNOWLEDGE EQUALS COMPREHENSION, DOCTOR BOYNTON SAID AT THE LAST MEETING HE DOESN'T WANT TO TELL CHILDREN WHAT TO THINK, BUT RATHER HOW TO THINK. AND WHILE THOSE ARE BEAUTIFUL WORDS IN THE CONTEXT OF HOW OUR BRAIN WORKS, IT MAKES NO SENSE. STUDY AFTER STUDY HAS SHOWN THAT DEEP AND MEANINGFUL THINKING IS BIRTHED FROM DEEP AND MEANINGFUL KNOWLEDGE. ONE SUCH STUDY I RECENTLY READ GOT A BRAIN DOCTORS AND FOOT DOCTORS. THEY HAD THE BRAIN DOCTORS READ A TEXT ABOUT THE BRAIN AND DISCUSS IT. THEY HAD THE FOOT DOCTORS GET A TEXT ABOUT THE FOOT AND DISCUSS IT. THEN THEY GAVE THE FOOT DOCTORS THE BRAIN TEXT AND THE BRAIN DOCTORS THE FOOT TEST. ALL OF A SUDDEN THEY COULDN'T HAVE AS MUCH OF A DEEP AND MEANINGFUL CONVERSATION BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T KNOW THE SUBJECT MATTER. GIVING OUR CHILDREN DEEP AND MEANINGFUL KNOWLEDGE OF THE WORLD IS MESSY WORK, AND IT MEANS NOT EVERYTHING WE SHARE IS GOING TO BE POSITIVE. ONLY THROUGH UNDERSTANDING, THOUGH, CAN WE DO ANALYSIS. EDDIE HIRSCH WROTE IN HIS BOOKS CULTURAL LITERACY AND HOW TO EDUCATE A CITIZEN ABOUT HOW WE AS A SOCIETY HAVE FAILED OUR CHILDREN BY DENYING THEM A RICH AND WELL-ROUNDED EDUCATION IN SCIENCE, HISTORY, LITERATURE, AND ART. MUCH OF THIS REMOVAL OF SPECIFIC TEACHING HAS BEEN DRIVEN BY THE FEAR OF CONTROVERSY IN ADDRESSING MESSY TOPICS, BUT EDDIE HIRSCH ARGUES IT IS THE VERY ACT OF DENYING SUCH CULTURAL CONTEXT THAT WE POLARIZE OUR SOCIETY. HE SPEAKS TO HOW, WHEN WE SPEAK TO ONE ANOTHER, IT'S NOT JUST THE WORDS WE SAY, BUT THE WORDS WE FILL IN IN BETWEEN THOSE WORDS, DUE TO OUR OWN BACKGROUND KNOWLEDGE THAT FEEDS COMMUNICATION. SO BY GIVING OUR CHILDREN ACCESS TO AS MANY COURSES AS POSSIBLE, WE ARE ABLE TO DEPOLARIZE OUR SOCIETY. BUT TO DENY THEM THIS ACCESS WILL ONLY FURTHER THE DIVIDE THAT EXISTS IN HARTFORD. NEXT WE HAVE JANINE CANIDA, FOLLOWED BY RODNEY JOHNSON.

GOOD EVENING, BOARD MEMBERS ARE VOTED OR APPOINTED BASED ON THE PERCEPTION THAT THEY WILL MAKE DECISIONS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF OUR KIDS. BUT THIS CANNOT BE ACCOMPLISHED IN THE ABSENCE OF DUE DILIGENCE TO COMPETENTLY VOTE ON ANYTHING AFFECTING STUDENTS REQUIRES MORE THAN A CURSORY REVIEW OF AN AGENDA. AN HOUR BEFORE THE BOARD MEETING, I'VE WITNESSED A GROSS MISS MISINTERPRETATION OF HISTORY BY A BOARD MEMBER WHO DEFENDED MARGARET SANGER IN THE JUNE MEETING. IT'S OBVIOUS THOSE WITH MY VIEWPOINT ARE GROSSLY OUTNUMBERED. TONIGHT DOESN'T MEAN THE OPPOSITE VIEW IS RIGHT. I'VE WITNESSED A LOT OF GRANDSTANDING AND ANGRY RHETORIC TONIGHT, SEEMINGLY DESIGNED TO INTIMIDATE BOARD MEMBERS. I WANT TO POINT OUT THAT ONLY 3% OF COLONISTS FOUGHT FOR FREEDOM FROM ENGLAND. IT TAKES COURAGE TO COUNTER GROUPTHINK AND WEAKNESS. I CHALLENGE THE ASSERTION THAT THERE IS A MOVEMENT TO WATER DOWN HISTORY.

IT'S QUITE THE OPPOSITE. THERE IS A MOVEMENT TO PORTRAY SLAVERY AS UNIQUE TO AFRICAN AMERICANS.

SOME REALITY NEEDS TO BE INSERTED INTO THIS DISCUSSION. IT IS NOT UNIQUE TO BLACK AMERICANS. THERE ARE FEW CIVILIZATIONS NOT GUILTY OF THIS HORRIFIC CRIME YET. I SAW NO REFERENCE TO THIS IN THE CURRICULUM. MOST AFRICAN AMERICANS WERE SENT TO BRAZIL OR THE CARIBBEAN. OUR OUR KIDS SHOULD NOT BE TAUGHT FALSEHOODS AND PROPAGANDA VERSUS TRUTH, I CAUTION THE BOARD MEMBERS NOT TO BLINDLY VOTE FOR THIS CURRICULUM. WE NEED TO BE REALLY CAREFUL ABOUT WHAT WE IMPART TO OUR NEXT GENERATIONS, BECAUSE THEY'RE GOING TO TAKE THAT AND

[02:30:02]

IMPACT OUR FUTURE. AT A TIME. I WON'T KEEP TALKING. GOOD EVENING, BOARD MEMBERS, MY NAME IS RODNEY JOHNSON, AND I'M A THIRD YEAR EDUCATOR AND FORMERLY A PROUD PRODUCT OF HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS. I WILL OFFER YOU A QUOTE THAT PROBABLY OUR STUDENTS WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO READ, NOT EVERYTHING THAT IS FACED CAN BE CHANGED, BUT NOTHING CAN BE CHANGED. THAT IS NOT FACED. JAMES BALDWIN IF HISTORY DOES NOT MAKE YOU UNCOMFORTABLE, YOU ARE NOT TEACHING IT CORRECTLY. AND I SAY THAT AS AN EDUCATOR WITH 30 YEARS IN THE CLASSROOM, AS AN AP TEACHER FOR OVER TEN YEARS, WE ARE HAVING ISSUES WITH THIS CURRICULUM. AND I THINK BACK TO MY EXPERIENCE AS A STUDENT IN HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS. I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S STILL IN THE CURRICULUM TODAY, BUT I READ HUCK FINN AND HUCK FINN WAS IN THE CURRICULUM. THE WORD APPEARS IN HUCK FINN 219 TIMES. JIM WAS A MONSTROUS, PROUD ABOUT IT, AND HE GOT SO CONFIDENT HE HARDLY COULD NOTICE THE OTHER COME, MILES, TO HEAR JIM TELL IN ABOUT AND WAS BOOK LOOKED UP TO THE DAY OF THE IN THAT COUNTY. I READ THAT AS A JUNIOR IN HARFORD COUNTY IN 1987, AND I REMEMBER FEELING REALLY UNCOMFORTABLE, BUT IT WAS CURRICULUM, SO I ASK YOU IF STUDENTS OF COLOR AND EVERY STUDENT CAN READ HUCK FINN, THEN CERTAINLY READING ABOUT AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY AND AFRICAN AMERICAN EXPERIENCES IS NOT A BRIDGE TOO FAR. I URGE YOU TO RECONSIDER YOUR POSITION.

NEXT, WE HAVE LEAH NGUYEN, FOLLOWED BY ADDISON GOLDING.

HELLO EVERYONE. MY NAME IS LEAH WINN. I'M A GRADUATE OF BELLAIRE HIGH SCHOOL, CLASS OF 2023, AND I AM HERE TO EXPRESS MY FRUSTRATION TOWARDS THE DECISION TO DISMISS THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN COURSE. I ASKED YOU TO REEVALUATE YOUR THINKING TOWARDS THE DIVERSITY, EQUITY AND INCLUSION CLASSES, CLUBS AND MOVEMENTS. ASIDE FROM THE EDUCATIONAL BENEFITS, THIS COURSE OFFERS A SAFE SPACE FOR BLACK HISTORY TO BE CELEBRATED THROUGH HONESTY AND TRANSPARENCY. THE GREATNESS OF BLACKNESS AND THE IMPACT WE'VE HAD ON THIS NATION IS SO RARELY ACKNOWLEDGED OUTSIDE OF FEBRUARY. SAFE SPACES ARE RARELY FOUND IN HARD AND EVEN HARDER TO CREATE. I STARTED BELLAIRE'S FIRST BLACK STUDENT UNION, BUT YEARS BEFORE STUDENTS FOUGHT FOR THE ORGANIZATION BUT WERE DENIED. THEREFORE HAVING A COLLEGE LEVEL COURSE MEANING IT IS ADVANCED, INTENSE AND TRUTHFUL, CELEBRATES THE TRIUMPH OF BLACK AMERICA. YOUNG MINDS THAT ARE INTERESTED IN TAKING THIS COLLEGE LEVEL ELECTIVE ARE YEARNING FOR A LESSON ON THE BLACK DIASPORA CULTURE IN ITS HISTORY, THE PRIVILEGE TO LEARN ABOUT OTHER MINORITIES SHOULD NOT BE STRIPPED FROM STUDENTS BECAUSE OLDER ADULTS THINK BLACK HISTORY IS A BIT TOO MUCH FOR YOUNG ADULTS TO HANDLE. THERE WERE TALKS OF THIS COURSE BEING TOO NEGATIVE, BUT I'D LIKE TO POSE THE QUESTION FOR WHOM? BECAUSE STUDENTS HAVE YET TO START COMPLAINING. THE. IN ADDITION, NO OTHER SUBJECT JAPANESE INTERNMENT CAMPS, THE KILLING OF THOUSANDS OF NATIVE AMERICANS DUE TO COLONIZATION, THE HOLOCAUST, ETC. DO BOARD MEMBERS COMMENT ON THE ISSUES BEING TOO NEGATIVE? AND THAT'S BECAUSE AS HUMANS, WE WOULD NEVER TELL ANOTHER INDIVIDUAL THEIR EXPERIENCE IS NOT POSITIVE ENOUGH. SO WHY, WHEN THE TOPIC OF BLACK OPPRESSION COMES TO THE TABLE, IT IS TOO MUCH FOR STUDENTS. ALTHOUGH THE TEACHING OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, SLAVERY, CIVIL RIGHTS, VOTING, JIM CROW BEGINS IN MIDDLE SCHOOL, THIS COLLEGE LEVEL ELECTIVE IS THE ONE COURSE THAT PUSHES THE BOUNDARY TOO FAR. JUST BECAUSE THE REALITY OF BLACK AMERICANS WHO ARE STILL OPPRESSED TODAY DUE TO POLICE BRUTALITY AND ACCESS TO CARE MAKES MANY UNCOMFORTABLE, DOES NOT MEAN EDUCATORS SHOULD TEACH THE COURSE THROUGH ROSE COLORED LENSES. LASTLY, IF THE FEAR IS THAT THE COURSE WILL PIT BLACK AMERICANS AGAINST WHITE AMERICANS, AMERICA DID THAT TO ITSELF LONG BEFORE THE COURSE WAS ESTABLISHED. HOWEVER, DEI ACTIVITIES HELPED CLOSE THAT GAP. HOWEVER, WHATEVER FEELINGS AWAKEN WITHIN STUDENTS AFTER EXPERIENCING TRUTHFUL KNOWLEDGE, I HOPE IT CHANGED THEM FOR THE BETTER. I PRAY FOR MY FUTURE THAT MY BLACK TRUTH IS NOT SILENCED. LASTLY, BLACK PEOPLE ARE NOT A REPRESENTATION OF VICTIM OF. GOOD EVENING, MEMBERS OF HARFORD COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION. MY

[02:35:16]

NAME IS ADDISON GOLDING AND I'M A RISING HIGH SCHOOL JUNIOR. I AM HERE TO EXPRESS MY CONCERN ABOUT THE DECISION TO REMOVE THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE AS A STUDENT WHO VALUES LEARNING AND DIVERSITY, I BELIEVE THAT ELIMINATING THIS COURSE IS NOT THE RIGHT APPROACH. WHILE NO COURSE IS PERFECT AND THERE MAY BE CHALLENGES SIMPLY REMOVING IT IS NOT THE SOLUTION. BY KEEPING THE COURSE, MANY STUDENTS WILL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN ABOUT DIFFERENT CULTURES AND BROADEN THEIR UNDERSTANDING OF HISTORY. SOME MIGHT ARGUE THAT TEACHING THIS SUBJECT COULD MAKE SOME STUDENTS UNCOMFORTABLE OR CAUSE OTHERS TO VIEW AMERICA NEGATIVELY. HOWEVER, I BELIEVE IT'S ESSENTIAL FOR STUDENTS TO LEARN FROM KNOWLEDGEABLE TEACHERS WHO CAN ADDRESS THEIR QUESTIONS AND PROVIDE ACCURATE INFORMATION. IF WE DON'T OFFER THIS EDUCATION, STUDENTS MIGHT TURN TO UNRELIABLE SOURCES AND MISUNDERSTAND HISTORY. HISTORY WON'T DISAPPEAR, AND WE HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY TO TEACH IT ACCURATELY TO PREVENT MISUNDERSTANDINGS. AS A COMMUNITY, WE NEED TO GET COMFORTABLE BEING UNCOMFORTABLE WHETHER WE'RE IN THE CLASSROOM OR MAKING DECISIONS ABOUT THE CURRICULUM, WE ALL HAVE SOMETHING TO LEARN FROM THIS COURSE. LEARNING TO BE UNCOMFORTABLE WITH THE COURSE IS THE FIRST STEP TOWARDS UNDERSTANDING GROWTH, WHICH WILL LEAD US TO FEELING COMFORTABLE WITH THE TOPIC. WITH HISTORY, AND WITH EACH OTHER. SO I URGE YOU TO CHANGE YOUR DECISIONS AND GO FOR THE COURSE. THANK YOU. NEXT, WE HAVE DEVIN DEFORD, FOLLOWED BY RAIN CURTIS. IS THERE A DEVIN TO FORD? THEN WE WILL DO RAIN. CURTIS. GOOD EVENING TO EVERYONE EXCEPT THE FIVE. I'M HERE TO MAKE A TWO MINUTE STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF, RENE, DANNY OR JESSICA FREDERICK. AS A PARENT OF AN AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDENT, I'M TRULY DISAPPOINTED IN THE BOARD OF EDUCATION'S VOTE AGAINST THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE. WHEN RESEARCHING THE AP COURSES OFFERED WITHIN HARFORD COUNTY, I BEGAN QUESTIONING WHY? WHY WEREN'T THE AP US STUDY COURSES FOR AP WORLD HISTORY COURSES UP FOR VOTE AS WELL? WHEN REVIEWING THE COURSES AND TAKING YOUR COMMENTS THAT THE AP COURSE WAS TOO POLITICAL, I NOTICED THAT THE FOLLOWING SECTIONS WITHIN OTHER AP COURSES ARE BEING TAUGHT IN AP US HISTORY. YOU'LL LEARN ABOUT THE RIVALRY BETWEEN THE SOVIET UNION AND THE UNITED STATES, THE GROWTH OF VARIOUS CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT AND THE ECONOMIC, CULTURAL AND POLITICAL TRANSFORMATIONS OF THIS PERIOD.

TOPICS MAY INCLUDE THE COLD WAR AND THE RED SCARE, AMERICA AS A WORLD POWER, THE VIETNAM WAR, THE GREAT SOCIETY, THE AFRICAN AMERICAN CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT, AND THE YOUTH CULTURE OF THE 1960S. YOU'LL LEARN ABOUT THE ADVANCED POLITICAL CONSERVATISM DEVELOPMENTS IN SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, DEMOGRAPHIC SHIFTS THAT HAD CULTURAL AND POLITICAL CONSEQUENCES IN THIS PERIOD.

TOPICS MAY INCLUDE REAGAN AND CONSERVATISM, THE END OF THE COLD WAR, SHIFTS IN THE ECONOMY, MIGRATION, AND IMMIGRATION. CHALLENGES OF THE 21ST CENTURY. UNIT FIVE REVOLUTIONS. YOU'LL START YOUR STUDY OF THE PERIOD 1750 TO 1900 BY EXPLORING THE NEW POLITICAL IDEAS AND DEVELOPMENTS AND TECHNOLOGY THAT LED TO LARGE SCALE CHANGES IN GOVERNMENT, SOCIETY AND ECONOMIES. IF YOUR HONEST CONCERN WAS THAT THE AFRICAN AMERICAN COURSE WAS TOO ROUGH OR VAGUE OR TOO POLITICAL, THEN I BELIEVE THERE SHOULD BE AN AUDIT REVIEW OF THE AFOREMENTIONED AP COURSES. TO YOUR POINT, THAT'S ALL THE IN-PERSON SPEAKERS. THANK YOU. I KNOW WE HAD A COUPLE NAMES. WE CALLED THAT, DIDN'T GET THE CHANCE TO GO. SO IF YOU DIDN'T SPEAK YET, IF YOU BUT YOU AND YOU WERE ON THE LIST, IF YOU COULD JUST STAND UP AND COME TO THE PODIUM AND IDENTIFY YOURSELF. THANK YOU. ARE YOU THE ONLY ONE, OR WERE THERE A FEW OTHERS, I'M STANDING FROM THE PODIUM. OR DID YOU STAND? YEAH. WE CALLED. SURE. WE CALLED A COUPLE NAMES. SO WE'LL GIVE YOU THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN WHATEVER ORDER YOU LIKE. HE TOOK, THE PEOPLE OUTSIDE OVER TO OUR CHURCH SO THEY CAN OBSERVE. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS CONSTANCE ROSSER, AND I AM A PROUD MEMBER OF THE RACIAL JUSTICE ALLIANCE OF MARYLAND, WHICH IS A GROUP OF

[02:40:05]

CHRISTIAN CHURCHES HERE IN HARFORD COUNTY WHO HAVE SEEN A NEED TO GET TOGETHER. WE ALSO ARE PARTNERED WITH BRIDGE OF ALLIANCE OF MARYLAND, WHICH IS WHO DOCTOR TILGHMAN REPRESENTS.

WE WROTE AN OP ED RESPONSE TO WHAT YOU SAID ON THE 26TH OF JUNE. IT HAS YET TO BE POSTED, BUT WE WILL CONTINUE TO FORGE AHEAD. ONE OF THE THINGS I WANT TO TELL YOU IS WE WENT TO THE SCHOOLS AND WE SPOKE TO THE CHILDREN. I MYSELF WENT TO JOPPATOWNE AND WHAT THE CHILDREN SAID WAS I AM NOW EMPOWERED, I AM INFORMED AND I AM EXCITED THAT CLASS WAS DIVERSE AND THEY WERE THERE TO LEARN. I HAD AN ENCOUNTER WITH A STUDENT FROM ENTERPRISE, ALABAMA. I'M A PROUD GRADUATE OF TUSKEGEE INSTITUTE AND I WAS ABLE TO COMMUNICATE WITH HER ABOUT WHY I CHOSE THAT SCHOOL AND THE FOURTH GRADE. I LEARNED ABOUT A MAN NAMED BOOKER T WASHINGTON. WHAT DID HE DO? HE LIFT A VEIL OF IGNORANCE FROM HIS PEOPLE. SO I KNEW IF I WAS THERE, THERE WAS SOMETHING THAT I WAS GOING TO LEARN AS MY CHURCH BONDED WITH OTHER CHURCHES, WE SAID WE NEEDED TO KNOW THIS. I MADE SURE MY CHILDREN LEARNED THEIR HISTORY AND WAS ENGAGED IN LEARNING EVERY RELIGIOUS EVENT THAT WAS HERE IN THE COUNTY, SO THEY COULD RESPECT PEOPLE. WE ARE GLAD TO HEAR THAT MISS ERIN LAN, AS THE SUPERVISOR OF SOCIAL SCIENTISTS, HAS BEEN WORKING WITH US. WE WANT YOU TO KNOW EDUCATION SHOULD SEEK TO INCLUDE TWO BRANDS AND PURPOSE CRITICAL THINKING AND MORAL DEVELOPMENT. FAILURE TO DO THAT WILL HANDICAP OUR GENERATION MORE. THANK YOU.

DEAR HARFORD COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS, I ASK THAT YOU DON'T LET THE PERFECT BE THE ENEMY OF GOOD AS DEDUCTED FROM AN OLD ITALIAN PROVERB BY FRENCH WRITER VOLTAIRE. FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO SUPPORTED THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES FOR REGULAR BASIS, THANK YOU FOR SEEING THE VALUE IN ITS ORIGINAL PROPOSAL. BUT I WAS A BIT DISMAYED BY THE COMMENTS OF OTHER BOARD MEMBERS BELIEVING THAT THIS COURSE WAS IMBALANCED WITH MORE NEGATIVES THAN POSITIVES. OVERALL, I DO ASK THAT BEFORE THIS BOARD MEETING INCIDENT THAT YOU AMEND THE AGENDA AND TAKE AN IMMEDIATE VOTE TO ACTUALLY HAVE THIS COURSE IMPLEMENTED ON A REGULAR BASIS. I SUBMIT TO YOU THAT EDUCATION CAN NEVER BE NEGATIVE. THE REASON WHY THIS COURSE IS CATEGORIZED UNDER THE SOCIAL SCIENCE UPDATE AS OPPOSED TO SOCIAL STUDIES, BECAUSE SOCIAL STUDIES PREPARES STUDENTS FOR CITIZENSHIP, WHILE SOCIAL SCIENCE STUDIES HOW SOCIETY FUNCTIONS, SOCIAL SCIENCE IS THE STUDY OF HUMAN SOCIETY AND RELATIONSHIPS THROUGH SCIENTIFIC ANALYSIS OF HUMAN GROUPS AND INSTITUTIONS. SOCIAL SCIENCE TOPICS INCLUDE ANTHROPOLOGY, SOCIOLOGY, PSYCHOLOGY, POLITICAL SCIENCE, ECONOMICS, EDUCATION, COMMERCE, AND DEMOGRAPHY. THERE'S HARDLY ANY IDEA THAT IS NOT POLITICALLY ORIENTED. THE ARGUMENT THAT THE WORLD WAS FLAT VERSUS ROUND WAS POLITICAL. AT SOME POINT IN TIME, THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION IS WORTH THE ACTIVATING ACTIVISM NEEDED TO UPHOLD DEMOCRACY. SO TEACHING ON ACTIVISM IS A POSITIVE THING. THE COURSE IS BALANCED BEYOND TEACHING ABOUT THE PROGRESS OF THE COUNTRY, AS WELL AS ON THE GREAT PEOPLE IN HISTORY. THE COURSE IS INTENDED TO EDUCATE THE GOAL OF EDUCATION IS TO MAKE PROGRESS IN SUPPORTING THIS COURSE IS INITIALLY, AS INITIALLY INTRODUCED, IS THE BEST THING GOING FORWARD. I ASK THAT YOU RECONSIDER THIS TONIGHT ON TODAY'S AGENDA OFFER AN AMENDMENT TO THE AGENDA TO VOTE TO SUPPORT THIS. BELIEVE ME, YOUR PERSONAL VIEWS SHOULD NOT TAKE IMPACT HERE. THINK ABOUT ALL THE PEOPLE WHO WANT THIS DONE. THANK YOU. CAN YOU PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME WHEN YOU COME TO THE PODIUM? OH, I THOUGHT YOU WERE COMING TO THE PODIUM. OKAY. IS THAT IT, I BELIEVE IF THERE IS, THERE WAS ONE PERSON IN THE WAITING ROOM, VIRTUALLY, I BELIEVE. YEAH. IS THERE A KAREEM WALLACE? YOU ALREADY SPOKE. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU THEN. NO OKAY. JILLIAN. JILLIAN HAS A VIRTUAL THERE IS ONE. YEAH. OKAY. JILLIAN, YOU MAY PROCEED. THANK YOU. DOCTOR BOYNTON. AND OUR SECOND VIRTUAL PREREGISTER HAS JOINED US IN THE LOBBY, SO I WILL HAVE TWO THIS EVENING.

[02:45:04]

GOOD EVENING. PHONE NUMBER ENDING IN EIGHT, FOUR, ONE, TWO. IF YOU CAN UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AT THIS TIME, YOU ARE NOW IN THE BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING. BEFORE YOU BEGIN YOUR PUBLIC COMMENT, PLEASE STATE YOUR FIRST AND LAST NAME. YOUR TIME WILL CONCLUDE IN TWO MINUTES. YOU WILL HEAR A BELL RING WHEN YOU HAVE 30S REMAINING. PLEASE INTRODUCE YOURSELF AND YOU MAY BEGIN YOUR PUBLIC COMMENT. NOW AGAIN, THAT'S PHONE NUMBER ENDING IN 8412. IF YOU CAN UNMUTE YOURSELF AT THIS TIME AND BEGIN YOUR PUBLIC COMMENT. WE CAN COME BACK TO THAT ONE.

LET'S JUST MOVE ON. YES. OH WHAT IS IT? GOOD IS IT LIKE A STAR SIX OR IS THERE SOMETHING THEY HAVE TO ENTER? DOCTOR POINT AND I WILL CIRCLE BACK TO THAT. I HAVE ADMITTED PHONE NUMBER ENDING IN FIVE, TWO, FIVE, THREE AND THEY ARE UNMUTED. SO I'LL GO AHEAD AND PROCEED WITH THAT NUMBER AND THEN CIRCLE BACK TO 8412. GREAT. THANK YOU. YOU'RE WELCOME. SO PHONE NUMBER ENDING IN 5253. YOU ARE NOW ON THE BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING. BEFORE YOU BEGIN YOUR PUBLIC COMMENT, PLEASE STATE YOUR FIRST AND LAST NAME. YOUR TIME WILL CONCLUDE IN TWO MINUTES. YOU WILL HEAR A BELL RING WHEN YOU HAVE 30S REMAINING. PLEASE INTRODUCE YOURSELF AND YOU MAY BEGIN YOUR PUBLIC COMMENT. NOW. HELLO? YES, GO AHEAD AND YOU CAN BEGIN YOUR PUBLIC COMMENT. YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES. OH, OKAY. I DON'T KNOW IF IT WAS THE RIGHT NUMBER, MY NAME IS ARAVINDA MURRAY. I WOULD LIKE TO SAY, THAT, BECAUSE I MIGHT RUN OUT OF TIME. I JUST WANTED TO TAKE A MINUTE TO RECOMMEND PRECIOUS KNOWLEDGE, WHICH IS A DOCUMENTARY ABOUT A STRUGGLE OVER ETHNIC STUDIES CURRICULUM. IT IS FROM 2011, IN ARIZONA. THAT'S SO RELEVANT FOR US HERE TODAY. WHAT PITS US AGAINST ONE ANOTHER IS NOT THE STUDY OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY, BUT THE SILENCING OF IT. WHAT CREATES DIVISIONS IS NOT THE STUDY OF WOMEN'S PERSPECTIVE, BUT IGNORING THEM. 40 YEARS AGO, WHEN I WAS IN HIGH SCHOOL HISTORY CLASS RIGHT HERE IN BEL AIR, OUR TEACHER TOLD US THAT IN DICTATORSHIPS, STUDENTS WERE TAUGHT A CLEANED UP VERSION OF HISTORY AND WERE NOT ALLOWED TO CRITICIZE THE NATION, THE LEADER, OR TO QUESTION THE WAY HISTORY WAS PRESENTED. IN CONTRAST, THEY TOLD US WE LIVED IN A DEMOCRACY WHERE WE WERE NOT ONLY ALLOWED BUT ENCOURAGED TO THINK CRITICALLY AND WITH AN OPEN MIND ABOUT THE PAST. AS WELL AS THE PRESENT. LISTENING TO STUDENTS TODAY MAKE SUCH ELOQUENT CASES FOR STUDYING HISTORY. IT IS CLEAR THAT WHAT MAKES HISTORYNG IS ITS HONESTY AND CRITICAL APPROACH.

CIVIL RIGHTS DID NOT JUST HAPPEN BY MAGIC. IT WAS THROUGH STRUGGLE, THROUGH COURAGEOUS ACTIVISTS WHO TOOK GREAT PERSONAL RISK TO CHALLENGE THE STATUS QUO. IF INSTEAD WE TEACH A WATERED DOWN, SANITIZED, FEEL GOOD VERSION OF SUCH EVENTS, THAT IS A RECIPE FOR MAKING HISTORY CLASS BORING. APPARENTLY SOME BOARD MEMBERS FOUND THAT THE AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CURRICULUM LACKED POSITIVITY. WHAT IS POSITIVITY? IS IT TRULY POSITIVE ONLY TO FOCUS ON WHAT IS GOOD AND RIGHT WHILE IGNORING THE PEOPLE WHO FOUGHT FOR THOSE RIGHTS, THE RISKS THEY TOOK? WHAT IS TRULY POSITIVE IS TO HAVE THE MATURITY, TO LOOK AT HISTORY FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THOSE WHOSE VOICES MAY HAVE BEEN SUPPRESSED IN THEIR TIME. WHAT IS TRULY POSITIVE IS TO LEARN FROM THE STRATEGIES THEY USE TO OVERCOME THAT SUPPRESSION, AND TO RECOGNIZE THAT OUR SOCIETY IS ALWAYS A WORK IN PROGRESS THAT WE MAY NEED TO USE THOSE VERY STRATEGIES TO ACHIEVE THE NEXT BIG SOCIAL CHANGE HAVE REACHED THE TWO MINUTE BRIGHTER THAN TODAY. THANK YOU. OKAY. PHONE NUMBER ENDING IN 8412. IF YOU CAN PRESS STAR SIX TO UNMUTE YOUR PHONE AT THIS TIME. AGAIN, THAT'S PHONE NUMBER ENDING IN 8412. AND I THINK WE HAVE WE MIGHT HAVE SOUND. SO PHONE NUMBER ENDING IN 8412. PLEASE BE SURE TO INTRODUCE YOURSELF. YOUR FIRST AND LAST NAME. YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES. YOU MAY BEGIN YOUR PUBLIC COMMENT NOW. HELLO, I AM DEB TALBOT AND AS A LONG TIME RESIDENT OF HARFORD COUNTY AND RETIRED SOCIAL STUDIES TEACHER FROM PAROCHIAL SCHOOL SYSTEMS, I'M SPEAKING TO EXPRESS WHAT MANY HAVE DONE TONIGHT, AND THAT'S DISAPPOINTMENT IN THE BOARD'S DECISION ABOUT THE AP. AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE, LET ME JUST SAY BOARD MEMBERS OPPOSED TO THIS COURSE HAVE SHARED THAT THEY FELT THAT THE CONTENT WAS UNBALANCED, PITTING RACE AGAINST RACE AND THUS CREATING A DIVISIVE ENVIRONMENT. HAVING STUDIED THE CURRICULUM, HOWEVER, I'M IN FULL SUPPORT OF IT. THE COURSE HAS BEEN SHAPED OVER THE YEARS BY MANY EMINENT SCHOLARS IN THE FIELD. HOWEVER, HEAR ME PLEASE, IF SOME BOARD MEMBERS DO SEE THE CURRICULUM AS TOO UNBALANCED OR DIVISIVE, WHICH I DO NOT CONSIDER THIS ONE OF THE OBJECTIVES OF THE AP

[02:50:07]

COURSE IS TO FOSTER CRITICAL THINKING AND ANY GOOD SOCIAL STUDIES TEACHER WOULD ENCOURAGE DISCUSSION TO CHALLENGE PERSPECTIVES THAT MIGHT APPEAR UNBALANCED OR DIVISIVE BY SOME PEOPLE, AND THEREBY GIVE STUDENTS A SAFE ENVIRONMENT TO LOOK AT DIFFICULT SUBJECT MATTER. AND ACTUALLY, IT IS THE COLLEGE BOARD'S PHILOSOPHY THAT AP AP STUDENTS ARE EXPECTED TO ANALYZE DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES TO MAKE UP THEIR OWN MINDS. AS A HIGH SCHOOL TEACHER OF AMERICAN GOVERNMENT, CONTEMPORARY ISSUES, US HISTORY, THE SAME COURSES TAUGHT BY HSPS. MY CLASS DISCUSSIONS NATURALLY INVOLVE PRESENTING DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES ABOUT THE HUMAN EXPERIENCE, WHICH HAS BEEN DIVISIVE AND CONTENTIOUS AT TIMES. WE ALL DON'T THINK ALIKE.

THE BOARD HAS NOT ADVOCATED THAT THESE COURSES SHOULD NOT BE TAUGHT, BECAUSE THEY MAY BE TOO DIVISIVE. SO LET'S NOT USE THAT ARGUMENT TO NOT ALLOW THE AP COURSE TO BE USED. TRUST YOUR TEACHERS. THE CURRICULUM IS FACTUAL, WITH VARIOUS VIEWPOINTS FROM GROUPS AND LEADERS.

ACTUALLY, IT ENLIGHTENS STUDENTS TO A MORE COMPLETE HISTORY OF OUR COUNTRY. INSTEAD OF DICTATING THOSE WHOSE HISTORY DOES AND DOES NOT BELONG, AND STUDENTS OF ALL RACES GAIN A DEEPER. YOU HAVE REACHED THE TWO MINUTE MARK. THANK YOU. AND THAT CONCLUDES OUR VIRTUAL PUBLIC

[Board Member Comments ]

SPEAKERS FOR THE EVENING. OKAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND THANK YOU, EVERYONE WHO SHOWED UP TO GIVE YOUR PUBLIC COMMENTS. THIS EVENING. WE WILL MOVE ON WITH BOARD MEMBER COMMENTS, WE'LL START DOWN ON THIS END WITH MISS STRAUSS. GOOD EVENING. SASHA, CONGRATULATIONS ON YOUR SWEARING IN. WE ARE EXCITED TO HAVE YOU. I LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH YOU AND KNOW THAT YOU WILL BRING A VERY UNIQUE AND IMPORTANT PERSPECTIVE TO THIS BOARD. TONIGHT, I WANT TO DISCUSS OUR ROLE IN APPROVING CURRICULUM. IT IS ONE OF OUR MOST CRITICAL RESPONSIBILITIES. SADLY, I BELIEVE THAT CPS IS TOO OFTEN FALLEN VICTIM TO A BOARD THAT HAS ADOPTED A RUBBER STAMP APPROACH TO GOVERNING. AT TIMES, WE HAVE WITNESSED A HANDS OFF APPROACH WITHOUT ACTIVE PARTICIPATION IN DELIBERATION. THIS APPROACH CAN BE DANGEROUS AND HAS LED TO OBSTACLES WE'RE CURRENTLY FACING. PASSIVE ENDORSEMENT WITHOUT MEANINGFUL ENGAGEMENT OR OVERSIGHT HAS LED TO COMPLACENCY, AND I BELIEVE IT'S CAUSING UNNECESSARY CONFLICT BETWEEN STAFF AND BOARD MEMBERS WHO I'M CERTAIN SHARE THE SAME GOAL OF PREPARING EACH STUDENT TO ACHIEVE SUCCESS, TO MAKE SOUND DECISIONS ABOUT WHAT AND HOW CHILDREN ARE BEING TAUGHT. WE HAVE TO BE ABLE TO SEE, REVIEW AND PROVIDE INPUT ON WHAT WE'RE BEING ASKED TO VOTE FOR. THIS BOARD WAS NOT GIVEN FULL ACCESS TO THE SOCIAL SCIENCES CURRICULUM IN CANVAS UNTIL JUNE 18TH, AND JUST LAST WEEK WE WERE NOTIFIED THAT THE CURRICULUM WE SPENT HOURS REVIEWING WAS CO-MINGLED WITH OLD AND NEW CURRICULUM ITEMS. I UNDERSTAND THAT WITH ANY NEW ROLL OUT PROCESS, CHALLENGES ARE GOING TO ARISE AND THAT PATIENCE DURING THIS PROCESS IS KEY. I'M HAPPY TO OFFER THAT PATIENCE, AND I ASK THAT THE STAFF AND THE COMMUNITY OFFER US BOARD MEMBERS THAT SAME PATIENCE, WHO HAS BEEN WORKING ON THESE CURRICULUM UPDATES AND CHANGES FOR OVER A YEAR, WAITING UNTIL THE LAST MINUTE TO SEEK APPROVAL AND THEN PRESSURING US TO APPROVE DUE TO LACK OF TIME IS NOT ACCEPTABLE.

IT'S IMPORTANT TO GET THIS RIGHT INSTEAD OF SUCCUMBING TO THE PRESSURE TO ADOPT A MANTRA, WE'LL FIX IT AS WE GO. WHEN IT COMES TO OUR CHILDREN'S EDUCATION, RUSHING TO FAILURE IS NOT AN OPTION. I HOLD THE BELIEF THAT OUR CHILDREN'S EDUCATION SHOULD BE BASED ON SCHOLARSHIP AND FACTS, SHOULD NURTURE THEIR DEVELOPMENT INTO THE HAPPY, RESILIENT, FREE THINKING, EDUCATED CITIZENS. EVERY DEMOCRACY NEEDS. OUR CLASSROOMS SHOULD INCLUDE RIGOROUS INSTRUCTION IN HISTORY, CIVICS, LITERATURE, MATH, THE SCIENCES AND THE IDEAS AND VALUES THAT ENRICH OUR COUNTRY. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT FOR THE COMMUNITY TO KNOW THAT CPS DOES CURRENTLY TEACH IN AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. COURSE. CURRENTLY, THERE ARE 49 STUDENTS ENROLLED FOR THE UPCOMING YEAR. I BELIEVE THAT AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY SHOULD BE TAUGHT. I BELIEVE THAT TEACHING IT ENCOURAGES BETTER CITIZENSHIP. IT EMPHASIZES THE TIES THAT BIND TOGETHER INDIVIDUALS, COMMUNITIES, AND GENERATIONS. IT ILLUMINATES THE STRUGGLES TO REDEFINE AND EXPAND CONSTITUTIONAL AND HUMAN RIGHTS FOR BOTH BLACK AND NON-BLACK PEOPLE. WE SHOULD NOT PREVENT THE TEACHING OF ABSOLUTE WRONG AS WRONG, AND WE SHOULD ENSURE WHEN CONTROVERSIAL TOPICS ARE

[02:55:02]

PRESENTED, THAT BALANCED AND DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES ARE OFFERE. REGARDING THE SIXTH GRADE SOCIAL STUDIES CURRICULUM, I STILL STRUGGLE TO UNDERSTAND THE MARYLAND STATE FRAMEWORK. IT REMOVES THE STUDY OF THE BYZANTINE EMPIRE, THE FALL OF ROME, AND INSIST THAT WE'RE TEACHING SIXTH GRADERS ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE AND PERPETUATES THE NOTION THAT CAPITALISM CAUSES IMPERIALISM. I'M INCREDIBLY APPRECIATIVE TO THE STAFF, WHO I KNOW HAVE SPENT COUNTLESS HOURS OVER THE LAST FEW WEEKS LISTENING TO US, WORKING UPDATES, COMMUNICATING TO ENSURE THAT DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES EXIST. I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO TONIGHT'S UPDATE. I TRULY HOPE THAT WE CAN FIND A PATH FORWARD. WE HAVE SO MUCH GOOD THAT BINDS US TOGETHER. I ENCOURAGE US ALL TO DO OUR BEST TO SHOW LOVE, HUMILITY, KINDNESS, AND RESPECT. THANK YOU, MR. SOWELL. I FIRST WANT TO WELCOME OUR NEW STUDENT MEMBER OF THE BOARD, MISS BOUZOUKI. I VERY MUCH LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH YOU AND MEMBERS OF STUDENT GOVERNMENTS FROM AROUND THE COUNTY, THIS COMING YEAR TO ADVANCE THE EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES AND ENVIRONMENT THROUGHOUT THE DISTRICT. SO WELCOME. I'M VERY GRATEFUL FOR THE ENGAGEMENT OF THE COMMUNITY THIS EVENING AND THOSE WHO TOOK THE TIME TO WRITE US THANK YOU TO THE PAST MEMBERS OF THE BOARD WHO ARE HERE TONIGHT. I APPRECIATE THE PERSPECTIVE YOU PROVIDE TO THIS BOARD. I ALSO WANT TO THANK, THOSE AT CPS, PARTICULARLY MISS ERIN LANG, WHO SPENT COUNTLESS HOURS, ANSWERING QUESTIONS FROM BOARD MEMBERS REGARDING THE TOPICS THIS EVENING. I ECHO THOSE WHO HAVE ADVOCATED FOR THIS BOARD TO APPROVE THE ADVANCED PLACEMENT AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE TO BE IMPLEMENTED AT ALL HIGH SCHOOLS THROUGHOUT THE DISTRICT. I SUPPORT THIS 100. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU, MISS PERRY. GOOD EVENING, AND I'M SO GLAD TO SEE SO MANY PEOPLE OUT IN FAVOR OF THIS PARTICULAR COURSE. I'M GOING TO READ, AN EMAIL THAT I THINK MOST OF THE BOARD MEMBERS RECEIVED FROM THE LEGISLATIVE BLACK CAUCUS OF MARYLAND, INCORPORATED. DEAR MEMBERS OF THE HARFORD COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION ON BEHALF OF THE LEGISLATIVE BLACK CAUCUS OF MARYLAND, THE LARGEST BLACK CAUCUS IN THE NATION WITH THE MEMBERSHIP OF 65 MEMBERS OF THE MARYLAND GENERAL ASSEMBLY. WE WRITE WITH GRAVE CONCERN ABOUT THE DISCUSSION ON ADVANCED PLACEMENT. AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES AT THE JUNE 24TH, 2024 HARFORD COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING AND THE FIVE FOUR DECISION TO DENY HARPER COUNTY STUDENTS ACCESS TO AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. WHILE THE LEGISLATIVE BLACK CAUCUS OF MARYLAND DOES NOT FREQUENTLY SPEAK OUT IN REGARDS TO LOCAL ACTIONS, WE BELIEVE OUR DECISION TO DENY THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE IN HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS IS OF STATEWIDE AND NATIONAL IMPORTANCE, AND THE STATE WITH RICH AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY AND AT A TIME WHERE BANS ON BOOKS AND DENIAL OF BLACK HISTORY ARE REAL, IT IS DISAPPOINTING TO SEE THIS ACTION TAKEN BY THE HARFORD COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD. WE RESPECTFULLY URGE YOUR RECONSIDERATION DURING THE MEETING, SOME MEMBERS EXPRESSED THAT THE COURSE WAS NOT POSITIVE ENOUGH AND THAT THE ACTIVISM TOPICS ARE TOO DIVISIVE TO BE TAUGHT IN HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS. THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES FRAMEWORK WAS CREATED BY EXPERTS WITHIN THE AP PROGRAM, WITH GUIDANCE FROM A COMMITTEE OF HIGHER EDUCATION FACULTY AND HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS. THEY FACE THE CHALLENGE OF CONDENSING THE EXTENSIVE FIELD OF AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES INTO A COURSE THAT MIRRORS THE STUDENT EXPERIENCE IN AN INTRODUCTORY, COLLEGE LEVEL CLASS. TO ACHIEVE THIS COMMITTEE, AN AP PROGRAM EXPERTS ANALYZED DATA FROM OVER 100 COLLEGE SYLLABI AND GATHERED FEEDBACK FROM HUNDREDS OF FACULTY MEMBERS, MAKING TOUGH DECISIONS ABOUT THE CONTENT TO INCLUDE. WHILE THE COURSE FRAMEWORK OUTLINES THE REQUIRED MATERIAL, INDIVIDUAL TEACHERS ARE ENCOURAGED TO SUPPLEMENT IT WITH ADDITIONAL CONTEXT CONTENT AS THEY SEE FIT. WE ARE INCREDIBLY IMPRESSED BY THE COLLEGE BOARD'S WORK, THOROUGH WORK IN DEVELOPING A FRAMEWORK THAT REFLECTS BOTH THE COLLEGE LEVEL INTRODUCTORY EXPERIENCE AND THE BREADTH OF AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. AN HONEST REVIEW OF ANY AREA OF HISTORY WILL OFTEN REVEAL UNCOMFORTABLE OR HARSH REALITIES, REALITIES THAT SHOULD BE STUDIED AND LEARNED FROM, ESPECIALLY BY STUDENTS WHO WILL BE OUR FUTURE LEADERS. FURTHERMORE, ACTIVISM AND SOCIAL JUSTICE ARE A CORE PART OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. FROM ENSLAVEMENT TO JIM CROW RACISM, THE TRIUMPH OF THE VOTING RIGHTS ACT OF 1965, AND OTHER CIVIL RIGHTS LEGISLATION. LEGISLATION. THE IMPACT OF BROWN VERSUS BOARD OF EDUCATION, AND MORE. THE RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS WE ENJOY NOW WERE NOT SIMPLY GRANTED TO BLACK PEOPLE IN THE

[03:00:01]

UNITED STATES. AFRICAN AMERICANS HAVE FOUGHT FOR THEIR OWN RIGHTS, FREEDOM AND EQUALITY, OFTEN IN COALITION AND WITH WHITE ALLIES. AS OUTLINED IN THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE, OUR HISTORY AND CONTRIBUTIONS BEGAN IN OUR HOMELANDS IN AFRICA. LONG BEFORE OUR ANCESTORS WERE BROUGHT TO AMERICA. THE LEGISLATIVE BLACK CAUCUS OF AMERICA OF MARYLAND EXISTS BECAUSE WE HAVE BEEN A PART OF PROGRESS IN OUR STATE FOR DECADES, BUT WE RECOGNIZE THAT WE STILL HAVE A LONG WAY TO GO. THE LEGISLATIVE BLACK CAUCUS OF MARYLAND EMBODIES AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY DAILY, WHERE SEVERAL OF OUR MEMBERS BEING THE FIRST BLACK LEGISLATORS TO EVER REPRESENT THEIR DISTRICT OR THEIR COUNTIES. THIS IS THE CASE IN HARFORD COUNTY, WHERE DELEGATE ANDRE JOHNSON WAS THE FIRST AMERICAN BLACK AFRICAN AMERICAN TO REPRESENT HIS DISTRICT ON THE HARFORD COUNTY COUNCIL AND IS NOW THE ONLY MEMBER OF OUR CAUCUS HAILING FROM HARFORD COUNTY IN THE MARYLAND GENERAL ASSEMBLY. THE GREATEST ABOLITIONIST IN OUR NATION, FREDERICK DOUGLASS WAS BORN ON THE SHORES OF MARYLAND AND FAMOUSLY SAID, WITHOUT STRUGGLE, THERE IS NO PROGRESS. OUR HERO, OUR NATIONAL HERO RECOGNIZED THAT THE HISTORY OF AMERICA AND THE HISTORY OF AFRICAN AMERICANS IS INTERTWINED AND AT TIMES IS A DARK AND PAINFUL HISTORY. HOWEVER, WITHOUT THE STRUGGLES AND ADVOCACY THAT A PART OF THE FABRIC OF OUR HISTORY, WE CANNOT MAKE PROGRESS TOWARDS THE COUNTRY AND STATE THAT IS AS GREAT AS OUR IDEALS AND MAKING DECISIONS FROM THE HISTORY CURRICULUM. WE URGE YOU TO CONSIDER PRIORITIZING ACCURACY AND SCHOLARLY INTEGRITY OVER THE PERCEIVED DIFFICULTY OF TRUTHFUL HISTORY. HISTORY SHOULD NOT BE COUCHED IN WHETHER IT IS NEGATIVE OR POSITIVE. IT SHOULD BE COUCHED IN THE TRUTH AND FACT. IF YOU VIEW THE HISTORICAL TRUTH TO BE DIVISIVE OR CHALLENGING, IMAGINE THE IMPACT OF THOSE OF US WHO LIVE WITH IT DAILY. FURTHERMORE, SINCE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS NOT A REQUIRED COURSE AND NO STUDENT IS OBLIGATED TO TAKE THIS COURSE, KNOWING IT AS AN OPTION FOR STUDENTS LIMITS THEIR OPPORTUNITY FOR FUTURE ACHIEVEMENT. ACCORDING TO THE COLLEGE BOARD, STUDENTS WHO EARN A THREE OR HIGHER ON ONE OR MORE AP EXAMS OR MORE LIKELY TO GRADUATE FROM COLLEGE IN FIVE YEARS OR LESS, EVEN WHEN CONTROLLING FOR PRIOR ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT, DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES AND SCHOOL LEVEL VARIABLES, PROVIDING A VARIETY OF COURSES OF INTEREST SUCH AS AN AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES THAT STUDENTS CAN IDENTIFY WITH HELP PROVIDE AN OPTION TO STUDENTS WHO MAY NOT HAVE SEEN THEMSELVES REFLECTED IN THE OTHER AVAILABLE COURSES.

STUDENTS OF ALL RACES AND EXCUSE ME, ETHNICITIES ARE DEPRIVED IF NOT ALLOWED. THIS CHOICE, AS THE COURSE OFFERS OPPORTUNITIES FOR SHARED EXPERIENCES AND EXPRESSION OF VARIED OPINIONS.

WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION OF THIS LETTER AND OUR REQUEST TO RECONSIDER YOUR VOTE, TO DENY THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE. WE ALSO REQUEST A PRIVATE MEETING TO FURTHER DISCUSS THIS MATTER IN THE NEXT FEW WEEKS. JANELLE WILKINS, CHAIR OF THE LEGISLATIVE BLACK CAUCUS OF MARYLAND. THANK YOU, MISS. ALL RIGHT, SO BEFORE I GET AHEAD OF MYSELF, I FIRST WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT TO ACKNOWLEDGE ALL THE SUPPORT AND WARM SMILES I'VE RECEIVED SINCE BEING ELECTED AS YOUR STUDENT MEMBER OF THE BOARD. I CANNOT WAIT TO SEE WHAT MY TERM HOLDS AND WHAT YOU GUYS ALL HAVE TO SAY. ADDITIONALLY, THE GOAL OF MY ELECTION WAS TO ENHANCE MY TRANSPARENCY BETWEEN THE BOARD AND THE STUDENTS AND I PLAN TO DO THAT BY USING VARIOUS PLATFORMS TO NOT ONLY REACH TO THE STUDENTS, BUT TO THE COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE. I THOUGHT THAT SO NOW THAT THAT IS OUT THE WAY, I'D LIKE TO SPEAK ON THE MOST RECENT DECISION REGARDING THE STATUS OF THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. SO PERSONALLY, I'M A STUDENT AT THE ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL AND I HAVE BEEN I HAVE A LOT OF FRIENDS AND PEERS WHO ARE ENROLLED IN AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY AND WITH THAT IS CLEAR TO ME TO SEE THE IMPACT AND SIGNIFICANCE THAT THIS COURSE HOLDS TO THE STUDENT BOD. ALTHOUGH IT HAS BEEN ACKNOWLEDGED THAT THERE ARE A FEW FLAWS IN THE CURRICULUM, I CANNOT SUPPORT THAT. THAT IS A VALID REASON TO REMOVE THE ENTIRETY OF A COURSE. HISTORY MAY NOT BE MY FAVORITE SUBJECT, BUT I CAN APPRECIATE ITS CONTRIBUTIONS TO DEVELOPMENT AND GROWTH FOR THE STUDENTS, AND IT WOULD DENY SUCH A PRIVILEGE TO TAKE THAT AWAY FROM THEM. NOW, NOT ONLY DOES THIS COURSE EDUCATE THE STUDENTS, BUT ALSO PROVIDES THEM WITH THE OPPORTUNITY TO EXCEL WITH THAT KNOWLEDGE BY TRANSLATING INTO COLLEGE, I HAVE TAKEN NINE AP COURSES DURING MY THREE YEARS ENROLLED AT ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL, AND USING THAT EXPERIENCE, I CAN CONFIDENTLY SAY THAT THESE AP COURSES HAVE ALLOWED HAVE ALLOWED ME TO BECOME COLLEGE AND CAREER READY, WHICH IS ULTIMATELY ONE OF OUR GOALS AS HSPS. I ALSO LIKE TO MAKE THE POINT, AND I'M SURE THAT THIS HAS BEEN ECHOED, BUT IT'S NOT FAIR TO PULL APART A CERTAIN CURRICULUM AND SPECIFIC AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY WITHOUT EQUALLY ANALYZING THE OTHER HISTORIES AVAILABLE. ADDITIONALLY, I'D LIKE TO TAKE THE MOMENT TO CONSIDER THE ALTERNATIVE. IF WE FALL THROUGH AND VOTE AGAINST REDEEMING THIS COURSE AS A REGULAR STATUS. STUDENTS WHO ARE EASILY SUSCEPTIBLE TO ONLINE INFLUENCE

[03:05:01]

WILL SEARCH FOR EXTERNAL RESOURCES TO EDUCATE THEMSELVES ON SUCH TOPIC. ALTHOUGH I AM GRATEFUL TO LIVE IN A TIME WHERE THERE ARE MILLIONS OF RESOURCES AVAILABLE BY THE TOUCH OF THE HAND. I'M ALSO AWARE OF HOW EASILY IT IS TO STUMBLE UPON FALSE NEWS. IF YOU WANT TO TALK ABOUT ULTERIOR OR ULTERIOR AGENDAS, THEN PLEASE DON'T LEAVE THE STUDENTS TO BLINDLY SEARCH FOR ANSWERS WHEN WE HAVE QUALIFIED TEACHERS WHO ARE WILLING AND EXCITED TO PROVIDE A STRUCTURED EDUCATION FOR OUR STUDENTS. FURTHERMORE, AS I ENTER THE COLLEGE PROCESS, I HAVE BUILT CLOSE RELATIONS WITH MY COUNSELORS AND HAVE BEEN ABLE TO SEE THE IMMENSE WORK THAT THEY'VE BEEN PUTTING IN TO DEVELOPING THE SCHEDULES THAT ALIGN WITH THE STUDENTS AND THEIR DESIRES. I WANT US NOT TO NEGLECT THE CONTENT. I WANT US NOT TO NEGLECT THE CONCEPT THAT BY REMOVING THIS COURSE, YOU WILL BE PLACING PLACING A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF WORK ON THE COUNSELORS AS WELL AS DEVASTATING ALL THE STUDENTS WHO INTENDED ON TAKING THE COURSE.

NOW, IF WE SEEK TO APPRECIATE THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF AFRICAN AMERICANS AND THE PERSISTENCE AND THEIR HARDSHIPS, THEN I BELIEVE WE SHOULD BE ABLE TO INCORPORATE THOSE IN THE MONTH OF MAY AND JUNE AFTER THE EXAM IS OVER. HOWEVER, I DO FIND IT DIFFICULT TO SPEAK ON SUCH DETAILS REGARDING THE COURSE HAS NOT BEEN AS I HAD NOT TAKEN IT AND I DON'T HAVE FULL ACCESS TO THE CURRICULUM. I'M PURELY SPEAKING OFF THE STUDENT PERSPECTIVE AND THAT IS NOT TO BE DISREGARDED. THAT IS ONE OF THOSE WHO ARE BEING DIRECTLY IMPACTED BY THIS DECISION. NOW, SPEAKING OF A SCRIPT, I WANT TO GET A LITTLE MORE PERSONAL AND TALK ABOUT MY EXPERIENCE. SO YOU GUYS MAY NOT KNOW THIS, BUT I'M THE FIRST STUDENT REPRESENTATIVE ON THE SCHOOL PERFORMANCE AND ACHIEVEMENT TEAM AT ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL, AND THAT IS THE ONLY STUDENT REPRESENTATIVE OUT OF ALL THE SCHOOLS IN CPS. NOW WITH THAT, JUST IN SHORT, DURING THESE MEETINGS WE WERE ABLE TO LOOK OVER THE STATISTICS OF THE SCHOOL TO ULTIMATELY FURTHER OUR STUDENTS EDUCATION AND MAKE SURE THAT IT'S A GOOD ENVIRONMENT. AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE CONSTANTLY LOOK AT ARE THE AP ENROLLMENT RATES. AND BEING A STUDENT THAT ATTENDS A PREDOMINANTLY BLACK SCHOOL, WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO SEE THAT THE COURSE OPTION FOR AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY HAS ULTIMATELY WORKED AS A GATEWAY FOR ALL THE STUDENTS HAVE ACCESS TO THAT, AND IT HAS BEEN AMAZING TO WATCH MY STUDENTS AND MY PEERS GROW AS THEY START HAVING THESE DIFFERENT OPPORTUNITIES TO HAVE THE CAREER AND COLLEGE READY AND LASTLY, WITH THAT SAID, I DO APPRECIATE THE BOARD'S EFFORT TO ANALYZE THE CURRICULUM AND TAKE A MOMENT TO CREATE AN OPINION WITHOUT JUST BLINDLY ACCEPTING OR DECLINING THIS COURSE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, DOCTOR MUELLER. THANK YOU. TWICE. ONCE LAST MONTH AND ONCE THIS MONTH. I HEARD A BOARD MEMBER SAY THAT THIS BOARD IS MORE ENGAGED THAN PREVIOUS BOARDS. I WONDER HOW CASSANDRA BEVERLY WOULD FEEL ABOUT THAT. I WONDER HOW DAVID BAUER WOULD FEEL ABOUT THAT. AND I DEFINITELY WONDER HOW JIM THORNTON WOULD FEEL ABOUT THAT, BECAUSE ALL THREE OF THOSE FORMER BOARD MEMBERS CAME HERE TONIGHT TO SPEAK ABOUT THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. I ALSO KNOW FOR A FACT THAT JOE VASCO LISTENS TO EVERY MEETING I'VE HEARD FROM HIM BEFORE. WHEN HE TALKS ABOUT WHAT GOES ON AT THE MEETINGS. I KNOW THAT DOCTOR ROY PHILLIPS AND SONJA KARWACKI OFTEN LISTEN TO THE MEETINGS. THEY DID MISS ONE RECENTLY. BUT THERE ARE A LOT OF BOARD MEMBERS WHO NOT ONLY PAID A LOT OF ATTENTION WHILE THEY WERE ON THE BOARD, BUT PAID A LOT OF ATTENTION. NOW, NANCY REYNOLDS WOULD BE ANOTHER ONE. I THINK IT'S REALLY UNFAIR FOR PEOPLE HAVE ONLY BEEN ON THE BOARD FOR A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME. A YEAR TO SIT THERE AND SAY THAT PREVIOUS BOARDS DIDN'T CARE, DIDN'T DO THEIR DUE DILIGENCE, DIDN'T DO THE THINGS THAT THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO DO BECAUSE I DON'T SEE HOW I WOULD KNOW WHAT EVERY OTHER BOARD MEMBER DID, AND I DON'T KNOW HOW THEY WOULD DO, HOW THEY WOULD KNOW THAT. SO I REALLY FEEL LIKE THOSE ARE UNFAIR STATEMENTS AND MAYBE STATEMENTS THAT ARE JUST MADE TO MAKE THEMSELVES FEEL BETTER ABOUT THE THINGS THAT THEY SAY. I DO THINK WE SHOULD OFFER AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY OR AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. EXCUSE ME. I DO THINK THAT THAT COURSE SHOULD BE OFFERED IN OUR SCHOOLS. IT IS AN ELECTIVE COURSE. THE STUDENTS WHO WANT TO TAKE IT CAN TAKE IT. THE STUDENTS THAT DON'T WANT TO TAKE IT DON'T NEED TO TAKE IT. THE WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE CLASS THEY'VE MENTIONED, MARGARET SANGER. OF COURSE, WE ALL KNOW WHO MARGARET SANGER IS. SO WE LEARNED ABOUT HER AT SOME POINT IN OUR LIVES, WHETHER IT WAS IN A CLASS OR NOT. BUT WE'VE ALL HEARD OF HER BEFORE. SO IF YOU DON'T LIKE MARGARET SANGER, THAT'S FINE. BUT WAS SHE AN IMPORTANT WOMAN IN HISTORY? YES. SHE WAS. WAS SHE A SAVORY CHARACTER? NO. I MEAN, IS SHE A PERSON THAT I WANT TO EMULATE? NO, BUT SHE WAS AN IMPORTANT PERSON AND MAYBE A WOMAN THAT WOMEN SHOULD KNOW ABOUT. THE SIXTH GRADE SOCIAL STUDIES CURRICULUM. IT DOES MENTION, MAN CAUSED GLOBAL WARMING. YOU MAY OR MAY NOT AGREE WITH IT. TO TALK ABOUT BEING GOOD STEWARDS OF THE EARTH IS SOMETHING THAT I THINK WE CAN ALL AGREE ON, AND MAYBE, YOU KNOW, YOU HAVE TO LOOK AT WHAT THE COURSE WAS TRYING TO TEACH, WHAT THE

[03:10:04]

FRAMEWORK SAYS. I KNOW MRS. STRAUSS MENTIONED SHE DIDN'T UNDERSTAND WHAT THE FRAMEWORKS WENT WITH, HOW THE FRAMEWORKS WORKED, BUT THE FRAMEWORKS ARE JUST AN OUTLINE OF THE COURSE THAT THEN THE TEACHERS, WITH THEIR EXPERTISE FILL IN. OKAY SO, IF WE DON'T APPROVE THE CURRICULUM FOR THE SIXTH GRADE SOCIAL STUDIES, WE WILL LOSE FUNDING FROM THE STATE AND ALL THE TEST SCORES THAT WERE SO WORRIED ABOUT THAT. WE WANT OUR STUDENTS TO DO BETTER. WE WILL BE TEACHING THINGS THAT ARE NOT ON THE TEST, AND NOT TEACHING THINGS THAT ARE ON THE TEST.

SHOULD WE TEACH TO THE TEST? NO. BUT IF OUR STUDENTS DON'T HAVE THE COURSE THAT FOLLOWS, WHAT IS GOING TO BE TESTED ON, WE'RE GUARANTEED THAT THERE'S GOING TO BE A FAILURE THERE, DON'T WE? OKAY, SO I'M JUST SAYING THAT THAT WE NEED TO START LOOKING AT THESE, NOT JUST DO THEY FIT OUR AGENDA? DO THEY FIT THE THINGS WE BELIEVE IN, BUT WE HAVE TO LOOK AT WHAT'S REQUIRED BY THE STATE AND ELECTIVE COURSES ARE ELECTIVE COURSES. WE ALL WANT PARENT CHOICE, BUT THE PARENTS HAVE THE CHOICE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MISS KOCHER. OKAY, THANKS EVERYONE FOR BEING HERE, FOR LISTENING IN, LOTS IS GOING ON. WE DO APPRECIATE YOU ALL BEING HERE AND ALL THE PERSPECTIVES. BASED ON THE DISCUSSION TO DATE, I KNOW THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO ARE INTIMATELY FAMILIAR WITH THE COURSE. I HEAR THAT I THINK THERE'S PROBABLY JUST AS MANY THAT WE GOT EMAILS FROM THAT MAYBE WEREN'T FAMILIAR WITH, WITH ALL THE COURSE, I BASED ON MY REVIEW OF THE 294 PAGE DOCUMENT THAT WE GOT, MY GOAL WAS TO REVIEW THIS DOCUMENT IN DETAIL TO JUDGE WHETHER THE COURSE ACHIEVES ITS STATED OBJECTIVES, AND PROVIDES CRITICAL THINKING VALUE TO OUR STUDENTS, AND DETERMINE WHETHER IT WAS A GOOD COURSE FOR HARFORD COUNTY. I WHAT I SAID AT OUR LAST BOARD MEETING WAS THAT WE WANT AND NEED AN AFRICAN AMERICAN AP COURSE. WE DO HAVE A REGULAR AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY COURSE AS WELL. AND SO LET'S COME BACK TO THAT IN A LITTLE BIT, BUT THE MISSING INFORMATION IN TERMS OF POSITIVE MESSAGES, I WANTED TO CLARIFY THAT, I REALIZE THAT HISTORY IS UGLY. NO ONE, INCLUDING ME, SUGGESTED TO REMOVE ANY OF IT. I DON'T THINK ANYONE ELSE DID EITHER. BUT NO ONE HERE SUGGESTED REMOVING OR WHITEWASHING ANY OF THE HISTORY. WHAT WE SAID WAS, LET'S CAPTURE THE PROJECT, THE PROGRESS THAT HAS BEEN MADE SINCE HISTORY IS IN THE PAST. ONE OF THE OBJECTIVES OF THE COURSE IS TO RELATE CURRENT THE LEARNING TO CURRENT EVENTS. THAT'S GREAT, BUT TO DO THAT, YOU'VE GOT TO ACKNOWLEDGE WHAT'S IN THE PAST, VICE, WHAT'S GOING ON NOW. AND SO IF YOU DON'T INCLUDE UPDATED INFORMATION SUCH AS THE HARVARD STUDY ON RACIAL BIAS IN POLICE SHOOTINGS BY ROLAND FRYER, IF YOU DON'T INCLUDE INFORMATION ON THE PROGRESS MADE IN THE CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1964, EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY AND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION, DEI ACTIVITIES, ALL THOSE RECENT KINDS OF PROGRESS THINGS, I DID NOT SEE THEM IN THE COURSE. MAYBE SOMEONE ELSE CAN TELL ME, BUT I DID SEARCH THROUGH THE COURSE SEVERAL TIMES. SO THE PROGRESS THAT'S BEEN MADE, THAT'S WHAT I WAS TALKING ABOUT. THOSE POSITIVE THINGS, ABOUT THE PROGRESS I DID NOT SEE IN THE COURSE. AND SO MY GOAL IS WHEN YOU SAY HAVE A BALANCE, I WANT, ALL ASPECTS OF THE COURSE TO BE OF THE HISTORY AND THE EVENTS AND THE FACTS. I HEARD SEVERAL PEOPLE HERE TALK ABOUT, WE NEED A SOUND FOUNDATION OF FACTS, I TOTALLY AGREE, WE NEED UNCOMFORTABLE CONVERSATIONS. I TOTALLY AGREE, WE NEED ALL THE FACTS TO CREATE A BETTER PATH, SOME, ONE CITED THE SUN HEADLINES. WE ARE WHITEWASHING HISTORY. WE ARE NOT. WE NEVER SUGGEST REMOVING ANYTHING. SO.

BUT WHEN YOU HAVE THESE INFLAMMATORY HISTORIES OR THESE INFLAMMATORY HEADLINES AND PEOPLE TAKE, YOU KNOW, EXAGGERATE WHAT WE SAID, THAT'S NOT HELPING US COME TO A GOOD SOLUTION. WE DO WANT TO KEEP ALL THE HISTORY IN THE HISTORY COURSE. ABSOLUTELY. OKAY. OTHER THINGS THAT WE'RE MISSING, GREAT CONTRIBUTIONS FROM CLARENCE THOMAS, THOMAS SOWELL, TIM SCOTT, THURGOOD MARSHALL, RONALD MCNAIR. IT'S INTERESTING THAT NONE OF THESE TYPE OF GREAT BLACK AMERICANS WERE INCLUDED. SO THERE IS SOME ONE SIDEDNESS. AND WHEN WE TALK TO THE EXCELLENT, AFRICAN AMERICAN AP COURSE TEACHERS, WE HAD A MEETING WITH THEM LAST WEEK, AND I UNDERSTAND THAT THE STAFF IS WORKING TO ADDRESS OUR CONCERNS. IF WE COULD JUST PLEASE KEEP THE TALK TURNED OFF AND LISTEN TO THE BOARD MEMBERS, PLEASE. YOU CAN'T HEAR ME, THERE IS SOME CHATTER IN THE BACK, SO. OH, OH, OKAY. OKAY. WE MET WITH SOME EXCELLENT TEACHERS THAT TAUGHT THE COURSE, AND I DO TRUST THEM TO TEACH THE COURSE IN A WAY THAT IS NOT PROMOTING

[03:15:05]

DIVISIVENESS. I JUST FEEL THAT THERE WERE SOME INFORMATION MISSING FROM THE COURSE AS IT IS, AND WE ARE LOOKING AT THE OPTION TO LOOK AT THE POST EXAM MONTH AND MAKE SURE THAT SOME OF THIS INFORMATION IS PRESENTED. SO WE DO NOT VOTE TO NEVER, EVER TEACH AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY.

WE WERE TRYING TO MAKE THE COURSE BETTER AND MORE COMPLETE SO THAT ALL THE FACTS ARE PRESENTED. JUST LIKE MANY OF THE FOLKS HERE WANT TO DO. OKAY AND WE DO WANT TO COMMUNICATE THIS TO THE COLLEGE BOARD ITSELF IN THE HOPES THAT THEY WILL SEE THE BENEFITS OF INCLUDING SOME OF THE UPDATED, MORE RECENT INFORMATION ON THE PROGRESS AND THE POSITIVE PROGRESS. IN THAT IN THEIR COURSE ITSELF, TECHNICALLY, THE COURSE IS STILL ON PILOT. IT WOULD GO ON TO A FULL STATUS IN THE FALL, SO HOPEFULLY THE BOARD COULD CONSIDER THESE IMPROVEMENTS. OR AT LEAST WE WOULD DRAW SOME VISIBILITY TO THEM. WE HAD SIMILAR CONCERNS WITH THE OTHER SOCIAL STUDIES CURRICULUM BALANCE AND COMPLETENESS TO SUPPORT TEACHING CRITICAL THINKING. AND I ECHO MISS STRAUSS'S CONCERNS ABOUT ACCESS TO THE CURRICULA WE JUST GOT THIS DECISION JUST RECENTLY. SO THESE THINGS WE'VE BEEN WORKING ON OVER THE PAST YEAR, BUT NOT HAVING A LOT OF TIME AND NOT BEING FAMILIAR WITH ALL THE CURRICULA TO SEE WHERE THESE COURSES FIT IN AND HOW IT RELATES TO OTHER HISTORY COURSES. THE OTHER AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY COURSE, WE NEED TO HAVE THAT ACCESS SO THAT WE CAN UNDERSTAND ALL THE CURRICULA. SO THESE DECISIONS WON'T BE SO HARD. THE REASON WHY THIS COURSE IS COMING NOW IS BECAUSE IT'S THE DECISION WAS TO GO FROM PILOT STATUS TO FULL STATUS. SO IT'S NOT THAT WE'RE IGNORING THE OTHER COURSES, IT'S JUST THAT THAT WAS THIS WAS THE DECISION REQUIRED RIGHT NOW.

OKAY, SO WE'LL HEAR TONIGHT HOW THE STAFF HAS ADDRESSED OUR CONCERNS, AGAIN, THE REQUEST TO HAVE READ ACCESS TO THE CURRICULA STILL STANDS, I SEND MY BEST WISHES TO EVERYONE FOR THE REMAINDER OF THE SUMMER FOR ALL OUR FAMILIES. AND I ESPECIALLY WANT TO WELCOME SASHA AS OUR NEW STUDENT MEMBER OF THE BOARD. I KNOW YOU'LL DO A FANTASTIC JOB. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MISS BRUCE. SO WELL, I GUESS I'M AT A LOSS FOR WORDS. AND THAT'S TRULY SOMETHING THAT.

I'VE NEVER BEEN. WHEN I CAME ON AS A BOARD MEMBER, THERE WAS QUITE A BIT THAT I HAD TO LEARN, AND I MET WITH, A VARIETY OF STAFF TO INCLUDE CURRICULUM STAFF BECAUSE I WANTED TO GET AN UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT THEY DID. SO I UNDERSTAND, I FEEL I UNDERSTAND THAT THE CURRICULUM IS UP HERE, AND WHAT HAPPENS IS THE TEACHERS TAKE THAT INFORMATION TO MAKE YOU KNOW, THEIR LESSON PLANS AND STUDIES. SO I FELT VERY CONFIDENT OR I FELT THAT THEY WERE COMPETENT IN PROVIDING THAT INFORMATION. I'M I WAS MIFFED LAST WEEK BECAUSE I WAS AT HOME, AS A RESULT OF A PERSONAL HEALTH PROBLEM. AND I IT WAS LIKE I HAD LEFT THIS BOARD AND I WAS LISTENING TO PEOPLE COME UP WITH THINGS ABOUT THE CURRICULUM THAT I JUST COULDN'T BELIEVE BECAUSE I WHEN PEOPLE SAID THEY DON'T HAVE ACCESS, IF THERE IS ANY CURRICULUM OR COURSE THAT YOU NEED INFORMATION ON, THE STAFF IS ALWAYS THERE TO PROVIDE IT. AS A NOVICE PERSON, I, I DID THAT, I DID MY DUE DILIGENCE. I DIDN'T INCLUDE ALL THE OTHER BOARD MEMBERS TO ANSWER THOSE QUESTIONS AND WHAT I SAW AND WHAT I'VE SEEN IN THE EMAILS. PEOPLE ARE GETTING TOGETHER COMING UP WITH THESE ISSUES AND THEREFORE THOSE WHO DON'T AGREE. YOU KNOW, WE'RE LEFT OUT HERE AS THE MINORITY. AND, YOU KNOW, WHEN WE HAD THE VOTE LAST WEEK, IT WAS OBVIOUS THAT MY FELLOW BOARD MEMBERS WHO HAD GONE OVER THESE ISSUES AGREED THAT THEY WEREN'T GOING TO APPROVE THIS CURRICULUM. I WAS SURPRISED, AND I AM STILL SURPRISED. AND TO SEE, THE PRESIDENT'S RESPONSE TO, CERTAIN PEOPLE AND SAYING THAT YOU KNOW, REGARDING THE AP, WE FULLY RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY AND CULTURE AND ITS INCLUSION IN OUR EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM. HOWEVER, A MAJORITY OF THE BOARD MEMBERS HAD SPECIFIC CONCERNS ABOUT THE CONTENT OF THIS CURRICULUM THAT NEEDED TO BE ADDRESSED BEFORE A SYSTEM WIDE ROLLOUT. I DON'T THIS IS WHERE I SEE THE DISCONNECT, BECAUSE, MR. PRESIDENT, WHEN YOU WROTE THIS LETTER, I WAS NOT A PART OF THAT CONVERSATION. I DID NOT I MEAN, AND I WILL SAY THAT THERE I DON'T MY OTHER FOUR BOARD MEMBERS, WERE YOU A PART OF ANY CONVERSATION REGARDING THIS? NO. SO IT WAS KIND OF LIKE

[03:20:01]

A SELECTIVE THING THAT HAPPENED. AND I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS IS OUT IN FRONT WHEN I MAKE A VOTE OR A DECISION, IT IS FROM ME AS A MEMBER OF THIS BOARD. IT'S NOT BECAUSE DOCTOR MUELLER OR DENISE TALKED TO ME ABOUT IT, AND LET'S DO THIS. THAT IS NOT WHAT WE DO. WE'RE SUPPOSED TO BE A BOARD, AND WE ARE SUPPOSED TO BRING OUR INDIVIDUAL EXPERTISE TO THIS ORGANIZATION. AND I DON'T SEE THAT HAPPENING. I DON'T SEE THAT HAPPENING. SO, NO, I DID NOT SIT DOWN AND TAKE THE STAFF'S TIME TO GO THROUGH THE AP CURRICULUM OR THE SOCIAL SCIENCE CURRICULUM TO SUIT MY BENEFIT. IF THE COURSE CLASS IS BEING TAUGHT, I WOULD GO IN THE CLASSROOM. I WOULD SEE IT DELIVERED TO THE STUDENTS. AND I'VE SAID THIS TO MY FELLOW BOARD MEMBERS, THAT'S THE WAY TO SEE WHAT'S HAPPENING, BECAUSE I'VE DONE IT AS A PARENT WITH A STUDENT, AND I THINK THAT I ADVISE EACH OF YOU TO DO THAT, TO GO LISTEN AND SEE WHAT'S BEING TAUGHT AND NOT WHAT SOME OF THE BOARD MEMBERS ARE TELLING YOU. AND THANK YOU, EVERYBODY WHO SENT WISHES FOR MY HEALTH AND THE LOSS OF MY HUSBAND. AND I'M BACK. THANK YOU. BACK GOOD. MISS ALVAREZ, AND WE'RE GLAD THAT YOU'RE BACK. SO WELCOME BACK. WE HAVE MISSED YOU. SO, AND ALSO WELCOME TO OUR NEW SMOB, TO THE BOARD, TO THE DAIS, WE'RE GLAD TO HAVE YOU HERE. WE HOPE THAT YOU WILL HAVE A GREAT YEAR. AND, YOU KNOW, LOOK FORWARD TO ALL YOUR COMMENTS. FIRST, I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY SOMETHING THAT I THINK SOME PEOPLE UNDERSTOOD THAT WE DIDN'T CHERRY PICK AP AMERICAN AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. IT WAS THE IT'S THE TIME. IT'S JUST THE NATURAL TIMELINE. AND PROGRESSION. IT WAS A PILOT PROGRAM LAST YEAR AND IT CAME UP FOR APPROVAL THIS YEAR. SO IT WASN'T LIKE WE WENT OUT AND SAID, OKAY, WE'RE JUST GOING TO LOOK AT THIS PROGRAM BECAUSE IT WAS, YOU KNOW, SOMETHING THAT WE DIDN'T LIKE, YOU KNOW, SO I THINK THAT THAT WAS NOT REALLY CLEAR FROM SOME OF THE PUBLIC COMMENTS, THIS WAS JUST UP FOR APPROVAL. I VIEW HISTORY AS THE STUDY OF WHERE WE WERE, WHERE WE CAME FROM, AND HOW ITS IMPACT THE PATH OF WHERE WE'RE AT TODA, AND I THINK THIS AP, AS WELL AS THE SOCIAL STUDIES PROGRAM SHOULD CULMINATE INTO WHAT THE CIVIL PROCESS IS THAT HAVE BEEN IN PLACE BECAUSE OF ACTIONS BY, YOU KNOW, ACTIVISTS AND OUR LEADERS OF THE PAST. WHAT HAVE THEY PUT IN PLACE THAT'S GOOD. THAT CAN MAKE US A MORE CIVIL SOCIETY, WHERE WE ARE MORE UNITED TOGETHER AND I DON'T SEE THAT IN EITHER ONE OF THE COURSES, HONESTLY, I THINK THAT'S MISSING FROM A LOT OF THE EDUCATION. WHERE, YOU KNOW, STUDENTS ARE TAUGHT HOW DO I ADDRESS INJUSTICE, SOCIAL INJUSTICE, HOW DO I CONNECT WITH THE JUSTICE SYSTEM? HOW DO I CONNECT WITH THE GOVERNMENT, ORGANIZATIONS THAT HAVE BEEN IN PLACE TO HELP SUPPORT, YOU KNOW, THE SOCIAL INJUSTICES THAT HAVE TAKEN PLACE? AND I THINK WE DO A DISSERVICE TO THE LEADERS THAT HAVE PUT THEM THERE. WHEN WE DON'T ENGAGE WITH THEM. SO I JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT I DID NOT SEE THAT IN IN THE COURSE, THERE WERE A FEW THINGS THAT, THAT. WELL, IT'S NOT ANYWHERE. SO, YOU KNOW, I DON'T SEE IT ANYWHERE IN THE EDUCATION. SO.

YEAH. AND MAYBE IT IS SOMEWHERE ELSE, BUT I'VE ASKED, WELL, WHERE IS THAT? WE NEED TO HAVE A CIVIL PROCESS. WE'RE SEEING WHAT'S GOING ON IN SOCIETY. WE SEE THE DIVISION, YOU KNOW, WE DON'T WANT TO CONTINUE DOWN THAT PATH. HONESTLY I HAD I HAD TO KEEP THE CHATTER DOWN TO A MINIMUM. I HAVE I HAD A STUDENT WHO WENT THROUGH HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC EDUCATION, AND I DON'T REALLY THINK THAT HE GOT A GOOD EDUCATION IN CIVICS. I THINK THAT THAT IS MISSING FROM OUR EDUCATION. MAYBE IT IS ANOTHER MATTER, BUT WHEN I READ THROUGH THE CURRICULUM, I WAS LEFT WITH AN OPPRESSION PRESENT, A PRESENT STATE OF OPPRESSION WITH NOWHERE. FOR THE AFRICAN AMERICAN PERSON TO GO. BUT THEN OTHER TO OTHER THAN TO FEEL OPPRESSION. AND THERE WERE SOME OTHER THINGS IN THE CURRICULUM. AND LIKE PEOPLE HAVE SAID, IT'S NOT A PERFECT CURRICULUM. SO I

[03:25:02]

AM MARRIED TO A, IMMIGRANT FROM CUBA, FROM COMMUNIST CUBA WHO CAME OVER. YOU KNOW, HE'S A HE'S A LEGAL IMMIGRANT, AN AMERICAN CITIZEN. WE'VE BEEN MARRIED FOR 30 YEARS, SO I DO HAVE AN UNDERSTANDING OF THE COMMUNIST REGIME. AND I SAW SOME OF THAT ELEMENT BOTH IN THE AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. AND I QUESTIONED WHY IT WAS THERE, YOU KNOW, A JOE LEWIS, AN ICON IN THE AFRICAN COMMUNITY, WAS MEETING WITH CASTRO. WHY WAS THAT THERE? AND THEN IN, IN THE STUDIES IN THE AMERICAN AND THE, SOCIAL STUDIES PROGRAM THAT SAID COMMUNIST COMMUNISM DOESN'T, DOESN'T EXIST. YOU KNOW, AND I'VE BEEN MARRIED TO A MAN WHO CAME FROM A COMMUNIST COUNTRY, YOU KNOW, FOR 30 YEARS. AND I UNDERSTAND THAT THERE IS COMMUNIST. HE COMMUNISM. HE UNDERSTANDS THAT IT IS ALSO VERY REAL. SO, YOU KNOW, SO I COME FROM A PLACE OF QUESTIONING, WHY ARE WE TEACHING OUR STUDENTS THAT COMMUNISM DOESN'T EXIST? AND WHY ARE WE PUTTING IMAGES IN OUR CURRICULUM THAT SHOWS A WHAT LOOK LIKE A FRIENDLY MEETING? IT HAD NO OTHER SOUNDTRACK. SO I'M LIKE, YOU KNOW, WHAT IS IT? EVEN HERE FOR, YOU KNOW, AND I GET THE TEACHERS ARE GOING TO MAYBE GUIDE THE CLASS OR WHATEVER, BUT YOU KNOW AND YOU KNOW, SO I, YOU KNOW, I QUESTION SOME OF THE THINGS THAT RAISED RED, RED FLAGS TO ME, WHERE WE'RE BOTH SHOWING IMAGES OF FRIENDLY RELATIONSHIPS WITH COMMUNIST LEADERS, AND WE'RE SAYING COMMUNISM DOESN'T EXIST. SO I'M VERY CONCERNED, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, EXCUSE ME, MISS ALVAREZ, PLEASE, LET'S BE RESPECTFUL TO THE BOARD MEMBERS. IT'S ALSO VERY DIFFICULT FOR ME TO HEAR WHAT SHE'S SAYING BECAUSE THERE'S TOO MUCH CHATTER. OKAY LET'S JUST CHILL OUT A LITTLE BIT. LET HER FINISH HER COMMENTS. PLEASE CONTINUE. SO. AND I WANT TO ECHO WHAT MISS STRAUSS SAID. YOU KNOW, THE BOARD HAS REQUESTED ACCESS SO THAT WE CAN REVIEW THE CURRICULUM, UNDERSTAND WHAT WE'RE APPROVING. I DO NOT HAVE THE DESIRE TO APPROVE SOMETHING UNLESS I HAVE SEEN IT, AND UNFORTUNATELY, THERE WERE SOME HICCUPS IN GETTING THAT PORTAL TOGETHER, AND THE CURRICULUM THAT WAS PUT IN THERE, WAS NOT CLEAN. IT CONTAINED OLD CURRICULUM. AND THAT'S JUST CREATED MORE WORK FOR THE STAFF. IT'S BEEN A FRUSTRATING PROCESS. AND WE KNOW THAT EVERYBODY IS AT THIS IN THE STAFF IS WORKING HARD, BUT WE WANT TO GET THIS RIGHT. SO, I, I JUST WANT TO, YOU KNOW, END WITH, I APPRECIATE THE HARD WORK THAT CPS HAS DONE IN TRYING TO GET THIS PORTAL TOGETHER, LET'S LET'S GET IT RIGHT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MISS ALVAREZ, MISS HAHN IS NOT HERE, RIGHT? SHE'S STILL NOT HERE. VIRTUALLY. RIGHT. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. SO I WILL JUST, END WITH SOME FINAL COMMENTS, FOR BOARD MEMBER COMMENTS. AND YOU'VE ALREADY HEARD SOME OF MY THOUGHTS EARLIER TODAY. I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING PREPARED, JUST A FEW THINGS HERE. OFF THE CUFF, LISTENING AND DIGESTING ALL OF THIS. FIRST, I'M GOING TO CHANGE THE TONE JUST A LITTLE BIT BECAUSE I AM EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED. I GOT SOME VERY BAD NEWS TODAY THAT WE ARE LOSING ONE OF OUR BEST AND OUR BRIGHTEST BECAUSE HE'S GETTING PROMOTED. MR. CORNELL BROWN, CAN YOU STAND UP, PLEASE? HE WILL BE LEAVING US ON AUGUST 16TH TO GO BE THE CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER AT HOWARD PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM. CONGRATULATIONS. WELL DESERVED.

NOW, IF YOU'RE PAYING ATTENTION. HE WAS ACTUALLY SUPPOSED TO BE ON THE AGENDA TONIGHT, BUT BECAUSE OF THE LONG PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD, WE MOVED IT TO THE NEXT BOARD MEETING. AND YOU'RE IN LUCK, BECAUSE THAT'S AUGUST 12TH, FOUR DAYS BEFORE YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO LEAVE. SO WE'LL WE WILL SEE YOU THEN. OKAY. SO WHAT'S HAPPENED IN THE PAST MONTH AS EVERYONE IS WELL AWARE, YOU KNOW, THE BOARD DELAYED THE VOTES ON SOME CURRICULUM AND THERE WAS A PROPER VOTE THAT WAS HELD AND SOME OF THE CURRICULUM WAS NOT APPROVED. I'M A VERY SOLUTIONS ORIENTED, PRACTICAL PERSON. SO WHAT DID I DO? I ENGAGED THE BOARD AND I ENGAGED THE STAFF TO NOT JUST DISMISS THINGS, BUT TO HAVE GOOD CONVERSATIONS ABOUT WHAT IS IT SPECIFICALLY WITH THE CURRICULUM THAT YOU DON'T LIKE? WHAT CAN WE DO TO POTENTIALLY RESOLVE THIS? AND AS I SIGNALED AT THE LAST BOARD MEETING, HOW COULD WE POSSIBLY, YOU KNOW, WORK TOGETHER TO POTENTIALLY BRING THIS UP FOR ANOTHER VOTE? AND I MUST SAY, OVER THE PAST MONTH OR SO, SOME OF THE BOARD

[03:30:05]

MEMBERS AND CERTAINLY ALL OF THE STAFF HAVE ENGAGED, AND WE'VE HAD VERY GOOD DISCUSSIONS. WE'VE LISTENED FROM ALL DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES ON BOTH SIDES AND SOME OF THESE IDEAS AND THOUGHTS WERE ALSO GIVEN FROM THE BOARD MEMBERS TO THE STAFF AND THE STAFF. I MUST COMMEND THEM BECAUSE THEY WORKED VERY, VERY HARD OVER THE PAST MONTH TO ADDRESS MANY OF THESE BOARD MEMBER CONCERNS IN FACT, WHEN I MET WITH THE STAFF NOT LONG AFTER THE LAST BOARD MEETING, I SAID, WELL, WE HAVE A LOT TO ACCOMPLISH AND WE DON'T HAVE A LOT OF TIME. I SAID, SO DO YOU WANT TO FOCUS ON SOCIAL STUDIES OR DO YOU WANT TO FOCUS ON AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY? AND THEY LOOKED AT EACH OTHER AND THEY SAID, WELL, WE WANT TO DO ALL OF IT. AND I SAID, WELL, YOU KNOW, THAT'S A LOT TO ACCOMPLISH. THEY SAID, WE WANT TO DO ALL OF IT BECAUSE IT'S IMPORTANT TO US. SO OVER THE NEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS, THEY WORK NIGHTS, THEY WORKED WEEKENDS.

MISS LANG CAME BACK FROM THE BEACH AND CUT HER VACATION SHORT TO ADDRESS THE BOARD MEMBERS CONCERNS. AND I THINK THE DIALOG THAT WE'VE HAD WILL HOPEFULLY YIELD BETTER CURRICULUM THAN WE HAD BEFORE. MORE BALANCED, WHATEVER YOU WANT TO CALL IT. BUT MORE VOICES THAT ARE BEING HEARD. SOME BOARD MEMBERS CRITIQUED ME FOR EVEN PUTTING THIS BACK ON THE AGENDA. I THINK THAT IF WE'VE WORKED SO HARD TO TRY TO RESOLVE THESE ISSUES, IT'S AT LEAST WORTH HEARING HOW THESE ISSUES HAVE BEEN RESOLVED OR ON OR ARE ON THEIR WAY TO BEING RESOLVED. SOME BOARD MEMBERS ARE ALSO FORMING A BLOCKADE OF SORTS, AND I THINK THIS GOES TO WHAT IS THE ROLE OF THE BOARD. AND WE TALKED ABOUT THIS QUITE A BIT. THE ROLE OF THE BOARD IS TO NOT PASSIVELY OR RUBBER STAMP OR WHATEVER TERMS HAVE BEEN USED BEFORE, AND I WASN'T NECESSARILY SUGGESTING EVERYTHING WAS RUBBER STAMPED. BUT WHAT I WAS SUGGESTING IS THAT THIS BOARD IS TAKING THE ROLE OF CURRICULUM OVERSIGHT AND GOVERNANCE MORE SERIOUSLY. SO WHAT IS THE ROLE OF THE BOARD? IT IS NOT TO FORM A BLOCKADE AND JUST SAY, I AM NOT GOING TO VOTE ON ANYTHING UNTIL I GET X, Y, OR Z. I THINK THAT THERE ARE ISSUES THAT NEED TO BE RESOLVED LIKE THIS. READ ACCESS TO THE CURRICULUM. BUT I DON'T THINK THAT HOLDING CERTAIN CURRICULUM HOSTAGE IS NECESSARILY THE ANSWER. I THINK THERE'S A BETTER APPROACH. ALSO, I THINK THE ROLE OF THE BOARD IS TO PROVIDE THAT EXTRA LEVEL OF SCRUTINY, WHICH WE'RE DOING. SOME OF THE PROBLEMS WITH THE CURRICULUM, AS WAS NOTED EARLIER AND AS WAS NOTED IN MY PUBLIC COMMENTS LAST BOARD MEETING, WERE FOR EXAMPLE, THE ISSUES THAT I HAD WITH TERRORISM. WE FOUND OUT THAT SOME OF THE OLD CURRICULUM AND NEW CURRICULUM MAY GOT MIXED TOGETHER, AND THAT WAS ACTUALLY PART OF THE OLD CURRICULUM. SO IT WAS A PREVIOUS BOARD THAT APPROVED THAT CURRICULUM. I'LL ALSO SAY THAT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE TAKE OUR JOB SERIOUSLY. ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE AISLE, THERE WERE BOARD MEMBERS LAST MEETING WHO WANTED TO TAKE A VOTE ON CURRICULUM THAT WE HAD NOT EVEN SEEN, THAT WAS NOT EVEN COMPLETE YET. IN ITS FINAL FORM. I DON'T THINK THAT'S TAKING YOUR JOB SERIOUSLY. I THINK IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT THAT WE GET THE FACTS STRAIGHT. I APPRECIATE THE CONVERSATIONS THAT I HAD WITH EVERYONE IN THE COMMUNITY AND ALL OF THE BOARD MEMBERS WHERE WE COULD TALK ABOUT THE SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES. WHAT ARE THE CONCERNS, HOW CAN WE ADDRESS THOSE CONCERNS AND HOW CAN WE LOOK AT MOVING A NO TO A YES OR IMPROVING THE CURRICULUM? I HAD A LOT OF THOSE CONVERSATIONS. IN FACT, I SAT DOWN ALONG WITH TWO OTHER BOARD MEMBERS, AND WE MET REGARDING THE AP CURRICULUM. WE MET WITH THE THREE EDUCATORS WHO TAUGHT THE CLASS AND GOT THEIR PERSPECTIVE. WE MET WITH LOTS OF COMMUNITY MEMBERS AND I APPRECIATE THAT. AND SOMETIMES THIS IS LIKE RIPPING OFF A BAND AID. YOU HAVE TO GO THROUGH THIS DISCOURSE AND YOU HAVE TO HAVE THESE CONVERSATIONS BECAUSE THEY ARE UNCOMFORTABLE. BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY, I THINK WE'LL HAVE BETTER CURRICULUM AND WE WILL HAVE A BETTER SCHOOL SYSTEM, BUT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE GET THE FACTS STRAIGHT AND THERE IS A LOT OF MISINFORMATION OUT THERE, MOST OF WHICH I DON'T ADDRESS BECAUSE I'D BE DOING IT ALL DAY LONG. BUT THERE ARE SOME THINGS THAT ARE WORTH ADDRESSING. SO, FOR EXAMPLE, THIS EVENING, MISS CRAWFORD, THE HEAD OF THE UNION, STOOD UP AND SHE QUOTED SOMETHING FROM MY LETTER. YOU KNOW, WHICH WAS JUST INACCURATE. SHE SAID THAT IN MY LETTER TO HER THAT IT WAS THE BOARD'S ROLE TO DEVELOP CURRICULUM. I SAY IN MY LETTER AND I'LL READ SPECIFICALLY

[03:35:04]

DEVELOPING CURRICULUM IS INDEED A SIGNIFICANT TASK THAT RELIES ON THE EXPERTS OF THE EXPERTISE OF SPECIALISTS TO CREATE CONTENT THAT ALIGNS WITH THEIR ACADEMIC GOALS AND MEETS THE REGULATORY FRAMEWORK. HOWEVER, IT IS ESSENTIAL TO RECOGNIZE THE BOARD OF EDUCATION'S CRITICAL ROLE IN OVERSEEING AND APPROVING THE CURRICULUM. IF WE ARE NOT OVERSEEING AND APPROVING THE CURRICULUM, THEN WE ARE NOT DOING OUR JOBS, AND THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT WE'RE DOING. IN ANOTHER ARTICLE FROM THE BALTIMORE SUN, HENRY GIBBONS WROTE A COMPLETE OP ED ABOUT HOW MY COMMENTS REGARDING TERRORISM DIDN'T MAKE SENSE TO THE CURRICULUM THAT HE READ ON AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. AND THAT'S BECAUSE IF YOU GO BACK AND YOU LISTEN TO MY COMMENTS, THEY WERE GENERAL COMMENTS AND THEY WERE ABOUT THE SOCIAL STUDIES CURRICULUM, NOT THE AP CURRICULUM. SO AS WE ENGAGE IN THESE CONVERSATIONS, IT'S IMPORTANT TO GET THE FACTS STRAIGHT. AND THEN LASTLY, YOU KNOW, TO MISS BRUCE'S COMMENTS ABOUT MY LETTER, WHICH I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHERE THAT WAS REGARDING THE FIVE FOUR VOTE AND SAYING THAT A MAJORITY OF THE BOARD MEMBERS HAD CONCERNS. THAT WAS AFTER THE VOTE HAD OCCURRED AND 5 TO 4 WAS A MAJORITY. SO A MAJORITY, FIVE OF THE NINE BOARD MEMBERS HAD THESE CONCERNS. SO I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT AS WE MOVE FORWARD, WE REMAIN SOLUTIONS ORIENTED AND THAT WE TRY TO ALL WORK TOGETHER AND

[1. Decision on Previously Tabled - Contract Award: Discovery Education Experience District License Renewal ]

THAT WE KEEP THE FACTS STRAIGHT. I THINK THAT'S ALL I HAD. THOSE WERE SUPPOSED TO BE BRIEF, BUT I THINK I WENT OVER MY TWO MINUTES. BUT OKAY, SO WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON AND WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO OLD BUSINESS. THERE WAS SOME OLD BUSINESS, THERE WERE SOME PREVIOUSLY TABLED ITEMS, NUMBER ONE DECISION ON PREVIOUSLY TABLED AWARD CONTRACT FOR DISCOVERY EDUCATION EXPERIENCE DISTRICT LICENSE RENEWAL, WE WILL OPEN THIS UP FOR, ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM BOARD MEMBERS? I THINK THE ONLY QUESTION I HAVE IS WE HAVE REQUESTED ACCESS TO DISCOVERY EDUCATION, AND IT WAS IN PART OF THE CURRICULUM THAT WE LOOKED AT, IS IT POSSIBLE FOR US TO HAVE ACCESS TO THAT, THOSE MATERIALS? LET'S JUST GIVE A SECOND FOR THE ROOM TO CLEAR OUT, BECAUSE IT'S JUST DIFFICULT TO HEAR. NOT ONLY CONSENT AGENDA. ARE YOU SURE, SIR? SO THE DISCOVERY, THERE'S THE NEW ONE. THAT'S THE OLD BUSINESS DISTRICT.

MAYBE YOU SHOULD JUST GET UP AND STRETCH YOUR LEGS. I DON'T SEE YOU ON HERE, BUT YOU PROBABLY HAVE SOMETHING TO SAY. MISS KUTCHER, PLEASE WELCOME YOUR TEAM. AND THEN WE'LL GET TO QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS OR. AND YOU'RE SPEAKING ON DISCOVERY EDUCATION RENEWAL. SURE WE HEARD YOU. THE QUESTION. SO WE WANTED TO COME UP. SURE. THANK YOU. I'M HEATHER KUTCHER, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CURRICULUM INSTRUCTION AND ASSESSMENT. ANDREW RENZULLI, DIRECTOR OF CURRICULUM INSTRUCTION AND ASSESSMENT, SUPERVISOR OF INNOVATION AND LEARNING. WE CAN'T HEAR YOU. YEAH JUST GIVE ME, SOMETHING. YEAH WE MAKE SURE THEIR BIKES ARE ON AS WELL. OKA.

OKAY. MISS ALVAREZ, CAN YOU REPEAT YOUR QUESTION, PLEASE? YEAH. MY QUESTION IS, WE HAD REQUESTED SOME OF US HAD REQUESTED, THE ABILITY TO GO IN AND LOOK AT THE DISCOVERY EDUCATION. MATERIALS, I HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO GET INTO THAT SITE. IT'S ALSO PART OF THE CURRICULUM, THAT'S UP FOR, FOR APPROVAL. SO IT'S WHAT IS THE STATUS OF THAT? SO IT IS JUST A RESOURCE USED WITHIN THE CURRICULUM. IT'S NOT A REQUIRED RESOURCE IN THE CURRICULUM, AND DOCTOR BARWICK CAN SPEAK TO THE ACCESS ISSUES. I NEED TO INVESTIGATE LICENSING AND WORK WITH DISCOVERY EDUCATION ON THAT PIECE. HOWEVER, RIGHT NOW ALL OF OUR INTEGRATIONS, ALL OF OUR THIRD PARTY DIGITAL RESOURCES INTEGRATE THROUGH CANVAS OR A SYSTEM CALLED CLEVER, AND ALL OF THAT GETS FROZEN FOR THE SUMMER, WHILE WE PREPARE THE NEW CURRICULUM TEMPLATES FOR THE NEXT YEAR. SO WE WOULD BE LOOKING AT, AROUND AUGUST 8TH TO 10TH TO, TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE

[03:40:04]

THAT ACCESS IF IT'S POSSIBLE. THANK YOU. WHEN YOU SAY FROZEN, YOU MEAN YOU CAN ACCESS IT EITHER. NO, I IT'S, PEOPLE OR STUDENTS. TEACHERS OR STUDENTS WHO HAD ACCESS IN THE PRIOR SCHOOL YEAR CAN ACCESS, BUT I CAN'T ADD ANY NEW USERS UNTIL THAT INTEGRATION IS TURNED BACK ON. AND THAT'S IN THE NUMBER OF NEW LICENSES THAT YOU HAVE. IS THAT A PART OF THAT? TWO PIECES WE WOULD NEED TO LOOK AT OUR LICENSING AGREEMENT AND SEE WHAT HOW THAT EXTENDS. AND THEN, THEN THE INTEGRATION PIECE IS A SEPARATE PIECE THAT, THERE'S JUST NOT THE ABILITY TECHNICALLY TO ADD NEW USERS AT THIS POINT. FOR THE PEOPLE WHO NEED TO SEE THIS, WOULD THERE BE, ACCESS FOR THEM TO COME AND SEE IT WITH YO? ANYONE IS WELCOME TO COME IN AND SEE IT. I WILL SAY THAT THIS IS A LIBRARY OF CONTENT THAT INCLUDES, CLOSE TO 300,000 DIFFERENT LEARNING OBJECTS, ACTIVITIES, VIDEOS, SO TO GO THROUGH THAT AMOUNT, WOULD REALLY BE IMPOSSIBLE FOR ANY ONE PERSON BECAUSE IT IS SUCH A LARGE NUMBER AND IT IS A RESOURCE THAT CROSSES ALL AREAS FROM READING TO HEALTH TO SOCIAL STUDIES TO SCIENCE AND EVERYTHING IN BETWEEN. SO THINK OF IT LIKE A LIBRARY OF CONTENT THAT TEACHERS USE TO SUPPLEMENT THE CURRICULUM THAT THEY'RE PROVIDED, SO THAT LIBRARY OR RESOURCES IS USED REGULARLY BY TEACHERS ACROSS OUR ENTIRE SCHOOL SYSTEM. IT'S BEEN IN USE FOR APPROXIMATELY 15 YEARS. AND WHEN THIS PARTICULAR SOURCE WAS CHOSEN, WERE THERE ANY OTHER SOURCES THAT WERE CONSIDERED, OR DO WE JUST LIKE THIS ONE AND THAT'S IT, AS MR. GONZALEZ MENTIONED, WE'VE HAD THIS RESOURCE IN OUR DISTRICT FOR ABOUT 15 YEARS. HOWEVER, WE HAVE OCCASIONALLY ENGAGED OUR LIBRARIANS AND TEACHERS IN A SMALL REVIEW COMMITTEE TO LOOK AT THE RESOURCE TO REEVALUATE, AND TO EVEN LOOKED AT ALTERNATE PRODUCTS FORMALLY, BECAUSE THIS PRODUCT HAS BEEN MEETING THE NEEDS AND IT IS ALSO THOSE RESOURCES ARE SUGGESTED IN THE CURRICULUM. SO A SIGNIFICANT LIFT FOR EVERY CONTENT AREA TO GO BACK AND TO FIND THOSE AND TO REPLACE THEM, IF WE WERE TO MOVE TO A DIFFERENT A DIFFERENT SOURCE, I HAVE PERSONALLY LOOKED AT DIFFERENT STREAMING SOURCES AND, OUR, OUR, OUR OPTIONS AREN'T THERE, AREN'T A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF OPTIONS. SO IF WE WEREN'T TO APPROVE THIS, THEN WE WOULD HAVE A NUMBER OF CLASSES THAT WOULD NOT HAVE THESE RESOURCES AVAILABLE ANYMORE, AND THEY WOULD HAVE TO GO OUT AND FIND SOMETHING ON YOUTUBE OR WHATEVER TO REPLACE IT. OKAY THANK YOU. AND THE POWER OF THE PRODUCT IS THAT WE THE CONTENT HAS BEEN VETTED BY DISCOVERY EDUCATION STREAMING AND THEIR CONTENT PARTNERS. AND IT IS BEHIND THAT SUBSCRIPTION, WHICH TECHNICALLY SOMETIMES GETS DIFFICULT FOR US. BUT, WE KNOW THAT THAT CONTENT DOESN'T POINT OUT TO THE WEB THAT IT'S NOT GOING TO TAKE OUR STUDENTS SOMEWHERE WHERE AN AD IS GOING TO POP UP OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. SO, AND THAT THE LIBRARY CONTENT, DOES IT ADDRESS, AGE GROUPS AND IS IT SEPARATED BY, YOU KNOW, THAT, AND, AND ARE THERE OTHER, OTHER LIBRARY, LIBRARY, STREAMING LIBRARY CONTENT BESIDES DISCOVERY EDUCATION THAT WE ALSO USE? OR IS THIS OUR PRIMARY? THIS IS OUR PRIMARY DIGITAL RESOURCE FOR STREAMING. AND ALTHOUGH DISCOVERY EDUCATION INCLUDES ALMOST 300 LEARNING OBJECTS, IT HAS ALWAYS BEEN A PLATFORM THAT HAS BEEN FOCUSED ON VIDEO STREAMING. SO THERE ARE ABOUT 115 JUST UNDER 115,000 VIDEOS, THERE, AT THIS TIME, IT IS NOT, DIVIDED BY AGE GROUP. AND ALTHOUGH A STUDENT CAN GO INTO DISCOVERY STREAMING, IF THE TEACHER OPENS THAT ACCESS PIECE UP IN THEIR NAVIGATION CANVAS, MOST OFTEN THE TEACHERS ARE CHOOSING THE VIDEOS AND EMBEDDING THAT SPECIFIC VIDEO INTO A CANVAS MODULE. SO IT'S USUALLY MORE OF A TEACHER RESOURCE RATHER THAN A STUDENT.

AND I WOULD SAY IN, YOU KNOW, IN OUR THE CASE OF OUR YOUNGEST STUDENTS, PROBABLY MOST OFTEN

[03:45:08]

DISPLAYED ON THE INTERACTIVE WHITEBOARD OR PANEL, AND MANY OF THE RESOURCES DO HAVE RECOMMENDED GRADE LEVELS SO THAT TEACHERS CAN SEE THAT WHEN MAKING THEY'RE MAKING THEIR DECISIONS. OKAY. THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? OKAY. I'LL TAKE A MOTION IN A SECOND.

SORRY, I'M A DECISION ON WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE. NO, NO, NO, WE'RE ONLY ON THE FIRST ONE. OH, I THOUGHT WE WERE VOTING AS A GROUP. BUT YOU KNOW WHAT? EACH ONE INDIVIDUALLY. SORRY. ANY ANY MORE QUESTIONS ON THIS TOPIC? OKAY, I'LL ACCEPT A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE CONTRACT AWARD DISCOVERY EDUCATION. I MOVE THAT WE APPROVE THE CONTRACT AWARD FOR DISCOVERY EDUCATION EXPERIENCE DIRECT LICENSE RENEWAL. THIS IS LAUREN. I SECOND, THANK YOU. ALL IN FAVOR,

[2. Decision on Women in Perspective for Regular Status, Ms. Erin Lange, Supervisor of Social Sciences, Ms. Heather Kutcher, Executive Director of Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment, Mr. Andrew Renzulli, Director of Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment, Ms. Karen Gonano-Martin, Social Science Teacher, Ms. Alyssa King RELA Teacher, and Ms. Erica Richardson, Social Science Teacher ]

PLEASE SAY YES. YES YES. IS THERE ANY OPPOSED? PLEASE SAY N. THANK YOU. THE MOTION PASSES.

WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO THE SECOND ONE, WHICH IS THE WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE. AND I BELIEVE THERE'S A PRESENTATION FOR THIS ONE BECAUSE IT WAS NEW AS WELL. SO IF WE COULD JUST HOLD QUESTIONS UNTIL THE END OF THE PRESENTATION AND WELCOME ERIN LANG. ANYBODY ELSE? I GOT IT.

OKAY. THANK YOU MA'AM. MISS LANG, CAN YOU ALSO INTRODUCE ALL THE REST OF YOUR ABSOLUTE STAFFERS? TO WELL, GOOD EVENING AGAIN. BOARD OF EDUCATION AND SUPERINTENDENT WILSON, AGAIN, I'M HEATHER CRUTCHER, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CURRICULUM, INSTRUCTION AND ASSESSMENT. AND TRULY DIRECTOR OF CURRICULUM INSTRUCTION AND ASSESSMENT. I'M ERIN LANG, SUPERVISOR OF SOCIAL SCIENCES. AND I HAVE WITH ME SOME OF OUR EDUCATORS AND A STUDENT WHO HAD TAKEN WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE. AND I'LL LET THEM INTRODUCE THEMSELVES TO YOU ALL. MR. KING, ERICA RICHARDSON, KAREN MARTIN, KAYLEE BROWN, VOLKER. SO THE CURRICULUM OFFICE IS HERE THIS EVENING TO PRESENT NOT ONLY WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE, BUT ALSO THE REVISED CURRICULUM FOR SOCIAL STUDIES. SIX HUMAN GEOGRAPHY AND ADVANCED PLACEMENT, AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. THE PROCESS TO BRING ALL OF THESE COURSES BACK THIS EVENING HAS BEEN UNDERTAKEN WITH A COMMITMENT TO COLLABORATION, WHILE MAINTAINING THE INTEGRITY AND EDUCATIONAL EXCELLENCE OF THESE COURSES. WE HAVE CAR BALAE BOARD'S INPUT WITH OUR DEDICATION TO DELIVERING COMPREHENSIVE EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCES ALIGNED TO STATE AND OR COLLEGE BOARD REQUIREMENTS, AND ENSURING THAT EACH CONTINUES TO HELP STUDENTS LEARN HOW TO PROBLEM SOLVE. THINK CRITICALLY, ASK QUESTIONS, RESEARCH SHREWDLY, COMMUNICATE EFFECTIVELY, WORK ACROSS DIVERSE TEAMS AND ENGAGE RESPONSIBLY IN TODAY'S WORLD. EMPOWERING STUDENTS TO NAVIGATE CHALLENGES AND CONTRIBUTE POSITIVELY TO SOCIETY. WE WANT TO ESPECIALLY THANK MRS. LANG, SUPERVISOR OF SOCIAL SCIENCES, MRS. PRICE. OUR CURRICULUM SPECIALIST IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES, AND OUR TEACHERS WHO HAVE AND WILL CONTINUE TO WORK THROUGH EDITS AND WHO GAVE OF THEIR TIME TO COME AND SPEAK WITH BOARD MEMBERS ABOUT THEIR WORK TEACHING SOCIAL SCIENCE COURSES.

SINCE THESE ITEMS WERE FIRST BROUGHT TO THE BOARD DURING THE TWO WEEKS PRIOR TO THE MAY 20TH MEETING, WE HAVE HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO WORK IN MULTIPLE SMALL GROUP SESSIONS WITH BOARD MEMBERS. WE HAVE RESPONDED TO MULTIPLE LINES OF QUESTIONING THROUGH EMAIL. WE HAVE OFFERED MULTIPLE INDIVIDUALIZED SESSIONS FOR OUR BOARD MEMBERS TO COME WALK THROUGH THE CURRICULUM WITH US. WE HAVE OFFERED AN OVERVIEW SESSION OF THE CANVAS PLATFORM, AND WE HOSTED A DISCUSSION WITH OUR AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES TEACHERS AND BOARD MEMBERS. THIS ONGOING EFFORT UNDERSCORES OUR UNWAVERING COMMITMENT IN THE DIVISION OF CURRICULUM, INSTRUCTION, AND ASSESSMENT TO BEING COLLABORATIVE AND DEDICATED TO PROVIDING THE BEST POSSIBLE EXPERIENCES TO THE STUDENTS OF HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS. AND YOU WILL SEE THAT COMMITMENT THROUGHOUT OUR PRESENTATIONS THIS EVENING. AT THIS TIME, WE WOULD LIKE TO TURN THE PRESENTATION OVER TO MRS. ERIN LANG, SUPERVISOR OF SOCIAL SCIENCES, WHO WILL LEAD US IN OUR PRESENTATION. THANK YOU. I'M SO EXCITED TO BE BACK HERE IN FRONT OF ALL OF YOU. AND AS I SAID, I BROUGHT GIFTS, WE HAVE OUR EDUCATORS. THIS IS OUR TEAM OF WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE CURRICULUM WRITERS. IT IS THAT CROSS CURRICULAR TEAM THAT I HAD MENTIONED TO YOU IN SMALL GROUPS BEFORE. AND WE ALSO WANTED TO BRING THAT STUDENT PERSPECTIVE. THE MOST IMPORTANT VOICE THAT WE COULD EVER BRING BEFORE YOU. AND SO I AM GOING TO TURN IT OVER TO MRS. KING TO GET US STARTED WITH A LITTLE BIT OF CONTEXTUALIZATION OF WHERE WE ARE, MISS BLANK ASKED ME TO EXPLAIN A LITTLE BIT OF THE

[03:50:03]

BACKGROUND, I'VE BEEN TEACHING. THIS WILL BE MY 25TH YEAR. I WAS AN ENGLISH TEACHER AT MILTON, AND THEN I WAS A LIBRARIAN THERE. AND THEN I WORKED AS A TEACHER SPECIALIST IN THE OFFICE OF TECHNOLOGY, AND NOW I'M BACK TO TEACHING AT BOSTON HIGH SCHOOL AS AN ENGLISH TEACHER. IN 2002. MY, I THINK IT WAS 2002, MY DEPARTMENT CHAIR, TAMMY BODDY, AT THE TIME, AND I DISCUSSED THE IDEA OF ME TEACHING AN ELECTIVE CLASS TITLED WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE, WHERE IT WAS ALREADY LISTED AS A COURSE IN THE MASTER SCHEDULE AND CURRICULUM IS REALLY CHANGED IN ALL THE YEARS I HAVE BEEN HERE, AND AT THAT TIME WHEN I SAID, WELL, WHAT'S THE CURRICULUM NOW? IT WAS A ONE PAGE DOCUMENT AND IT JUST HAD A COURSE DESCRIPTION AND AN OUTLINE THAT INCLUDED A BUNCH OF FEMALE WRITER NAMES. SO TAMMY BODDY AND LYNN OWEN, WHO WAS THE SUPERVISOR OF RILLA AT THE TIME, ASKED ME TO WRITE CURRICULUM AND I'D DONE SOME CURRICULUM PRIOR TO THAT. SO FOR THEY HAD THIS FAITH IN ME TO APPROACH IT WITH AND THE DIRECTION WAS UNIT THEMES, AND THE THEMES WOULD CONNECT TO THE WORKS TO BE STUDIED IN THE TOPICS THAT SURROUNDED WOMEN'S LIVES PAST AND PRESENT. SO THAT'S HOW IT KIND OF BEGAN. THE UNITS WERE FRAMED WITH A MORE PERSONAL CONNECTION FROM STUDENT PERSPECTIVE. THAT WAS ONE OF THE KIND OF GOALS AT THE TIME THAT YOU WOULD WANT STUDENTS TO HAVE CONNECTION TO THEIR OWN LIVES AND SUBJECT MATTER, AND IT MOVES CHRONOLOGICALLY THROUGH HISTORICAL TIMELINE AND END OF YEAR CELEBRATION OF WOMEN'S ARTISTIC VOICE. THE UNITS AT THAT TIME WERE ONE. FAMILY TIES AND IDENTITY. BECAUSE YOU WANT TO START WITH WHAT STUDENTS KNOW AND THEN IT MOVED TO UNIT TWO.

COMMON STRUGGLES. UNIT THREE WOMEN BREAKING FREE, UNIT FOUR HERCULEAN WOMEN AND UNIT FIVE WOMEN'S VOICE. THE GLOBAL GLOBAL CURRENT EVENTS AND WOMEN'S LIVES WERE OFTEN CONNECTED TO THE LESSONS. A GOOD EXAMPLE IS THE STUDY OF WOMEN AND WAR. SO DEBORAH SAMPSON, THIS IS A GOOD EXAMPLE, WAS A WOMAN WHO FOUGHT ALONGSIDE REVOLUTIONARY WAR MEN IN AN ELITE UNIT. SHE WAS THAT TALENTED AND PEOPLE DIDN'T KNOW FOR A LONG TIME BECAUSE SHE WAS ACTUALLY IN DISGUISE, SO A CONTEMPORARY CONNECTION TO THAT. AT THE TIME, I WAS TEACHING EARLY ON WAS THE CURRENT EVENTS WHERE STUDENTS WOULD READ ABOUT WOMEN TODAY IN SPECIAL UNITS LIKE THE ARMY RANGERS. THE COURSE IS ONLY OFFERED AND EVER WAS ONLY EVER OFFERED TO 11TH AND 12TH GRADERS. MOSTLY IT WAS YOUNG WOMEN WHO WOULD TAKE IT. BUT I WILL TELL YOU, EVERY YEAR I EVER TAUGHT IT, WHICH INCLUDES LAST YEAR, THERE WAS ALWAYS A BOY WHO TOOK IT AND THAT HIS PERSPECTIVE, BECAUSE IT WAS ONLY EVER ONE IN MY EXPERIENCE, WAS VERY WELL VALUED, OTHER STUDENT, INCLUDING BOYS THAT THAT BOYS TOOK IT, STEVE MILTON BEGAN WITH ONE SECTION AND IT GREW TO TWO. IT WAS TAUGHT FOR MANY YEARS.

AND AFTER I LEFT, WHEN I WAS IN THE LIBRARY, THEIR TEACHERS STILL TAUGHT IT. I KNOW IT WAS TAUGHT AT BELLAIRE HIGH SCHOOL FOR A LITTLE WHILE, AND I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY YEARS ACTUALLY KEPT GOING. I DO WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR BECAUSE IT'S COME UP MANY TIMES THAT IN THE CURRICULUM THAT I HAD WRITTEN, MARGARET SANGER WAS NEVER BROUGHT UP LIKE AND EVER LIKE AS A LESSON, THE TOPICS SURROUNDING BIRTH CONTROL AND ABORTION WAS DEFINITELY OFF LIMITS. THAT'S NOT SOMETHING YOU TEACH ABOUT IN A WOMEN'S SOCIAL STUDIES TYPE CLASS, OR LITERARY FOR THAT MATTER. I NEVER HAD A STUDENT EVER WISH TO RESEARCH THAT TOPIC. NO ONE EVER SAID I'D LIKE TO RESEARCH THIS IN MY EXPERIENCE, SO THE COURSE BECAME POPULAR DUE TO THE IMPACTFUL NATURE OF THE CONTENT AND THE REAL WORLD CONNECTIONS. AND I'LL GIVE AN EXAMPLE EARLY ON, AT THE TIME WE WERE REALLY DOING A LOT WITH STUDENT SERVICE LEARNING. SO IN OCTOBER, IT'S, BREAST CANCER AWARENESS MONTH. AND SO, STUDENTS LIKED THE IDEA OF RESEARCHING A FOUNDATION LIKE THE SUSAN G. KOMEN FOUNDATION.

AND, HEY, LET'S DO SOMETHING IN SCHOOL. IN MY SCHOOL, THEY WOULD RAISE SOME MONEY WITH, LIKE, LITTLE TOPS OF THE YOGURT AT THE TIME, AND THEY SET UP A TREE, TO HAVE, LIKE, STUDENTS. RIGHT.

BECAUSE IN SOME WAY, BREAST CANCER HAS TOUCHED ALL OF OUR LIVES, WHETHER IT'S WITH A CLOSE FAMILY MEMBER OR A FRIEND AND THE STUDENTS WOULD HANG UP IN HONOR OF OR IN MEMORY OF. AND IT WAS REALLY SPECIAL KIND OF MOMENT IN OCTOBER, IN FACT, IN THE FEW YEARS EARLY ON THAT I

[03:55:03]

TAUGHT IT STUDENTS AND THEIR FAMILIES, BECAUSE IT WAS NOT A FIELD TRIP, THEY WANTED TO GO DOWN AND DO THE RACE FOR THE CURE IN THE CITY. AND I HAVE SOME REALLY NEAT PICTURES OF ALL THESE KIDS WALKING THAT WALK, THOSE WERE REALLY GOOD AND SPECIAL TIMES, SO I DON'T KNOW AT WHAT POINT THE CLASS WAS NOT OFFERED AT CERTAIN SCHOOLS. I KNOW WHEN I WENT BACK TO TEACHING AND I BROUGHT IT UP TO MY PRINCIPAL AND I SAID, WHAT ABOUT WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE? IF FALLSTON, HE WAS ALL IN AND WE HAD STUDENTS LIKE KAY TAKE IT LAST YEAR AND IT KIND OF CAME BACK, BUT IT MADE MORE SENSE IN THE WAY OUR CURRICULUM IS TODAY, THAT IT FIT BETTER IN SOCIAL SCIENCES, WHICH IS WHY IT WAS REWRITTEN. AND WE WILL TALK ABOUT THAT. YOU CAN JUST CLICK THROUGH. SO OUR CURRENT ENROLLMENT IN THE LAST SCHOOL YEAR, WE HAD STUDENTS TAKING THIS COURSE AT BOTH FALLSTON AND JOPPATOWNE. AND THROUGH ACTIONSCRIPT. I'M SORRY. YOU'RE GOOD. SO AS MRS. KING MENTIONED, IN JANUARY, WE HAD A CONVERSATION IN THE OFFICE OF CURRICULUM OR, I'M SORRY, THE DIVISION OF CURRICULUM, INSTRUCTION AND ASSESSMENT TO TALK ABOUT REALIGNING THIS COURSE TO SOCIAL STUDIES STANDARDS BECAUSE IT MADE MORE SENSE IN TERMS OF STATE STANDARDS FOR RILLA VERSUS SOCIAL STUDIES AND SO WE PUT TOGETHER A FOUR PERSON WRITING TEAM, INCLUDING THE TWO RILLA TEACHERS WHO WERE TEACHING THE COURSE AT THE TIME. ONE HAS SINCE MOVED OUT OF AREA, AND OUR TWO SOCIAL SCIENCE TEACHERS TO BRING THAT STATE STANDARD PERSPECTIVE AND EXPERTISE WITH THE GOAL OF HAVING THEM COLLABORATE TO ADJUST THE SCOPE AND SEQUENCE TO ALIGN TO MARYLAND STATE SOCIAL STUDIES STANDARDS. AND THEY UTILIZE THE INTERDISCIPLINARY MODEL OF AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES AS AN APPROACH. THAT'S ME, SO DO YOU SEE THE STATE STANDARDS HERE ON OUR SCREEN, WE HAVE FIVE DISCIPLINARY STATE STANDARDS THAT ARE BROAD FOUNDATIONAL CONTENT STANDARDS AND CIVICS PEOPLES OF THE NATION'S AND WORLD'S GEOGRAPHY, ECONOMICS AND HISTORY. AND THEN STANDARDS 6.0, WHICH IS OUR INQUIRY BASED SKILLS STANDARD. YOU CAN SEE THAT HERE. AND I'LL TURN IT OVER TO YOU. SO AS WE WERE DEVELOPING THIS CURRICULUM, WE AND ALL CURRICULUM, FRANKLY, AS TEACHERS, WE IN SOCIAL STUDIES, WE USE THE INQUIRY ARC. WE FRAME OUR LESSONS AROUND COMPELLING QUESTIONS, AND WE SPECIFICALLY DESIGNED OUR LESSONS SO THAT NOT ONLY WERE WE OFFERING QUESTIONS TO STUDENTS THAT HAD MULTIPLE POTENTIAL ANSWERS AND OFFERED STUDENTS TO DEVELOP MULTIPLE PERSPECTIVES AND THINK ABOUT MULTIPLE PERSPECTIVES, BUT WE ALSO DESIGN LESSONS THAT ALLOW STUDENTS TO, CREATE THEIR OWN QUESTIONS IN THE PROCESS, WE DID A LOT OF RESEARCH IN ALL PERSPECTIVES, SO WE COULD ENGAGE OUR STUDENTS WITH FACTS, ALLOW THEM TO EVALUATE EVIDENCE AND PROVIDE THEM AN OPPORTUNITY TO REALLY DEVELOP THEIR, YOU KNOW, THEIR OWN IDEAS, SO FOR EXAMPLE, I WROTE THE LESSONS ON FIRST THROUGH FOURTH WAVE FEMINISM. AND IN MY RESEARCH AND UNDERSTANDING IT, I WANTED MY STUDENTS TO UNDERSTAND THE FULL PERSPECTIVE OF WOMEN AS WE WERE WRITING THIS. NOT ALL WOMEN AGREED AND HAVE NOT AGREED IN FEMINIST MOVEMENTS, IN THE PROCESS, I'LL SHARE A PERSONAL STORY. I WAS WRITING CURRICULUM WHILE SITTING NEXT TO MY 97 YEAR OLD GRANDMOTHER, AND I ASKED HER, WHAT DID YOU THINK OF THE FEMININE MYSTIQUE? AND SHE SAID, THAT WAS THE BIGGEST MISTAKE. I LOVED BEING A STAY AT HOME MOM, AND THAT MADE ME REALLY THINK ABOUT THIS CLASS, BECAUSE IF WE ARE REALLY, TRULY TELLING THE PERSPECTIVE OF WOMEN, IT'S THE PERSPECTIVE OF EVERYONE. AND SO IN THOSE LESSONS, I WAS SURE TO INCLUDE THE ABILITY FOR STUDENTS TO DISCUSS, APPRECIATE AND, ARGUE ANY PERSPECTIVE OF ANY WOMAN. SO IN THE INQUIRY ARC, THAT'S WHAT WE TRY TO DO WITH EVERY LESSON. FOR EXAMPLE, THE LESSON THAT ALYSSA MENTIONED ON WOMEN IN THE MILITARY, WE ALLOW STUDENTS TO DO THE TAKE A STAND WHERE WOMEN CAN DISCUSS SOME OF THE DRAWBACKS OF WOMEN BEING IN THE MILITARY, AND TO DO THAT IN A REALLY SAFE SPACE. I CAN GIVE A FULL EXAMPLE OF HOW THIS INQUIRY ARC WORKS FOR THE LESSON WE DID THIS YEAR, AND I CHOSE THE INQUIRY ABOUT WOMEN IN THE AMERICAN WEST JUST BECAUSE THERE WAS SOME MOMENTS, EVEN FOR

[04:00:02]

MYSELF, AS THE STUDENTS WERE LOOKING AT PRIMARY SOURCES. SO FOR DIMENSION ONE, AN EXAMPLE OF THE DRIVING QUESTION WAS WHAT WERE WOMEN DOING IN THE WEST AND HOW DID WESTERN WOMEN SHAPE WOMEN'S ROLES FOR GENERATIONS TO COME? IN DIMENSION TWO, WHERE WE WERE TAKING IN CONSIDERATION THE CONTEXT WITHIN THE HISTORICAL CONSTRUCT AND GEOGRAPHY, THERE'S A LOT THERE. SO THE GOLD RUSH WAS HAPPENING IN THE 1800S. LAND TERRITORIES WERE SHIFTING. WE HAD THE NATIVE AMERICAN EXPERIENCE. WE HAVE LAND BARRIERS LIKE MOUNTAINS AND THE MISSISSIPPI AND THE TRANSPORTATION AFFORDED TO VARIOUS GROUPS LIKE COVERED WAGONS. SO ALL OF THAT WAS TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION, AND SOME OF THAT BECAME PART OF THE RESOURCES STUDENTS WOULD USE, LIKE MAPS. BUT I THINK, THE, THE MOST ESSENTIAL OF THE RESOURCES WERE PRIMARY SOURCES. SO THOSE WERE LETTERS AND JOURNALS WRITTEN BY THE WOMEN THEMSELVES. AND SOME OF THOSE ARE VERY HARD TO FIND, BUT IT'S KIND OF LIKE A DIAMOND IN THE ROUGH, YOU KNOW, WE HAVE ONE. SO THE STUDENTS EVALUATED AND COMPARED THOSE AND THE CONCLUSIONS THAT THEY CAME UP WITH AFTER THEY BECAUSE WE DID A LOT OF FORMS OF DISCUSSION WHERE THEY SHARED, THEY CONFIRMED OPINIONS THAT WOMEN IN THE WEST REQUIRED IT BEING A WOMAN IN THE WEST REQUIRED GRIT AND BRAVERY. BUT STUDENTS PRIOR REALLY ONLY CONSIDERED WOMEN AS MORE PASSIVE PLAYERS IN THE WEST. SIMPLY LIKE, OH, I'M RIDING IN THE COVERED WAGON. AND NO, I HAVE TO BE STRONG TO GET THROUGH ALL OF THIS, BUT THROUGH THE INQUIRY PROCESS, STUDENTS DISCOVERED MORE ESPECIALLY A SURPRISING CONCLUSION, WHICH WAS WOMEN WERE A MINORITY FIRST IN THE WEST BECAUSE IT MADE SENSE MORE MEN KIND OF TRAVELED OUT THERE, AND MOST OF SINGLETON'S FOR THE GOLD RUSH. AND, WHAT WOMEN DID IS THEY LEARNED TO LEVERAGE THIS SITUATION THROUGH CAPITALISTIC ENTERPRISE. AND I HAVE EXAMPLES THAT THE STUDENTS PULLED OUT. AND THIS IS A SEA HUNT WHO MADE MONEY BY SELLING BUTTER, COTTAGE CHEESE AND BREAD THAT SHE MADE. AND REALIZED, OH, PEOPLE WILL BUY THIS, THERE WAS MARY ELLEN PLEASANT WHO INVESTED MONEY AND OWNED RESTAURANTS AND BOARDING HOUSES. IT MADE SENSE. PEOPLE NEEDED PLACES TO EAT AND PLACES TO SLEEP. THEY WERE DESPERATELY NEEDED IN WESTERN TOWNS. AND ANNIE OAKLEY, WHO MANY OF US KNOW AS BEING A FAMOUS, ENTERTAINING SHARPSHOOTER. BUT WHAT OUR STUDENTS DIDN'T REALIZE IS THAT WHEN SHE WAS AGE EIGHT, HER FAMILY WAS VERY POOR AND SHE ONLY HONED THOSE SHARPSHOOTER SKILLS BY LEARNING TO HUNT AND HUNTING WELL. AND SHE WOULD TAKE WHAT SHE THE GAME SHE KILLED AND SOLD IT TO LOCAL RESTAURANTS. SO SHE COULD HELP SUPPORT HER FAMILY. SO ALL TO EARN THAT MONEY. THAT'S THE CAPITALISTIC PROWESS OF WOMEN IN THE 19TH CENTURY, WEST PAVED THE WAY FOR WOMEN. WESTERN WOMEN EARNED THE RIGHT TO VOTE IN THEIR STATES WAY BEFORE WOODROW WILSON WOULD CALL FOR THE PASSAGE OF THE 19TH AMENDMENT, AND THIS WAS KIND OF A TOUCHSTONE WHEN WE GOT TO THAT PIECE LATER IN THE YEAR, AND THEN PAVED THE WAY FOR WOMEN LIKE WE KNOW TODAY, LIKE KYLIE JENNER. MY DAUGHTER'S A BIG FAN OF. AND MARTHA STEWART, WHO MANY OF US KNOW WHO HAVE HAD CAPITALISTIC SUCCESS. AND THE LAST THING I JUST WANT TO SAY ABOUT THAT, BECAUSE AS A TEACHER, IT WAS MEANINGFUL TO ME, OUR STUDENTS CREATED IN TERMS OF THE FINAL PRODUCT, FOUND POEMS, WHICH MEANS THEY TOOK THE PRIMARY SOURCES AND LIKE, CROSSED OUT CERTAIN WORDS TO CREATE KIND OF A POEM ABOUT THE WOMAN'S LIFE. AND WE HUNG THEM OUTSIDE OF MY CLASSROOM. AND I HAD SEVERAL TEACHERS COME BY TO TELL ME THAT THEY STOPPED AND ACTUALLY READ THOSE. AND WITH OUR SIGN THAT SAID WOMEN WERE IN THE WEST, THEY A COUPLE OF THEM SAID TO ME, WOW, I LEARNED SOME THINGS I DIDN'T KNOW. AND ALSO, THIS IS VERY BEAUTIFUL. AND THAT MEANT A LOT. AND THAT SO THAT IS HOW THE INQUIRY, FRAMEWORK WORKS IN REAL TIME. AND TO BE CLEAR, THAT WAS SOMETHING THAT MRS. KING PILOTED FOR US DURING THE WRITING PROCESS. SO THAT WAS NOT A LESSON THAT WAS IN THE OLD CURRICULUM. IT WAS ONE THAT THIS TEAM DEVELOPED. AND THEN SHE TEST DROVE IT FOR US WITH OUR STUDENTS TO REALLY GET A PRIMARY UNDERSTANDING OF THAT INQUIRY. ARC SO I HAVE A DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE ON THE COURSE BECAUSE I DON'T TEACH THE COURS, BUT IT IS OFFERED AT MY SCHOOL, IT IS NOW UNDER THE SOCIAL SCIENCE UMBRELLA AND AS DEPARTMENT CHAIR, IT IS DIRECTLY CONNECTED TO ME, WHEN I JOINED THE CURRICULUM WRITING TEAM, WHEN ERIN APPROACHED ME, AND I WANT TO THANK ERIN PUBLICLY FOR ALLOWING ME TO DO THIS, THIS IS SOMETHING THAT I HAD NOT EXPERIENCED PRIOR TO THIS MOMENT, TO BE ABLE TO WRITE WIT, OTHER WOMEN THAT ARE TEACH CURRENTLY TEACHING THE COURSE.

SO UNDERSTAND MY PERSPECTIVE. I'M OUTSIDE LOOKING IN SO ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS, OF COURSE, IS THAT OF COURSE IT'S ALIGNED TO MARYLAND STATE MARYLAND SOCIAL STUDIES STANDARDS THAT ERIN

[04:05:02]

SPOKE ABOUT EARLIER IN A PREVIOUS SLIDE. ALSO, THE GROUNDED ON COMPELLING QUESTIONS. SO THESE ARE QUESTIONS THAT ARE THOUGHT PROVOKING. THESE ARE QUESTIONS THAT WILL INSPIRE AND CREATE, AN ATMOSPHERE OF LEARNING IN A CLASSROOM. AND ANY LIKE YOU WOULD IN ANY OTHER CLASSROOM. I, AS A SOCIAL SCIENCES TEACHER, CAN TELL YOU ONE OF THE TWO THINGS THAT YOU NEED THE FORMULA, SO TO SAY, FOR A SUCCESSFUL COURSE IS ONE INTEREST. YOU NEED INTEREST. SO THE INTEREST WAS THERE. 18 STUDENTS TOOK IT LAST YEAR AND I DON'T WANT TO STEAL YOUR JOY. BUT 60 STUDENTS AT JOPPATOWNE HIGH SCHOOL HAVE SIGNED UP TO TAKE THE CLASS. 2425 LET ME SAY THAT AGAIN. 18 THIS PAST YEAR, 60 COMING UP, THIS IS THE OTHER PART OF THAT FORMULA COMES FROM THE ACTUAL INSTRUCTOR. AND SHE'S NOT HERE WITH US. LIKE ERIN SAID, SHE'S MOVED ON TO ANOTHER SCHOOL DISTRICT, BUT HER ENJOYMENT AND HER EXCITEMENT FOR THE COURSE IS WHAT WE HEARD ABOUT ALL THROUGHOUT THE SCHOOL. SO EVEN THOUGH I WASN'T PHYSICALLY IN THE CLASSROOM TEACHING, I STILL HAD THE EXPERIENCE OF WITNESSING SOMETHING REALLY GREAT HAPPENING AT JOPPATOWNE WITH THIS COURSE IN THE COURSE, JUST FOR MY UNDERSTANDING OF THE PAST FEW MONTHS. THEY PROVIDE MULTIPLE PERSPECTIVES AND BALANCED RESOURCES, BASICALLY TELLING BOTH SIDES OF THE STORY. YES, WE DO HAVE WOMEN THAT WERE HEROIC.

WE HAVE WE DO HAVE WOMEN THAT WE ARE VERY PROUD TO SPEAK ABOUT. WE ALSO HAVE WOMEN THAT WE MAY HAVE SOME CONCERNS ABOUT. THAT'S THE BEAUTY OF A SOCIAL SCIENCE COURSE. YOU HAVE THAT VOICE FROM EVERY PERSON IN THE ROOM. SEVERAL CONNECTIONS, REGARDLESS OF BACKGROUNDS. SO THERE WERE MULTIPLE JOPPATOWNE HIGH SCHOOL IS A VERY DIVERSE SCHOOL, SO THERE ARE MULTIPLE BACKGROUNDS IN THIS CLASSROOM. IN AND OF COURSE WITH 60 STUDENTS, WHICH IS GOING TO INCREASE NEXT YEAR, THE UNIQUE PERSPECTIVES THAT WERE ALSO SHAPED BY THEIR EXPERIENCES. SO EACH OF THE 18 STUDENTS THAT TOOK IT THIS YEAR WERE ABLE TO HAVE THEIR OWN EXPERIENCES BROUGHT TO THE TABLE AND DISPLAYED IN A COMFORTABLE, SAFE ENVIRONMENT, A COMFORTABLE, SAFE ENVIRONMENT, THAT'S THE ULTIMATE GOAL FOR AN EDUCATOR. I WANT PERSONALLY, IN MY CLASSROOM FOR STUDENTS TO FEEL SAFE, TO FEEL THAT THEIR PERSPECTIVE IS HEARD, THAT THEIR THEIR INFORMATION, THAT THEIR KNOWLEDGE IS, IS RESPECTED. AND THAT'S WHAT I, YOU KNOW, WITNESSED IN THIS CLASS, WE CELEBRATE THE ACCOMPLISHMENTS OF WOMEN. AND I SAY WE BECAUSE WE ARE ALL OBVIOUSLY IN THIS COURSE TOGETHER NOW. SO WE CELEBRATE. IT'S A IT'S A CELEBRATION BASICALLY. WHEN I SPOKE TO, AMY AND ALYSSA, I SAID, WHAT DO YOU WANT ME TO KNOW ABOUT THIS COURSE? WHAT DO YOU NEED? AND AGAIN, OUTSIDE OF LOOKING IN, WHAT DO I NEED TO REMEMBER ABOUT THIS COURSE? IF YOU HAD ONE TAKEAWAY, IT'S A CELEBRATION. IT'S A CELEBRATION OF WOMEN THAT SPEAKS FOR ITSELF. LEADERSHIP AT ANY LEVEL, CONTRIBUTIONS TO HISTORY. AGAIN, IT IS A CELEBRATION OF WOMEN. AND THE LAST COMPONENT IS ABOUT SUPPORT FOR STUDENTS AND UNDERSTANDING THEMSELVES, THEIR FAMILIES AND THE COMPLETE PICTURE OF THE WORLD AROUND THEM. I'M ALL ABOUT REAL LIFE RELEVANCE, REAL WORLD RELEVANCE. THERE ARE STUDENTS THAT HAVE A LOT TO SAY. THEIR VOICES WANT TO BE HEARD, AND THIS IS A PRIME EXAMPLE OF A COURSE WHERE THIS CAN HAPPEN. THEIR FINAL PROJECT THAT ALYSSA AND AMY SPOKE ABOUT, WHEN WE WERE PLANNING THE FINAL PROJECT, WAS TO CREATE A CHILDREN'S BOOK, AND THEY WERE GIVEN A CHOICE. THAT'S ANOTHER GREAT COMPONENT OF A CLASSROOM. THEY WERE GIVEN A CHOICE ON WHAT TOPIC THEY WOULD LIKE TO WRITE THE CHILDREN'S BOOK, LIKE WHAT THEY WOULD LIKE TO INCLUDE. THEY BOTH SAID IN FALLSTON AND JOPPATOWNE, MANY STUDENTS CHOSE TO SPEAK ABOUT THEIR OWN EXPERIENCES. THEY WROTE CHILDREN'S BOOKS FOR THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS. SO AGAIN, MAKING THIS PERSONAL FROM ALL WALKS OF LIFE, BUT BEING EXTREMELY PERSONAL AND BEING VULNERABLE ENOUGH TO SHARE THIS EXPERIENCE WITH PEOPLE THAT THEY MAY OR MAY NOT BE FRIENDS WITH.

IT'S A VERY SHORT AMOUNT OF TIME TO SPEND WITH SOMEONE, BUT TO BE ABLE TO SHARE YOUR INNER MOST IMPORTANT FEELINGS, VALUES, BELIEFS THROUGH THIS CHILDREN'S BOOK. AND AGAIN, IT WAS A SELF-REFLECTION. THAT'S A HARD NEEDLE TO THREAD, BUT THESE AMAZING EDUCATORS DID IT, AND CREATING THE SCOPE AND SEQUENCE FOR THIS COURSE. SO I'D LIKE THEM TO JUST SPEAK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT HOW THAT GOT BUILT. SO THE UNITS ARE BASICALLY THE SAME. WE SHIFTED SOME OF THE, THE WORDS, BUT THEY'RE KIND OF THE SAME, EXCEPT FOR THE LESSONS THAT LIVE WITHIN THE MULTI-DAY EXPERIENCES THAT KAREN WILL GO INTO MORE DEPTH ABOUT. BUT IT FOLLOWS THE INQUIRY FRAMEWORK, AND SO WHAT IT USED TO BE, IT WAS JUST KIND OF LIKE A LOT OF LESSONS. THIS IS SO MUCH MORE IMPROVED. I LOVE THIS CURRICULUM JUST THE WAY IT'S FORMATTED AND HOW THERE'S PROBABLY WAY TOO MUCH FOR ONE PERSON LIKE THERE. IT LEAVES A LOT LEFT TO ASKING THE STUDENTS, WHAT DO YOU FEEL PASSIONATE

[04:10:06]

ABOUT AND WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO STUDY? HERE ARE SOME OF THE TOPICS. AND THEY CAN CHOOSE BECAUSE THERE'S SO MUCH HERE YOU CAN'T DO IT ALL, SO THE BREAKING BARRIERS UNIT MARCH FALLS WITHIN THAT, WHICH IS WHY LISTED THERE IS WOMEN'S HISTORY MONTH AS A PROJECT, I LOVE THAT MONTH, IT ALLOWS STUDENTS TO DO A DEEP DIVE INTO A SPECIFIC PERSON, ESPECIALLY THEY COULD PICK AN EVENT, BUT THEY'VE ALWAYS WANTED TO KIND OF PICK A PERSON, THAT PROJECT CAN CAN BE MEANT FOR AN AUTHENTIC AUDIENCE. FOR SOME SCHOOLS, THAT MIGHT BE THAT THEY JUST WANT TO DO SOMETHING WITH ANNOUNCEMENTS EVERY DAY OR DO A BIG DISPLAY, AT MY SCHOOL, SPECIFICALLY, WE'VE WORKED SO HARD AS A CAMPUS TO COLLABORATE WITH OUR MIDDLE SCHOOL THAT IT GAVE US AN OPPORTUNITY TO GO OVER THERE AND HAVE STUDENTS WORK WITH SIXTH GRADERS, AND THEY WERE KIND OF TEACHERS. WE WORKED ON THAT FOR WEEKS, AND THEY HAD TO PRACTICE IN THE ROOM, AND THEY NEEDED ME TO KIND OF BE THE JUDGE OF, OH, YEAH, THE, THE ACTIVITIES THEY DID. ONE OF THE STUDENTS, PROBABLY LOTS OF YOU PLAY CONNECTIONS. ONE OF THE STUDENTS LIKE MADE A CONNECTIONS FOR STUDENTS TO DO.

AND I WAS LIKE, THAT'S GENIUS. AND THEN I COPIED THAT AS A TEACHER. I WAS LIKE, I CAN'T BELIEVE THAT. THAT WAS LIKE THEIR CLOSURE FOR THEIR THEIR LESSON, SO THAT AUTHENTIC AUDIENCE CAN VARY. AND I DID WANT TO SPEAK TO UNIT TWO. JUST TO GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE OF AN EXPERIENCE LIKE THERE'S THE CHALLENGES AND STRUGGLES, THAT WHILE IT'S CALLED WOMEN'S, WITHIN THE CHALLENGES AND STRUGGLES, THERE'S A WOMEN'S HEALTH AND WELFARE. THERE ARE LOTS OF LESSONS UNDERNEATH THAT UMBRELLA FOR THAT EXPERIENCE. AND ONE EXAMPLE, AND I JUST THOUGHT I'D BRING IT UP BECAUSE THERE ARE SOME OPPORTUNITIES FOR GUESTS TO COME INTO A CLASSROOM.

AND STUDENTS ABSOLUTELY LOVE THAT, AND ONE IS THE LESSONS ENTITLED PERSONAL SAFETY, WHERE YOU'RE NOT THE EXPERT ON THIS STUFF. THAT'S YOUR SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER, AND IT GIVES THEM AN OPPORTUNITY TO BE KIND OF UP CLOSE AND PERSONAL TO THEIR SCHOOL RESOURCE OFFICER, WHO GIVES THEM REALLY WONDERFUL ADVICE ABOUT JUST GENERAL SAFETY TIPS, ESPECIALLY, WHY WOULD IT FIT IN A WOMEN'S STUDIES COURSE? BECAUSE LOCAL, NATIONAL DATA SHOWS THAT WOMEN AND THE ELDERLY ARE THE MOST TARGETED DEMOGRAPHIC WHEN IT COMES TO VARIOUS CRIMINAL OFFENSES. SO THE TAKEAWAYS THERE, THEY HEAR SOME OF THE DATA. NONE OF IT'S MEANT TO SCARE. I DON'T THINK YOU WERE SCARED, BUT JUST REALLY LOTS OF THEM ARE ABOUT TO BE COLLEGE BOUND LIKE KAY HERE. GO INTO DELAWARE NEXT YEAR, AND SOME OF THAT WILL LIKE THEY'RE GOING TO ACTUALLY TAKE WITH THEM AND GO, YEAH, I REMEMBER HEARING THIS. THIS IS WHAT I SHOULD DO WITH MY CARD. I SHOULD ALWAYS WALK WITH A PERSON, THINGS LIKE THAT. I WANT TO CARRY. SO AS WE TOOK THE COURSE FROM, A ELA COURSE TO A SOCIAL SCIENCE COURSE, WE WANTED TO ENSURE THAT WE HIT AS MUCH OF THE SOCIAL SCIENCES AS WE COULD AND GET THE CONTEXT OF HISTORY. SO I WORKED ON INFUSING A LOT OF LESSONS ON, THE HISTORY OF WOMEN, PREHISTORY TILL TODAY, OBVIOUSLY, IN HISTORICAL STRUGGLES AND IN THAT PROCESS, I WANTED TO ENSURE THAT PEOPLE THAT WERE TAKING THE COURSE WERE INTRODUCED TO WOMEN WHO WERE IN SCIENCE, WOMEN WHO WERE IN MILITARY, WOMEN WHO WERE LEADERS, AND TO BE ABLE TO ALSO UNDERSTAND THE GEOGRAPHICAL REALITIES THAT LED TO, IN MANY CASES, WOMEN'S STATUS CHANGING FROM PALEOLITHIC TO NEOLITHIC TIMES, FOR EXAMPLE. SO WE'RE YOU KNOW, I'M CONSTANTLY BRINGING IN, WE'RE CONSTANTLY BRINGING IN AS SOCIAL SCIENCE TEACHERS, ARE ALL OF THE THEMES THAT ARE REQUIRED BY THE STATE OF MARYLAND. AND OF COURSE, IN SOCIAL SCIENCES IN GENERAL. AND I THINK THE OTHER THING I DO WANT TO BRING UP, TOO, IN CREATING THIS COURSE IS THAT WE FRAMED IT AROUND IT BEING MULTIDISCIPLINARY, SO WE INCLUDED ART PROJECTS. WE INCLUDED, CHANCES FOR, FOR OUR STUDENTS TO CREATE, TO ARGUE, TO WRITE. TO EXPLORE ALMOST EVERYTHING THAT WE COULD POSSIBLY IMAGINE. SO, SO YOU CAN TELL OUR EDUCATORS ARE OBVIOUSLY VERY PASSIONATE ABOUT THIS COURSE, BUT OUR MOST IMPORTANT VOICES ARE OUR STUDENTS VOICES.

AND SO WE'LL TURN IT OVER TO OUR STUDENT TO GIVE A LITTLE BIT OF CONTEXT OF HER EXPERIENCE TAKING THIS COURSE. THANK YOU SO MUCH. SO I'M GOING TO BE THE HUNDREDTH PERSON TO SAY THIS TO YOU ALL TONIGHT. GOOD EVENING. I'D LIKE TO FIRST START BY REINTRODUCING MYSELF TO YOU. MY NAME IS KAYLEE FROWNFELTER. I AM A RECENT GRADUATE OF FALLSTON HIGH SCHOO, WHERE I TOOK WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE, TAUGHT BY MISS KAY AND THIS IS GENUINELY THE MOST IMPACTFUL CLASS I HAVE EVER

[04:15:03]

TAKEN, AND I BELIEVE IT IS THE ONE WHOSE LESSONS WILL REMAIN WITH ME THE LONGEST WITHIN THIS CLASS, WE EXAMINED MULTICULTURAL PERSPECTIVES, WHICH IS INCREASINGLY IMPORTANT IN AN INCREASINGLY DIVIDED WORLD. WE ANALYZED FEMALE WRITTEN TEXTS DATING FROM ANCIENT GREECE, OBVIOUSLY, TO THE MODERN ERA. WE LEARNED ABOUT THE FIRST WOMAN TO COMPETE IN THE OLYMPICS, THE COMFORT WOMEN OF ANCIENT CHINA, THE PIONEER WOMEN OF THE AMERICAN WEST, THE POETS OF THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT. AND AS YOU WILL HEAR, AND AS YOU ALREADY HAVE HEARD, MANY MORE LEARNING THE HISTORY OF FEMALE STRUGGLE IS SO IMPORTANT. SLIGHTLY LESS THAN 50% OF OUR WORLD'S POPULATION IS FEMALE. YET OUR HISTORY HAS BEEN REDUCED TO SINGLE SLIDES. AT THE END OF HISTORY CLASS POWERPOINTS IN OTHER HISTORY CLASSES, WE LEARN THE INFORMATION, WE TAKE A TEST, AND THEN WE MOVE ON. BUT IN WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE, WE LEARN THE INFORMATION AND DISCUSSED IT. AND WHEN I SAY WE REALLY DISCUSSED IT, THEN WE CONNECTED IT BACK TO OUR LIVES. AND I THINK OTHER YOUNG GIRLS CAN RELATE TO NOT RELATING TO THE POWERFUL MAN WE LEARN ABOUT IN HISTORY CLASS. BUT WE WERE READING AND TALKING ABOUT ISSUES THAT WERE TANGIBLY REAL TO US TODAY. THESE REASONS ARE TO BE EXPECTED, AND NATURALLY IT'S KIND OF WHAT I ASSUMED WHEN I SIGNED UP FOR THE CLASS. BUT WHAT I DIDN'T EXPECT WAS TO FIND THE COMMUNITY WE WOULD DEVELOP.

WE WERE ENCOURAGED TO REFLECT ON OUR RELATIONSHIPS WITH THE WOMEN IN OUR LIVES, TO THINK ABOUT HOW WE TREAT INDIVIDUALS WHO LOOK DIFFERENT THAN US, AND TO CONSIDER OUR PLACE IN HISTORY.

WE FORGED A SAFE SPACE TO DISCUSS FAMILIAL RELATIONSHIPS, BODY IMAGE, AND HOW WE SEE OURSELVES. TOPICS THAT WOULD BE CONSIDERED TABOO IN ANY OTHER CLASSROOM WERE OPENLY SPOKEN ABOUT IN A HEALTHY MANNER. THE NATURE OF TOPICS DISCUSSED, FOSTERED HEALTHY VULNERABILITY.

WE PRACTICE FORMING OUR OWN THOUGHTS AND LEARN HOW TO DEFEND THEM WITH VALID EVIDENCE. MY WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE CLASS WAS A BREATH OF FRESH AIR FOR ME. I LEARNED ABOUT THINGS I CARE ABOUT. I COULD TALK ABOUT MY THOUGHTS IN A SAFE SPACE WHERE MY THOUGHTS WERE VALIDATED. AND I THINK THAT WHEN PROVIDED WITH THE OPPORTUNITY, OTHER STUDENTS WILL EXPERIENCE THE EXACT SAME THING. MY OWN PERSONAL SPIRIT. EXCUSE ME, MY OWN PERSONAL EXPERIENCE ASIDE, WOMEN'S PERSPECTIVE NEEDS TO BE CELEBRATED. THANK YOU. SO WE HAVE GATHERED FEEDBACK FROM A VARIETY OF STUDENTS. YOU'VE HAD THESE QUOTES BEFORE YOU BEFORE, AND THEY HAVE BEEN IN THE PUBLIC SPHERE. SO FOR THE SAKE OF TIMELINESS, WE'LL GO TO OUR FEEDBACK FROM TEACHERS. SOME OF THE, BULLET POINTS HERE ON YOUR SCREEN REALLY CAPTURE THE FEEDBACK FROM TEACHERS IN OUR SCHOOL DISTRICT. BUT SINCE WE DO HAVE THE EXPERTS HERE, I WANTED TO GIVE THEM AN OPPORTUNITY TO SHARE THEIR PERSPECTIVE. LET ME GO FIRST, BECAUSE I COULD BE PRETTY QUICK, THERE ARE A FEW THINGS THAT I DO LIKE ABOUT IT, AND ONE THAT ACTUALLY AN EXPERIENCE THAT WE HAD THIS YEAR, WE WERE INVITED. I WAS INVITED TO A TEA PARTY, AND I HAVE NEVER BEEN A TEA PARTY BEFORE, BUT WHEN I WAS INVITED TO A TEA PARTY AND THIS TEA PARTY WAS HOSTED BY THE STUDENTS AND THIS WOMAN IN PERSPECTIVE OF COURSE, THEY INVITED TEACHERS PRIMARILY THAT WERE HAD PLANNING TO BE, BUT WE WERE ABLE TO COME AND SIT WITH STUDENTS, OF COURSE, MIXED, MIXED TABLES, YOU KNOW, WITH STUDENTS AND HAVE CONVERSATIONS WE SHARED, YOU KNOW, TEA, OF COURSE. AND THEN, YOU KNOW, FINGER FOODS. BUT IT WAS MORE ABOUT THE CONVERSATION, THE DIALOG THAT WAS HAPPENING.

WE DON'T REALLY HAVE TIME TO SIT DOWN IN A RELAXED ENVIRONMENT DURING THE SCHOOL DAY TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THESE CONVERSATIONS AT THE END OF THAT TIME TOGETHER, WE WERE TAUGHT HOW TO CROCHET. I AM TERRIBLE AT IT. SO NOW THAT I KNOW I WILL NOT BE DOING THAT AGAIN, BUT IT WAS GREAT TO EXPERIENCE THAT. SO ONE OF THE STUDENTS IN THE CLASS TAUGHT US HOW TO CROCHET, AND OTHERS EXCELLED, I STRUGGLED. THAT DOESN'T MEAN I DIDN'T ENJOY MYSELF, I JUST PUT IT DOWN AND JUST TOOK THE LOSS RIGHT? BUT THE IDEA BEHIND IT IS THIS WAS A MOMENT THAT COULD NOT HAVE HAPPENED, AND IT HAPPENED BECAUSE OF THIS WOMAN'S PERSPECTIVE COURSE. SO I SHARE THAT STORY WITH YOU BECAUSE THAT'S THAT'S THE FONDEST MEMORY THAT I HAVE OF THAT COURSE FROM THIS PAST YEAR. I CANNOT WAIT TO SEE WITH NOW TWO SECTIONS OF THIS COURSE, POSSIBLY WHAT THE NEXT TEACHER YOU KNOW WILL COME UP WITH IT IS IN GREAT HANDS. THE EDUCATOR THAT WILL BE TEACHING IT NEXT YEAR. SHE IS VERY CLOSE TO THE TEACHER THAT LEFT AND I KNOW THAT SHE WILL DO A PHENOMENAL JOB. I LOVE THE FACT THAT WOMEN'S VOICES ARE HEARD. OBVIOUSLY THE INSIGHTS AND SOLUTIONS, THAT MIGHT BE OVERLOOKED IN OTHER COURSES, LIKE OUR STUDENTS SAID, THAT WE UNFORTUNATELY IN HISTORY WE DON'T HAVE THE TIME TO ACTUALLY BREAK DOWN SOME OF THE, YOU KNOW, REALLY IMPORTANT CONCEPTS ABOUT WOMEN BECAUSE WE ARE ON A TIME CRUNCH. WE HAVE A PACE, WE HAVE SCOPE AND SEQUENCE. THERE ARE THINGS THAT WE HAVE TO COVER. BUT IN THIS CLASS YOU CAN FOCUS ON THAT, DISCUSSING VIEWPOINTS THAT IMPACT SOCIETY AS A WHOLE. THAT'S JUST WHAT A SOCIAL SCIENCE TEACHER DOES EVERY DAY. AND THEN OF COURSE, THE FINAL IDEA IS THAT WE ADDRESS ISSUES THAT CHALLENGE, EACH PERSON EVERY DAY, BUT ESPECIALLY WOMEN, THEY'RE ABLE TO VOICE THEIR OPINIONS. THAT'S THE PART THAT I ENJOY THE MOST ABOUT THE COURSE. WELL, I HAVE

[04:20:02]

NOT TAUGHT THE COURSE. I'VE ONLY WRITTEN CURRICULUM, MY BIGGEST TAKEAWAY IS THAT IT, IT MADE ME, CONNECT WITH FAMILY, AND OTHER WOMEN AROUND ME AND ASK OPINIONS THAT THEY HAD AND DEVELOP RESPECT FOR EVEN DIFFERING OPINIONS THAT THEY HAD. THAT WAS PROBABLY MY BIGGEST TAKEAWAY, I THINK SECONDLY, I FOUND THIS QUOTE FROM VIRGINIA WOOLF, AND IT WAS FOR MOST OF HISTORY, ANONYMOUS WAS A WOMAN. AND I THOUGHT THAT THIS COURSE WOULD DO JUSTICE TO OVERTURN THAT.

QUOTE. I LOVE TEACHING THIS COURSE, AND ONE THING I LOVE ABOUT IT IS THAT IT IS FOR ALL STUDENTS, EVEN THOUGH IT'S CALLED WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE. LIKE I SAID, MALES. I HAVEN'T SEEN MY NEW ROSTER, BUT I GUARANTEE THERE'S SOME MALES ON THERE, BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY, IT'S STUDENTS OF ALL ABILITY LEVELS SUCCEED. AND I'VE TAUGHT ALL LEVELS AS AN ENGLISH TEACHER. AND WHILE SOME STUDENTS IN MY ESPECIALLY OTHER CLASSES WILL STRUGGLE WITH WRITING OR FACE READING BARRIERS, THOSE THAT ARE SO HIGH STAKES NOW BECAUSE OF TESTING AND I TEACH 10TH GRADE, AND, AND I SAW SOME OF THEM COME TO ME IN WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE IN THIS CLASS. THEY STILL DID. WELL, IT'S AN ELECTIVE. THEY CHOSE TO TAKE. SO THEY WERE MOTIVATED BY THE TOPICS AND THEY HAD PLENTY OF CHOICE. CHOICE IS SO KEY, AND THAT MEANS IN WITH REGARD TO HOW THEY SHOW THEIR LEARNING. SO YOU GIVE THEM LOTS OF CHOICE, ACCORDING TO THE FEEDBACK GIVEN TO ME WHEN I ASK AS KIND OF VALIDATED, IT IS A SAFE SPACE FOR STUDENTS TO FEEL SEEN AND HEARD AND VALUED. IN ADDITION, THE COURSE ALLOWS FOR AUTHENTIC, REAL WORLD LEARNING EXPERIENCE.

AS I GAVE SOME EXAMPLES, MY FAVORITE MEMORY IS OF ONE OF MY STUDENTS AND SHE WAS IN A GROUP THAT DECIDED TO DO LIKE ONE OF THOSE BREAKOUT ROOM TYPE THINGS ABOUT MADAM C.J. WALKER AND THIS ONE STUDENT WHO COULD OFTEN BE KIND OF HAVE SOME ANXIETY IN FRONT OF A GROUP AND THINGS LIKE THAT. I SAW HER SITTING ON THE FLOOR NEXT TO SIXTH GRADERS WITH THEIR COMPUTERS OPEN AS THEY WERE GOING INTO THIS ONENOTE NOTEBOOK TO OPEN PAGES, AND SHE WAS JUST RIGHT UP IN IT. AND THEN TOWARD THE END OF THE YEAR, SHE WAS THE ONE SAYING, I THINK I WANT TO BE A TEACHER NOW. SHE LIKES PRIMARY AGE, AND I WAS LIKE, YEP, I SEE THAT IN YOU, TOO. AND I DIDN'T SEE THAT THE YEAR BEFORE. IT JUST MADE ME SO PROUD, THE COURSE ALLOWS STUDENTS TO CONNECT WITH, REFLECT ON, AND APPRECIATE AND SOMETIMES LEARN NEW STORIES ABOUT FEMALES IN THEIR OWN FAMILY. BUT IN ADDITION, THEIR PEER CIRCLE. I LOVED THAT ABOUT YOUR CLASS. WHAT TOUCHED ME MOST AT THE END OF THE SCHOOL YEAR WAS THE TREND I NOTICED IN THE CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT, WHICH WAS THE CHILDREN'S BOOKS, AND THEY COULD DO IT ON PAPER, OR THEY COULD DO IT DIGITALLY. THEY HAD CHOICE. BUT ABOUT HALF OF THEM CHOSE TO REFLECT ON UNIT ONE BECAUSE IT WAS A REFLECTION OF ANY OF THE UNITS AND LESSONS LEARNED IN THERE. THEY AND THEY THEY WENT BACK TO THE NARRATIVE.

THEY WROTE ABOUT THEIR FAMILY MEMBER. I READ SO MANY STORIES ABOUT SISTERS, AUNTS, GRANDMOTHERS AND MOTHERS, SO THEY WERE ADDING SPECIAL DEDICATIONS AND PICTURES OF FAMILY MEMBERS AND OTHER SPECIAL ITEMS LIKE RECIPES. I WAS LIKE, THAT'S YOUR GRANDMOTHER'S BREAD RECIPE. YOU KNOW? AND THEY WERE JUST BEAUTIFULLY. I WAS LIKE, CRYING AT THE END. LIKE IT WAS LIKE AN EMOTIONAL TIME ANYWAY, BECAUSE SENIORS WERE LEAVING, SOME RELATED TO IMPORTANT WOMEN IN EVENTS THAT RESONATED WITH THEM, LIKE KS. SHE WROTE ABOUT HEDY LAMARR AND IT WAS CALLED HEDY DID IT. AND IN THE END OF YOUR STORY WAS JUST BEAUTIFUL. IF HEDY DID IT, I CAN TOO. AND SHE DEDICATED THAT BOOK TO HER SISTER, WHO WILL BE A RISING NINTH GRADER. I JUST LOVE THAT SHE HAD A PICTURE OF HER IN THERE AND HER MESSAGE TO HER SISTER WAS, YOU CAN DO ANYTHING YOU WANT TO DO. SO ANYWAY, SO I'M PROUD OF THOSE. AND THE LAST THING I WANT TO SAY IS WHEN STUDENTS CREATE FROM THEIR HEART AND PERSONAL INTEREST, DO YOU DO GET QUALITY WORK? IT'S WORK.

THEY WILL REMEMBER. IT'S WORK THAT CAN CHANGE THEIR LIVES IN A POSITIVE WAY, EVEN JUST A LITTL.

THAT'S WHAT WE STRIVE FOR IN OUR WORK AS TEACHERS. I CAN'T THINK OF WHY WE WOULD NOT WANT TO OFFER A COURSE THAT CAN HAVE THAT KIND OF IMPACT ON STUDENTS, AND OUR PRINCIPALS HAVE SIMILARLY POSITIVE FEEDBACK, ESPECIALLY AS IT RELATES TO THINGS LIKE GROWING OUR OWN, OUR TEACHERS INSPIRING OUR STUDENTS TO BE TEACHERS, THE OPPORTUNITY TO EXPOSE CHILDREN OR OUR STUDENTS TO BUILDING DEBATE AND DISCUSSION SKILLS, BOTH VERBAL AND IN WRITING, AND EXPOSE OUR

[04:25:04]

STUDENTS TO A VARIETY OF OPINIONS AND TO HELP THEM LEARN TO IDENTIFY FACTS THAT ARE RESEARCHED AND WELL INFORMED. AND OUR PRINCIPALS REALLY SAW THAT SAME LEVEL OF POSITIVE ENGAGEMENT FROM OUR STUDENTS. AND ESPECIALLY HELPS THEM TO BE BETTER SOCIAL SCIENTISTS AND FOR THEIR REQUIRED COURSES. THIS IS A COURSE THAT CAN BUILD THAT ENGAGEMENT THAT IS GOING TO HELP OUR STUDENTS IN COURSES THAT THEY ARE REQUIRED TO TAKE. NOW, WE DO KNOW THAT THE BOARD HAD SOME CONCERNS AND WE DID WANT TO ADDRESS THEM. SO THE FIRST IS ENSURING THAT BALANCED PERSPECTIVES. AND I DO HOPE THAT YOU HEARD THAT FROM THE TEACHERS DIRECTLY, THAT USING THAT INQUIRY DESIGN MODEL PROVIDES STUDENTS WITH AN OPPORTUNITY TO LOOK THROUGH MULTIPLE LENSES AND MULTIPLE PERSPECTIVES ON THAT COMPELLING QUESTION THAT HAS NO RIGHT OR WRONG ANSWER. OFTEN OUR TEACHERS ARE USING DISCUSSION BASED STRATEGIES THAT CENTER STUDENT VOICE AND ALLOW STUDENTS TO DRAW THEIR OWN CONCLUSIONS. ALWAYS SUPPORTED BY EVIDENCE. THERE WAS ALSO A CONCERN ABOUT THE PERCEIVED LACK OF INCLUSION AND WOMEN IN SCIENCE, MEDICINE, BUSINESS, LEADERSHIP AND POLITICS AND I DID CALL OUT SPECIFICALLY ON THE SCREEN NARRATIVES THAT ARE SPECIFICALLY INCLUDED BY NAME IN THE CURRICULUM, INCLUDING THINGS LIKE SOME LEADERS FROM EARLY ANTIQUITY, ARE SUFFRAGISTS, OLYMPE DE GOUGES, WOMEN IN LEADERSHIP OR POLITICS AND RESEARCHING LIKE THAT, SO A LOT OF FEMALE SCIENTISTS, LEADERS IN BUSINESS AND POLITICS, SCIENCE AND MEDICINE, AS WELL AS OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS TO HAVE CHOICE IN WHO THEY ARE STUDYING AND TO BE ABLE TO HIGHLIGHT THOSE WOMEN. AND IN PARTICULAR, WE HAVE IN THAT EXPERIENCE, A RECOMMENDATION FOR TEACHERS TO THINK ABOUT USING GROUPS OF WOMEN TO SUPPORT STUDENTS IN MAKING THOSE CHOICES. SO THINK ABOUT HAVING SOMEBODY THINK ABOUT SCIENCE, SOMEBODY ELSE THINK ABOUT A WOMAN IN BUSINESS AND HAVING THAT BE THE DRIVING FORCE OF THAT WOMEN'S HISTORY MONTH PROJECT. WE DID WANT TO ADDRESS, SPECIFICALLY THAT INCLUSION OF MARGARET SANGER AND HILLARY CLINTON. THERE IS A DOUBLE NEGATIVE TYPO THERE. SO LET ME BE VERY CLEAR THAT THERE IS NO MENTION OR INCLUSION OF MARGARET SANGER IN EITHER THE OLD OR THE NEW CURRICULUM. SHE IS NOT INCLUDED AT ALL, NOR IS HILLARY CLINTON, THOSE WERE TWO PIECES OF CONCERN THAT WERE BROUGHT UP BY THE BOARD, AND I WANTED TO ADDRESS THOSE IN PARTICULAR, THERE ARE A VERY EXTENSIVE LIST. SO THERE IS AN EXTENSIVE LIST OF SUPPLEMENTARY RESOURCES TO HELP STUDENTS IN CONSIDERING WHO THEY WANT TO CHOOSE FOR WOMEN'S HISTORY MONTH. SO A LIST OF THE TIME MAGAZINE'S WOMEN OF THE YEAR, A LIST FROM SPORTS ILLUSTRATED AND FEMALE ATHLETES.

THOSE ARE IN THERE. AND I DID FIND AN EXAMPLE WHERE HILLARY CLINTON WAS SPECIFICALLY MENTIONED IN THE NATIONAL ARCHIVES LIST THAT IS INCLUDED BOTH IN NOTABLE WOMEN AND ANOTHER LIST THAT WAS ON FIRST LADIES, AS WELL AS IN TIME MAGAZINE'S 100 WOMEN OF THE YEAR ARCHIVE SITE. SO THAT MAY HAVE BEEN WHERE THAT CONFUSION CAME FROM, BUT THEY ARE NOT EXPRESSLY EXPLICITLY CALLED OUT IN THE CURRICULUM AT ALL. SO AS WAS MENTIONED AND CELEBRATED, WE DO HAVE AN INCREASE IN INTEREST FOR NEXT SCHOOL YEAR FOR WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE, WITH BOTH BOSTON AND JOPPATOWNE SEEING AN INCREASE IN ENROLLMENT AS WELL AS INTEREST IN EDGEWOOD HIGH SCHOOL COMING ON BOARD. AND SO THE REQUEST OF THE OFFICE OF SOCIAL SCIENCES IS TO REQUEST THAT THIS COURSE, WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE, BE APPROVED FOR REGULAR STATUS ON THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE SUPERINTENDENT. AND AT THIS POINT, WE WILL TAKE QUESTIONS.

THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE THOROUGH PRESENTATION. WE'LL OPEN UP THE BOARD MEMBERS FOR QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. SAID THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE A CONVERSATION. YOU KNOW, ONE OF THE AREAS I SAW WAS, WOMEN IN LEADERSHIP AND IN GOVERNMENT AND MAKING SURE THAT WE WERE PROVIDING OPPORTUNITIES FOR ONE OF THE REASONS THAT I ALSO SEE ON HERE, WHERE, STUDENTS WILL PARTICIPATE IN AN IN-SCHOOL IN SCHOOL FIELD TRIP, ABERDEEN PROVING GROUND. I'D BE HAPPY TO HELP YOU FACILITATE THAT AND WORK WITH SOME AMAZING WOMEN IN THE MILITARY. SO, YOU KNOW, IF YOU NEED HELP, HELP WITH THAT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. SO I JUST HAVE, A QUESTION ABOUT THE STATUS OF THE CURRICULUM AS IT STANDS ON THE WEB, ON THE PORTAL TODAY. IS THAT, IS THAT COMPLETE OR ARE THERE STILL BEING MODIFICATIONS MADE THAT IS COMPLETE? NOW I WILL HAVE A FINAL PASS THROUGH, BUT WE WANTED TO WAIT FOR THE WHOLE CONVERSATION THAT WE WERE HAVING WITH BOARD MEMBERS TO DO THAT FINAL PASS THROUGH. BUT THESE LOVELY, EDUCATORS HAVE FINISHED THEIR WRITING AND YOU DO HAVE FULL ACCESS TO THE UPDATED CURRICULUM. SO THAT'S WHAT'S CHANGED SINCE LAST TIME WHEN WE TABLED IT. IT WAS NOT TO THIS POINT. SO NOW IT'S AS COMPLETE AS IT'S GOING TO BE, EXCEPT FOR THE ONE PASS THROUGH AND THAT'S ON THE CANVAS PASSWORD THAT WE HAVE RIGHT NOW. THAT IS CORRECT. ON CANVAS. YOU KNOW, I WANT TO ADDRESS SOMETHING THAT, THAT DOCTOR MUELLER BROUGHT UP ABOUT MARGARET SANGER. IT WASN'T SO MUCH THAT SHE WAS ON THERE BECAUSE SHE WAS A HISTORICAL WOMAN, BUT IT WAS WHAT WAS SAID

[04:30:02]

ABOUT HER THAT IT WAS, YOU KNOW, THERE WERE THERE WERE, CONCLUSIONS MADE ABOUT HER CHARACTER THAT WERE VERY POSITIVE, AND, YOU KNOW, I DIDN'T THINK THAT THAT WAS APPROPRIATE FOR CONCLUSIONS TO BE DRAWN TO FOR THE STUDENT, REPRESENTING SOMEONE WHO WAS VERY CONTROVERSIAL FIGURE. WELL, AS I MENTIONED, AND AS THE LADIES MENTIONED, MARGARET SANGER WAS NOT IN THE OLD OR THE NEW. SO I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE A CONVERSATION WITH YOU ABOUT WHERE YOU SAW THAT. SO THAT WE CAN ADDRESS THAT CONCERN. SHE IS NOT IN THERE AT ALL. ANY SOCIAL STUDIES? NO, NO, I THINK I'LL GO BACK AND LOOK AT MY NOTES. I THINK I, I DID TRY I CAN'T SAY THAT I DID IT 100% OF THE TIME. I TRIED TO TAKE A SCREENSHOT OF WHEN I SAW ITEMS THAT, YOU KNOW, I HAD CONCERNS ABOUT, BUT, YOU KNOW, SO I'LL GO BACK AND LOOK AND TRY TO GET BACK TO YOU ON THAT. PERFECT. I LOOK FORWARD TO IT. THANK YOU. OKAY, SO JUST TO RECAP WHAT WE ARE HERE. THIS WAS PREVIOUSLY TABLED BECAUSE WE DIDN'T THE BOARD DIDN'T HAVE THE COMPLETE INFORMATION. IT'S NOW COMPLETE. YOU BRIEFED THE BOARD, IN SMALL GROUP. AND THIS EVENING WE HAVE ACCESS TO IT. NO MORE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. I'LL JUST A COMMENT. AGAIN, I HAVEN'T SEEN WHAT'S ON CANVAS NOW, AND I JUST. I'M NOT FORMING A BLOCKADE. I'M JUST REITERATING THE IMPORTANCE THAT YOU KNOW, WHEN WE MAKE A CURRICULUM DECISION, IT HELPS TO UNDERSTAND THE CURRICULUM. AND I HAVEN'T GOTTEN A CHANCE TO LOOK AT IT, SO I WOULD HAVE TO ABSTAIN. I'M SURE YOU DID A GREAT JOB. I JUST AND AGAIN, I REITERATE THE REQUEST FOR ACCESS TO ALL THE CURRICULUM BECAUSE IT'S NOT JUST LOOKING AT ONE COURSE THROUGH A STRAW. I WANT TO UNDERSTAND IT IN RELATION TO OTHER COURSES AS WELL. I THINK AT LEAST TWO OF THE BOARD MEMBERS GOT WALKED OUT OF CANVAS AND WEREN'T ABLE TO VIEW EVERYTHING YET, SO THAT'S REASONABLE. THANK YOU, MISS COKER. OKAY, THEN I'LL ENTERTAIN A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE FOR REGULAR STATUS. THIS IS MOTION TO APPROVE THE REGULAR STATUS PENDING READ ACCESS AND PENDING A REVIEW OF THE CURRICULUM ON CANVAS. THAT WOULD REALLY BE. I DON'T THINK THAT'S A MOTION THAT WE CAN ENTERTAIN BECAUSE IT'S A MOTION TO BASICALLY TABLE IT. RIGHT. WELL I MOVE THAT. WE APPROVE, THE WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE COURSE. I SECOND THE MOTION, MISS ROLLO, ROLL CALL, VOTE, PLEASE. MISS ALVAREZ. YES MISS BRUCE? YES MISS COKER, I HAVE TO ABSTAIN. DOCTOR MUELLER. YES MISS BOUZOUKI. YES.

PREFERENTIAL YES, MISS PERRY. YES, MR. SILO. YES, MR. ROSS? YES. PRESIDENT BOYNTON. YES.

THIS MOTION PASSES. OKAY. THANK YOU, I THINK YOU'LL BE BACK, BUT WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO YOU, I

[B. Consent Agenda ]

THINK, JUST AFTER BREAK. SO DON'T GO TOO FAR. THANK YOU VERY MUCH I APPRECIATE IT. OKAY. SO WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO THE CONSENT AGENDA, ACTING VICE PRESIDENT, PLEASE READ THE CONSENT AGENDA. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. SO I'LL WAIT FOR THEM TO SIT DOWN. ALL RIGHT. ON THE CONSENT AGENDA. CONSENT AGENDA. TODAY, WE HAVE THE CONTRACT AWARD FOR THE RENEWAL OF THE COMMON LIT DIGITAL DIGITAL LITERACY PROGRA. AND THEN WE'LL BE REVIEWING THE MINUTES OF THE PREVIOUS BOARD MEETINGS, THAT BEING APRIL 15TH, APRIL 29TH AND APRIL 20TH OF 2024. MAY 20TH, MAY 20TH, 2024.

SO WE WON'T BE REVIEWING IT. WE'LL BE, APPROVING IT BECAUSE IT'S ALREADY BEEN PROVIDED UNLESS THERE WAS ANY ISSUES IN EITHER OR IN THE MINUTES THAT WEREN'T ACCURATE. SO IF THERE'S NO CONCERNS THAT WERE IDENTIFIED IN YOUR REVIEW, WE'LL TAKE A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA. I MOVE THAT WE APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA COUNCIL. BRUCE, I SECOND YOU.

THANK YOU ALL IN FAVOR, PLEASE SAY YES. YES, YES. ANY OPPOSED? PLEASE SAY NO. ANY ABSTENTIONS? THANK

[C. Revised Advanced Placement African American Studies for Regular Status Decision, Ms. Erin Lange, Supervisor of Science, Ms. Heather Kutcher, Executive Director of Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment, and Mr. Andrew Renzulli, Director of Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment • Advanced Placement African American Studies for Regular Status ]

ITEM D ACTION ITEM FOR REVISED. ADVANCED PLACEMENT AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES FOR REGULAR STATUS DECISION. WELCOME BACK. PLEASE INTRODUCE YOUR TEAM OR ANY CHANGES. WE'LL BE INTRODUCING HER TEAM, SO AS WE STATED IN THE FIRST PRESENTATION, NOT ONLY ARE WE

[04:35:04]

HERE TO PRESENT THE WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE COURSE, WHICH YOU JUST SAW, BUT ALSO THE REVISED SOCIAL STUDIES SIX HUMAN GEOGRAPHY COURSE AND THE ADVANCED PLACEMENT AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. SO WE HAVE WORKED TO CAREFULLY BALANCE THE BOARD'S INPUT WITH OUR DEDICATED SECTION TO DELIVERING COMPREHENSIVE EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCES THAT ARE ALIGNED TO STATE FRAMEWORKS AND COLLEGE BOARD REQUIREMENTS. SO I'LL TURN IT OVER TO MRS. LANGE TO INTRODUCE HER TEAM. THANK YOU. SO I BROUGHT MORE GIFTS WE HAVE WITH US, TWO OUT OF THREE OF OUR AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES TEACHERS IN PERSON. WE HAVE OUR THIRD ONE VIRTUAL, AND THEN WE HAVE OUR PRINCIPAL PERSPECTIVE AS WELL. AND I WILL LET EVERYBODY INTRODUCE THEMSELVES.

MR. MICHAEL HARRIS, JOPPATOWNE HIGH SCHOOL SOCIAL SCIENCE. ROB BELIVEAU, PRINCIPAL OF BEL AIR HIGH SCHOOL. JOHN MOBLEY, ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL. MR. AUSTIN, DO WE STILL HAVE YOU, YES. I'M HERE. SORRY. ANDREW AUSTIN, BEL AIR HIGH SCHOOL, HE'S COMING TO US LIVE FROM HIS VACATION, WE ALSO HAVE SOME STUDENTS WHO WILL OFFER SOME PERSPECTIVES DURING THIS, PRESENTATION. SO AS BRIEF CONTEXTUALIZATION AS A REMINDER, THIS IS A FULL YEAR COURSE OF EVIDENCE BASED INTRODUCTION TO AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES THAT MULTIPLE MULTIPLE MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACH. WHEW. IT'S GETTING LATE, THAT WAS CREATED BASED ON FEEDBACK FROM OVER 355 COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES. I'M SORRY, WITH THE 355 COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES SIGNING ON TO PROVIDE CREDIT, AND IT WAS CREATED USING OVER 100 PLUS COLLEGE SYLLABI, AS WELL AS THAT SMALL GROUP FEEDBACK AND DISCUSSION. WE ARE IN THE AT THE END OF OUR SECOND YEAR OF PILOT AS COLLEGE BOARD, WITH THIRD YEAR BEING FULL IMPLEMENTATION, AND WE WERE ONE OF THE 700 SCHOOLS THEY WERE LOOKING FOR 60, I'M SORRY, THEY WERE LOOKING FOR 100. THEY GOT OVER 700. AND WE REPRESENT THREE OF THOSE 700 SCHOOLS THAT WERE IN THE YEAR TWO OF PILOT. WE DID HAVE FOUR SECTIONS AT OUR THREE SCHOOLS. WE HAD ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL, BEL AIR HIGH SCHOOL AND JOPPATOWNE HIGH SCHOOL, WHICH ARE REPRESENTED BY OUR EDUCATORS HERE. AND ONLINE. SURE, JUST FOR BREVITY. BREVITY'S SAKE AND FOR THE SAKE OF TIME, AS YOU CAN SEE THAT THE FOUR, UNITS STUDY DEALING WITH THE ORIGINS OF THE AFRICAN DIASPORA FREEDOM, ENSLAVEMENT, AND RESISTANCE, PRACTICE OF FREEDOM, AND THE MOVEMENTS AND DEBATES, VERY LIGHT FOR AP COURSES, MOSTLY. AP COURSES USUALLY HAVE ANYWHERE BETWEEN 6 TO 7 UNITS, AND THIS ONE HAS FOUR, WITH UNIT ONE HAVING 15 LESSONS. UNIT TWO HAVING 28 LESSONS, UNIT THREE AND UNIT FOUR HAVING 19 LESSONS, AND AS YOU CAN SEE, EACH ONE HAS A DIMENSION OF TIME THAT IS COVERED WITHIN EACH ONE OF THOSE UNITS. BUT HOWEVER, SOME OF THOSE TOPICS WITHIN THOSE UNITS, CAN BE, MATCHED WITH OTHER, PIECES OF INFORMATION FROM OTHER UNITS. NOW, WHAT'S NOT ON THE SCREEN, WHICH IS VERY UNIQUE FOR THIS CLASS, IS THE, PROJECT THAT EACH STUDENT MUST PARTICIPATE, WHICH IS AN ORAL DEFENSE. AND WITHIN THAT, PROJECT, THEY HAVE TO PRESENT A FIVE MINUTE ORAL PRESENTATION AND THEIR TOPIC IS OF THEIR CHOICE. IT CAN BE ANY, TOPIC THAT WAS COVERED WITHIN THE SCOPE OF WHAT WE HAD DISCUSSED THROUGHOUT THE FOUR UNITS OR SOMETHING. THAT WAS OUTSIDE OF THE SCOPE. IT'S THEIR DECISION, THEY ARE ALSO GIVEN A RUBRIC OF WHAT IS WHAT IS EXPECTED. ALSO TO THEY ARE GIVEN QUESTIONS WITHIN A THREE MINUTE PERIOD THAT I WILL BE GIVING THEM, OR THE TEACHER WOULD BE GIVING THEM WITHIN THAT TIME FRAME. NOW ALSO TO EACH LESSON THERE ARE SUGGESTED SKILLS AND, REAL BRIEFLY THERE ARE THREE CATEGORIES. THE FIRST CATEGORY IS APPLYING DISCIPLINARY KNOWLEDGE. THE SECOND CATEGORY IS SOURCE ANALYSIS. AND THEN THE THIRD ONE IS, ARGUMENTATION. AND WHAT THIS REALLY IS, IS THAT WE'RE ENSURING THAT FIRST, THAT ANY INFORMATION THAT IS GIVEN ABOUT THIS CLASS IS FACTUAL. THAT'S NUMBER ONE, BUT ALSO TWO, TEACHING OUR STUDENTS HOW TO HANDLE THAT INFORMATION. BUT THEN ALSO TO WITH, CATEGORY TWO, WITH THE SOURCE ANALYSIS, STUDENTS ARE NOW TAUGHT TO USE PROPERLY PRIMARY AND SECONDARY SOURCES. SO WITHIN THAT CONTEXT, STUDENTS ARE NOW NOT ONLY ABLE TO USE IT, BUT ALSO TO APPLY IT AND THEN NOT ONLY DISSECT IT, BUT MAKE EVALUATIONS AS WELL. AND THEN FINALLY ON THE THIRD, SKILLS CATEGORY, STUDENTS ARE GIVEN THE ABILITY TO LOOK AT AN ARGUMENT. AND ULTIMATELY, ULTIMATELY, THEY HAVE TO FORMULATE, A CLAIM, WHICH IS A SKILL THAT THEY WOULD NEED FOR

[04:40:01]

DIFFERENT DISCIPLINES SUCH AS SCIENCE AND OTHER SUBJECTS OF THAT NATURE. BUT HOWEVER, WHAT'S IMPORTANT WITH, EACH ONE OF THOSE THOSE LESSONS IS GIVEN. ALSO, THERE ARE THREE CATEGORIES THAT ARE ALSO COVERED, WHICH IS SOURCES LEARNING OBJECTIVES AND ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE. NOW WITHIN THAT CONTEXT THAT THE SOURCES ARE, WE ARE GIVEN AS EDUCATORS THE OPTION OR IS SUGGESTED WITHIN THE CURRICULUM ITSELF OF THE SOURCES THAT ARE GIVEN. BUT TEACHERS ARE MORE THAN HAPPY TO USE SOURCES THAT ARE OUTSIDE OF THE SUGGESTED. BUT THEN ALSO TO. AND I CANNOT STRESS ENOUGH. IT'S THE PREROGATIVE OF THE TEACHER OF KNOWING THEIR STUDENTS AND KNOWING WHAT INFORMATION THEY WOULD NEED IN ORDER FOR THEIR STUDENTS TO GET A CLEAR UNDERSTANDING OF THE INFORMATION THAT IS GIVEN. NOW, SOME OF THE TOPICS THAT WE DO COVER IN THIS CURRICULUM, SUCH AS, DEALING WITH CARTER G. WOODSON, THE COLORED CONVENTIONS, QUEEN ZINGA AND OTHER MATRIARCHAL, SOCIETIE, JUNETEENTH, THE CONTRIBUTION OF BLACK PEOPLE IN ALL WARS THAT WOMEN FOUGHT IN THIS COUNTRY.

THE HBCU AND ITS NECESSITY. ALSO THE AFRO CARIBBEAN MIGRATION AND ALSO MODERN CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT AND THE GREAT MIGRATION. THERE ARE SO MANY OTHER, TOPICS THAT ARE DISCUSSED. BUT JUST TO GIVE YOU AN OVERVIEW OF WHAT WHAT IS DONE IN THIS CLASS. SO AS WE MENTIONED BEFORE, OUR MOST IMPORTANT VOICES ARE STUDENT VOICES. AND SO WE BROUGHT SOME GIFTS WITH US TODAY OF SOME STUDENTS THAT TOOK THIS COURSE THIS LAST SCHOOL YEAR IN OUR HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS CLASSROOMS. AND WE WANTED TO PROVIDE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THEM TO SPEAK DIRECTLY TO THEIR EXPERIENCES TAKING THIS COURSE IN HARFORD COUNTY, PUBLIC SCHOOLS. OKAY GOOD EVENING EVERYONE. MY NAME IS HAVEN ROSEN AND I AM A STUDENT ENTERING MY SENIOR YEAR AT ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL. OVER 50 YEARS AGO, MY UNCLE BISHOP FRANKLIN C CORNELIUS SHOWELL, LED THE CHARGE IN FIGHTING FOR AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY TO BE A PART OF OUR EDUCATION, TO BE A PART OF OUR EDUCATION FOR ALL MARYLANDERS. TODAY, I STAND HERE AND REITERATE THE NECESSITY OF EDUCATION THROUGH THE 2023 2024 SCHOOL YEAR. I HAD THE IMMENSE PLEASURE OF TAKING AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES UNDER THE TEACHING AND LEADERSHIP OF DOCTOR EXCUSE ME OF JOHN MOBLEY. THE COURSE IS NOT ONLY EDUCATIONALLY BENEFICIAL TO STUDENTS OF ALL BACKGROUNDS BY PROVIDING INSIGHT, KNOWLEDGE AND PERSPECTIVE ABOUT THE HISTORY AND CULTURE OF BLACK PEOPLE, BOTH DOMESTICALLY AND INTERNATIONALLY. BUT IT GIVES A SENSE OF COMMUNITY AND BELONGING TO ALL STUDENTS THROUGH OPEN AND HONEST DIALOG. IT HAS BRIDGED THE GAP BETWEEN BLACK AND WHITE, LEFT AND RIGHT OR RIGHT AND WRONG. BY CREATING A SAFE SPACE FOR OPEN DIALOG, DISCUSSION AND COMMUNICATION. HAVING THIS COURSE AVAILABLE HAS MEANT EVERYTHING TO ME AND MORE. I HAVE FELT, SEEN, HEARD AND UNDERSTOOD. IT HAS INTRODUCED NEW PERSPECTIVES AND IDEAS AND CHALLENGED MY WAYS OF THINKING. IT HAS CREATED FRIENDSHIPS WITH PEOPLE THAT I SHARE SIMILAR EXPERIENCES WITH AS PEOPLE OF COLOR IN AMERICA, AS WELL AS THOSE I DON'T. THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS DIVERSE AND INCLUSIVE CURRICULUM IS CRUCIAL FOR THE UNDERSTANDING TO THE UNDERSTANDING OF KNOWING OUR HERITAGE AND FROM WHENCE WE'VE COME, ALLOWING FOR A SENSE OF BELONGING AND PRIDE IN A COUNTRY THAT TRIES TO STRIP THAT AWAY.

BANNING THIS COURSE NOT ONLY BANS AND CENSORS CRITICAL PARTS OF UNITED STATES HISTORY, IT PREVENTS THE LEARNING OF GEOGRAPHY, BIOLOGY AND SOCIOLOGY. AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES TEACHES STUDENTS THE ORIGINS OF THE HUMAN RACE FROM WHERE WE'VE COME, HOW WE'VE EVOLVED, ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS, ETC, SOME MAY ARGUE THAT THE COURSE DOESN'T ADEQUATELY OR ACCURATELY CAPTURE THE PROGRESS THIS COUNTRY HAS MADE, BUT THAT SIMPLY ISN'T TRU.

THIS COURSE DOESN'T ONLY TEACH SLAVERY AND RACISM AS SOME MAY BELIEVE, BUT IT EMBARKS UPON THE TELLING OF TREMENDOUS ACHIEVEMENTS TO SOCIETY THAT BLACK AMERICANS HAVE CONTRIBUTED TO OUR COUNTRY. IT IS IMPERATIVE THAT WE ARE MINDFUL AS A PEOPLE THAT THE ONLY WAY TO MEASURE PROGRESS IS TO KNOW WHERE WE STARTED FROM. THE GOOD, THE BAD AND EVEN THE UGLY IS ALL A PART OF OUR PROGRESS IN OUR HISTORY. FINALLY AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS 100% AMERICAN HISTORY. TO IGNORE SLAVERY. OTHER CRITICAL MOVEMENTS WOULD ERASE MOMENTS. EXCUSE ME, MOMENTS WOULD ERASE MONUMENTAL EVENTS LIKE THE EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATION WOULD, WHICH IS AS INSTRUMENTAL TO THE SHAPING OF OUR NATION AS THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE, THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION, AND OUR 19TH AMENDMENT, WHICH GAVE WOMEN THE RIGHT TO VOTE. PLEASE SEE THIS FROM A DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE. I ASK THAT YOU REVERSE THE DECISION TO REMOVE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES FROM OUR CURRICULUM. THANK YOU. HELLO? WAIT ALL RIGHT. HELLO. MY NAME IS BRIAN CRAWFORD. I'M A

[04:45:08]

RISING SENIOR AT ABERDEEN HIGH SCHOOL, AN UNDERCLASSMAN AT HARFORD COMMUNITY COLLEGE, AND ONE OF FEW STUDENTS WHO HAD THE PLEASURE OF STUDYING AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY UNDER PROFESSOR JOHN MOBLEY DURING THE 2023 THROUGH 2024 SCHOOL YEAR. THE INCLUSION OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IN HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS IS NOT MERELY ABOUT ACKNOWLEDGING PAST INJUSTICES AND SUFFERINGS OF AFRICAN AMERICANS, BUT SERVES TO ILLUMINATE THE PAST AND PRESENT OF AMERICA AS A WHOLE AND OUR HISTORY. LONG BEFORE CHATTEL SLAVERY WAS INTRODUCED TO US.

THIS COURSE WAS THOROUGH, ENLIGHTENING, AND FASCINATING FOR ALL BLACK AND NON-BLACK STUDENTS WHO ARE ENROLLED IN MY CLASS CLASSES AT JOPPATOWNE, JOPPATOWNE, AND BEL AIR SCHOOLS AND WILL PROVE TO BE THE SAME FOR THE 90 PLUS STUDENTS WHO WILL HOPEFULLY TAKE IT NEXT YEAR. THE CURRICULUM WAS DESIGNED TO EMPOWER STUDENTS WITH A DEEPER UNDERSTANDING OF SOCIETAL COMPLEXITIES, AND TO INSPIRE AN EVEN GREATER CHANGE IN OUR COUNTRY'S FUTURE.

HOWEVER, WHAT THE COURSE WAS NOT DESIGNED TO DO IS CHERRY PICK THE HISTORY OF OUR NATION. TO QUOTE, PRESENT POSITIVE MESSAGES OF UNITY AND GREAT AMERICAN CONTRIBUTIONS. WE OFFER YOU AP, US HISTORY FOR THAT. THE POSITIVE MESSAGES AND AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES INCLUDE THE CULTURAL, ARTISTIC AND INTELLECTUAL ACHIEVEMENTS OF AFRICAN AMERICANS FROM LITERATURE AND MUSIC TO SCIENCE AND POLITICS. AND WE STUDIED PLENTY OF IT. THE TRUTH IS, AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY IS AN OVERWHELMINGLY POSITIVE, BUT IT ALSO ISN'T SHROUDED IN PATRIOTIC PROPAGANDA TO MAKE AMERICA LOOK BETTER. THAT ISN'T WHAT HISTORY IS. IF IT WERE UP TO ME, AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES WOULDN'T BE A COURSE AT ALL, AS IT WOULD BE WELL INTEGRATED IN THE AP US HISTORY CURRICULUM. BLACK HISTORY IS ALSO AMERICAN HISTORY, AND THE ACHIEVEMENTS OF AFRICAN AMERICANS CONTRIBUTED TO AMERICA'S GREATNESS. SAID BETTER BY THAT, CLARK. BUT IT'S NOT HAVEN ROSEN, A PEER OF MINE, ASKED HER AP, US HISTORY TEACHER IF THEY WOULD LEARN ANYTHING BLACK HISTORY RELATED IN THE COMING WEEKS OF INSTRUCTION, AND HE RESPONDED, NOT YET, NEXT MONTH. THIS EXCHANGE WAS IN THE MIDDLE OF FEBRUARY. I WAS NOT FORCED TO TAKE THE CLASS, NOR WAS ANY OTHER STUDENT. SO I'M CONTINUOUSLY PERPLEXED AS TO WHY THERE'S AN ACTIVE DISCUSSION ABOUT WHETHER IT'S PUSHING A RADICAL AGENDA OR CLOUDING OUR SCHOOLING WITH NEGATIVE INFORMATION. I HAVEN'T SAID THIS AS MUCH AS I COULD. I KNOW EVERYBODY'S READY TO LEAVE.

THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO SHARE MY PERSPECTIVE ON THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE AS A STUDENT, AND I HOPE THIS SPEECH, AND THOSE OF MY PEERS ARE COMPELLING ENOUGH TO ALLOW THE CLASS ACCEPTANCE WITHOUT A CURRICULUM REEXAMINATION. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS SCOTT CROSS, AND I'M A JUST GRADUATED SENIOR FROM BEL AIR HIGH SCHOOL. I HAD THE HONOR OF BEING ONE OF 19 STUDENTS WHO TOOK THE FIRST CLASS OFFERED AT BEL AIR HIGH SCHOOL, TAUGHT BY MR. AUSTIN, AND IT WAS EASILY MY FAVORITE CLASS I'VE EVER TAKEN TO BEGIN AN AP AFRICAN AMERICAN. I LEARNED ABOUT JUAN GARRIDO, AND AN IDEAL WORLD. HE'D BE A HOUSEHOLD NAME. IN REALITY, IT TOOK ME 18 YEARS TO LEARN HIS NAME. THE FIRST BLACK MAN TO STAND ON US SOIL AND A RENOWNED CONQUISTADOR. A CONQUEROR, I'M SURE AT LEAST HALF OF THIS ROOM IS, OR ONCE WAS IN A POSITION SIMILAR TO MINE. HOW MANY PEOPLE HERE BELIEVED THE FIRST BLACK MAN IN THE US TO BE SLAVES? HOW MANY OF US VIEW BLACK AMERICAN HISTORY AS IF IT BEGINS WITH SUFFERING? WHEN WE'RE TAUGHT THAT STORIES BEGIN WITH PAIN, IT'S IMPOSSIBLE NOT TO FIXATE ON THE THREADS OF STRIFE WOVEN THROUGHOUT THEM, RATHER THAN ANY SEMBLANCE OF THEIR SUCCESSES. FOR MINORITIES EVERYWHERE, IT'S THIS PAIN THAT DEFINED HISTORY FOR YEARS. HISTORY CLASS BECOMES CHARACTERIZED BY ANXIETY. IT BECOMES SNICKERS BEHIND HANDS AS SLURS ARE TOSSED AROUND IN NOVELS, HEADS WHIPPING AROUND TO FACE YOU AT THE SLIGHTEST MENTION OF SLAVERY BEING BOMBARDED WITH IMAGES OF TORN AND TATTERED BLACK AMERICANS DURING DOCUMENTARIES, AND FEELING PARTICULARLY FRAGILE AS YOU'RE UPSET AND OTHERS DOZE OFF IN THE BACK OF THE ROOM. AP AFRICAN AMERICAN REVERSED THIS NARRATIVE FOR THE FIRST TIME. WE DIDN'T BEGIN WITH SLAVERY. WE BEGIN WITH GREATNESS. DID YOU KNOW THERE WERE GREAT KINGDOMS IN AFRICA, WEALTHY KINGS AND GREAT FEATS OF ARCHITECTURE? AND THEY ALL EXISTED BEFORE CHAINS. DID YOU KNOW THAT BEFORE BLACK WALL STREET BURNED, IT PROSPERED? DID YOU KNOW THAT MUSIC IN THE BLACK COMMUNITY DIDN'T BEGIN WITH SLAVE HYMNS, BUT INSTEAD STRETCHES FROM ANCIENT BANJO PLAYING TO HEALING SPIRITUALS? DID YOU KNOW THAT BLACK AMERICANS ARE ONLY DEFINED BY THEIR SUFFERING? FOR AS LONG AS WE MAKE THAT OUT TO BE ALL THERE IS. THE FIRST BLACK MAN WAS NOT A SLAVE. THE FIRST BLACK WOMAN EXISTS OUTSIDE OF BLACK AND WHITE, WANTED PORTRAITS. THERE IS BLACK SUCCESS, BLACK JOY, AND CENTURIES WORTH OF BLACK GREATNESS. AND ALL OF IT DESERVES TO BE TAUGHT. IT'S MY BELIEF THAT WE MIRROR WHAT WE LEARN IF WE NEVER LEARN OF SUCCESS, HOW WILL WE EVER PURSUE IT? AFTER THE FIRST FEW LESSONS OF AP AFRICAN AMERICAN, OUR CLASS BECAME MORE COMFORTABLE. WE STARTED TO HAVE REAL CONVERSATIONS, GENUINE CONVERSATIONS. AND DO YOU KNOW HOW HARD IT IS TO HAVE A REAL CONVERSATION WITH A BUNCH OF HIGH SCHOOLERS? IT'S HARD, BUT IT HAPPENED EVERY SINGLE DAY.

[04:50:04]

STUDENTS THAT TYPICALLY SHIED AWAY FROM AP CLASSES WERE EVEN SUDDENLY EAGER TO SHARE. WE READ EACH OTHER POEMS, ANALYZED LYRICS OF OUR FAVORITE SONGS, AND DEBATED MODERN POLITICS SO RESPECTFULLY. IT FELT LIKE THE TWILIGHT ZONE. THE FACT WAS THAT THESE VIBRANT, BRILLIANT MINDS WERE ALWAYS AT OUR SCHOOL AND ALWAYS WILL BE. HOW COULD WE DEPRIVE THEM OF SUCH AN AMAZING SPACE TO LEARN IN? WHEN YOU ASK THE QUESTION OF HOW THIS CLASS CAN BENEFIT ANYONE BESIDES AFRICAN AMERICANS, THE ANSWER IS OBVIOUS. AP AFRICAN AMERICAN DOES WHAT MANY COURSES FAIL TO DO. IT VETS, DIGS DEEPER AND CONNECTS. IT STRETCHES TWINE BETWEEN THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT AND THE WOMEN'S SUFFRAGE MOVEMENT. IT AMPLIFIES AND UPLIFTS THRIVING HISPANIC CULTURES, AND IT HIGHLIGHTS 100 YEAR OLD RELATIONSHIPS AND ALLIANCES BETWEEN INDIGENOUS AMERICANS AND AFRICAN AMERICANS. MOST IMPORTANTLY, IT TEACHES THE SIGNIFICANCE OF PERSEVERANCE THROUGH LIFE, VIBRANCE, AND CREATION RATHER THAN VIOLENCE. IT'S HARD TO FIGHT FOR WHAT MATTERS TO YOU, BUT IT'S HARDER, SO, SO MUCH HARDER TO TAKE THE ROTTEN HAND YOU'VE BEEN DEALT WITH AND CREATE ART, MUSIC, LANGUAGE AND CULTURE. REGARDLESS OF RACE. THE WORLD DOESN'T NEED MORE VIOLENCE OR PAIN. IT NEEDS STORIES OF HOPE, PERSEVERANCE, AND SUCCESS. THESE AREN'T JUST STORIES OF BLACK HISTORY. THEY'RE STORIES OF RESILIENCE AND STRENGTH. STORIES WE CAN ALL STAND TO LEARN FROM. WE ALL DESERVE TO LEARN FROM FROM A FROM A CLASSROOM AUDIENCE ABOUT PEOPLE OF ALL RACES SUCCEEDING IN FINDING JOY AND IMBUING THE WORLD WITH LIFE TO FAIL AT ACKNOWLEDGING THIS NOW AND AS HUNDREDS OF SCHOOLS JOIN THE MOVEMENT, WITHOUT US WILL CONDEMN US TO THE WORST OF ALL FATES BEING LEFT IN THE PAST. THANK YOU. SO I REALLY CAN'T SAY MUCH MORE BEYOND THAT. WE PULLED OUR STUDENTS DURING THE SCHOOL YEAR TO GET THERE, OR AT THE TAIL END OF THE SCHOOL YEAR TO GET THEIR IMPRESSIONS. AND YOU HAVE HAD THIS DATA BEFORE YOU.

AND SO IN HONOR OF OUR TIME, I WILL CLICK THROUGH BUT OVERWHELMINGLY POSITIVE FEEDBACK FROM OUR STUDENTS, INCLUDING 87% WHO EITHER SAID THEY AGREED OR STRONGLY AGREED THAT THEY WOULD BE LIKELY TO RECOMMEND THIS COURSE TO OTHER STUDENTS AND THERE ALSO WERE BROAD FEEDBACK THAT WAS OPEN ENDED. AND YOU'VE HAD THIS DATA BEFORE YOU. SO FOR THE SAKE OF TIME, I'M GOING TO CLICK THROUGH AND GET TO OUR FEEDBACK FROM TEACHERS. THANK YOU.

I COULD GO AHEAD AND START IF YOU WANT. BEAUTIFUL. MR. AUSTIN. THANK YOU, AND I JUST SKY AND THE REST OF YOU STUDENTS. WOW. I'M JUST FLOORED, HUMBLED AND AMAZING, I, YOU KNOW, I THINK I THINK I'VE JUST SORT OF THE STORY OF MONOLITH, BUT I, I KIND OF HAD THE STATEMENT A LITTLE WHILE AGO AND STILL, LIKE, RESONATES AND MEANS SOMETHING, BUT I JUST THINK OF HISTORY STORIES A REMARKABLE INDIVIDUALS DEMONSTRATING COURAGE, RESILIENCE, TRIUMPH OVER TRAGEDY, PERSEVERANCE, YOU KNOW, FACING CHALLENGES, THE STRUGGLES, THE TIME AND TIME AGAIN, WE THINK ABOUT HISTORY. AND EVERY SOCIETY, WE LOOK TO OUR PAST, WE LOOK TO THESE STORIES OF GREAT INDIVIDUALS, THE CONTRIBUTIONS THAT THEY MAKE. I THINK ABOUT MY, YOU KNOW, HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE LIKE, LOOKED SORT OF PATRIOT PROGRAMS. MY STUDENTS HAVE BEEN INVOLVED IN THE PATRIOT PROGRAMS, FAMILIES THAT LIKE TO LOOK FOR ANCESTRY.COM AND GENEALOGY STUDIES AND THINGS LIKE THAT. AND DEMONSTRATING A DESIRE TO EXPLORE THAT PAST, FIND THAT PERSONAL CONNECTION TO THOSE EVENTS, INDIVIDUALS THAT SHAPED WHO WE ARE TODAY, AND I THINK FOR FAR TOO LONG, THE HISTORY OF AFRICAN AMERICANS, IN OUR EXPERIENCE, HAS EITHER BEEN LIMITED, SOMETIMES JUST OUTRIGHT DENIED OR MARGINALIZED TO JUST DISCUSSIONS OF TOPICS AND NOT TAKING AWAY ANY OF THE IMPORTANCE OF CIVIL WAR, CIVIL RIGHTS, THE TRANSATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE. BUT AS MANY OF THE STUDENTS SAID TONIGHT, SO MANY OF THE PEOPLE WHO SPOKE ON BEHALF OF THIS COURSE, IT'S SO MUCH RICHER THAN THAT, SO MUCH RICHER THAN THAT, 20 YEAR TEACHER MASTER'S DEGREE IN AMERICAN HISTORY. I WAS SHOCKED BY HOW MUCH I DID NOT KNOW ABOUT THE HISTORY OF AFRICA. THE CONTINENT OF AFRICA, THE COMPLEX, DIVERSE SOCIETIES, THE KINGDOMS, THE CONTRIBUTIONS MAD. I LEARNED SO MUCH. ABSOLUTELY. SO MUCH, SHOCKED BY THE STORIES THAT I DID NOT KNOW. THE STRUGGLES, THE CHALLENGES. EXTRAORDINARY ACCOMPLISHMENTS, OVER THE PAST 400 YEARS AND LEARNED SO MUCH FROM MY STUDENTS THROUGHOUT THE YEAR. IT WAS JUST IT WAS ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT, AMAZING. AND I JUST THINK THAT, YOU KNOW, THIS COURSE IS SO IMPORTANT. IT EMPOWERS THE STUDENTS, YOU KNOW, THAT THAT IDEA OF A MONOLITH TO DISPEL THE MYTH OF JUST THIS SORT OF ONE STORY FITS ALL COULDN'T BE FURTHER FROM THE TRUTH FOR A COURSE LIKE THIS. AND I, YOU KNOW, JUST IMPLORE YOU TO REALLY RECONSIDER, YOU KNOW, THE VOTE TONIGHT BECAUSE THIS THIS COURSE IS EXTREMELY IMPORTANT FOR THE STUDENTS NOW AND THE STUDENTS IN THE FUTURE. LET ME ALSO, PIGGYBACK TO MANY THINGS THAT THE STUDENTS HAVE SAID, WHICH IS FOR ME, PARTICULARLY IN MY CLASS, IS THAT I'M I'M A PROPONENT OF GIVING CHILDREN THE

[04:55:05]

ABILITY TO EXPRESS THEMSELVES, TO BE ABLE TO LEARN NOT ONLY JUST THE HISTORY ITSELF, BUT TO SEE THEMSELVES IN THAT HISTORY, TO BE ABLE TO ARTICULATE FOR THEMSELVES MANY OF THE ISSUES THAT HAVE PLAGUED THE AFRICAN AMERICAN COMMUNITY, AND ALSO TO BE ABLE TO LEARN SOMETHING NEW ABOUT THEMSELVES WITHIN THAT CONTEXT. FOR ME, IT'S VERY SIMPLE. IT'S GIVING THEM THE INFORMATION, BUT ALSO TO GIVING THEM THE RIGHT TOOLS TO USE THAT INFORMATION. ONE OF THE THINGS, AS I SHARED IN THE MEETINGS BEFORE, AND I DON'T LIKE TO SAY MY AGE, BUT AT ONE TIME I CAN REMEMBER THERE WAS ONLY THREE CHANNELS ON ON THE TV, AND THE TV HAD THE NERVE TO TURN OFF ABOUT 2 A.M. IN THE MORNING. HAD THE DIGNITY TO SHUT OFF AND THEN EARLY IN THE MORNING COME BACK ON. BUT NOW WE DON'T HAVE THAT LUXURY. TELEVISION IS ON 24 HOURS, MULTIPLE CHANNELS, AND MY FEAR HAS ALWAYS BEEN WITH ALL THESE DIFFERENT VOICES THAT CHILDREN ARE HEARING, HOW CAN THEY DECIPHER THE REAL FROM THE FAKE? SO FOR ME, IT'S IMPORTANT TO BE THAT FACILITATOR THAT TRUE FACILITATOR OF LEARNING TO GIVE THEM THE ACCESS OF THIS INFORMATION AND NOT TELL THEM HOW TO THINK AND NOT WHAT TO THINK, BUT TO SHOW THEM THE TOOLS OF HOW TO THINK. AND MY JOB IS NEVER TO INDOCTRINATE. I DON'T HAVE THE TIME NOR THE INCLINATION TO INDOCTRINATE ANY STUDENT THAT COMES IN MY ROOM. I WANT THEM TO LEAVE WITH A PERSPECTIVE THAT IS GENUINELY THEIRS, BUT ALSO TO CAREFULLY BEING RESPONSIBLE WITH THE INFORMATION THAT IS BEING GIVEN.

IT'S FUNNY, I HAD THIS IDEA OF WHAT I WAS GOING TO SAY, AND THEN IT'S BEEN A LONG NIGHT.

IT'S WAY PAST MY BEDTIME, AND SO MANY THINGS HAVE JUST HIT ME DIFFERENTLY. THERE'S PROBABLY TWO, ONLY TWO OTHER PEOPLE THAT KNOW THIS IN THIS ROOM. ONE. CONGRATULATIONS, MR. SUZUKI, FOR, WELL, 30 PLUS YEARS AGO, I WAS YOU. 30 PLUS YEARS AGO, I WAS SITTING UP THERE AND LET ME SAY, FIRST OF ALL, YOU DID AN AMAZING JOB EARLIER. AND DO NOT BE AFRAID TO EXPRESS YOUR VOICE.

IT MATTERS. IT WAS. I KNOW THERE WAS. TALK ABOUT HOW HARD WE WORK. IT IS HARD WORK. BACK THEN WE ONLY HAD BINDERS. SO BE THANKFUL THAT YOU HAVE COMPUTER. I HAD BINDERS ON TOP OF BINDERS, BUT I WAS AS I WAS LISTENING TO THE YOUNG WOMEN TALK, I REMEMBER BEING THEM. AND IN MIDDLE SCHOOL, HOW DESPERATE I LOVE SOCIAL SCIENCE, BUT HOW THINGS NEVER SOUNDED PROPERLY TO ME. IT NEVER FELT RIGHT AND I WAS SO DESPERATE FOR THE INFORMATION AND RESOURCES THAT I WOULD SOMETIMES HEAR IN, LIKE LITTLE RAP SONGS. AND I WOULD GO OUT AND LOOK IT UP AND THERE'S NO INTERNET TO GO TO, AND YOU FIND A BOOK AND YOU READ THE BOOK FROM COVER TO COVER, AND THEN FINALLY I GOT TO TAKE A HALF CREDIT OF AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. AND MR. MELVIN JOHNSON AT JOPPATOWNE HIGH SCHOOL, WHERE I'M LUCKY ENOUGH TO TEACH NOW. AND I REMEMBER READING THAT BOOK FROM COVER TO COVER AND HOW IMPORTANT IT WAS TO ME. AND IT'S LIKE A HAJJ. MALIK EL-SHABAZZ SAYS. YOU CAN'T HATE THE ROOTS OF THE TREE. AND NOT HATE THE TREE ITSELF. AND THIS GIVING JUST EXPOSING CHILDREN TO THIS, I THINK, IS SO IMPORTANT AND WHAT MAKES IT. AND I'VE TAUGHT THIS CLASS FOR ALMOST 20 YEARS. I'VE TAUGHT IT AT THE COMMUNITY COLLEGE LEVEL, BUT WHAT MAKES THE AP CLASS SO SPECIAL IS IT'S BEEN HARD FOR ME TO GET STUDENTS TO TAKE THE CLASS, BECAUSE WHAT THEY KNOW IS AND SOMETIMES STUDENTS WILL DROP IN, THEY HEAR THINGS, THEY SEE THINGS LIKE, OH, I WISH I WOULD HAVE SIGNED UP. AND I SAID, I TOLD YOU YOU SHOULD HAVE SIGNED UP. BUT THEIR UNDERSTANDING WAS SLAVERY, SOME DANCING DURING THE HARLEM RENAISSANCE OR ROSA PARKS HAD TO SEEK DOCTOR KING OBAMA. AND I WAS LIKE, NO, THERE'S SO MUCH MORE TO IT THAN THAT. AND PART OF WHAT THE AP DOES, IT BRINGS MORE STUDENTS IN BECAUSE AP HAS THAT WEIGHT AND THAT PROMISE AND SO IT'S OPENED IT UP TO A WHOLE NEW SET OF STUDENTS THAT WOULDN'T NECESSARILY TAKE THE CLASS. SO I DON'T KNOW. THESE BEAUTIFUL YOUNG PEOPLE MADE ME REFLECT ON MY CHILDHOOD. AND I THINK I THANK YOU GUYS FOR THAT. SO IN ADDITION TO OUR TEACHER PERSPECTIVE, WE DO HAVE MR. LEVITT HERE TO OFFER THE ADMINISTRATOR PERSPECTIVE. I THINK, YOU KNOW, JUST SOME OF THE INFORMATION THAT YOU'RE HEARING TONIGHT, JUST FROM MY PERSPECTIVE, YOU KNOW, AS A BUILDING ADMINISTRATOR, ONE OF OUR RESPONSIBILITIES TO MAKE SURE IS TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE PROVIDING OPTIONS AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR OUR STUDENTS FOR FUTURE SUCCESS. AND THIS COURSE DEFINITELY LEADS INTO THAT. YOU KNOW, AS YOU LOOK AT SOME OF THE COURSES THAT WE DO TEACH, YOU KNOW, WE TEACH BIOLOGY, WE TEACH PHYSICS, WE TEACH, YOU KNOW, UNITED STATES HISTORY, WE TEACH GOVERNMENT, BUT WE ALSO TEACH AP US HISTORY. WE ALSO TEACH AP PHYSICS, AP BIOLOGY, AP CHEMISTRY FOR THAT POSITION, MEMBER OF RIP, SO IT'S VERY IMPORTANT FOR US AT THE

[05:00:07]

SCHOOL LEVEL. TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE THOSE OPTIONS. TO OUR STUDENTS, YOU HEARD SOME OF THE STUDENTS IN OUR TEACHERS HERE JUST TALKING ABOUT, YOU KNOW, STUDENTS TAKING THIS COURSE THAT MAYBE WOULD HAVE NEVER TAKEN AN AP COURSE BEFORE. AND IT'S 100% TRUE, LAST YEAR WE HAD 46, JUST 46% OF THE STUDENTS IN, IN THE THREE SCHOOLS THAT WERE TAKING AP AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY. IT WAS THE FIRST AP COURSE, THIS YEAR, WELL, THIS UPCOMING YEAR, IN TERMS OF STUDENTS THAT HAVE SIGNED UP FOR THE COURSE, IT'S UP TO 39% OF STUDENTS THAT WILL BE THEIR FIRST AP COURSE. SO IT'S A GREAT INTRODUCTION. IT'S A GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO CHALLENGE THE STUDENTS. IF YOU KNOW, IT'S FINALLY MAYBE A COURSE THAT THEY'RE ACTUALLY INTERESTED IN. THE CONTENT. SO I KNOW FROM, AGAIN, FROM THE BUILDING PERSPECTIVE AS ADMINISTRATOR, THESE ARE THE TYPES OF NEW OPPORTUNITIES THAT THAT WE LOVE BEING ABLE TO OFFER TO OUR KIDS. WE WANT THEM TO DRIVE, YOU KNOW, THE COURSES THAT WE TEACH. SO NEXT SCHOOL YEAR, 200 STUDENTS HAD ACTUALLY REQUESTED THE COURSE OF THOSE 200 STUDENTS, NOT EVERY SCHOOL WAS ABLE TO OFFER IT. AND IN FACT, THREE SCHOOLS DIDN'T EVEN ALLOW STUDENTS TO CHOOSE IT AS AN OPTION BECAUSE OF THEIR STAFFING AND LIMITED STAFFING. IT JUST WASN'T FEASIBLE TO EVEN OFFER IT AS AN OPTION. BUT OF THE SCHOOLS THAT DID OFFER IT, 200 STUDENTS SELECTED IT AND EVENTUALLY WE GOT TO SEVEN SCHEDULED SECTIONS OF THIS COURSE. NOW, WE DO KNOW THAT THERE WERE CONCERNS ABOUT THE COURSE, AND SO WE WANTED TO ADDRESS THEM DIRECTLY, ONE OF THE BIGGEST CONCERNS WAS ABOUT ENSURING THAT WE'RE NOT TEACHING THIS IDEA OF OPPRESSOR VERSUS OPPRESSED OR PERPETUATING A NARRATIVE OF VICTIMHOOD AND ENSURING THAT THE RESOURCES THAT WE ARE PROVIDING AND THE PERSPECTIVES THAT WE ARE OFFERING OUR STUDENTS ARE BALANCED. SO THE FIRST THING TO REALLY CONSIDER IS THAT THIS COURSE, IN AND OF ITSELF, IS MEANT TO BALANCE WHAT IS ALREADY UNBALANCED. AS YOU HEARD OUR STUDENTS SAY, BOTH IN PUBLIC COMMENT AND OUR STUDENTS THAT WE BROUGHT HERE WITH US TODAY, OUR COURSES DO NOT HAVE A BALANCED PERSPECTIVE IN THEM. AP, US HISTORY, AP WORLD HISTORY. THEY OFFER A SKEWED PERSPECTIVE OF HISTORY. WE OFFER AP EUROPEAN HISTORY AND HAVE FOR YEARS. AND SO THIS COURSE IN AND OF ITSELF WAS SEEKING TO PROVIDE SOME OF THAT BALANCE THAT WAS ALREADY LACKING. HOWEVER, WHEN WE GET DOWN TO THE GRANULAR LEVEL OF WHAT THIS COURSE LOOKS LIKE AND ENSURING THAT WE PROVIDE BALANCED PERSPECTIVES, AND ESPECIALLY THAT WE ARE NOT TEACHING OPPRESSOR VERSUS OPPRESSED OR PERPETUATING A NARRATIVE OF VICTIMHOOD, OUR TEACHERS WILL SHARE IN A MOMENT JUST WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE IN THEIR CLASSROOMS. BUT AS A BROAD OVERVIEW, WE PROVIDE OUR TEACHERS WITH A RUBRIC THAT THEY USE TO ENSURE THAT THEY ARE MEETING THE EXPECTATIONS OF WHAT WE AND HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS BELIEVE MAKES A HIGH QUALITY EDUCATION. AND WE USE THE DANIELSON FRAMEWORK TO DO THAT. DOMAIN TWO, IN PARTICULAR, ENSURES THAT ALL STUDENTS FEEL VALUED, SAFE AND COMFORTABLE. THAT'S DIRECTLY OUT OF THE DANIELSON LANGUAGE CARING INTERACTIONS AMONG TEACHERS AND STUDENTS ARE THE HALLMARK OF COMPONENT TWO, WHICH IS CREATING AN ENVIRONMENT OF RESPECTFUL RAPPORT AND POSITIVE INTERACTIONS AMONG STUDENTS AND BETWEEN TEACHER AND STUDENTS ARE MUTUALLY SUPPORTIVE AND CREATE AN EMOTIONALLY HEALTHY SCHOOL ENVIRONMENT. SO BEFORE I REALLY GET INTO THE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN, I WANTED TO TURN IT OVER TO THESE GENTLEMEN WHO ARE IN SCHOOLS EACH AND EVERY DAY. I SPEND ABOUT 60% OF MY CALENDAR IS ACTUALLY SCHEDULED IN SCHOOLS, BUT THESE GENTLEMEN LIVE AT EVERY SINGLE DAY. AND SO I WANTED TO TURN IT OVER TO THEM TO TALK DIRECTLY ABOUT WHAT THAT MEANS IN THEIR CLASSROOMS AND IN THEIR SCHOOL BUILDING. ANDY, DO YOU WANT TO GO? YEAH, I CAN SO, I WAS GOING TO SAY, YOU KNOW, REGARDLESS OF WHAT TEAM OR CLASS I'VE TAUGHT OVER THE YEARS, AND I'VE TAUGHT AP US HISTORY, I TAUGHT AP GOVERNMENT, AND THERE ARE CONTROVERSIAL TOPICS, RIGHT? I MEAN, WE'RE IN SOCIAL SCIENCE. WE LIVE IN A REPUBLIC. WE HAVE PEOPLE THAT ARE VYING FOR POWER, BUT LET ME LET ME TAKE A STEP BACK. REGARDLESS OF WHAT COURSE I'M TEACHING, IT'S, YOU KNOW, KIND OF GOING WITH THE FRAMEWORK. IT'S ALL ABOUT, YOU KNOW, MAKING THE STUDENTS FEEL COMFORTABLE, EMPOWERED, ABILITY TO SPEAK THEIR VOICE, BE HEARD, RESPECT, MUTUAL RESPECT FOR OTHER STUDENTS, OPPOSING VIEWPOINTS IN DIFFERENT VOICES. AND LISTEN AND REALLY LISTEN, AND ARTICULATE WHAT THEY THINK ABOUT THINGS. SO THAT'S, YOU KNOW, PART OF, I THINK WHAT WE DO AS TEACHERS, REGARDLESS OF WHAT CLASSES WE TEACH, BUT THERE ARE, YOU KNOW, THERE'S CONTROVERSIAL TOPICS. THERE'S COMPLEX ISSUES. THAT'S DEMOCRACY. WE DON'T LIVE IN A AUTHORITARIAN STATE. WE DON'T INDOCTRINATE, WE ALLOW THE PROLIFERATION OF DIFFERENT IDEAS, AND, YOU KNOW, AS YOU KNOW, MISS FINE WAS JUST SAYING, WE HAVE IN THE KID, WE HAVE, YOU KNOW, THE SORT WE HAVE THE ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE. WE HAVE THE OBJECTIVES TO ADDRESS. WE HAVE THE SOURCES TO CONVEY, ALLOW THE STUDENTS TO TEACH THEM THE TOOLS TO CRITICALLY THINK, LOOK AT POINT OF VIEW, LOOK AT CAUSATION, CONTEXTUALIZATION. TO UNDERSTAND THESE THINGS AND THESE DEVELOPMENTS. AND YOU KNOW HOW INDIVIDUALS HAVE SHAPED, GOOD ACTORS, BAD ACTORS, YOU

[05:05:01]

KNOW, SOME A LITTLE BIT MORE CONTROVERSIAL, COMPLEX THAN OTHERS. BUT, BUT THERE'S NO NOTION OF TRUE JUST SORT OF OPPRESSED OPPRESSOR VICTIMHOOD. IT'S UNDERSTANDING JUST HOW EVENTS HAVE BEEN SHAPED. IT'S TEACHING HISTORY. MR. DO YOU WANT TO TALK ABOUT THAT FROM THE BUILDING ADMINISTRATOR PERSPECTIVE? I'VE HAD THE OPPORTUNITY OVER THE YEARS TO BE ABLE TO WATCH MR. AUSTIN AND MR. MOBLEY IN ACTION, AS AN ADMINISTRATOR AND AS MR. AUSTIN JUST PRESENTED. AND, MR. MOBLEY, I HAVEN'T HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO SEE MR. HARRIS TEACH, BUT, THEY DO AN INCREDIBLE JOB OF PRESENTING. AND, YOU KNOW, JUST GIVING THAT FAIR, FACTUAL INFORMATION AND GETTING THE KIDS TO, AGAIN, YOU KNOW, ENGAGE WITH EACH OTHER AND LEARN FROM EACH OTHER AND DIG DEEPER IN IT AND GET INTO THE CRITICAL THINKING, I MEAN, THAT'S AGAIN, THEY DO AN AWESOME JOB WITH IT. I LUCKILY, I'VE BEEN LUCKILY I'VE BEEN ABLE TO BE WITNESS TO IT. SO IN ADDITION TO WHAT WE KNOW, OUR TEACHERS ALWAYS ARE DOING ON A DAILY BASIS, ANYTIME WE HAVE A NEW COURSE, WE ARE GOING TO HAVE AN IMPLEMENTATION AND EVALUATION PLAN TO ENSURE THAT WHAT WE ARE IMPLEMENTING IS DONE WITH FIDELITY AND THAT WE'RE RESPONSIVE TO THE DATA THAT WE ARE GATHERING FROM THAT IMPLEMENTATION, SO THAT WE ARE ALWAYS PROVIDING A BETTER RESOURCE AND A BETTER EXPERIENCE FOR OUR STUDENTS EVERY DAY. AND SO WHEN WE THINK ABOUT WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE IN THIS PARTICULAR COURSE, IT WOULD BE PD DURING LAUNCH WEEK, PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT DURING LAUNCH WEEK THAT WOULD FOCUS ON CLASSROOM NORMS AND GUIDELINES FOR THE TEACHERS. THAT WOULD BE TEACHING THIS COURSE. THAT IS PART OF WHAT WE ALWAYS TALK ABOUT WITH OUR TEACHERS. THEY'LL TELL YOU MASLOW'S BEFORE BLOOMS. I TELL THEM EVERY TIME, BECAUSE THAT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO MAKE SURE THAT OUR STUDENTS FEEL SAFE AND A SENSE OF BELONGING BEFORE WE CAN GET TO ANY TYPE OF CRITICAL THINKING. ADDITIONALLY, WE HAVE PLANS FOR FACILITATED COLLABORATIVE PLANNING WITH OUR APA TEACHERS, AND WHAT THAT WOULD LOOK LIKE IS USING SOME OF OUR SUB MONEY TO HAVE TEACHERS COME TOGETHER DURING THE SCHOOL DAY AND PROVIDE THEM WITH RESOURCES AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT SO THAT THEY CAN COLLABORATE, BECAUSE THESE ARE THE VOICES THAT REALLY MATTER. OUR TEACHERS ARE THE EXPERTS, AND THEY KNOW WHAT THEIR INDIVIDUAL STUDENTS AND THEIR CLASSROOMS NEED AND CAN BE RESPONSIVE TO IT. SO WE'RE ALWAYS BETTER TOGETHER AND PUTTING THESE TEACHERS IN A ROOM TOGETHER AND ALLOWING THEM THE OPPORTUNITY TO DISCUSS RESOURCE IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS, THINKING ABOUT IDENTIFICATION OF DO WE NEED A BALANCE OF PERSPECTIVES? WHERE ARE WE LACKING IN THAT PERSPECTIVE? WHERE CAN WE BRING IN MORE, DIFFERENT OR MORE PERSPECTIVES AND EVALUATING TO ENSURE THAT WE ARE PROVIDING BALANCE IN THE STORIES THAT WE ARE TELLING? ADDITIONALLY ADMINISTRATORS AND PEOPLE IN MY OFFICE ARE ALWAYS REGULARLY IN CLASSROOMS, AND SO PART OF THIS IMPLEMENTATION PLAN IS VISITING THESE CLASSROOMS THROUGH WALKTHROUGHS, BOTH ANNOUNCED AND UNANNOUNCED, AND COLLABORATING WITH OUR BUILDING ADMINISTRATORS TO DO FORMAL OBSERVATIONS DURING THE APA BLOCK. SO THAT'S SOMETHING THAT ADMINISTRATORS DO. AND THAT'S SOMETHING THAT MY OFFICE PROVIDES AS WELL. ADDITIONALLY, WE WOULD BE GATHERING SURVEY FEEDBACK FROM STUDENTS, TEACHERS AND PARENTS TO BE ABLE TO REFLECT ON THE WAYS THAT WE ARE IMPLEMENTING THIS COURSE AND THE WAYS THAT WE CAN IMPROVE IT THROUGHOUT THE COURSE OF THE YEAR THROUGH THAT PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT. DURING COLLABORATIVE PLANNING TIME. AND LASTLY, WE WOULD BE ASKING FOR OUR TEACHERS TO PROVIDE ARTIFACTS OF WHAT THE STUDENTS ARE DOING SO THAT WE IN MY OFFICE CAN EVALUATE THAT AND PROVIDE ADDITIONAL FEEDBACK TO TEACHERS OF WHERE WE CAN DO BETTER TO SUPPORT TEACHERS, BUT ALWAYS, ALWAYS IN THE SOCIAL SCIENCES OR SOCIAL STUDIES, WE ARE FOCUSING ON MULTIPLE PERSPECTIVES AND AN ANALYSIS OR EVALUATION OF THAT. I SAY THE WORD PERSPECTIVE AD NAUSEAM UNTIL EVERYBODY IS ROLLING THEIR EYES AT ME, BUT IT IS THE LENS THROUGH WHICH WE VIEW THIS DISCIPLINE, AND IT IS PART OF THE SKILLS THAT ARE REQUIRED BY COLLEGE BOARD. ADDITIONALLY SOME BOARD MEMBERS HAVE BROUGHT UP IN PUBLIC, AS WELL AS BRINGING THEM TO ME THROUGH EMAILS, SPECIFIC TOPICS THAT ARE NOT BEING ADDRESSED IN THE SID THAT THEY WOULD LIKE TO SEE INCLUDED. NOW, WE'VE HAD DISCUSSIONS IN PRIVATE ABOUT THIS, ABOUT THE FACT THAT WE CANNOT SUBTRACT, BUT WE CERTAINLY CAN ADD IN PLACES. BUT WE NEED TO BE VERY JUDICIOUS IN HOW WE DO THAT, BECAUSE WE HAVE SUCH A RIGOROUS AND FAST PACED COURSE. AND SO THERE ARE OPPORTUNITIES TO EVALUATE THROUGH THAT FACILITATED COLLABORATIVE PLANNING TIME, WAYS THAT WE CAN INCLUDE THOSE DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES AND TOPICS THAT ALIGN TO THE ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE, BUT ARE NOT EXPLICITLY CALLED OUT. BUT ADDITIONALLY, THAT INDIVIDUAL STUDENT PROJECT IS AN OPPORTUNITY. IT IS REQUIRED COMPONENT WHERE STUDENTS HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO CHOOSE AND EXAMINE A TOPIC OF THEIR CHOICE ON ANY THEME OR ISSUE OR DEVELOPMENT IN THE FIELD OF AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. AND AS MR. MOBLEY MENTIONED, THEY HAVE TO PROVIDE AN EIGHT MINUTE PRESENTATION IN ORAL DEFENSE. AND STUDENTS HAVE TO IDENTIFY, EXPLORE AND ANALYZE FOUR RELATED SOURCES OF THEIR CHOOSING ON THEIR TOPIC. AND LASTLY, THERE IS AS MANY BOARD MEMBERS HAVE ALLUDED TO, AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THAT POST EXAM PERIOD. SO AFTER THE AP EXAM, WHICH I BELIEVE IS MAY 12TH NEXT YEAR, DON'T QUOTE ME ON IT THOUGH, THERE IS AN

[05:10:01]

OPPORTUNITY FOR ABOUT A MONTH OF INSTRUCTION THAT IS ALIGNED TO THE COURSE, BUT IS NOT PART OF THE REQUIRED CONTENT IN THE SID. AND SO BOARD MEMBERS HAD ASKED ME TO DEVELOP THAT, THAT UNIT A LITTLE FURTHER TO GET AN IDEA OF WHAT THAT COULD LOOK LIKE. AND SO HERE ON YOUR SCREEN, YOU SEE SOME OF THE POST EXAM OPTIONS THAT WE WOULD PROVIDE AS A MENU TO TEACHERS. THE FIRST OF WHICH IS A BIOGRAPHY PROJECT, THE ESSENTIAL QUESTION, BECAUSE WE ALWAYS GROUND OUR INQUIRY AND ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS. WHAT FAMOUS AFRICAN AMERICANS SHOULD COLLEGE BOARD ADD AS REQUIRED ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE AND WHY? SO THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR STUDENTS TO CHOOSE A FAMOUS AFRICAN AMERICAN THAT IS NOT DISCUSSED AS REQUIRED CONTENT, AND WILL DO A RESEARCH PROJECT ON THAT PERSON IN ORDER TO DEVELOP SOME TYPE OF PERSUASIVE PROJECT TO CONVINCE COLLEGE BOARD TO ADD THE SUBJECT OF THEIR RESEARCH TO THE SID FOR THE ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE WE WOULD PROVIDE PARAMETERS FOR THAT PROJECT, INCLUDING A RUBRIC THAT WOULD SPECIFY THE ELEMENTS OF THE PROJECT, INCLUDING BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION ON THE PERSON, DETAILS ON THE CONTRIBUTIONS OF THAT PERSON TO THE FIELD OF AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES, AND THEN A PERSUASIVE PIECE OF THE IMPORTANCE OF THAT PERSON. AND WHY THAT PERSON SHOULD BE INCLUDED IN COLLEGE BOARD APA. AND THEY WOULD HAVE THAT. STUDENTS WOULD THEN HAVE THAT OPPORTUNITY TO SHARE THEIR RESEARCH WITH PEERS. SO WE ARE DEEPENING OUR STUDENTS UNDERSTANDING OF THE DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES OF THE AFRICAN AMERICAN COMMUNITY. AND THEN STUDENTS WOULD BE ABLE TO PROVIDE FEEDBACK USING A RUBRIC SO THAT STUDENTS ARE ALWAYS GROWING. ANOTHER PROJECT THAT WE COULD DO DURING THAT POST EXAM PERIOD WOULD BE A MODERN DISCUSSIONS PROJECT, WITH THE ESSENTIAL QUESTION OF HOW TO HISTORICAL ROOTS AND DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES SHAPE CONTEMPORARY ISSUES. SO IN THIS EXPERIENCE, STUDENTS WOULD BE ABLE TO CHOOSE A MODERN DAY TOPIC OR ISSUE AND MANY HAVE BEEN BROUGHT UP IN PUBLIC AS WELL AS BROUGHT TO ME THROUGH EMAILS AND DISCUSSIONS WITH BOARD MEMBERS OF ONGOING SOCIETAL DEBATE AND STUDENTS WOULD BECOME AN EXPERT ON THAT THROUGH RESEARCH TO CREATE AN INFORMATIONAL PRODUCT AND COMMUNICATE THEIR OWN PERSPECTIVE. IF THEY'RE COMFORTABLE. THAT WOULD OBVIOUSLY BE DEPENDENT ON CLASSROOM NORMS AND THE LEVEL OF COMFORT OF STUDENTS, BUT STUDENTS WOULD THEN BE ABLE TO, USING A RUBRIC, DEVELOP A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THAT CONTEMPORARY TOPIC, OR ISSUE A THOROUGH HISTORICAL ANALYSIS OF THE ROOT CAUSES AND CONTRIBUTIONS OF HOW IT LOOKS TODAY. SO WHY IS IT THAT WE HAVE A MODERN DAY ISSUE THAT IS EVEN ONE THAT IS UP FOR DISCUSSION OR DEBATE? STUDENTS WOULD PROVIDE A BALANCED PRESENTATION OF DIFFERENT CONTEMPORARY PERSPECTIVES ON THE ISSUE, AND A THOROUGH ANALYSIS OF THOSE PERSPECTIVES. AND LASTLY, A SUMMARY OF THEIR OWN PERSPECTIVE, IF THEY WOULD SO CHOOSE. OR STUDENTS THAT WOULDN'T FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH THAT WOULD BE GIVEN AN ALTERNATIVE COMPONENT. AND THAT WOULD BE DEPENDENT ON THE NORMS AND STUDENTS CHOICE. THE LAST TWO OPTIONS ARE BOTH DISCUSSION BASED, AND THEY DO FOLLOW THAT SAME ESSENTIAL QUESTION OF HOW THE HISTORICAL ROOTS AND DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES SHAPE CONTEMPORARY ISSUES. SO IN THIS FIRST OF THE TWO DISCUSSION OPTIONS, STUDENTS WOULD HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO ENGAGE IN VERBAL DISCUSSION WHOLE GROUP. SO THE CLASS WOULD VOTE ON A MODERN DAY TOPIC OR ISSUE OF SOCIETAL DEBATE. AND THEN THEY WOULD DO RESEARCH ON THAT AND THEN ENGAGE IN A PHILOSOPHICAL CHAIRS DEBATE PROTOCOL, WHICH IS WHEN THE STUDENTS GET TO TAKE A STAND ON THE ISSUE, THEY LISTEN TO VARIOUS PERSPECTIVES AND HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY IF THEY CHOOSE TO MOVE PHYSICALLY TO REPRESENT THEIR CHANGING PERSPECTIVES. AND LASTLY, A SMALL GROUP DEBATE PROJECT IN WHICH THOSE SAME STUDENTS COULD THEN, IN SMALL GROUPS, CHOOSE A MODERN DAY TOPIC OR ISSUE OF ONGOING SOCIETAL DEBATE, AND THEY WOULD DIVIDE THEMSELVES UP IN THOSE SMALL GROUPS, BECOME EXPERTS, AND THEN USING A DEBATE PROTOCOL, ENGAGE IN AROUND A 15 MINUTE DEBATE WITH THEIR PEERS, AS FROM OTHER GROUPS FORMING THE CLASS, THE, THE AUDIENCE. THE PARAMETERS OF THAT DEBATE WOULD BE ADDRESSED THROUGH A RUBRIC OF COURSE, INCLUDING AN OUTLINE OF THE PROTOCOL FOR THAT DEBATE, INCLUDING EXPECTATIONS FOR CONTENT AND CONDUCT AND CONTENT AND QUALITY EXPECTATIONS. AND THEN THE CLASS WOULD HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO ASK QUESTIONS OF THE TEAM THAT'S DEBATING AND THEN VOTE ON WHICH SIDE WAS MOST PERSUASIVE, AND THEN UTILIZE THAT RUBRIC TO PROVIDE FEEDBACK TO EACH OF THE MEMBERS OF THE TEAM. ANOTHER CONCERN THAT WAS BROUGHT UP WAS ENSURING A BALANCE OF POSITIVE NARRATIVES TOLD IN THE CLASSROOM. AND I'D LIKE MR. AUSTIN TO SPEAK TO THAT. HE DID SUCH AN EXCELLENT JOB OF DOING IT. WHEN WE WERE IN OUR SMALL GROUPS TOGETHER. THANK YOU SO, SO, YOU KNOW, THE COURSE HAS FOUR THEMES, AND ONE OF THEM BEING RESILIENCE AND RESISTANCE.

AND IT'S AGAIN, NOT ENTIRELY UNIQUE TO JUST THE AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE. THIS IS SOMETHING YOU WOULD FIND IN AN AP U.S. HISTORY COURSE. I'M IMAGINING AN AP WORLD HISTORY COURSE, AND WITHOUT A DOUBT, YOU KNOW, AN AP UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT POLITICS COURSE, BUT THROUGHOUT THE FOUR UNITS, AS YOU KNOW, MR. MOBLEY WAS KIND OF DESCRIBING OVERLAPPING OF, EVENTS AND EXAMPLES. IT COVERS THESE THESE SITUATIONS IN WHICH AFRICAN AMERICANS ARE STARTING WITH SORT OF THE AFRICAN DIASPORA, THE TRANSATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE, HAVE BEEN AGENTS OF CHANGE AS INDIVIDUALS, RIGHT? WHETHER IT BE LIKE, YOU KNOW, THE STONO REBELLION OR THE AMISTAD EVENT IN THE 1830S, WHO ENSLAVED INSURRECTIONS, FORMATION OF COMMUNITIES, CHURCH

[05:15:07]

COMMUNITIES, CREATION OF SCHOOL, COVERT, OVERT METHODS TO SORT OF RESIST ENSLAVEMENT, AND ALL OF THESE ARE JUST THROUGHOUT THE FOUR UNITS TO DEMONSTRATE HOW THEY WERE, ESSENTIALLY, AGAIN, TRYING TO BE PARTICIPANTS, IN THE HISTORY OF THE UNITED STATE, AND IT AND IT OVERLAPS ECONOMICS, POLITICS, CULTURE, GENDER GEOGRAPHY, SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS, AND OF COURSE, IT CONTINUES THROUGH FROM, YOU KNOW, THE FIRST UNIT, THE DIASPORA ALL THE WAY UP THROUGH, YOU KNOW, SORT OF THE MODERN ERA, BUT IT'S A COMMON THEME IN THIS COURSE. AND AGAIN, NOT UNIQUE TO REALLY JUST THIS COURSE. IT'S SOMETHING YOU WOULD SEE IN ANY OF THE OTHER SOCIAL SCIENCE COURSES. THE NEXT AREA OF CONCERN WAS WHY WE SHOULD APPROVE THIS COURSE WHEN WE HAVE THAT HOME GROWN ON LEVEL AMERICAN HISTORY COURSE THAT'S ALREADY IN THE COURSE CATALOG.

AND SO I ASKED MR. DOLEVA TO SPEAK TO THAT IN PARTICULAR. EARLIER, I TOUCHED ON QUITE A FEW OF THESE POINTS, BUT WHEN I TALKED ALSO ABOUT, YOU KNOW, OUR RESPONSIBILITY TO, TO GIVE OPTIONS AND OPPORTUNITIES TO THE STUDENTS, ONE OF THE POINTS THERE IS THE OPPORTUNITY TO EARN COLLEGE CREDIT, WHICH TIES RIGHT INTO YOU KNOW, BLUEPRINT REQUIREMENTS AND AP PATHWAYS. I DON'T KNOW THE DATA FOR THE ENTIRE COUNTY. I CAN AND I'M SURE MOST OF THE SCHOOLS WILL MIRROR WHAT WE HAD. I KNOW OUR GRADUATING CLASS LAST YEAR, WE HAD JUST OVER 35% OF THE GRADUATING CLASS THAT PASSED AT LEAST ONE AP EXAM, EARNING THEM COLLEGE CREDIT. THAT NUMBER IS ONLY GOING TO GO UP AS WE CAN AGAIN OFFER MORE OPPORTUNITIES OF COURSE, LIKE THIS, OTHERWISE, LIKE I SAID, I'VE KIND OF ALREADY HIT ALONG MANY OF THESE POINTS. IN THE EARLIER INFORMATION I GAVE, I WILL CELEBRATE BEFORE I CLICK ON IN THE NEXT ONE THAT ALL OF THE STUDENTS THAT TOOK THE AP EXAM FOR THIS COURSE GOT A THREE OR BETTER THIS PAST YEAR. YEAH OBVIOUSLY THERE WERE SOME CONCERNS ABOUT THE NEGATIVE PORTRAYAL OF POLICE THAT WAS SEEN IN THE CID AS REPRESENTED BY THE BOARD. SO I'D LIKE MR. MOBLEY AND MR. HARRIS TO ADDRESS THAT, POLICING IS INCREDIBLY COMPLICATED WHEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT AFRICAN AMERICAN HISTORY OR AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. AND WE DO COVER POLICING FROM THE FIRST INTRODUCTION TO THE END.

AND THE FIRST INTRODUCTION IS GOING TO BE THAT SLAVE CATCHER, AND THEN WE'RE GOING TO REVISIT AGAIN WHEN WE SEE LYNCHINGS. AND THAT'S WHEN IT REALLY STARTS TO BECOME INCREDIBLY COMPLEX, BECAUSE YOU'LL HAVE SOME POLICE OFFICERS WHEN YOU'RE LOOKING AT THOSE PICTURES AND POSTCARDS THAT ARE STILL SOLD TODAY, YOU'LL SEE POLICE OFFICERS THERE. BUT WE CAN ALSO WE ALSO GO TO THE POEMS AND THE STORIES WHERE THERE'S POLICE OFFICERS THAT HAVE HELD OFF A MOB PROTECTING SOMEONE. AND THEN WHEN WE GET TO THE 60S, IT BECOMES EVEN MORE COMPLEX WHEN WE'RE LOOKING AT THOSE PICTURES OF DOCTOR KING. WELL, WHEN DOCTOR KING IS MARCHING AND IS GETTING HIT, WE HAVE TO DISCUSS THE POLICE THAT ARE THERE. BUT THEN AT THE SAME TIME, POLICE ARE ALSO PART OF INTEGRATION AND THEN WE HAVE TO BRING IT TO THE PRESENT, WHICH OUR STUDENTS WHO LOVE OUR SROS, OUR STUDENTS WHO HAVE FAMILY MEMBERS THAT ARE POLICE OFFICERS, OUR STUDENTS WHO WANT TO BE POLICE OFFICERS. AND WE HAVE THOSE TOUGH CONVERSATIONS ABOUT, WELL, HOW DO YOU FEEL? AND SO OFTEN, BECAUSE THIS IS WHAT WE DO AS SOCIAL SCIENTISTS, THEY DON'T KNOW WHAT WE BELIEVE OR WHAT WE FEEL A STUDENT MIGHT SAY, WELL, I HATE ALL POLICE. WELL, I SAY, WELL, WHAT ABOUT SUCH AND SUCH? OH WELL YEAH. HE'S OKAY. WELL THEN WHAT ARE WE SAYING HERE? AND THOSE ARE THE CONVERSATIONS THAT WE HAVE AS EDUCATORS AND IT IS NOT OUR DESIRE OR IT WOULD BE IRRESPONSIBLE FOR US FOR ANYTHING TO EVER TELL A KID THIS IS HOW TO BELIEVE. BUT YOU'RE RIGHT WHEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES AND POLICE, IT IS A COMPLEX ISSUE.

MR. MOBLEY, DID YOU WANT TO ADD ANYTHING? THE NEXT TOPIC OF CONCERN WAS THE EXTENT TO WHICH THE COURSE TEACHES ABOUT THE NATURE OF SLAVERY IN AFRICA AS MULTIFACETED, SHAPED BY INDIGENOUS PRACTICES, ISLAMIC INSTITUTIONS, AND EVENTUALLY THE ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE PLAYING A ROLE IN AFRICAN SOCIETIES FOR CENTURIES. SO IN GENERAL, BEFORE I TURN IT OVER TO OUR TEACHERS TO REALLY GET INTO SPECIFICS, WE HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THAT A COURSE ON AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES CAN'T BE UNDERTAKEN WITHOUT AN IN-DEPTH AND INTENTIONAL STUDY OF THE TRANSATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE AND THE WAYS THAT AMERICAN CHATTEL SLAVERY UNIQUELY AND INHERENTLY SHAPED THE EXPERIENCES OF BOTH THOSE WHO DIRECTLY EXPERIENCED IT AND ALSO AMERICAN SOCIETY. MORE BROADLY.

SO WE DO HAVE TO TACKLE THAT. HOWEVER, THIS COURSE IS REALLY RICH IN ITS REPRESENTATION OF THE DIVERSE HISTORY IN THE AFRICAN CONTINENT. AND SO I WANTED TO TURN IT OVER TO OUR EXPERTS TO TALK ABOUT WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE IN PARTICULAR. YOU CANNOT TALK ABOUT PRE-COLONIAL CIVILIZATIONS WITHOUT DISCUSSING SLAVERY, WITHOUT DISCUSSING TRADITIONAL SLAVERY. I CANNOT DISCUSS ALL OF THOSE AFRICAN DYNASTIES WITHOUT DISCUSSING SLAVERY AND AFRICA'S ROLE IN IT.

[05:20:04]

I CANNOT DISCUSS THE TRANSATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE WITHOUT SAYING THAT, YES, AFRICANS WERE PART OF THAT GUNS AND BUTTER. AFRICANS WERE PART OF THOSE TRADING PORTS. IT'S IT WOULD BE IRRESPONSIBLE. IT CAN'T BE DONE. AND THEN WHEN WE LOOK AT THE IMAGES, WE SEE THE AFRICANS TAKING PART IN IT, I DON'T KNOW WHERE THE IDEAS COME FROM BECAUSE I'VE HEARD IT ON NEWS THINGS THAT WHERE PEOPLE SAY, WELL, AFRICA DIDN'T HAVE SLAVES OR AFRICA WASN'T PART OF IT. I DON'T KNOW WHERE THAT NARRATIVE HAS COME FROM. AND THEN SOMETIMES THE STUDENTS SAY, OH, WELL, MR. HARRIS, WELL, IF THEY IF THEY KNEW WHAT WAS GOING ON, THEY WOULD. I SAID I, I DON'T KNOW THAT FOR SURE. I'D SAY I DON'T BELIEVE THAT TO BE TRUE, BUT I, YOU KNOW, I, WE DO NOT RUN AWAY FROM THAT AFRICA IN ALL ANCIENT CIVILIZATIONS PARTICIPATED IN TRADITIONAL SLAVERY. SO VERY QUICKLY, THERE WAS A CONCERN ABOUT THE EXTENT TO WHICH THE COURSE INCLUDED INFORMATION ABOUT ABOUT BLACK SCIENTISTS. I BELIEVE MR. AUSTIN IS GOING TO ADDRESS THAT. SO AGAIN, AND, AND KIND OF, YOU KNOW, THROUGHOUT THE CITY. RIGHT. AND THE ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE, THE COLLEGE BOARD AND THOSE, YOU KNOW, WHO KIND OF, YOU KNOW, WROTE THE CD AND ALL THE PROFESSORS AND HISTORIANS, A LITANY OF INDIVIDUALS, A LITANY OF INDIVIDUALS ACROSS. AND AGAI, BEING A STUDIES COURSE. RIGHT. I MEAN, YOU HAVE MUSIC, LITERATURE, ART, POLITICS, ECONOMIC ENTREPRENEURS, BUT ALSO STEM AND SCIENTISTS. AND SO, OF COURSE, IN UNIT FOUR, YOU'RE GOING TO FIND SO MUCH MORE WITH, YOU KNOW, KATHERINE JOHNSON, MARY JACKSON, I MEAN, NASA, YOU HAVE MADE JEMISON AN ASTRONAUT IN THE 90S, YOU HAVE, YOU KNOW, GEORGE WASHINGTON CARVER.

BOTANY, BUT BUT IT GOES IT I MEAN, THERE'S COUNTLESS EXAMPLES ESSENTIALLY, OF, YOU KNOW, FOUNDERS OF HOSPITALS, COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES, YOU KNOW, SOME OF THE AND DURING THE RECONSTRUCTION PERIODS, THE FIRST MEMBERS TO BE ELECTED TO CONGRESS IN SOUTHERN STATES, AND JUST THERE'S ALWAYS THE INDIVIDUALS OF THOSE CONTRIBUTIONS. BUT BUT WHAT I'D REALLY LIKE TO ADD IS THAT WHEN, WHEN I'M TEACHING AND THIS KIND OF GOES TO WHAT, YOU KNOW, MISS LYNN WAS TALKING ABOUT WHAT POTENTIAL FOR THE PROJECT AND EVEN WHAT MR. MOBLEY WAS TALKING ABOUT WITH THE APES PROJECT, THE HISTORIC GEOGRAPHICAL SORT OF, ORAL DEFENSE PROJECT IS THEN STUDENTS HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO CHOOSE. THEY HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO EXPLORE THE INDIVIDUALS THAT HAVE MADE GREAT CONTRIBUTIONS IN AMERICAN, AFRICAN AMERICAN EXPERIENCE. AND I USUALLY ENCOURAGE THEM TO, YOU KNOW, TO EXPLORE THOSE INDIVIDUALS THAT SHARE COMMON INTERESTS, WHETHER IT BE MUSIC, LITERATURE, YOU KNOW, ACTING, AGAIN, MAYBE, YOU KNOW, SCIENCE, MEDICINE, ECONOMICS. BUT THERE IS, YOU KNOW, AN EXTENSIVE, YOU KNOW, LIST OF SORT OF THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN, YOU KNOW, SORT OF POSITIVE CONTRIBUTIONS THROUGHOUT THE AFRICAN AMERICAN EXPERIENCE. AND THE LAST REAL BUCKET OF CONCERN WAS AROUND THE LACK OF FULL CONTEXT OR INCOMPLETE INFORMATION ABOUT SOME SPECIFIC FIGURES OR GROUPS. AND SO I WANTED TO TURN IT OVER TO OUR TEACHERS, TO TALK ABOUT THE WAYS IN WHICH THE SPECIFIC LANGUAGE IN THE KID TRANSLATES INTO A MORE FULL PICTURE OF THOSE INDIVIDUALS THAT WERE CALLED OUT BY BOARD CONCERN, I THINK, ONE LET'S LET'S START WITH MALCOLM X, WHO IS, I THINK QUITE INTRIGUING WHEN YOU AND ONCE AGAIN, I WANT TO STRESS THAT WE'RE ALWAYS WE ALWAYS WANT TO LOOK AT THE WHY. WE ALWAYS WANT TO LOOK AT THE WHY. WHY DID THIS WHY DOES THIS HISTORICAL FIGURE DO THIS? WHY DOES THIS HISTORICAL FIGURE. SO WHEN YOU FOLLOW MALCOLM'S LIFE AND MALCOLM HAS HIS LIFE OF CRIME THAT THE KIDS ABSOLUTELY FIND FASCINATING AND HIS FATHER WAS LYNCHED AND THINGS OF THAT NATURE, AND THEN IN PRISON, HE JOINS THE NATION OF ISLAM. AND HE DOES. AND HE'S HE SAYS THINGS AS IT'S RELATED TO WHAT ELIJAH MUHAMMAD SAYS. AND THEN WE DISCUSS, WELL, IS THIS OKAY? IS THIS NOT OKAY? HOW DO WE GET TO THIS ROUTE? BUT THEN WHAT MAKES MALCOLM REALLY FASCINATING IS WHEN MALCOLM MAKES HIS BREAK FROM THE NATION OF ISLAM AND HE MAKES HIS PILGRIMAGE TO MECCA, AND HE OPENS UP HIS OWN MOSQUE, AND WE HEAR THAT AS WHERE IT'S CHANGED AND IF NOTHING ELSE, AND I ALWAYS TELL THE KIDS, I'M NOT HERE TO TELL YOU WHAT TO BELIEVE, BUT IT'S INTERESTING TO SEE SOMEONE. WHAT I DO TELL THE KIDS, IT'S INTERESTING TO SEE SOMEONE THAT HAS SUCH ROOTED A FOUNDATION AND THEN HAS THE COURAGE TO PUBLICLY TO SAY TO THE WORLD, I MIGHT FEEL DIFFERENT, OR I MIGHT SAY WRONG. AND I SAID, AND I ALWAYS TELL THE KIDS, I SAID, I'M NOT TELLING YOU WHAT TO BELIEVE. I'M NOT TELLING YOU TO SAY WHAT'S RIGHT OR WRONG. I SAID, BUT THAT IS A INTERESTING POSITION TO TAKE ON. INTERESTING WAY TO BE TO BE LIKE, I DON'T NECESSARILY FEEL OR I'M NOT NECESSARILY THE SAME PERSON. I KNOW THE BLACK PANTHER PARTY WAS ALSO SOMETHING THAT WAS BROUGHT UP, AND IT'S INTERESTING. AND WE WERE TALKING ABOUT I WAS TALKING ABOUT MISS ALVAREZ WITH, COMMUNISM AND WE'RE NOT HERE TO ENDORSE ANY ECONOMIC SYSTEM, THE ISSUE OF WHAT HARLEM RENAISSANCE WRITERS WOULD HAVE CALLED COLLECTIVE ECONOMICS, BECAUSE ALL THE WAY BACK THEN, WHEN WE'RE LOOKING AT THE NEW DEAL, WE KNOW THAT MOST, AS PRESIDENT TRUMP JUST SAID,

[05:25:03]

BLACK JOBS WEREN'T REALLY WEREN'T REALLY COVERED UNDER SOCIAL SECURITY. SO THERE WAS A LOT OF HARLEM RENAISSANCE WRITERS THAT TALKED ABOUT COLLECTIVE ECONOMICS. AND WE HAVE TO DISCUSS THAT IN THE SAME WAY. WHEN WE GOT TO THE BLACK PANTHER PARTY, THE BLACK PANTHER PARTY WAS THEN LOOKING AT MAO AND THEY WERE LOOKING AT CASTRO AND THINGS OF THIS NATURE. AND THEY THEY WERE THEY FELT THAT THEY WERE REVOLUTIONARIES. AND ALL WE CAN SAY IS WE SAY, WELL, THIS IS WHAT I, WHAT I LIKE TO DO, AND I'M SURE MY COLLEAGUES DO THE SAME THING. WE'LL LOOK AT THESE THREE VERY DIFFERING VIEWS WHERE YOU HAVE DOCTOR KING AND YOU HAVE MALCOLM X, AND YOU HAVE THE BLACK PANTHER PARTY. AND ONE OF THE QUESTIONS IS, WELL, TELL ME WHAT THEY THOUGHT AND WHAT THEY BELIEVED. WHAT WHO WOULD YOU FOLLOW? AND WHY? BUT IT IS ALSO THERE'S LOTS OF, YOU KNOW, THE BLACK PANTHER PARTY FELT THAT THEY WERE UNDER ATTACK, AND THEY FELT THAT THEY WERE POLICING THE POLICE, WHICH GOES BACK TO THAT INTERESTING. IT BECOMES QUITE DIFFICULT TO FOR KIDS TO PROCESS. WELL, WHAT ABOUT THE POLICE? WELL, WHEN THEY LOOK AT THOSE PICTURES, SAME THING. AND IT'S NO DIFFERENT THAN WHAT WE MIGHT DO WITH THE, THE SONS OF LIBERTY, YOU KNOW, AND IT'S OR THE SAME THING THAT WE'RE GOING TO DO 20 YEARS FROM NOW. PLEASE DON'T WANT ME TO BE TEACHING 20 YEARS FROM NOW THAT WE'RE GOING TO BE LOOKING AT, WHAT, JANUARY 6TH? AND THOSE TEACHERS ARE NOT GOING TO SAY, HEY, THESE PEOPLE ON JANUARY 6TH WERE GOOD OR BAD.

THEY'RE GOING TO SAY, THIS IS THE SPEECH THAT THE PRESIDENT GAVE. THIS IS WHAT PEOPLE WERE SAYING. LET'S LOOK AT THE VIDEO AND COME TO A CONCLUSION TO ADD ON TO WHAT MIKE MICHAEL HAS STATED, JUST BRIEFLY, IS THAT THE FACT OF JUST THE JUXTAPOSE DOCTOR KING AND MALCOLM X, IT'S A VERY INTERESTING AND CONTRASTING VIEW. AND TO UNDERSTAND HOW EACH ONE SEEMS TO SWITCH AS THEY ARE LATER ON IN THEIR YEARS. SO THOSE TYPE OF CONVERSATIONS IN CLASS MAKE AN INDELIBLE MARK ON OUR CHILDREN, BECAUSE HOW THEY THINK NOW MAY NOT BE THE SAME. 20 AND 30 YEARS FROM NOW. SO IT'S GETTING THEM TO CONNECT. WHAT HAPPENED YESTERDAY TO TODAY, BUT ALSO TO FORWARD LOOKING THAT PEOPLE CAN CHANGE BASED UPON SITUATION AND CIRCUMSTANCE. SO IT'S NOT NECESSARILY OUR INPUT OR OUR PERSONAL PERSPECTIVE AS TO HOW WE FEEL ABOUT THESE INDIVIDUALS, BUT WHAT IT IS TO SEE THEIR LIVES ON DISPLAY AND TO SEE CERTAIN CHARACTERISTICS THAT THEY MAY HAVE SIMILAR, BUT ALSO THEY CONTRAST AND ALWAYS AS SOCIAL SCIENTISTS, WE ALWAYS TRY TO GET TO THE WHY. SO LITERALLY, AS YOU CAN SEE FROM THE SCREEN. AND I KNOW THAT THE BOARD HAS HAD THESE IN FRONT OF THEM FOR A LITTLE WHILE. WE'VE CALLED OUT SPECIFICALLY AREAS WHERE WE SEE IN BLACK AND WHITE LANGUAGE FROM THE CID. WHAT IS REQUIRED KNOWLEDGE, BUT THEN THAT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION THAT CONTEXTUALIZES THAT LEARNING AND SO THAT CONCERN ABOUT NOT HAVING THAT FULL PICTURE OR FULL CONTEXT BECAUSE IT'S NOT EXPLICITLY CALLED OUT IN THE CID, I COMPLETELY UNDERSTAND THAT PERSPECTIVE, AND I BELIEVE I'VE SAID THAT IN OUR SMALL GROUPS, WHEN YOU DON'T HAVE THE EXPERTISE AND THE YEARS OF EXPERIENCE AND TRAINING TO UNDERSTAND PEDAGOGY, OF HOW TO INTERPRET A CURRICULUM DOCUMENT, YOU CAN SEE THESE WORDS ON THE SCREEN AND BE MISSING THE CONTEXT BEHIND IT OF NOT HAVING. I MEAN, THESE GENTLEMEN JUST TAUGHT ME A FEW THINGS TOO. AND I'M SITTING HERE AS THE SUPERVISOR OF SOCIAL SCIENCES.

WE ARE ALWAYS LEARNING NEW THINGS TO CONTEXTUALIZE THE LEARNING THAT IS REQUIRED. SO TO THAT END, THERE WERE JUST A COUPLE OTHER THINGS THAT WERE SENT TO ME RATHER LATE IN THE GAME, THE ONE WAS ABOUT A FULL CONTEXT OR INCOMPLETE INFORMATION OF ROSA PARKS AND HOW SHE WAS CHOSEN AND PROMPTED BY A GROUP, AND THAT IS ABSOLUTELY SOMETHING THAT COULD BE ADDRESSED THROUGH THE REQUIRED KNOWLEDGE. HOWEVER, ROSA PARKS IS NOT INCLUDED IN ANY ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE OR LEARNING OBJECTIVES. SHE IS MENTIONED AS A SOURCE NOTE FOR UNIT FOUR, AND IT DOES SPECIFICALLY CALL OUT THE FACT THAT SHE WAS THE SECRETARY OF THE NAACP. BUT THE LEARNING OBJECTIVE THAT ROSA PARKS MOST CLOSELY ALIGNS WITH IS EXPLAIN HOW NONVIOLENT RESISTANCE STRATEGIES MOBILIZE THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT. AND TO ADDRESS THAT, WE WOULD HAVE TO INCLUDE INFORMATION ABOUT THE FACT THAT BLACK WOMEN HAD BEEN REFUSING TO GIVE UP THEIR SEATS FOR SOME TIME BEFORE. ROSA REFUSED TO STAND AND IT CULMINATED THEN IN THE ARREST OF 15 YEAR OLD CLAUDETTE COLVIN, NINE MONTHS BEFORE. ROSA WAS FAMOUSLY ARRESTED. BUT THE NAACP IN PARTICULAR IN BLACK CIVIL RIGHTS LEADERS MORE BROADLY IN MONTGOMERY, HAD BEEN TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO DEAL WITH THE SEGREGATED BUSSES IN MONTGOMERY FOR SOME TIME AND CHOSE ROSA PARKS AS A TEST CASE BECAUSE OF HER NATURAL GRAVITAS AND THE FACT THAT SHE WAS AN ADULT WITH AN UNIMPEACHABLE REPUTATION. CLAUDETTE COLVIN HAD SOME QUESTIONABLE THINGS IN HER PAST, BY SOCIETAL STANDARDS, THAT THEY DID NOT WANT HER TO BE THE STANDARD BEARER FOR THIS. AND SO ANY DISCUSSION OF ROSA WOULD, OF COURSE, INCLUDE THE FACT THAT

[05:30:02]

SHE WAS CHOSEN AND PROMPTED BY A GROUP. IT WAS NOT A SPONTANEOUS ACT AT ALL, SIMILARLY, A CONVERT OR A CONCERN WAS BROUGHT TO MY ATTENTION ABOUT ANGELA DAVIS AND WHETHER OR NOT SHE IS A CIVIL RIGHTS HERO AND SO SIMILAR TO MISS ROSA. ANGELA DAVIS IS ONLY MENTIONED IN THE SED AS A SOURCE NOTE, WITH WRITERS SUCH AS ANGELA DAVIS AND TONI MORRISON DETAILED EXPERIENCES OF GENDER WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF RACE, SEXUALITY AND CLASS. SO WHILE KNOWLEDGE OF HER OR HER WORK IS NOT REQUIRED OR ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE, CERTAINLY AS ALWAYS, ANY STUDY OF AN INDIVIDUAL OR A GROUP WOULD BE CENTERED ON THAT BALANCED PERSPECTIVE OF INFORMATION THAT WOULD NOT ASSERT A DEFINITIVE STANCE IN EITHER VILIFICATION NOR UNRESERVED PRAISE. SO WITH ALL OF THAT, WE BRING OUR COURSE REQUEST BACK TO YOU WITH A JUST ONE THING. YES, PLEASE, AND A FINAL POINT, MR. MOBLEY AND I, WHEN WE WERE UPSTAIRS AND WE WERE LOOKING AND WE HEARD LOTS OF PEOPLE SAY THAT, WE'RE NOT TEACHING THE KIDS HOW TO PRACTICE APPROPRIATE CIVIL DISCOURSE. AND JOHN SAID, WHAT DO WE THINK ALL OUR STUDENTS ARE DOING TODAY? AND WE WATCHED HARFORD COUNTY STUDENTS GET ON THE LIST, SHOW UP, SPEAK IN THEIR ALLOTTED TIME, AND LEAVE PEACEFULLY. AND I THINK THAT'S A PRODUCT OF WHAT WE DO AS EDUCATORS. AND WITH THAT, WE WILL TAKE YOUR QUESTIONS. WELL, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I MEAN, I THINK IT'S EVIDENT FROM MY PERSPECTIVE THAT YOU GUYS HAVE DEFINITELY TAKEN THIS VERY SERIOUSLY AND PUT IN A LOT OF HARD WORK AS I MENTIONED IN MY EARLIER COMMENTS, I WANT TO THANK THE STUDENTS FOR ALSO STAYING WITH US VERY LATE TO THE EVENING, I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU TO CONSIDER JOINING A BOARD AT SOME POINT. WE DON'T ALWAYS GO UNTIL MIDNIGHT, JUST ON CERTAIN NIGHTS. AND TO THE EDUCATORS, THANK YOU, MY TIME WITH YOU, WITH SOME OF THE OTHER BOARD MEMBERS THE OTHER DAY WAS, WAS VERY ENLIGHTENING. AND I WANT TO BE CLEAR THAT THIS WAS NEVER I MEAN, WE KNOW THE STUDENTS LOVE IT. WE KNOW THE EDUCATORS ARE GOOD AT WHAT THEY DO. THIS WAS NEVER ABOUT THE EDUCATORS. THIS WAS NEVER ABOUT THE STUDENTS, THIS WAS REALLY ABOUT THE KID CURRICULUM THAT WE DIDN'T CREATE. AND WE DON'T CONTROL. THAT WAS UNDER A LOT OF SCRUTIN, A LOT OF CONTROVERSY. AND I THINK THE SIMPLY IT WAS CREATED BY EXPERTS IN HIGHER EDUCATION IS NOT A COMFORT LEVEL FOR ME. I'VE BEEN IN HIGHER EDUCATION FOR 20 YEARS IN ONE WAY OR ANOTHER, WITH MY LAW DEGREE, MY DOCTORATE, MY THREE MASTER'S DEGREE. I HAVE SEEN HOW EDUCATION HAS BIASES. IT IS 17 TO 1 LIBERALS TO CONSERVATIVES IN HIGHER EDUCATION. SO WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THESE PERCEIVED IMPLICIT BIASES AND THEY ARE PERCEIVED BECAUSE WE ALL SEE THINGS DIFFERENTLY, THAT IS THE LENS THAT SOME PEOPLE SEE. THE CURRICULUM WRITTEN THROUGH. AND WHEN WE SEE CERTAIN THINGS THAT PORTRAY THINGS AS WHAT BOARD MEMBERS OR MYSELF SEE IN A CERTAIN LIGHT, WE'RE SEEKING ANSWERS, WE'RE SEEKING CONTEXT, WE'RE SEEKING DIFFERENT OPINIONS. I THINK WE'VE WE'VE SEEN A LOT OF THAT OVER THE PAST MONTH WHILE WE'VE BEEN WORKING ON THIS, WITH ME IN PARTICULAR.

I MEAN, MANY OF MY CONCERNS HAVE BEEN BEEN ADDRESSED. I THINK I'M VERY COMFORTABLE WITH THE DIRECTION THAT WE ARE HEADED. I WOULD LIKE TO ENSURE THAT THERE IS, APPROPRIATE BALANCE THAT WE DO TALK ABOUT THE GOOD, THE BAD, THE UGLY. I HEARD A LOT OF PEOPLE SAY TONIGHT THE TRUTH IS UNCOMFORTABLE. I SAW SOME TRUTH THAT WEREN'T TOLD. AND I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THE ENTIRE STORY IS BEING TOLD, I'M SURE SOME OF THE OTHER BOARD MEMBERS WILL HAVE SOME COMMENTS, SO I'LL TURN IT OVER TO THEM. FOR NOW, I JUST I WANT TO THANK, EVERYBODY IN THE STAFF, THEY'VE TAKEN THE COMMENTS AND THE CONCERNS THAT THE THAT THE BOARD, EXPRESSED VERY SERIOUSLY.

IT'S VERY OBVIOUS IN YOUR RESPONSE, IN YOUR PRESENTATION THAT YOU DID TAKE THEM SERIOUSLY AND HOPEFULLY YOU KNOW, YOU CAN TAKE SOME OF THE CONCERNS THAT WE HAVE TO THE CLASSROOM, AND UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE BIASES, AND THERE'S, AND THERE'S SOME DEEP CONCERNS ABOUT THOSE, THAT OUR STUDENTS, YOU KNOW, NEED TO HAVE A BALANCED PERSPECTIVE. SO I APPRECIATE, YOU KNOW, LIKE, YOU SAID, THE EFFORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU. ARE YOU APPRECIATED YOU HAVE A FEW QUESTIONS, HOW IS HOW DIFFERENT IS THIS COURSE FROM THE HOMEGROWN AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES COURSE, I KNOW JOHN AND I BOTH TALKED TO THE COURSE AT BOTH LEVELS, THE RIGOR AND THE SOURCES AND THE AMOUNT OF SOURCES AND THE AMOUNT OF

[05:35:01]

WRITING. WELL, THE AMOUNT OF WRITING WOULD BE THE RIGOR. OKAY BUT YEAH, IN ADDITION TO THAT, WITH THE PASSAGE OF THE AP COURSE, THEY AUTOMATICALLY GET SOME KIND OF ECONOMIC INCENTIVE BECAUSE NOW THEY CAN DEFRAY THEIR COST FOR, FOR COLLEGE, WHEREAS THE GENERAL CLASS, IT'S MORE OF A COLLECTIVE WHERE THEY HAVE TO WAIT TO SEE WHETHER OR NOT THEY'RE GETTING IT, BUT ALSO TO WHAT I'VE LEARNED FROM THE YOUNG PEOPLE THAT I TOOK TAUGHT THIS PAST YEAR. THE MAJORITY OF THEM. THIS WAS THE FIRST TIME THEY EVER TOOK AN AP CLASS. SO FOR ME, IT WAS, A VERY, HUMBLING EXPERIENCE BECAUSE I'VE HAD TAUGHT AP US HISTORY FOR FIVE YEARS. SO FOR ME, IT WAS VERY A HUMBLING EXPERIENCE, BUT ALSO FOR THE KIDS, IT WAS SOMETHING THAT THAT STRETCHED THEM. SO I DEFINITELY BELIEVE, AS MR. HARRIS SAID, THE GENERAL DOES NOT, HAVE AS MUCH RIGOR AS THE AS THE AP COURSE DOES. AND I THINK THE REGULAR GIVES US MORE ROOM TO MEET ALL LEARNING LEVELS AND STYLES. AND OBVIOUSLY WE ALWAYS HAVE DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION, BUT IN THE REGULAR AND I CAN I CAN MEET MORE STUDENTS NEEDS. I CAN HAVE INCLUSION KIDS, I CAN HAVE, THE WHERE WHERE WE HAVE THAT AP CLASS, I WOULD REALLY HAVE TO PUT OUR FOOT ON THE GAS.

BASICALLY THE SAME KNOWLEDGE AND FACTS. OH, AND SO I WOULD THINK IT'S MUCH DEEPER. YES. VERY DEEP, MUCH DEEPER WITH THE AP COURSE AS OPPOSED TO THE GENERAL. YEAH. I THINK I MEAN, JUST IN ORDER TO LEARN, I THINK WE ADDED IN FOUR MORE, FIVE MORE DYNASTIES AND I ACTUALLY HAD TO DO A READING ON TWO OF THEM, I DON'T KNOW, BUT I, YOU KNOW, LIKE YOU SAID, WE'RE ALWAYS LEARNING. OKAY, SO ON THE OPPRESSION CONCERNS, ARE YOU SAYING THAT STUDENTS WILL LEAVE THIS COURSE? NOT THINKING THAT BLACK PEOPLE ARE STILL OPPRESSED TODAY, I MEAN, I CAN'T ANSWER THAT QUESTION FOR THEM. THAT'S SOMETHING THROUGH EDUCATION THAT THEY WILL COME TO THAT CONCLUSION. MY JOB AS AN EDUCATOR IS TO PRESENT THE INFORMATION AND FOR THEM TO DETERMINE HOW THEY FEEL. I CAN'T LEGISLATE HOW THEY FEEL. THE HISTORY IS WHAT IT IS. AND UNFORTUNATELY, AS HAS BEEN STATED, A LOT TONIGHT, THAT IT'S UGLY. IT'S NOT PRETTY, IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT, THAT THAT WE DON'T LIKE TO EMBRACE. BUT IT'S IT IS WHAT IT IS. BUT WHAT I FOUND WITH CHILDREN TAKING THE CLASS, THEY FEEL MORE EMPOWERED. AND LET ME TELL YOU, ONE, I CAN'T ANSWER IT THE WAY IT WAS ASKED, BUT I CAN TELL YOU THIS ABOUT MY STUDENTS, AND ONE OF THE LESSONS THAT I DO IN BOTH THE GENERAL AND THE AP IS IT'S TIME FOR NAMES. AND BOOKER T WASHINGTON WRITES THIS BEAUTIFUL PASSAGE ABOUT, YOU'VE GOT TO FIGURE OUT A NAME. AND BECAUSE PEOPLE DON'T HAVE LAST NAMES, IT'S AMAZING YOU'RE EMANCIPATED. AND THEN SOMETIMES HE SAYS PEOPLE AND I'M QUOTING BOOKER T WASHINGTON POORLY SAYS THEY PUT THE THEY PUT THE MIDDLE INITIAL S BECAUSE THERE WAS AN ENTITLEMENT. SO MASTER HAD AND THAT'S WHY GUIDANCE AND WHAT EVEN WITH THAT FIRST UNIT DOES IS AND I TELL THE KIDS AND I SAID, ALL RIGHT GUYS, WE'RE GOING TO LOOK UP OUR NAMES AND WE GO OUT ON THE INTERNET AND EVERYONE LOOKS UP THEIR NAME, AND I LOOK UP MY NAME, AND I THINK I HAVE AN IRISH OR SCOTTISH LAST NAME, AND I HAVE THESE AFRICAN KIDS THAT LOOK UP THEIR NAME AND THEY CAN TELL ME WHERE THEIR TRIBES ARE FROM. AND I MIGHT HAVE AN ITALIAN OR A SPANISH KID, AND THEY CAN GO BACK TO THE PLACE, AND THE PEOPLE THAT ARE DESCENDANTS FROM CHATTEL SLAVERY CAN'T DO THAT. AND WHAT THEY START TO DO WITH UNIT ONE IS THEY START TO HAVE AN UNDERSTANDING. IT'S WHAT'S CALLED A MYTHOLOGICAL ORIGIN THAT WE TALK ABOUT WHERE THEY START TO AT LEAST HAVING AN UNDERSTANDING. I KNOW I'M FROM AFRICA AND THESE THINGS ARE VERY AFRICAN AND I KNOW THIS IS WHO AND WHAT I AM. IN THE SAME WAY, I CAN GO TO WITH MY TIME BROTHERS AND SISTERS AND I CAN CELEBRATE AT THEIR FESTIVAL AND I CAN GO TO MY POLISH BROTHERS AND SISTERS. AND NOW I CAN SAY, NOW THESE KIDS IN CLASS ARE SAYING, WELL, I DON'T KNOW EXACTLY WHERE I'M FROM, BUT I KNOW THIS IS WHO I AM. AND I DO KNOW THAT KIDS GET THAT. OKAY, AND IF I MAY. OH, SORRY. I JUST WANTED TO IF I AS FAR AS JUST SORT OF THE CATCH ALL TERM OPPRESSION, I WOULD SAY THAT THIS IS WHAT SOCIAL SCIENTISTS DO IS WE'D SAY, WHERE ARE THE SPECIFIC EXAMPLES TO MAKE A CLAIM FOR SOMETHING LIKE THAT? IS IT A POLICY? IS IT A LAW? IS IT A LOCAL LAW? IS IT A STATE LAW? IS IT A FEDERAL LAW? IS IT A COURT DECISION? IS IT A STATE COURT DECISION? IS IT A PRESIDENTIAL ACTION? AND THEN YOU'RE LOOKING OBJECTIVELY AT THOSE PIECES OF POLICY, AND THEN YOU'RE MAKING THOSE CLAIMS TO SEE WHAT THE EFFECTS OF THOSE DECISIONS ARE. THAT'S WHAT THAT'S WHAT I THINK WE TRY TO DO IN THIS HOUSE. AND TO FURTHER ADD, LIKE I, YOU KNOW, WHEN WE COVER COWBOYS AND KIDS ARE LIKE, I DIDN'T KNOW THERE WERE BLACK COWBOYS OR I DIDN'T KNOW WE WERE PART OF THIS. AND SO EVERY TIME WE GO OR EVEN WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT EVERY ONE OF OUR WARS AND I CAN AND ONE OF THE THEMES THAT WE WANT TO KNOW, I WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT AFRICAN AMERICANS FOUGHT IN EVERY WAR AND WERE

[05:40:01]

DECORATED AND EVERY WAR, BECAUSE THAT'S NOT IN THE PICTURES. AND SO THEY DO START TO GET THOSE FEELINGS OF, OH, I AM PART OF DOTING THIS COUNTRY. I AM PART OF THAT FOUNDATION. SO BUT I CAN'T TELL YOU HOW IT FEELS ONCE THE CLASS IS OVER. I'M JUST WONDERING, YOU KNOW, AGAIN WHAT WHAT IMPRESSIONS ARE CONVEYED BECAUSE I KNOW YOU MENTIONED THAT JUST GENERAL IMPRESSION.

ALL RIGHT, IF THE COURSE IS BALANCED, WHAT DO YOU THINK WAS THE BASIS THERE WAS A STRONG REACTION WHEN I MENTIONED INCLUDING THE NAMES OF SOME CONSERVATIVE BLACK AMERICANS.

WHAT WOULD BE THE HESITATION WITH THAT? WHAT'S. LET'S SEE. IT WAS CLARENCE THOMAS, THOMAS SOWELL, TIM SCOTT, WHO HESITATED ABOUT INTRODUCING THESE NAMES. WELL I THE AUDIENCE I DON'T THEY'RE NOT IN THE CLASSROOM. I WE NO ONE NO, NONE OF THEM KNOW. THEY DON'T KNOW. THEY DON'T HAVE ANY IDEA. AND IF YOU THINK FOR ONE SECOND THAT MY KIDS DON'T SIT DOWN AND WATCH CANDACE OWENS AND WRITE A FREE RESPONSE ON IT, AND THEY GET NO OPINION FROM ME OTHER THAN MAYBE I'LL PLAY DEVIL'S ADVOCATE IF THE ROOM'S ALL ONE WAY OR ALL THE OTHER, BUT THAT'S NOT THAT'S NOT THESE THREE. AND THE PEOPLE THAT WILL BE TEACHING. AND I DON'T WANT TO SPEAK FOR MY COLLEAGUES, BUT I DO THE SAME WAY. YOU GUYS TRUST YOUR COLLEAGUES. AND I WAS JUST AT A RETIREMENT DINNER, FOR A POLICE OFFICER ONE SATURDAY, AND, MY BUDDY WAS LIKE, YOU KNOW, WE ARE GOOD. HE SAID 95.

HE SAID, LIKE HE SAID, IF YOU HAVE 100, HE SAID, FIVE OF US, FIVE MIGHT NOT BE OKAY. BUT HE SAID, THAT'S SOCIETY. AND THAT'S WHAT I BELIEVE ABOUT MY COWORKERS TOO, AND I DON'T. I DON'T I'VE NEVER COME ACROSS MY COWORKERS THAT DO THAT. AND WE DON'T RUN FROM ANY OF IT. OKAY WHAT WOULD BE THE HESITATION OF INCLUDING THE ROLAND FRYER STUDY IN THE MENU FOR THE POST EXAM PERIOD? TELL ME WHAT THE ROLAND FRYER, THE RACIAL BIAS IN POLICE SHOOTINGS, THE ROLAND FRYER FROM HARVARD, HARVARD ONE STUDY. I DON'T KNOW THAT WE'VE PUT THAT NAME ON IT, BUT WE DEFINITELY DISCUSSED THAT ABSOLUTELY. WE'RE NOT OPPOSED TO ANYTHING. BUT I MEAN, TO PUT IT ON THE MENU.

SURE. AS I STATED EARLIER, THAT THERE'S SUGGESTED MATERIAL THAT ARE IN EACH ONE OF THOSE, THOSE TOPICS, AND WE HAVE THE LUXURY OF DOING SO. SO, WE AND I WILL SPEAK FOR US THAT WE MEET OFTEN AND WE TRY TO GIVE UP AS MUCH OF A BALANCE, IN OUR LESSONS, AS MUCH AS WE POSSIBLY CAN. BUT WHAT WE ARE TASKED TO DO IS TO ENSURE THAT THE INFORMATION THAT WE HAD BEEN GIVEN THROUGH THAT, THAT CURRICULUM, THAT WE FOLLOW IT AND TRY TO GET AS MUCH OF THAT INFORMATION OUT AS POSSIBLE AS WE POSSIBLY CAN. SO WHEN WE MET INITIALLY, WE TRIED TO WORK WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES, RIGHT? SO ON THE MARGINS, WE SAID THERE ARE CERTAIN THINGS IN THE CURRICULUM THAT YOU JUST CAN'T CHANGE. I MEAN, THERE ARE CERTAIN THINGS THAT ARE ON THE TEST, BUT THERE ARE CERTAIN THINGS THAT WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO ADD THAT PROVIDE SOME MORE BALANCE. AND THAT'S SORT OF THE APPROACH THAT WE TOOK HERE RIGHT THROUGHOUT THE YEAR. IF WE SEE SOMETHING THAT WE THINK IS PRESENTING ONE SIDE OF AN ARGUMENT, WHAT ARE THE OTHER RESOURCES THAT WE CAN BRING INTO THE CLASSROOM TO PRESENT THE OTHER SIDE OF THE ARGUMENT? AND THERE'S ALWAYS TWO SIDES TO EVERY ARGUMENT. IN ADDITION TO YOU HAVE THIS PERIOD AT THE END, RIGHT, WHERE AFTER THE AP TEST HAS BEEN TAKEN, THERE'S SOME CALL IT DISCRETIONARY TIME WHERE YOU CAN DO THESE PROJECTS AND THINGS LIKE THAT. I THINK SPECIFICALLY WHAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT IS THERE WAS A PRESUMPTION, LIKE A TRUISM ALMOST IN WHAT CAME FROM THE COLLEGE BOARD, THAT POLICE BRUTALITY IS A THING. AND THERE ARE OTHER AND I'M SURE LOTS OF PEOPLE WOULD AGREE WITH THAT.

BUT THERE ARE OTHER FOLKS OUT THERE WHO HAVE A CONTRARY POINT OF VIEW, AND SPECIFICALLY PROFESSOR FRYER IS A BLACK ECONOMIST FROM HARVARD WHO WAS A TOP GUY, AND HE DID ONE OF THE MOST THOROUGH STUDIES ON POLICE, SHOOTINGS AND POLICE BRUTALITY. AND HIS FINDINGS WERE THAT THERE WAS NO RACIAL DIFFERENCES, IN EITHER RAW DATA OR CONTEXTUAL DATA FOR POLICE INVOLVED SHOOTINGS. AND HE WAS CANCELED, RIGHT. CANCELED BY HARVARD, CANCELED BY EVERYBODY. WE WANT BOTH SIDES TO BE PORTRAYED, WHETHER IT'S GOOD, BAD, UGLY, WHETHER THEY GOT CANCELED. WE WANT IT ALL. IT TALKS ABOUT WHAT'S THE MISSION OF BLM, DO YOU THINK IT'S ALSO APPROPRIATE TO SHOW THE DOWNSIDE OF BLM, FOR EXAMPLE, THAT IT CAUSED $2 BILLION IN ECONOMIC DESTRUCTION TO THE COUNTRY? OR SHOULD WE JUST SAY WHAT BLM'S MISSION IS AND NOT TALK ABOUT THE BAD OR THE UGLY? RIGHT. ONE. I, I WELCOME THE STUDY BECAUSE KIDS LOVE THOSE THINGS, AND DO YOU REMEMBER FROM THE MEETING THAT WE HAVE, DID YOU DISCUSS THE BATTLE? NO, I DON'T BELIEVE IT.

I DON'T I THINK THE BLM IS A MUCH BIGGER IDEA TO EVERYONE BUT THE PEOPLE IN THE CLASSROOM.

[05:45:01]

YEAH, I DON'T I DIDN'T EVEN COVER THE FIELD. WELL, I COVERED BLM IN MY GENERAL CLASS BECAUSE IT WAS SOMETHING THAT WAS DESIRED BY THE KIDS. AND WE TALKED ABOUT BLM, AND I'VE ALWAYS BEEN ONE TO GIVE THE WHOLE THE WHOLE STORY, NOT JUST PART OF THE STORY, BUT ALL THE STORY, INCLUDING WHAT YOU HAD STATED. DOCTOR BOYDEN, IN TERMS OF THE CORRUPTION THAT WAS THAT WAS, PRESENTED. BUT HOWEVER, AS TRUE SOCIAL SCIENTISTS, WE ALWAYS TRY TO GIVE THE, THE WELL-ROUNDED PERSPECTIVE ON ANY TOPIC TO GIVE KIDS A DEEPER UNDERSTANDING AND PERSPECTIVE ON THE INFORMATION THAT IS BEING GIVEN. BUT, THERE'S NO AS I SAID EARLIER, THERE'S NO INDOCTRINATION FOR MY PART, WE MAKE SURE THAT THE INFORMATION THAT IS GIVEN IS FACTUAL AND THAT WE USE QUALITY TEXTBOOKS AND OTHER RESOURCES WHEN WE DO PRESENT THAT INFORMATION THAT COMES THROUGH CLEARLY WITH ALL OF YOU. BUT IT DIDN'T COME THROUGH ON THE FIRST READING.

FOR MANY OF US OF THE TEXT AS IT CAME FROM THE COLLEGE BOARD. WELL, I THINK THAT THAT'S THE BEAUTY OF AND THE REASON WHY I ASKED YOU TO MEET WITH THESE TEACHERS AND WHY I BROUGHT THEM WITH ME TONIGHT, BECAUSE THEIR, THEIR PASSION AND THEIR DEDICATION TO THE CRAFT OF SOCIAL SCIENCE EDUCATION SHOWS THROUGH IN THE FACT THAT WE DON'T SHY AWAY FROM DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES AND PART OF THIS IMPLEMENTATION PLAN WOULD BE TO PROVIDE THEM WITH OPPORTUNITIES TO MEET REGULARLY, TO DISCUSS, TO COLLABORATE, TO TALK ABOUT WHAT'S COMING UP IN OUR CURRICULUM AND WHAT RESOURCES DO WE NEED TO FIND TO PROVIDE DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES, TO CHALLENGE STUDENTS TO THINK CRITICALLY, TO CHALLENGE THEIR ASSUMPTIONS, TO POKE HOLES IN VARIOUS ARGUMENTS. BECAUSE IF I HAD A FAST ENOUGH THUMB AND I CLICKED ALL THE WAY BACK TO THAT SKILLS SLIDE OF COLLEGE BOARD, ARGUMENTATION IS PART OF THE REQUIREMENT THAT SHOWS UP NOT ONLY IN THE STUDENT PROJECT, BUT ALSO THE EXAM. SO BEING ABLE TO SUPPORT AND DEFEND AN ARGUMENT, EVEN WHEN YOU DON'T AGREE WITH, IS AN ESSENTIAL SKILL THAT WE TEACH IN SOCIAL SCIENCES. AND SO THAT'S REALLY WHEN WE THINK ABOUT WHAT THESE TEACHERS ARE TALKING ABOUT. IT'S PROVIDING STUDENTS ALWAYS WITH MULTIPLE PERSPECTIVES AND GIVING AND GIVING THEM THE SKILLS TO BE ABLE TO EVALUATE THOSE PERSPECTIVES AND FORM THEIR OWN CONCLUSIONS THAT CAN BE SUPPORTED WITH EVIDENCE. IT'S EVEN HOW WE CHOOSE OUR STUDENTS FOR ASSIGNMENTS. SO, YOU KNOW, IN THE PAST I'VE DONE, SANFORD V SCOTT REENACTMENT. WELL, IF I FEEL A STUDENT IS SO FAR ON THE LEFT. OH, YOU'RE GOING TO DEFEND SANFORD. MR. HARRIS SAYS. OH, I KNOW, I KNOW, YOU'RE GOING TO BE YOU'RE GOING TO MAKE THIS ARGUMENT FOR SANFORD. AND THAT'S THE DISCIPLINE. ONE MORE QUICK ONE. DO YOU COVER THE TOPICS OF EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY, AFFIRMATIVE ACTION AND EVEN D D E EFFORTS? THE PROGRESS THAT'S BEEN MADE IN THOSE AREAS, YOU COVER THOSE OR DISCUSS THOSE YOU MENTIONED IN THE I DON'T BELIEVE SO IN THE CURRICULUM. NO, BUT THE CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1964 AND THEN I MEAN, BUT MY AP GOVERNMENT CLASS, WE COVER MORE OF THAT STUFF THAN WE THE SORT OF ADDENDUMS TO THE CIVIL RIGHTS ACT OF 1964, WHICH IS ALL THE EEOC AS. AND THAT'S REALLY WHERE WE WOULD SEE IN THAT POST EXAM UNIT THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THOSE THOSE CONVERSATIONS AND TO REALLY BE ABLE TO DIG INTO THE HISTORY BEHIND THESE CONVERSATIONS OF TRACING THE ROOTS BACK AND THEN LOOKING AT DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES AND EVALUATING THEM AND FORMING THEIR OWN OPINION, AND THEN TEACHING ONE ANOTHER THAT THAT WOULD BE A PLACE WHERE THAT COULD LIVE. YEAH, I JUST THINK IT WOULD BE GOOD IN THE MENU TO ADD SOME OF THESE SPECIFIC PEOPLE AND THE TOPICS THAT WEREN'T COVERED TO, TO GIVE KIDS KIND OF LIKE A LIST OR HERE'S SOME POSSIBLE THINGS THAT YOU COULD RESEARCH TO ADD SOME TOPICS TO THE MENU. WOULD THAT BE ACCEPTABLE? I CAN'T PROMISE THAT WE WOULD DO ANY SPECIFIC TOPICS, BECAUSE IT WOULD BE DRIVEN BY STUDENT CHOICE AND BY OUR TEACHERS KNOWLEDGE OF THEIR STUDENTS. SO YOU KNOW, SITTING HERE IN JULY OF 2024, I DON'T WANT TO MAKE A PROMISE THAT WE WOULD INCLUDE ANY ONE SPECIFIC TOPIC IN A LIST OF ITEMS FOR OUR STUDENTS, BECAUSE THAT'S NOT RELEVANT TO THE WORLD THAT OUR STUDENTS ARE GOING TO EXPERIENCE AT THAT POINT, NOR IS IT RELEVANT TO THE SPECIFIC STUDENTS THAT WOULD BE ENROLLED. WHAT I CAN SAY IS THAT WE WOULD FIRST AND FOREMOST, ALWAYS CENTER STUDENT CHOICE IN IN WHAT WE ARE OFFERING TO OUR STUDENTS, IN PROVIDING THEM WITH OPPORTUNITIES TO DIG INTO WHATEVER THAT TOPIC IS, AND THAT AMONG THOSE TOPICS, THOSE CERTAINLY COULD SHOW UP AND WE COULD HAVE A DEEPER CONVERSATION ABOUT WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE. BUT I WOULD NEVER PROMISE ANYTHING WITHOUT THE INPUT OF THESE TEACHERS BEING ABLE TO COLLABORATE TOGETHER. THEY ARE THE DECISION MAKERS. I UNDERSTAND IT'S A MENU. IT WOULD JUST BE LISTING SOME POTENTIAL THINGS THAT THE THEY MIGHT NOT KNOW. THERE'S SUCH A PERSON AS THOMAS SOWELL. UNLESS THEY GET A LITTLE LIST. THEY CAN CHOOSE IT OR NOT. I UNDERSTAND YOU'RE LETTING THEM CHOOSE. I THINK JUST TO UNDERSCORE MRS. LANG'S POINT IS WE STAND READY TO MAKE

[05:50:04]

A COMMITMENT TO BRINGING THAT VERY TOPIC BACK TO THE IMPLEMENTATION TEAM AND TO THE CURRICULUM TEAM TO MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE A WELL BALANCED SET OF TOPICS THAT A STUDENT COULD INVESTIGATE. BUT IN ABSENCE OF DOING THAT WITH TEACHERS, WE GIVE US SOME CONCERNS AND WE ARE NOT OPPOSED TO ANY TOPIC THAT THAT'S NOT OUR DISCIPLINE. WE'RE NOT AFRAID. WE'RE NOT OPPOSED, WE'RE NOT CONCERNED. WE GIVE THE KIDS THE INFORMATION AND WE HELP THEM GUIDE THROUGH AND PROCESS IT. AND WE DON'T GIVE THEM OUR OPINION. WE DON'T. WE'RE NOT OPPOSED TO ANY TOPIC AND ESCORT YOU TO MAKE THIS PLAY. I'M IN THE PROCESS NOW OF READING THIS PROJECT. 2025 MEMORANDUM. I DON'T WANT TO READ IT, BUT I HAVE TO BECAUSE AS A RESPONSIBLE EDUCATOR, I MUST BE PREPARED FOR ANYTHING THAT WALKS INTO MY CLASSROOM. SO FOR ME, I HAVE TO BE ON THE READY. AND AS MR. HARRIS SAID, I DON'T MIND CONTROVERSY AND MY STUDENTS WILL TELL YOU, BRING IT ON. I LOVE IT BECAUSE WHAT HAPPENS IS IT DRIVES CHILDREN TO DIG DEEPER AND THINK DEEPER. AND THAT'S WHAT I'VE ALWAYS BEEN ABOUT, IS THINKING, YOU CANNOT SURVIVE MY CLASS AND BE A LAZY THINKER. SO FOR ME, PERSPECTIVE IS ALWAYS CRUCIAL, ALWAYS SOMETHING THAT I DEMAND OUT OF MY KIDS. SO WHATEVER YOU WHATEVER ELSE YOU ADD, BRING IT ON. AND I WOULD ADD THAT THAT THAT NOTION OF PERSPECTIVE WILL BE A VERY PERVASIVE THEME THAT RESONATES THROUGHOUT ALL THE SESSIONS THAT MRS. LANE AND HER OFFICE WILL FACILITATE AMONG TEACHERS THROUGHOUT THE SCHOOL YEAR.

OKAY. THANK YOU. DOCTOR MILLER I'M GOOD. ANYBODY ELSE? THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING HERE AND FOR THIS CONVERSATION. I REALLY APPRECIATE IT, I WAS EXCITED TO HEAR THAT EVERY STUDENT PASSED THE EXAM. I WAS A LITTLE CONCERNED. I JUST WANTED YOUR THOUGHTS THAT ONLY SIX STUDENTS SAT FOR THE EXAM. DOES THAT SURPRISE YOU? DO YOU THINK THAT'S WHAT? JUST YOUR THOUGHTS.

HOW DO WE GET MORE STUDENTS TO HAVE THE CONFIDENCE TO SIT FOR IT RIGHT. IT'S I THINK YOU BROUGHT UP THE POINT OF IT'S TO FRAME SOME COLLEGE COSTS. AND I WAS SO WOULD HAVE HOPED MORE MORE KIDS AT THAT POINT. WE WERE WE HAD THE KIDS HAD TO MAKE A DECISION BY NOVEMBER. AND WE WERE WE WERE SUPER HONEST WITH THEM. WE SAID, HEY GUYS, THIS IS A PILOT COURSE. THERE'S A PRESENTATION AT THE END. DID I EVEN HAVE THE STANDARDS FOR THE PRESENTATIONS YET? AND COLLEGE DOESN'T HAVE TO DECIDE WHETHER OR NOT THEY ACCEPT THE CREDIT YET. SO THAT'S ANOTHER THING. I SAW THE ONLY 3 A.M. I RIGHT IN THAT THE ONLY THREE MARYLAND UNIVERSITIES ARE ACCEPTING THIS, THAT THAT WAS SURPRISING TO ME AS WELL. 350. THAT WAS JUST FOR THE I WAS JUST TALKING ABOUT THE STATE OF MARYLAND. I DON'T HAVE THE BREAKDOWN BY THE STATE OF MARYLAND. THERE WERE ONLY 3 OR 4 MARYLAND SCHOOLS. I DON'T KNOW THE LIST OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD. SORRY. THAT SURPRISED ME TOO. SO NOW IT'S AND I WILL I WILL TELL MORE KIDS OR I WILL ENCOURAGE MORE KIDS LIKE, HEY, THIS IS WHAT TO THINK ABOUT. THERE'S ACTUALLY A YOUNG LADY. AND I SAID, WELL, HEY, WHY DON'T WE WAIT A YEAR BEFORE WE DO IT? JUST BECAUSE NOW IT SEEMS TO HAVE MORE CONCRETE DIRECTION OF THINGS, BUT WE I DON'T EVEN THINK WE FULLY UNDERSTOOD THE PRESENTATION. NO, BECAUSE AT THE POINT AT THE TIME, AS YOU STATED, MR. HARRIS, IT'S THE FACT THAT WE HAD NO CONCRETE, IDEA OF WHAT THEY WERE GOING TO DO, BECAUSE AT ONE POINT WE DIDN'T HAVE ANY COLLEGES THAT WERE WERE BUYING INTO THE CREDITS, AND THEY WENT TO LATER THAT WE FOUND OUT THAT, SCHOOLS FROM NOW OPEN TO THE FACT OF, GIVING CREDIT TO STUDENTS WHO ACTUALLY PASSED THE EXAM, WAS THE THAT WAS JUST ANOTHER SITUATION. I TELL YOU, I'M ON I'M, I DON'T I, I APPRECIATE MY OWN. RIGHT. THE GOOD THING THIS IS THE GUYS WE GOT TO MAKE A DECISION TODAY. THIS IS WHERE WE ARE WITH THE TEST. WHAT DO YOU WANT TO DO? YOU THINK YOU'LL BE BETTER PREPARED GOING INTO THE SCHOOL YEAR? IT'LL PROBABLY BE ANOTHER YEAR BEFORE. I THINK NOW MORE. IT'LL BE THE SAME INFORMATION. HEY, GUYS. MORE COLLEGES ARE ACCEPTING IT. WE HAVE A BETTER UNDERSTANDING WHAT THE PRESENTATION IS. WE CAN START THINKING ABOUT THE PRESENTATIONS EARLIER BECAUSE BEFORE THE PRESENTATION WAS SUPPOSED TO BE THIS ELABORATE PAPER. AND THEN IT CAME BACK TO A PRESENTATION THAT WE WERE SO NOW IT'S LIKE, ALL RIGHT, GUYS, I'M NOT SURE WHAT YOU MEAN BY PRESENTATION. LIKE TO EDUCATORS ON WHAT THE EXAM, WHAT IS THAT THE STUDENT. SO THERE'S A PROJECT WE HAVE FOR THE PROJECT OKAY. YES. THEY HAVE A PROJECT THAT'S THAT'S COMING WITH THE EXAM. SO THEY HAVE TO DO THE PROJECT AS WELL AS EXAM. YES, I KNOW MINE TOO. YOU MIGHT SIMPLY MIGHT NOT BE IF I MAY, SIMPLY PUT SIMPLY PUT, THE COURSE WAS EVOLVING DURING THE 2023 2024 SCHOOL YEAR. THANK I JUST HAVE A QUICK QUESTION. SO STUDENTS ARE OR STUDENTS AND THEIR FAMILIES

[05:55:06]

ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR PAYING FOR THE AP EXAM, DO YOU FEEL LIKE THAT WAS A BARRIER OR THIS PAST YEAR OR MAYBE IN THE FUTURE, FOR STUDENTS TO WANT TO TAKE THE AP EXAM? IT WASN'T THIS YEAR. I DON'T THINK, BUT I DON'T KNOW IF THE RESOURCES ARE. SO SOMETIMES THERE'S RESOURCES FOR STUDENTS.

YEAH, WE HAVE A LOT OF STUDENTS THAT RECEIVE FEDERAL FORM. SO I DON'T KNOW WHAT I KNOW. THEY HAVE DIFFERENT RESOURCES AS OPPOSED TO KIDS THAT AREN'T I DON'T THINK RESOURCES WERE SUFFICIENT. I THINK IT WAS MORE JUST THE UNCERTAINTY. JUST THIS PAST SCHOOL YEAR, WE DID PAY FOR ANY STUDENT WHO RECEIVES FREE AND REDUCED MEALS TO TAKE AN AP TEST AT NO CHARGE. OKAY. GOT IT.

OKAY. IF THERE'S NO OTHER QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS, I CAN READ YOUR REQUEST THERE FOR A MOTION. ALTHOUGH I'M RECOGNIZING THAT THIS IS ACTUALLY A NEW AGENDA ITEM BECAUSE THERE HAVE BEEN, I GUESS, SOME RECOMMENDATIONS AND SOME MINOR CHANGES ON THE FRINGES. AND WITH THE FINAL PROJECT AND THINGS LIKE THAT. SO I'LL ACCEPT A, MOTION IN A SECOND THAT WE APPROVE THE REVISED CURRICULUM, WHICH INCLUDES THE CURRENT AND PROPOSED CHANGES AS PRESENTED TODAY. I MOVE THAT WE BRUCE. PERFECT. IS THERE A SECOND? SECOND? I'LL SECOND THE MOTION.

THANK YOU, MISS ROLLO. ROLL CALL. VOTE, PLEASE. YES YES, YE, YES YES YES. YES YES. YES. THIS MOTION PASSES. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. OKAY, SO YOU MIGHT AS WELL

[D. Revised Social Sciences 6 for Regular Status Decision, Ms. Erin Lange, Supervisor of Science, Ms. Heather Kutcher, Executive Director of Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment, and Mr. Andrew Renzulli, Director of Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment • Social Sciences 6 for Regular Status]

STAY UP HERE. I THINK WE GOT ONE MORE. SO WE'RE GETTING TO THE END OF IT, FOLKS, I PROMISE. ALL RIGHT. ITEM E, REVISED SOCIAL STUDIES. SOCIAL SCIENCES SIX FOR REGULAR STATUS DECISION. ANYBODY ELSE THAT YOU'RE CALLING UP? OKAY. PLEASE INTRODUCE THEM AS WELL. THEY'RE GETTING CRAZY. AND I'M CRAZY. I THINK WE CAN DO THAT. LAST. I HAVE ONE PERMANENT PROGRAM PRESENTATION. SO DO WE GO THERE? WE HAD A MEETING WITH OUR STUDENTS TO DO THIS. I WANT TO TRY TO DO THIS. OKAY. ALL RIGHT. YEP. SORRY. ONE QUESTION HERE. OUT OF THERE WE GO. ALL RIGHT, ALL RIGHT. SO CONTINUING. LAST ITEM FOR THE NIGHT FOR THE SUPERINTENDENT, REVISED SOCIAL STUDIES SIX. WELCOME. THANK YOU. MISS. NICE TO SAY GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE. GOOD MORNING, THIS IS OUR FINAL CURRICULUM THAT WE'RE BRINGING FORTH TONIGHT. SO, MR. RENZULLI, MRS. LANG AND I ARE HERE AGAIN. AND MRS. LANG IS GOING TO INTRODUCE TWO TEACHERS TO HELP WITH THE PRESENTATION ON SOCIAL STUDIES. SIX, THE HUMAN GEOGRAPHY COURSE. SO I HAVE WITH ME TODAY, THIS MORNING, MR. FISHER, BRIAN FISHER OF ABERDEEN MIDDLE SCHOOL AND ELIZABETH NEMETH. NEMETH RIGHT NOW, I'M HAVING A GREAT MIDDLE SCHOOL IN NOVEMBER. AND I HEARD THAT SHE WAS ONE OF OUR CPS TEACHER FINALISTS FOR 20, 20 YEARS AS WELL. SO QUICK BACKGROUND TO CONTEXTUALIZE US, WE HAVE A NEW FRAMEWORK IN THE STATE. IT WAS GIVEN TO US BY THE STATE AS A JANUARY 24TH BOARD MEETING OF 2024, AND SO IT'S A VERY RECENT DEVELOPMENT. IT WAS A FRAMEWORK WE ACTUALLY WERE ANTICIPATING FOR A WHILE, AND THERE WAS SOME HOLDUPS WITH THE CHANGE IN ADMINISTRATION AT MSBA. AND SO IT WAS SOMETHING THAT WAS LONG OVERDUE THAT WE HAD BEEN PLANNING FOR. AND THEN THERE WERE SOME DELAYS IN ACTUALLY APPROVING IT AT THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION LEVEL AND GETTING IT TO US. BUT IT IS A TWO YEAR HUMAN GEOGRAPHY COURSE, AND I'M GOING TO TURN IT OVER TO LIZ AND BRIAN. ALL RIGHT. SO WE JUST WANTED TO SHOW YOU THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY AND HUMAN GEOGRAPHY. JUST TO CLARIFY THE DIFFERENCES, PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY IS OFTEN WHAT PEOPLE THINK ABOUT WHEN THEY THINK ABOUT GEOGRAPHY, IT RELATES TO THE NATURAL ENVIRONMENT AND THE LANDSCAPE OF OUR PLANET. A LOT OF TIMES I TALK TO MY KIDS ABOUT IT'S WHAT'S ON THE EARTH'S SURFACE. IT'S THE LANDFORMS, THE BODIES OF WATER, THERE ARE QUESTIONS LIKE, WHAT HAPPENS WHEN A VOLCANO ERUPTS? HUMAN GEOGRAPHY

[06:00:05]

IS TAKING THE INTERACTION OF HUMAN ACTIVITY AND THE PLANET. SO THERE'S MORE INVOLVED, SO IT MIGHT BE WE'RE GOING TO GET MORE INTO IT, BUT IT MIGHT BE. HOW DOES THE EARTH, HOW HOW MIGRATES AND HOW DOES IT SHAPE HOW PEOPLE LIVE? SO EVEN THOUGH IT IS HUMAN, GEOGRAPHY IS THE FOCUS.

PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY IS STILL A PART OF THE ENTIRE PICTURE. SO IT BREAKS DOWN INTO THREE.

PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY IS THE FOCUS, BUT THAT'S STILL WITH WITH WHAT WE'RE DOING HERE. THAT'S STILL BEING BROUGHT UP IN WARM UPS, DISCUSSION BUILT INTO ACTIVITIES. SO IT'S NOT AN ISOLATED THING, PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY IS STILL VERY MUCH A PART OF WHAT WE DO. AND TEACHERS ARE TRAINED TO MEET THE NEEDS OF THEIR STUDENTS. SO IF THEY HAVE A DEFICIT IN PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY, THAT WILL BE A LITTLE BIT MORE OF AN EMPHASIS. BUT HUMAN GEOGRAPHY IS THE MAIN FOCUS. SO WE'VE DEVELOPED OUR CURRICULUM WRITING TEAM AS SOON AS WE ACTUALLY WHILE WE WERE ANTICIPATING THE FRAMEWORK AND ALL HONESTY, SO THAT AS SOON AS THAT FRAMEWORK WAS APPROVED BY THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION, WE PUT THAT PLAN INTO PLACE, WITH A CURRENT SIXTH AND SEVENTH GRADE SOCIAL SCIENCE TEACHERS REPRESENTING A NUMBER OF OUR MIDDLE SCHOOLS. AS WELL AS HIGH SCHOOL TEACHERS AND A MEDIA CENTER SPECIALIST TO PROVIDE DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES IN THE WRITING PROCESS. THE WRITING PRIORITIES AS WE OUTLINE THEM, WERE PRIMARILY TO ALIGN TO THE NEW FRAMEWORK, WHICH MEANT THAT WE WERE TAKING THE ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS FOR BATUM FROM THE FRAMEWORK. AND THEN WE TOOK THE FOCUS QUESTIONS TO. THAT WAS ACTUALLY A REQUEST OF OUR TEACHERS FROM FEEDBACK WE'VE RECEIVED FROM THEM OF OTHER CURRICULA TO INSTEAD OF HAVING STATEMENTS, ESSENTIAL INDICATORS THAT ARE WHAT WE SEE IN THE CURRICULUM, I'M SORRY, THE FRAMEWORK THAT THEY BE POSED AS QUESTIONS TO SUPPORT THAT INQUIRY PROCESS. AND SO WE CHANGED THE ESSENTIAL, I'M SORRY, THE INDICATORS AND OBJECTIVES FROM THE FRAMEWORK INTO ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS AND FOCUS QUESTIONS. BUT ALL OF THAT LANGUAGE IS VERBATIM OUT OF THE FRAMEWORK, WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE INDICATORS BEING POSED AS QUESTIONS. WE FOCUSED ON A VARIETY OF LEARNING EXPERIENCES AND ACTIVITIES, PROVIDING CHOICE TO TEACHERS. THAT WAS REALLY IMPORTANT TO US AS WE THINK ABOUT THE DIVERSE LEARNERS THAT ARE IN OUR CLASSROOMS, THAT THERE IS NO ONE SIZE FITS ALL. AND SO A CURRICULUM IS REALLY MEANT TO BE A REPOSITORY OR, A RESOURCES FOR OUR TEACHERS TO USE IN MAKING INFORMED DECISIONS ABOUT HOW TO SUPPORT THE DIVERSE NEEDS IN THEIR CLASSROOMS. SO AS OUR WRITERS WERE COLLABORATING WITH ONE ANOTHER TO CREATE THIS RESOURCE, WE FOCUSED ON A VARIETY OF LEARNING EXPERIENCES, ALWAYS INCLUDING DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES AND FOCUSING ON THOSE HIGH QUALITY RESOURCES, WHICH IS WHY WE FELT IT WAS SO IMPORTANT TO INCLUDE A MEDIA CENTER SPECIALIST ON THE TEAM. SO THE MAIN FOCUS OF THE OF THE FRAMEWORK HERE IS ONE IS ON MOVEMENT ACROSS THE PLANET, PEOPLE, GOODS, IDEAS, TRADE, MIGRATION, ETC. AND THEN HUMAN SYSTEMS AND HOW THEY DEVELOP FROM A HUMAN GEOGRAPHIC PERSPECTIVE. SO ECONOMIC, SOCIAL, POLITICAL AND CULTURAL SYSTEMS AND THEN ALSO HUMAN INTERACTIONS WITH THE ENVIRONMENT. SO OUR WE AND THE ENVIRONMENT ARE INTERDEPENDENT ON EACH OTHER. AND SO HOW DO WE MODIFY THE EARTH FOR THE THINGS THAT WE NEED AND WANT, AND HOW DO WE ADAPT TO THE EARTH AND THEN PLACE AND REGION, LOOKING AT WHAT MAKES CERTAIN AREAS, UNIQUE AND WHAT SHARED ATTRIBUTES THEY HAVE THAT ALLOW THEM TO BE CONSIDERED A REGION.

SO THE STATE STANDARDS ARE THE SAME ONES THAT WERE WE SAW EARLIER. BUT CIVICS, PEOPLES AND PEOPLES OF THE NATIONS AND THE WORLD, GEOGRAPHY, ECONOMICS, HISTORY AND SKILLS AND PROCESSES. SO THIS IS THROUGH ALL THE CURRICULUM AND SOCIAL STUDIES. THERE'S THAT STANDARD 6.0 FOR THE INQUIRY ARC, WHICH WE HAD DISCUSSED A LITTLE BIT. SO HOW HISTORY AND GEOGRAPHY AND EVERYTHING ELSE IN SOCIAL SCIENCES WORKS IS IT'S NOT JUST MEMORIZATION ANYMORE. IT'S NOT MULTIPLE CHOICE. IT'S IT'S EVOLVED TO TEACHERS PRESENTING TOPICS AND CAREFULLY SELECTED SOURCES, ALLOWING STUDENTS TO ANALYZE, ANALYZE, FOR BIAS, INTERPRET THE MATERIAL, AND COME TO THEIR OWN CONCLUSIONS AND THAT'S IN IN THE INQUIRY ARC WHERE WE CREATE COMPELLING QUESTIONS AND, HELP FIND SOURCE. WE APPLY THOSE CONCEPTS OF CIVICS, ECONOMICS, GEOGRAPHY AND HISTORY, BUT WE EITHER WE OR WITH THE HELP OF OUR MEDIA SPECIALISTS, OR ALLOWING BY ALLOWING STUDENTS TO FIND, GATHER AND FIND THEIR OWN SOURCES. AND WE TEACH STUDENTS HOW TO EVALUATE THOSE SOURCES FOR THINGS LIKE BIAS OR RELEVANCY AND RELIABILITY, AND THEN WE COMMUNICATE AND CRITIQUE CLAIMS AND, AND HAVE STUDENTS COMMUNICATE THOSE AND CRITIQUE THE CLAIMS AND TAKE ACTION BASED ON THE EVIDENCE THAT THEY HAVE FOUND. SO WHEN WE THINK ABOUT THE CONTENT FROM THE MSI FRAMEWORK, IT IS BEFORE YOU HER. AND THIS IS A TWO YEAR HUMAN

[06:05:02]

GEOGRAPHY COURSE. SO WHAT YOU SEE BEFORE YOU, THESE EIGHT UNITS REPRESENT TWO YEARS OF INSTRUCTION, SIXTH GRADE. AND SEVENTH GRADE. AS THE TEAM STARTED LOOKING AT THIS SCOPE AND SEQUENCE THAT THE FRAMEWORK OUTLINES WITH UNIT ONE, GEOGRAPHIC THINKING PROVIDING A FOUNDATION UPON WHICH TO BUILD. AND IT'S SERVING AS A BRIDGE FROM FIFTH GRADE US HISTORY INTO SIXTH GRADE. AND THEN WITH UNIT EIGHT BEING A US HISTORY FOCUSED BRIDGE INTO EIGHTH GRADE, THERE WAS SOME ROOM FOR FLEXIBILITY AND WHAT THE TEAM FOUND WAS THAT THERE WERE REALLY SOME FOUNDATIONAL PIECES THAT NEEDED TO BE TAUGHT OR WHAT WE WOULD CALL FRONTLOADED IN EDUCATIONAL JARGON. IN ORDER TO UNDERSTAND SOME OF THE OTHER UNITS. AND SO THE TEAM REQUESTED THAT WE, SWITCH UP THE SEQUENCE OF UNITS TO BE RESPONSIVE TO THE NEEDS OF THE STUDENTS. AND SO THAT'S WHAT THIS LOOKS LIKE ON YOUR SCREEN HERE IS, ACCORDING TO THE MSDE FRAMEWORK, UNITS ONE, TWO, THREE AND SIX NOW BECOME THE SIXTH GRADE CURRICULUM. AND WE DO HAVE THE FLEXIBILITY OF DOING THAT PER MSDE. SO WHAT'S CHANGING? WHAT'S CHANGING IS THAT ORIGINALLY IN THE OLD SOCIAL STUDIES CURRICULUM IN GRADE SIX, IT WAS KIND OF TOPICS TAUGHT IN ISOLATION THAT IT WAS KIND OF SMATTERING OF ALL OF THE TOPICS AND THEN IN SEVENTH GRADE, IT WAS A FOCUS ON ANCIENT WORLD HISTORY, SO IT WAS MORE OF THAT CHRONOLOGICAL HISTORY COURSE FROM PREHISTORY TO THE MIDDLE AGES, SO WHAT IS CHANGING IS THAT WE WILL NOW BE SPIRALING THE CONTENT AND SKILLS THROUGHOUT CURRICULUM, AND IT'S TAUGHT IN A THEMATIC WAY THAT WE'RE GOING TO EXPLAIN A LITTLE BIT MORE, IN THE NEXT COMING SLIDES. INSTEAD OF BEING TAUGHT IN ISOLATION AND APART FROM EACH OTHER. SO AS WE SAID THAT ALL THE MATERIALS FROM THE OLD SIX AND SEVENTH GRADE CURRICULA ARE STILL ACCOUNTED FOR, BUT ARE PRESENTED IN A MORE THEMATIC WAY. SO THIS IS THESE ARE THE OLD THIS IS UNITS ONE, TWO, THREE AND FOUR OF THE OLD SIXTH GRADE CURRICULUM. AND YOU CAN SEE GEOGRAPHIC TOOLS INTERPRETING MAPS, PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS, STUDY OF HUMAN CULTURE. BUT INSTEAD OF THIS JUST BEING AN ISLAND UPON ITSELF, IT'S MIXED IN WITH ACTUAL CULTURES. AND FOR UNIT FOR POLITICAL SYSTEMS. SO THAT'LL BE A BIG PART OF, UNIT FOUR FOR THE NEW CURRICULUM. SO, GOING OVER, YOU CAN SEE THE GREEN LINES UNDERNEATH, THE GREEN BARS UNDERNEATH, YOU CAN SEE WHERE YOU CAN FIND THAT INFORMATION IN THE NEW CURRICULUM. AND THEN SEVENTH, AS WELL, YOU CAN SEE THE ANCIENT CIVILIZATIONS, HOW IT WAS BROKEN DOWN BEFORE. AGAIN, ALL INCORPORATED. IF YOU GO TO THE LAST ONE, YOU CAN SEE ON THE OLD SEVENTH GRADE CURRICULUM, YOU SEE THE UNIT FIVE, UNIT SIX, THERE'S A FEW THINGS THAT AREN'T ACCOUNTED FOR, BUT THEY ARE ACCOUNTED FOR IN THE 11TH GRADE CURRICULUM FOR WORLD HISTORY, AND THEN THE FALL OF ROME, RESOURCES ARE BEING ADDED TO UNIT THREE OF THE POLITICAL UNIT. SO THE BYZANTINES, THE MIDDLE AGES, ALL OF THAT ARE STILL ACCOUNTED FOR. BUT IN 11TH GRADE, INSTEAD OF SIX. AND AS FAR AS WHAT'S NEW, YOU HAVE THE GREEN REVOLUTION, WHICH IS INCREASING FOOD PRODUCTION, REDUCED POVERTY AND HUNGER IN DEVELOPING NATIONS, AND THEN CLIMATE CHANGE, MORE TO THE MORE TO THE THEME OF HOW IT DEALT WITH THE FALL OF THE MAYAN EMPIRE, OR HOW IT DEALT WITH HOW THE MONGOLS, WHY THE MONGOLS LEFT MONGOLIA TO BEGIN WITH. SO THE CLIMATE CHANGE PLAYED AN INTEGRAL PART IN THAT. SO IT JUST SHOWS HOW IT'S PLAYED A PART THROUGHOUT HISTORY. SO WHAT'S NEW FOR SEVEN, FORTHCOMING IS, SEVENTH GRADE IS GOING TO DEAL WITH TRADE PANDEMICS, THE COLLAPSE OF EMPIRES. BUT IT ALSO ROUNDS OUT THE STUDENT EXPERIENCE THAT LEADS THEM DIRECTLY INTO THE EIGHTH GRADE US CURRICULUM, WITH PRE-COLUMBIAN CIVILIZATIONS, FIRST AMERICANS, TRANSATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE, COLONIAL AND NATIVE INTERACTIONS. SO IT'S GOING TO HAVE A MORE COHESIVE FLOW INTO THE EIGHTH GRADE CURRICULUM THAN IT DOES NOW. AND TO BE CLEAR THAT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE WOULD BE BRINGING TO NEXT SCHOOL YEAR, WE ARE DOING THIS ONE YEAR AT A TIME BECAUSE IT WAS THE BELIEF OF THE TEACHERS AND OF THIS OFFICE THAT STUDENTS NEEDED THE NEW SIX IN ORDER TO BE SUCCESSFUL IN A NEW SEVEN. AND SO IT WAS BENEFICIAL TO US TO BE ABLE TO ROLL IT OUT ONE YEAR AT A TIME. AND THAT WAS SOMETHING THAT WE WERE PROVIDED WITH SOME FLEXIBILITY TO DO, SO THE SIXTH GRADE SCOPE AND SEQUENCE IS IN FOUR UNITS, AS YOU CAN SEE THERE, EACH OF THESE UNITS IS GUIDED BY AN ESSENTIAL QUESTION.

AND UNIT ONE IS A BRIDGE FROM FOURTH AND FIFTH GRADE US HISTORY, SO THAT IT WILL KIND OF HELP STUDENTS TO TAKE THE KNOWLEDGE THAT THEY HAD IN FOURTH AND FIFTH AND APPLY IT, AND ALLOW TEACHERS TO UNDERSTAND WHAT WHAT IS NEEDED TO MOVE FORWARD. THIS IS A SCOPE AND

[06:10:03]

SEQUENCE APPROACH. SO THE UNITS ARE BUILT ON COMPELLING GEOGRAPHIC QUESTIONS. THE CONTENTS OF EACH UNIT IS A CASE STUDY THROUGHOUT HISTORY, IT BUILDS BROAD, DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES ON HUMAN, GEOGRAPHIC THEMES. SO ONE THING THAT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT EVEN AT ME AS A SEVENTH GRADE SOCIAL STUDIES TEACHER IS LIKE, WHAT IS THAT GOING TO LOOK LIKE? I'M SO USED TO TEACHING IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER. BUT AN EXAMPLE THAT WAS ON THE FIRST SLIDE, BUT THAT I WANT TO BRING BACK TO YOUR ATTENTION IS, LOOKING AT HUMAN INTERACTION WITH THE ENVIRONMENT. WE'RE LOOKING AT THINGS LIKE THE NEOLITHIC REVOLUTION AND RIVER VALLEY CIVILIZATIONS, BUT THEN ALSO LOOKING AT INDUSTRIALIZATION AND URBANIZATION, THEN TO THE GREEN REVOLUTION AND THEN TO CLIMATE CHANGE AND CLIMATE RESILIENCE.

SO IT'S A NEAT WAY OF LOOKING AT IT AGAIN, THEMATICALLY, AT, AT A TOPIC AND SEEING IT IN DIFFERENT PARTS THROUGHOUT HISTORY, THE FOUNDATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC THINKING SKILLS, INCLUDING PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY, ARE SPIRALED AND EMBEDDED THROUGHOUT EACH UNIT. SO WHEN WE THINK ABOUT THIS CURRICULUM DOCUMENT, I THOUGHT IT WAS APPROPRIATE AND IMPORTANT TO STRESS WHAT'S INCLUDED AND WHAT'S NOT. SO A CURRICULUM DOCUMENT IN CANVAS INCLUDES THINGS LIKE THE REQUIRED ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS, INDICATORS AND OBJECTIVES FROM MSDE. SOME OF OUR PARTNERS AND OTHER LEAS ACTUALLY JUST PROVIDE THAT TO THEIR TEACHERS. THEY SAY, HERE'S THE FRAMEWORK. GOOD LUCK, WHAT WE DO TO HELP TEACHERS ABOVE AND BEYOND THAT IS TO PROVIDE PACING RECOMMENDATIONS. SO HOW MANY DAYS SHOULD AN EXPERIENCE TAKE IDEAS OF HOW TO APPROACH TEACHING STUDENTS THE KNOWLEDGE AND THE SKILLS THAT THEY NEED TO BE ABLE TO ANSWER THOSE ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS, INDICATORS AND OBJECTIVES, WE INCLUDE IDEAS FOR HOW TO MEASURE WHAT STUDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO DO AND WHAT THEY SHOULD KNOW. RESOURCES THAT COULD BE USED TO APPROACH THE WAY A TEACHER TEACHES THE ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS. SO THAT COULD BE AN ARTICLE, AN IMAGE, A LESSON STEM, EVERY ONCE IN A WHILE WE LUCK OUT AND THERE'S A MORE FULLY FLESHED OUT LESSON THAT'S BEEN DEVELOPED THAT WE CAN ADAPT, AND INFORMATION TO HELP TEACHERS CONTEXTUALIZE THAT REQUIRED EXPERIENCE. SO THAT MIGHT BE LETTING TEACHERS KNOW, HEY, THIS IS SOMETHING STUDENTS HAVE LEARNED BEFORE, SO MAYBE PRE-ASSESS THEM TO START TO GET A BASELINE OF WHERE STUDENTS ARE. AND YOU MIGHT BE ABLE TO ACCELERATE THAT LEARNING, OR YOU MAY HAVE TO DO SOME RETEACHING, BUT WITH THE CURRICULUM DOCUMENT DOES NOT INCLUDE, IS KNOWLEDGE OF SPECIFIC STUDENTS IN EACH CLASS. SO KNOWING THEIR LIFE EXPERIENCES, THEIR LEARNING DIFFERENCES BEFORE AS AN IEPS, IF THERE ARE AN EMERGENT MULTILINGUAL LEARNER, BACKGROUND KNOWLEDGE OF GAPS IN AREAS OF STRENGTH, COMFORT LEVEL WITH SPECIFIC ACTIVITIES. SO IF YOU HAVE A LOT OF STUDENTS THAT DON'T WANT TO HAVE A DISCUSSION, YOU'RE PROBABLY NOT GOING TO DO A FULLY FLEDGED SOCRATIC SEMINAR ON DAY ONE. YOU'RE GOING TO NEED TO DO SOMETHING THAT IS A LITTLE MORE ACCESSIBLE TO THEM, MAYBE A WRITTEN DISCUSSION OR A SILENT DISCUSSION. IT ALSO DOESN'T INCLUDE KNOWLEDGE OF WHAT'S WORKED ON OR WORKED IN THE PAST.

SO YOU KNOW, DOES THIS GROUP HAVE A COMFORT LEVEL WITH VERBAL DISCUSSION? DID THEY JUST DO A GALLERY WALK? SO MAYBE THERE'S A GALLERY WALK IN THE CURRICULUM, BUT YOU CREATED A GALLERY WALK LAST WEEK. PROBABLY NOT GOING TO WANT TO DO THAT AGAIN BECAUSE WE WANT TO PROVIDE THAT VARIETY OF EXPERIENCES FOR OUR STUDENTS. IT DOESN'T CONTEXTUALIZE THE LEARNING, SO DOESN'T TALK ABOUT WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE SCHOOL BUILDING, WHERE STUDENTS ARE IN THEIR OTHER SUBJECT AREAS, AND HOW YOU MIGHT BE ABLE TO PROVIDE THAT CROSS CURRICULAR CONNECTION OR WHAT NORMS EXIST IN YOUR CLASSROOM. AND THEN IT ALSO DOESN'T INCLUDE THAT CONTENT EXPERTISE. AND OUR TEACHERS FROM OUR LAST PRESENTATION DEMONSTRATED THAT FAIRLY WELL. WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE TO HAVE THAT DEPTH OF CONTENT EXPERTISE TO BE ABLE TO TAKE WHAT IS WRITTEN AND TURN IT INTO SOMETHING TRULY MEANINGFUL FOR OUR STUDENTS. SO WE DO KNOW THAT THE BIG FOCUS HERE WAS ON THE ITEMS OF FEEDBACK FROM THE BOARD AND REALLY BEING RESPONSIVE TO THAT, IN PARTICULAR WITH SOCIAL SCIENCE. SIX OF THE 71 PIECES OF FEEDBACK THAT WERE PROVIDED ON JULY SECOND, 65 OF THEM WERE RELATED TO THE SOCIAL SCIENCE SIX CURRICULUM, ADDITIONALLY, WE RECEIVED AROUND 150 TO AROUND 175 DISCRETE PIECES OF FEEDBACK. BETWEEN THAT INITIAL FEEDBACK THAT WAS PROVIDED ON JULY 2ND AND AS LATE AS 430 TODAY IN AN EMAIL, OF THAT INFORMATION, 62% OF THE ORIGINAL FEEDBACK, AROUND 40 ITEMS OR EXACTLY 40 ITEMS WAS DIRECTLY DIRECTED TO THE OLD CURRICULUM, AS WAS DISCUSSED EARLIER IN THE BOARD MEETING, OF THOSE REMAINING ITEMS, THE 25 WERE DIRECTED AT THE NEW CURRICULUM. THREE WERE ABOUT MATERIALS THAT WERE ACTUALLY INTENDED FOR OUR CURRICULUM WRITERS, SO THEY WERE NOT ONES THAT WOULD APPEAR TO OUR CLASSROOM TEACHERS, BUT RATHER WERE FOR THE PURPOSES OF DEVELOPING THE CURRICULUM AND WILL BE REMOVED THEN PRIOR TO IT BEING PUSHED TO TEACHERS. AND THAT INCLUDES A SAMPLE MODULE THAT WAS INTENDED JUST AS A MODEL FOR FORMATTING AND LANGUAGE PURPOSES. AND IT IS NOT PART OF THE GEOGRAPHY CURRICULU.

SO OF THAT FEEDBACK, WE WANTED TO ADDRESS SOME SPECIFIC ITEMS, AND WE TRIED TO ORGANIZE THEM INTO BIG BUCKETS. THE FIRST IS A PORTRAYAL OF COMMUNISM AND THE IDEA THAT BOARD MEMBERS WERE

[06:15:03]

CONCERNED THAT OUR PRESENTATION OF COMMUNISM AND SOCIALISM WAS TOO POSITIVE, SO I WENT INTO THIS EXPERIENCE AND DOVE DEEP INTO THE ESSENTIAL QUESTION AND INDICATORS AND EVALUATED THE LEARNING EXPERIENCE, MATERIALS THAT WERE PROVIDED BY THE CURRICULUM WRITERS IN THAT FIRST PASS, KNOWING THAT WE DO HAVE THAT TEAM THAT IS CONTINUING THIS PROCESS THROUGHOUT THE MONTH OF JULY, SO THAT ESSENTIAL QUESTION OF HOW DID CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMIES CONNECT AND DIVIDE PEOPLE? THERE ARE THREE INDICATORS OR FOCUS QUESTIONS. THE FIRST OF WHICH IS ABOUT THE PHILOSOPHY BEHIND CENTRALLY PLANNED ECONOMIES. AND SO IT IS JUST ABOUT THE IDEAS OF MARX AND ENGELS AND HOW IT OUTLINED COMMUNISM AS A PHILOSOPHY. AND THAT'S WHERE I KNOW MISS ALVAREZ, IN PARTICULAR, HAD CALLED OUT EARLIER IN THE MEETING ABOUT THE CONCERN THAT WE PORTRAY, THAT WE SAY THAT COMMUNISM DOESN'T EXIST, AND THAT IS NEVER OUR INTENTION, AND IT'S NOT SOMETHING WE WOULD SAY TO STUDENTS, BUT RATHER WE WOULD TALK ABOUT THE IDEA THAT MARX AND ENGELS, AS THEY OUTLINED THIS PHILOSOPHY, IT WAS NEVER IMPLEMENTED. AND THAT'S NOT TO SAY THAT IT WAS GOING TO BE SUCCESSFUL WHEN IT WAS IMPLEMENTED. WE KNOW IT HAS NOT BEEN SUCCESSFUL IN IMPLEMENTATION, AND THERE'S PLENTY OF EXAMPLES OF THAT IN THE CURRICULUM. HOWEVER, MY EVALUATION OF THE LEARNING EXPERIENCES THAT WERE PROVIDED TO STUDENTS SHOWED THAT WHILE THERE WAS A STRONG FOCUS ON THAT FIRST INDICATOR, INDICATORS TWO AND THREE, I BELIEVE WE CAN MAKE MORE ROBUST. AND THERE WERE SOME SPECIFIC WAYS THAT I SAW THAT HAPPENING, AND I DID PROVIDE THAT FEEDBACK DIRECTLY TO THE BOARD IDENTIFYING, WAYS THAT WE WILL SPECIFICALLY BE ADDRESSING THIS, INCLUDING IDENTIFYING SOME NEW RESOURCES, ADJUSTING SOME OF THE READINGS THAT WERE PROVIDED BY OUR OUR WRITERS TO STRENGTHEN THOSE NEGATIVE CONNOTATIONS AND REALLY ADDRESS THE FACT THAT COMMUNISM IS IMPLEMENTED, HAS HISTORICALLY AND RATHER CONSISTENTLY LED TO HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS AND SO WE ARE GOING TO BE BEEFING UP, FOR LACK OF A BETTER WORD, THAT INDICATOR TWO AND THREE, TO ENSURE THAT THE PRESENTATION OF COMMUNISM IS NOT JUST ONE OF THE PHILOSOPHY OF COMMUNISM, BUT HOW IT ACTUALLY LOOKS IN IMPLEMENTATION HISTORICALLY AROUND THE GLOBE. THE NEXT CONCERN WAS ABOUT VERY SIMILAR OUR PORTRAYAL OF CAPITALISM AS BEING TOO NEGATIVE. AND THERE WAS A SUGGESTION FROM BOARD MEMBERS, FROM THAT FEEDBACK THAT WE SHOULD FOCUS ONLY ON THE MAIN IDEA OR OBJECTIVE OF ANALYZING THE ROLE OF CAPITALISM IN SPURRING INNOVATION AND CREATING WEALTH, TO SHOW NOT ONLY HOW CAPITALISM CONNECTED OR DIVIDED PEOPLE, BUT ALSO HELPED THEM. SO THEY WERE QUOTING FROM THAT ESSENTIAL QUESTION OF HOW DID CAPITALISM CONNECT OR DIVIDE PEOPLE? AND THERE ARE FOUR FOCUS QUESTIONS, AND I AM BEING A VISUAL PERSON, HAVE COLOR CODED THEM, THE FIRST TWO GREEN REALLY ARE SEEN AS VERY POSITIVE PORTRAYALS OF CAPITALISM, AND AN ANALYSIS OF THE PRINCIPLES OF CAPITALISM, INCLUDING PRIMARY SOURCE READINGS FROM ADAM SMITH, AS WELL AS HOW THE ROLE OF CAPITALISM, SERVED IN SPURRING INNOVATION AND CREATING WEALTH, INCLUDING OPPORTUNITIES FOR OUR STUDENTS TO EVALUATE ENTREPRENEURS. HISTORICALLY INTERVIEW BUSINESS OWNERS IN OUR COMMUNITY AND PRESENT THEIR FINDINGS TO ONE ANOTHER. HOWEVER, WHAT I DID NOTICE WAS THAT INDICATORS THREE AND FOUR, REQUIRED SOME ADDITIONAL RESOURCES TO STRENGTHEN THEM, ESPECIALLY INDICATOR THREE, WHICH HAS BOTH POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE CONNOTATIONS, OF POTENTIAL IMPACTS, THAT WE COULD REALLY STRENGTHEN AND SO THERE WAS ONE PARTICULAR ACTIVITY RELATED TO INDICATOR THREE. AND THEN A SIGNIFICANT A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF CHOICES FOR INDICATOR FOUR. AND SO INDICATOR THREE IS REALLY WHERE I HAVE INSTRUCTED THAT CURRICULUM WRITING TEAM THAT'S WORKING THROUGH JULY TO BE RESPONSIVE TO THIS FEEDBACK TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL RESOURCES THAT ARE GOING TO PROVIDE MORE BALANCED PORTRAYALS OF, IN INDICATOR THREE, WHICH DOES GET US THEN TO OUR NEXT ITEM OF CONCERN OR, FEEDBACK FROM THE BOARD, WHICH WAS A CONCERN THAT THERE WAS A DIRECT CONNECTION BETWEEN CAPITALISM AND IMPERIALISM. SETTLER COLONIALISM, SO THERE WAS A CONCERN ABOUT THE FACT OR ABOUT THE IDEA THAT THIS WAS, PRESENTED AS FACT, THAT THERE WAS THIS CONNECTION BETWEEN CAPITALISM AND IMPERIALISM OR SETTLER COLONIALISM. SO, AGAIN, SAME LANGUAGE ON YOUR SCREEN. BUT WHAT I REALLY HAD TO DIG INTO AND DISSECT WAS, INDICATORS THREE AND FOUR, WHICH REALLY LOOK AT THE POLITICAL, ECONOMIC, SOCIAL AND CULTURAL IMPACTS OF IMPERIALISM. AND ALSO HOW COMMUNITIES THEN RESPOND TO OR RESIST IMPERIALISM AND SETTLER COLONIALISM. SO IT PROVIDES STUDENTS WITH AN OPPORTUNITY TO STUDY THE IMPACTS AND RESPONSES TO IMPERIALISM AND COLONIALISM, AND TO CONSIDER WAYS IN OR TO CONSIDER IN WHAT WAYS CAPITALISM COULD BE A FACTOR IN THAT. I WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR, BECAUSE I KNOW THAT OVER THE COURSE OF THE WEEKEND THAT SOME OF THE EMAILS THAT WENT BACK AND FORTH WERE NOT CLEAR. WE ARE NOT TEACHING THAT IMPERIALISM AND COLONIALISM ARE AN INEVITABLE OUTCOME OF CAPITALISM, BUT RATHER EVALUATING THE EXTENT TO WHICH THERE IS A CORRELATION AND

[06:20:01]

PROVIDING STUDENTS WITH OPPORTUNITIES TO EVALUATE WHAT CONNECTION EXISTS AND TO WHAT EXTENT THAT CONNECTION EXISTS. OTHER ITEMS OF FEEDBACK INCLUDED SOME DISCRETE, INSTANCES OF YOUTUBE VIDEOS THAT HAD ADS PLAYING PRIOR TO THEM, WHEN THOSE VIDEOS ARE PROVIDED DIRECTLY TO STUDENTS, THEY ARE EMBEDDED IN CANVAS. AND CANVAS DOES FILTER OUT THE ADS THAT PRECEDE VIDEOS. HOWEVER, WE WERE ABLE TO IDENTIFY THAT THERE WERE A COUPLE INSTANCES WHERE THOSE VIDEOS, THE WAY THAT THEY WERE EMBEDDED, AND I DON'T WANT TO GET INTO ALL THE SPECIFICS, BUT THE WAY THAT THEY WERE EMBEDDED, DID NOT, ACTIVATE THAT CANVAS FILTERING. AND SO WE HAVE GONE IN AND FIXED THOSE. SO BASICALLY IT'S A MATTER OF EMBEDDING IT AS AN EXTERNAL LINK OR AN EXTERNAL TOOL. IF IT'S AN EXTERNAL TOOL CANVAS THEN IS ABLE TO FILTER OUT THAT AD. IF IT'S A LINK, IT'S JUST A LIVE LINK LIKE ANY OTHER. AND THEN IT LINKS OUT TO YOUTUBE. AND SO THAT IS WHAT WE SAW. AND WE HAVE RECTIFIED THAT, THERE WAS ALSO A CONCERN ABOUT NEWSELA BEING A BIASED SOURCE WHO DOES NOT PAY FOR NEWSELA. THERE WAS ONE ARTICLE THAT A CURRICULUM WRITER HAD BROUGHT OVER FROM A PREVIOUS VERSION OF A CURRICULUM THAT THEY HAD TAUGHT THAT THEY HAD SAVED AS A PDF AND WANTED TO INCLUDE IN THIS CURRICULUM. HOWEVER, THAT WOULD BREAK COPYRIGHT SINCE NEWSELA IS A PAID SUBSCRIPTION, AND SO THAT WAS REMOVED, AND THERE ARE NO OTHER NEWSELA RESOURCES THAT ARE INCLUDED. ADDITIONALLY, THERE WERE NINE SPECIFIC INSTANCES OF CONCERNS OVER A SPECIFIC RESOURCE. OF THOSE, SIX, RESOURCES WERE ONES THAT COULD EITHER BE MODIFIED OR REPLACED TO ADDRESS A SPECIFIC CONCERN. SO FOR EXAMPLE, A VIDEO ABOUT CLIMATE VERSUS WEATHER AND DIFFERENTIATING THOSE TWO. AND THERE WERE SOME STATEMENTS THAT WERE MADE IN THAT VIDEO THAT CONCERNED A BOARD MEMBER. THE PURPOSE OF THE VIDEO WAS TO TEACH STUDENTS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CLIMATE AND WEATHER. AND SO WE WERE ABLE TO FIND ADDITIONAL VIDEOS TO REPLACE THAT VIDEO, ONES THAT EXPLICITLY AND DIRECTLY JUST ADDRESS THE ISSUE OF WHAT IS CLIMATE AND WHAT IS WEATHER AND WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE. THERE WERE THREE RESOURCES THAT WERE ALIGNED TO ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS AND FOCUS QUESTIONS THAT ARE EITHER A.GOV RESOURCE OR, IN ONE INSTANCE, A NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC RESOURCE THAT WERE DEEMED CREDIBLE AND THAT HAD NO REPLACEMENT OPTION.

AND SO THOSE WILL REMAIN IN THE CURRICULUM. THERE WAS A CONCERN ABOUT MARYLAND STATE SOCIAL STUDIES STANDARDS BEING WEAK IN CONTENT, SPECIFICALLY ABOUT AMERICAN CIVIL PROCESS. AND SO THERE WAS A SUGGESTION ABOUT EITHER CHANGING THE LANGUAGE OR POINTING OUT WHERE THAT CONTENT DOES LIVE. OBVIOUSLY, WITH A MARYLAND STATE SOCIAL SCIENCE STANDARDS OR SOCIAL STUDIES STANDARDS BEING REGULATED BY COMAR, WE CANNOT CHANGE THE LANGUAGE. HOWEVER, THERE IS A ROBUST EVIDENCE OF THE WAYS WE TEACH THE AMERICAN CIVIL PROCESS, INCLUDING A QUARTER LONG CIVICS UNIT IN GRADES ONE THROUGH THREE. SO EVERY YEAR, GRADES ONE THROUGH THREE, STUDENTS GET A WHOLE QUARTER OF CIVICS IN WHICH THEY LEARN THINGS LIKE HOW TO BE A RESPONSIBLE CITIZEN, HOW LEADERS IN A DEMOCRACY ADDRESS THE WANTS AND NEEDS OF THE PEOPLE THEY SERVE, TOOL THE TOOL OF VOTING AS PART OF CIVIC LIFE. HOW TO INTERACT WITH LOCAL CIVIC AND COMMUNITY LEADERS, INCLUDING OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS TO WRITE TO CIVIC LEADERS AS APPROPRIATE. TO IDENTIFY COMMUNITY HELPERS IN THE EARLIEST PRIMARY GRADES. SO THE WAYS THAT COMMUNITY SUPPORTS AND, PROVIDES OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS TO INTERACT WITH COMMUNITY IN GRADES FOUR AND FIVE, THEN THAT CIVIL PROCESS IS EMBEDDED THROUGH THAT SPIRAL, A SPIRALED FORM OF THE HISTORICAL STUDY OF THE FRAMING OF THE CONSTITUTION, AMONG OTHER HISTORICAL US HISTORY TOPICS. I LIKE TO BRAG ON THIS ONE IN PARTICULAR, BECAUSE WE COLLABORATED TO CREATE A SIMULATION IN WHICH STUDENTS GET TO ACT AS LEGISLATORS AND DEBATE IN ORDER TO CREATE A BILL, A POTENTIAL BILL AS PART OF THEIR LEARNING AROUND THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS. GRADE EIGHT CONTINUES WITH THAT LENS OF AN HISTORICAL STUDY OF US HISTORY. AND IT IS ASSESSED. AND SO THERE ARE SPECIFIC SKILLS RELATED TO THAT, THAT SPECIFICALLY ADDRESS STANDARD 1.0. AND LASTLY, WE HAVE A FULL YEAR OF HIGH SCHOOL, US GOVERNMENT, A YEAR LONG STUDY ALSO ASSESSED, IT PROVIDES TOPICS RANGING FROM THE FOUNDATIONAL PRINCIPLES OF AMERICAN DEMOCRACY. I'VE GOT GREAT HAND SIGNALS WITH CHECKS AND BALANCES AND FEDERALISM, SHARED POWERS. AS WELL AS HOW THOSE THINGS THEN SHOW UP IN THE SPECIFIC THREE CO-EQUAL BRANCHES OF GOVERNMENT AT THE LOCAL, STATE AND NATIONAL LEVEL. WE ALSO STUDY INFLUENCES ON GOVERNMENT DECISIONS AND ACTIONS, INCLUDING THE WAY THAT BOTH INDIVIDUALS AND GROUPS CAN INFLUENCE THE GOVERNMENT. AND SO THOSE ARE ALL THE AREAS WHERE WE DO SEE THAT STANDARD 1.0 IN ACTION, THOUGH IT IS NOT AS ROBUST IN OUR HUMAN GEOGRAPHY COURSE. THERE WERE ALSO CONCERNS ABOUT TEACHING ANTHROPOGENIC OR HUMAN INDUCED CLIMATE CHANGE. THIS IS EXPLICIT LANGUAGE IN THE FRAMEWORK THAT CAN'T BE MODIFIED, AND I HAVE BOLDED THOSE TWO INDICATORS THAT ARE RELATED TO SPECIFICALLY CALLING OUT HUMAN CAUSED, HUMAN CAUSED CLIMATE CHANGE, UNDER THE ESSENTIAL QUESTION OF HOW DOES CLIMATE CHANGE FORCE HUMANS TO LIVE DIFFERENTLY? SO THE

[06:25:01]

ESSENTIAL QUESTION IS VERY BROAD AND DOES NOT NECESSARILY REQUIRE STUDENTS TO EVALUATE HUMAN CAUSED CLIMATE CHANGE. HOWEVER. INDICATOR ONE WHAT ARE THE ORIGINS OF HUMAN CAUSED CLIMATE CHANGE? AND INDICATOR FOUR WHAT ARE THE LOCAL, REGIONAL AND GLOBAL ATTEMPTS TO ADAPT TO OR MITIGATE THE EFFECTS OF HUMAN CAUSED CLIMATE CHANGE ARE EXPLICITLY CALLED OUT. I'VE ALSO INCLUDED ON YOUR SCREEN THE NUMBER OF DAYS THAT WE HAVE ALLOTTED TO EACH EXPERIENCE RELATED TO THOSE INDICATORS, WHICH REPRESENTS THE 1.6% OF ALL OF THE INSTRUCTIONAL DAYS THAT STUDENTS EXPERIENCE, AND 3.5% OF ALL THE OBJECTIVES IN THE FRAMEWORK. AND SO WHILE I KNOW THAT THAT PARTICULAR CONCERN, COULD NOT NECESSARILY BE COMPLETELY, RESOLVED, I AM HEARTENED BY THE FACT THAT WE'RE ONLY TALKING ABOUT 1.6% OF THE INSTRUCTIONAL DAYS. HOWEVER, WE ALSO DO WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE, MUCH LIKE OUR GENTLEMAN DID WITH AP AFRICAN AMERICAN, THAT WE ARE ALWAYS OPEN TO ACKNOWLEDGING THAT THERE ARE CONTROVERSIES THAT EXIST. WE WOULD REALLY NOT BE PREPARING OUR STUDENTS FOR THE WORLD IN WHICH THEY LIVE IF WE WERE NOT ACKNOWLEDGING THE FACT THAT THEY'RE GOING TO GO HOME, AND POTENTIALLY EVEN THEIR PARENTS ARE GOING TO SAY, I DON'T KNOW THAT I BELIEVE THAT. LET'S TALK ABOUT THAT. AND SO WE NEED TO PREPARE OUR STUDENTS FOR THAT AND CAN ACKNOWLEDGE THAT IN THE EXPERIENCE. AND SO I HAVE DIRECTED THE WRITERS TO FIND WAYS TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT IN A WAY THAT STILL ALIGNS WITH AND SUPPORTS THE TEACHING OF THE FRAMEWORKQUIRED. SO WHEN WE THINK ABOUT OUR NEED FOR NEW, OBVIOUSLY THE FIRST AND FOREMOST IS THAT IT IS A REQUIREMENT OF THE STATE THAT WE ALIGN TO THE FRAMEWORKS, AND THERE IS, AS IT'S BEEN MENTIONED TODAY OR YESTERDAY, AS THE CASE MAY BE AT THIS POINT, FUNDING TIED TO IT, BUT IT GOES BEYOND JUST THAT. THIS PROVIDES FOR A COHESIVE FLOW OF CONTENT BETWEEN ELEMENTARY AND MIDDLE SCHOOL. AND SO I REALLY WOULD LIKE MY TEACHERS HERE TO, TO SPEAK A LITTLE MORE TO WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE. AND ITS IMPORTANCE. SO CURRENTLY, GRADES ONE THROUGH FIVE HAVE EFFICIENCY, FOCUS AS WELL AS, YOU KNOW, ESPECIALLY SINCE HIGH SCHOOL IN OUR SEQUENCE SIX AND SEVEN ARE KIND OF THE ISLANDS UPON THEMSELVES. ARE JUST SIT APART IN ISOLATION WITH THE SWITCH. IT'LL BE A MORE COHESIVE FLOW FROM RACE ONE. ALL THE TIME. AND THEN, ONE OF THE REASONS THAT THIS NEEDS TO CHANGE IS THAT THE NEW CURRICULUM IS MORE, DIRECTLY RELATED TO THE SKILLS THAT ARE NEEDED TO BE SUCCESSFUL ON THE STATE MCAT STATE, EXCUSE ME, THE STATE MCAT GRADE EIGHT ASSESSMENT. AND THESE SKILLS ARE IMPORTANT TO AID IN STUDENT EMPLOYABILITY IN ALIGNMENT WITH THE NORTH STAR INITIATIVE, ADDITIONALLY, I JUST WANT TO, YOU KNOW, KIND OF SPEAK TO HOW IT'S SO IMPORTANT THAT OUR CURRICULUM DOES CHANGE BECAUSE AS I TEACH A CURRICULUM RIGHT NOW THAT'S VERY HISTORICALLY, IT'S CHRONOLOGICAL IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER, AND WE'RE JUST WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HISTORY. THIS CURRICULUM WILL REALLY ALLOW US TO EMBED THAT INQUIRY ARC, WITH MORE FIDELITY AND ALLOW STUDENTS TO LOOK AT TWO SIDES OF A, OF A PERSPECTIVE AND UNDERSTAND, BOTH SIDES AND BE ABLE TO HAVE A DISCUSSION, ONE OF THE STRATEGIES THAT, THE OFFICE OF SOCIAL SCIENCE HAS TAUGHT US ABOUT IS DELIBERATION.

AND I'VE EVEN EXPLAINED TO MY STUDENTS THE IMPORTANCE OF ME LEARNING THAT EVERY DISCUSSION DOESN'T HAVE TO BE A DEBATE, THAT IT CAN BE A DELIBERATION WHERE WE ARE, IN UNDERSTANDING OF BOTH SIDES AND THAT WE ARE ABLE TO TAKE THAT INFORMATION AND HAVE A DISCUSSION, STUDENTS KIND OF TAKE THEIR SIDE AND TALK ABOUT IT. THEN THEY TALK ABOUT THE OTHER SIDE, AND BUT MY FAVORITE PART ABOUT A DELIBERATION IN THIS TIME OF, POLITICAL ISOLATION IS THAT A DELIBERATION ASKS STUDENTS TO TRY TO COME TO SOME SORT OF CONSENSUS, COME TO SOME SORT OF IDEA OF WHAT THEY CAN DO TO MAKE, MAKE, YOU KNOW, FIGURE OUT THE ANSWER TO THEIR QUESTION. IS IT A IS IT SOME TYPE OF, COMPROMISE? IS IT DID DO THEIR DISCUSSION. THEY, THEY LEAN TO ONE SIDE OR THE OTHER AND THE DISCUSSIONS THAT MY STUDENTS HAVE HAD WITH THIS ARE REMARKABLE, THERE IS ONE TOPIC THAT WAS RELATED TO ANCIENT HISTORY, ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT, ARTIFACTS SHOULD BE RETURNED TO THEIR COUNTRY OF ORIGIN AND WHAT STUDENTS CAME UP WITH ON THEIR OWN ABOUT WHERE THEY SHOULD GO BASED ON THE EVIDENCE. THERE WAS NO CLEAR, RIGHT ANSWER. AND THEY ALL HAD DIFFERENT OPINIONS. AND IT WAS BEAUTIFUL. I DIDN'T HAVE THE RIGHT ANSWER, AND THEY WERE ABLE TO COME UP WITH WHAT THEY THOUGHT SOLUTIONS COULD BE. SOME OF THEM WERE GIVING IDEAS ABOUT, WELL, IF, YOU KNOW, IF IT'S FROM THIS CERTAIN TIME PERIOD ON, THEN IT SHOULD BE RETURNED. BUT

[06:30:02]

OTHERWISE IT SHOULDN'T. IT WAS JUST REMARKABLE TO SEE WHAT OUR STUDENTS ARE DOING. AND BY MY MINDSET CHANGING, BEING ABLE TO FACILITATE DISCUSSIONS THAT LEAD ALL STUDENTS, EVEN WITH DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES, TO COME TOGETHER AND COME TO SOME TYPE OF COMPROMISE, SO I THINK THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE GOING TO SEE WITH THIS NEW CURRICULUM IS THAT ABILITY TO EMBED MORE OF THAT, INQUIRY AND ALLOWING STUDENTS TO COME UP WITH THEIR OWN PERSPECTIVES ABOUT HISTORY AND, AND WHAT'S GOING ON. AND OH, SORRY, THIS COULDN'T COME AT A BETTER TIME CONSIDERING THAT YOUR BLUEPRINT COMING NEXT YEAR, WE HAVE EXTRA TIME SEVERAL DAYS AND SOMETIMES GETTING INTO DISCUSSIONS WITH STUDENTS, YOU HAVE TO CUT THEM OFF AS THE NEXT CLASS, BUT THIS WILL ALLOW THEM TO REALLY DIVE DEEP INTO SUBJECTS THAT THAT WE WERE DISCUSSING DURING THIS CLASS AND WHAT THEY'RE ALLUDING TO, AND POLITELY NOT SAYING IS THAT THIS CURRICULUM THAT WE CURRENTLY HAVE IN PLACE THAT WE ARE ASKING TO REPLACE WITH THE ONE WE ARE PRESENTING NOW IS REALLY OUT OF DATE, AS WE CLEARLY HAVE DISCOVERED THROUGH THIS COLLABORATIVE PROCESS AND SOMEWHAT MESSY PROCESS OF YOU ALL HAVING THE OPPORTUNITY TO SEE BOTH OLD AND NEW, THAT THIS OLD CURRICULUM WAS FIRST WRITTEN IN 20, 20 YEARS AGO AND BASICALLY WHAT HAPPENED WAS THE STATE WENT TO A MANDATORY FRAMEWORK SYSTEM. THEY REWROTE OUR STATE STANDARDS, AND THEN THEY WENT ABOUT REWRITING ALL OF THE FRAMEWORKS FOR SOCIAL STUDIES. AND AS THEY DID A SURVEY OF ALL OF THE LEE'S FOR ALL THE DIFFERENT SUBJECT AREAS, THEY FOUND THAT SIX AND SEVEN WERE THE MOST DISPARATE IN TERMS OF THE 24 LEE'S AND WHAT THEY TAUGHT. ALMOST EVERYBODY TAUGHT EIGHTH GRADE US HISTORY, AND THAT BECAME SOLIDIFIED WITH THE ADVENT OF AT THE EIGHTH GRADE LEVEL FOR SOCIAL STUDIES, THERE WAS AN UNDERSTANDING OF THE THREE COURSES THAT WERE OFFERED IN HIGH SCHOOL. BUT IN SIX AND SEVEN ACROSS THE STATE, IT LOOKED DIFFERENT. AND SO THEY KICKED THE PROVERBIAL CAN DOWN THE ROAD FOR QUITE SOME TIME. AND SO WHAT WE HAVE NOW IN PLACE IS A REALLY OLD CURRICULUM. THERE WERE, SOME ADJUSTMENTS THAT WERE MADE WHEN WE TRANSITIONED TO ITS LEARNING, AND THAT'S WHERE SOME OF THOSE LINKS THAT WERE SINCE BROKEN, WEBSITES THAT WERE DEFUNCT, THAT YOU ALL ENCOUNTERED THERE, THAT'S REALLY WHERE OUR TEACHERS ARE STRUGGLING RIGHT NOW. AND WHAT THESE TEACHERS ARE VERY POLITELY TRYING TO DANCE AROUND IS THE IDEA THAT THIS IS REALLY NEEDED. SOME OF THE EXAMPLES THAT THEY USED ARE ONES THAT THEY HAVE DEVELOPED THEMSELVES TO USE IN THEIR CLASSROOMS, AND THAT'S A LOT OF EXTRA WORK FOR TEACHERS WHEN WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE THEM WITH SOMETHING THAT ALIGNS TO THE STATE STANDARDS, ALIGNS TO THE FRAMEWORK, AND ALIGNS TO OUR NEW SCHEDULE. AND SO WHEN WE THINK ABOUT WHAT TEACHERS NEED AND WHAT WE ARE GOING TO OFFER AS SUPPORT, FIRST OF ALL, WE KNEW THAT THIS WAS COMING. AND SO LAST SCHOOL YEAR, WE PROVIDED AN INTRODUCTION TO THE SCOPE AND SEQUENCE DURING OUR MARCH PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT DAY, WE ASKED TEACHERS FOR FEEDBACK THEN, AND THAT HELPED US TO BE RESPONSIVE TO THEIR NEEDS, BOTH IN THE SHORT TERM. SO PROVIDING RESOURCES AND INFORMATION TO THEM IN THE SHORT TERM, BUT ALSO PROVIDING FOR THAT LONG TERM PLAN, DURING DEPARTMENT SHARE TIME, BOTH OF MY TEACHERS HERE THAT ARE WITH ME TODAY, OUR DEPARTMENT CHAIRS, WE HAVE WHAT IS CALLED LEADERSHIP HUDDLE. AND THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR OUR DEPARTMENT CHAIRS TO BRING PROBLEMS OF PRACTICE AND STRUGGLES THEY'RE HAVING IN THEIR BUILDINGS TO THE GROUP AS A WHOLE WHERE THEY CAN PROBLEM SOLVE TOGETHER. AND SO WE HUDDLED UP ON THIS IDEA OF WHAT DO TEACHERS NEED AS SUPPORTS. AND SO WE USED THAT DATA AS WELL TO FORMULATE OUR IMPLEMENTATION PLAN, WHICH AT THIS POINT WE'RE HOPING WE CAN STILL OFFER THOSE CURRICULUM SNEAK PEEKS, TIME IS RUNNING SHORT, BUT WE ARE HOPEFUL. WE ALSO CURATED RESOURCES TO HELP OUR TEACHERS WITH, BACKGROUND KNOWLEDGE AROUND THESE TOPICS, BECAUSE WE KNOW SOME OF OUR TEACHERS MAYBE HAVEN'T TAUGHT HUMAN GEOGRAPHY BEFORE, OR MAYBE THEY DON'T KNOW AS MUCH ABOUT THE NEOLITHIC REVOLUTION. AND SO SHOUT OUT TO, MRS. KATE PRICE, MY CURRICULUM SPECIALIST, WHO SPENT A LOT OF TIME CURATING PODCASTS, BOOKS AND OTHER ARTICLES TO PROVIDE TO TEACHERS TO SAY IF YOU'RE CONCERNED ABOUT UNIT ONE, EXPERIENCE TWO. HERE'S SOME RESOURCES TO BUILD YOUR CAPACITY AROUND THE CONTENT BEFORE WE EVEN GET TO THE PEDAGOGY. THEN WHEN WE GET INTO SCHOOL YEAR 2425 COMING UP IN JUST OVER A MONTH, IT'S A LITTLE TERRIFYING, WE HAVE DESIGNATED PD TIME THAT WILL FOCUS EXCLUSIVELY ON NEW CURRICULUM SUPPORT AND FACILITATED COLLABORATIVE PLANNING. AND ALSO MY CURRICULUM SPECIALIST OFFERS OFFICE HOURS.

SO THIS IS SCHOOL EMBEDDED PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT THAT IS DIFFERENTIATED FOR OUR TEACHERS.

SO SHE ASKS OUR TEACHERS IN ADVANCE WHAT THEIR NEEDS ARE. AND SHE SPENDS AN ENTIRE DAY IN OUR SCHOOLS WITH OUR TEACHERS BEING RESPONSIVE TO THOSE NEEDS. AND SO THAT WILL BE ANOTHER WAY THAT WE CAN SUPPORT OUR TEACHERS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THIS. AND THEN THE EVALUATION PIECE, MUCH LIKE APA, WE WILL BE DOING CLASSROOM OBSERVATIONS AND WALKTHROUGHS AND ENGAGING WITH OUR BUILDING ADMINISTRATORS ON THOSE FORMAL OBSERVATIONS. WE'RE ALSO GOING TO BE IMPLEMENTING SURVEYS FOR OUR TEACHERS TO GET REGULAR FEEDBACK THAT WE CAN BE RESPONSIVE TO, SO THEY CAN SAY, HEY, THIS THIS EXPERIENCE IS A LITTLE SHAKY HERE. I FEEL LIKE I COULD USE A LITTLE MORE SUPPORT

[06:35:04]

HERE AND WE CAN BE RESPONSIVE TO THAT. BECAUSE OF THIS DYNAMIC CURRICULUM MANAGEMENT SYSTEM. WE ALSO WANT TO GET OUR PERSPECTIVES OF OUR STUDENTS AND THOSE WE DON'T HAVE STUDENTS WITH US FOR THIS PARTICULAR PRESENTATION BECAUSE IT IS NEW CURRICULUM, BUT WE DO WANT OUR STUDENT VOICES HEARD. AND SO WE WANT TO GET FEEDBACK FROM STUDENTS. AND WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S NOT DISRUPTIVE TO STUDENT NEEDS THAT IT'S RESPECTFUL OF PARENT CONCERNS ABOUT SURVEYS. I KNOW THAT THAT'S ALWAYS A CONCERN ABOUT THE NUMBER OF INSTRUCTIONAL MINUTES THAT ARE LOST WITH THAT, BUT ALSO JUST BEING ABLE TO HAVE CONVERSATIONS WITH OUR STUDENTS WHEN WE'RE IN CLASSROOMS. AND WE LIKE TO SIDLE UP TO THEM AND SAY, WHAT ARE WE LEARNING TODAY? WHAT'S GOING ON? AND THAT PROVIDES SOME OF THE MOST ROBUST FEEDBACK THAT WE EVER GET, AND THEN MUCH LIKE APA ASKING FOR ARTIFACTS OF STUDENT WORK SO THAT WE CAN MEASURE THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THIS CURRICULUM WITH FIDELITY AND BE RESPONSIVE TO IT BY PROVIDING ADDITIONAL PD AS NECESSARY. AND SO I BELIEVE THAT THIS REQUEST WILL NEED TO BE MODIFIED ON THE FLY AS WELL. BUT WE ARE OFFICIALLY AT THE REQUEST AND QUESTIONS PART. AND SO THE REQUEST IS FOR APPROVAL OF REGULAR STATUS FOR THIS MODIFIED CURRICULUM. AND AT THAT POINT I WILL TAKE QUESTIONS ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. APPRECIATE IT. WE'LL OPEN IT UP FOR BOARD MEMBER QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS. AGAIN, I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR THE EFFORT. THERE'S OBVIOUS, YOU KNOW, A LOT OF EFFORT THAT WENT INTO ADDRESSING THE CONCERNS OF THE BOARD. SO I REALLY WANT TO, YOU KNOW, PUT PUT PUT THAT OUT UP FRONT THAT I APPRECIATE THAT.

BUT MOST OF THE BOARD MEMBERS HAD A PASSWORD UPDATE AND I DON'T KNOW, BUT I'M KIND OF SUSPECTING THAT MY COMPUTER DID NOT POPULATE BECAUSE WHAT I WAS LOOKING AT YESTERDAY WAS VERY DIFFERENT THAN WHAT I'M SEEING TODAY. SO I HAVE SOME CONCERNS THAT I HAVEN'T HAD A CHANCE TO LOOK AT THE WORK THAT YOU'VE DONE, WHAT I LOOKED AT YESTERDAY LOOKED LIKE A LOT OF THE MODIFICATIONS WERE DONE IN HASTE, AND SO I'M SUSPECTING IT DIDN'T POPULATE PROPERLY, OR THERE WERE SOME GLITCHES. SO I WOULD LIKE, YOU KNOW, TO HAVE SOME OPPORTUNITY, TO LOOK AT THE WORK THAT YOU'VE DONE. WE HAVEN'T UPDATED YOUR CANVAS COURSE. THE ONLY UPDATE I MADE IN PARTICULAR WAS TO LABEL CLEARLY THE OLD VERSUS THE NEW CURRICULUM, THE WORK THAT THE WRITERS ARE DOING IN THE MONTH OF JULY HAS NOT BEEN POPULATED. THAT IS SOMETHING THAT, YOU KNOW, FROM OUR FIRST ITEMS OF FEEDBACK OF 71 ITEMS OF FEEDBACK ON JULY 2ND. TILL NOW, WE HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO FINISH THAT WORK. WELL, I CAN WHAT I'M LOOKING AT HERE IS DIFFERENT FROM WHAT I'M SEEING AT HOME. SO JUST I'M NOT ENTIRELY. I WOULD HAVE TO HELP YOU WITH THAT, I GUESS BEHIND THE SCENES AT SOME POINT, BECAUSE THE ONLY UPDATE THAT WAS MADE TO YOUR CANVAS COURSE WAS TO MORE CLEARLY LABEL THE OLD CURRICULUM AS OLD AS I COMMUNICATED TO EVERYBODY WITH THOSE SCREENSHOTS OF HOW TO NAVIGATE CANVAS THROUGH MODULES. AND POPULATING THAT OLD LABEL.

SO I WOULD NEED TO GET WITH YOU ONE ON ONE TO LOOK AT WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE. WE'LL DO THAT. YEAH.

I MAY CALL AND TRY TO DO THAT ALSO. SO WHAT WHAT PERCENT IS THIS CURRICULUM COMPLETE NOW? WHAT WHAT ELSE HAS TO BE DONE? ALL OF THE ITEMS THAT WE HAVE SAID THAT WE WILL DO, WE NEED TO DO. OKAY. SO THE CHANGES ON TO ADDRESS OUR CONCERNS ARE IN THAT BUCKET. YES THEY ARE. THEY'RE IN THE PROCESS OF BEING DONE, NOTHING HAS BEEN UPDATED. AND YOUR CANVAS COURSE IN TERMS OF ACTUALLY POPULATING EDITS TO WHAT YOU HAVE IN CANVAS, OKAY. SO WHAT'S THE PLAN THEN TO PUT THAT INTO OUR CANVAS COURSE AS WELL? OR HOW WOULD WE GET ACCESS TO THAT. WOULD YOU MIND REPEATING THAT QUESTION. HOW WILL WE GET ACCESS TO LOOKING AT THE CURRICULUM WITH THE CHANGES? SO AS YOU MAKE UPDATES, YOU KNOW, BASED ON WHAT'S BEEN PROPOSED, WILL THE BOARD BE ABLE TO SEE THAT IN CANVAS? I THINK WE CAN CERTAINLY WORK WITH THE SUPERINTENDENT TO END HIS DIRECTIVE ON HOW WE CAN BEST COMMUNICATE THAT WITH ALL OF YO, BECAUSE WE WOULD DO A MOTION BASED ON WHAT YOUR WHAT'S BEEN DONE IN PART, BUT ALSO WHAT YOU PROPOSED IN PART. RIGHT. AND SO I GUESS THE QUESTION IS, WILL THE BOARD BE ABLE TO SEE THE FINAL PRODUCT TO ENSURE ONCE YOU KNOW, WE AGREED ON WAS DONE AND TO BE ABLE TO SEE IT IN CANVAS? I THINK THAT'S TO SOME DEGREE THAT'S OFTEN WHAT I MEAN WHEN WE MAKE CHANGES AT THE DAIS, I MEAN THE EXPECTATION WE HAVE A RECORD THAT THAT'S THE CHANGE WE'RE MAKING AND IT'S A COMMITMENT TO DOING IT. SO I LET ME REPHRASE IT. IS CANVAS GOING TO BE IS THAT LIKE WE'VE SEEN A VERSION IN CANVAS THAT WE'VE LOOKED AT

[06:40:03]

OVER THE PAST COUPLE OF WEEKS, RIGHT. AS YOU MAKE THESE CHANGES, WILL CANVAS ALSO BE UPDATED OR. NO. OR IS THAT LIKE COMPLETELY DIFFERENT? THEY'RE COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. SO WHAT THE ONLY PEOPLE THAT HAVE ACCESS TO THE FULL CURRICULUM AND THE EDITS IN LIFETIME ARE ME, MY CURRICULUM SPECIALIST, AND THE WRITERS THAT ARE IN THAT TEMPLATE IS WHAT IT'S CALLED.

THEY ARE ENROLLED AS TEACHERS IN THAT TEMPLATE, AND ONCE THEIR WORK IS COMPLETED, THEY WILL BE UNENROLLED, SO OUR CURRENT ALL OF OUR CURRENT SIXTH GRADE TEACHERS, THEY DO NOT HAVE ACCESS TO THIS RIGHT NOW. AND WHAT YOU HAVE IN YOUR COURSE IS SOMETHING THAT WAS COPIED OVER FROM THAT TEMPLATE INTO YOUR COURSE. SO WILL THE BOARD BE ABLE TO SEE THE FINAL PRODUCT IN CANVAS OR ANY OTHER FORMAT THAT YOU FIND EASY TO PRODUCE? ONCE THOSE FINAL EDITS ARE MADE, I DON'T SEE ANY REASON WHY THAT WOULD NOT BE VIEWABLE ON YOUR END. OKAY, MAYBE THIS I THROUGHOUT THIS CONVERSATION TONIGHT, I'VE WANTED TO CLARIFY SOMETHING AND I THINK THIS IS PROBABLY THE RIGHT TIME FOR THA. CANVAS IS A LEARNING MANAGEMENT SYSTEM. IT'S NOT A CURRICULUM MANAGEMENT SYSTEM EXCLUSIVELY. IT HAS MANY, MANY OTHER RESOURCES THAT IT MANAGES.

STUDENTS CREATES STUDENTS, HISTORICAL RECORDS, THE MATERIALS THAT TEACHERS ARE BUILDING IN AN ONGOING WAY. ANYONE WITH FULL ACCESS TO CANVAS HAS FULL ACCESS TO ALL THAT INFORMATION. THERE IS NO LET ME SAY IT A FEW TIMES. THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS READ, ONLY ACCESS IN CANVAS. WE'VE SAID THAT TO THE BOARD, BUT STILL, NEARLY EVERY MEETING THERE'S SOMEONE WHO SAYS WE NEED READ ACCESS. CANVAS DOES NOT HAVE THAT CURRICULUM, DOESN'T GET PRODUCED IN THAT FORMAT. IT GETS PRODUCED AS A SERIES OF INTERACTIVE THINGS WITHIN A LEARNING MANAGEMENT SYSTEM THAT COVERS THE WHOLE PROCESS OF LEARNING AND GIVING ANYONE FULL ACCESS TO THAT, BUT ALSO GIVE THEM ACCESS TO ESSENTIALLY ALL STUDENTS CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION AND ANYTHING ONGOING IN CLASSES. AGAIN, ABSOLUTELY NOT SOMETHING APPROPRIATE FOR ANYONE WHO COULD GET IN THERE, WHO DOESN'T A HAVE ACCESS TO ALL STUDENTS CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, BUT B DOESN'T KNOW WHAT PRESSING THIS BUTTON COULD DO TO A WHOLE TEACHER'S CLASS OR RECORDS OR EVERYTHING. SO ANOTHER THING I WOULD LIKE TO CLARIFY. WHEN WE GO BACK TO THE DATA ON. THE QUESTIONS THAT WERE ASKED, WE FIND THE YOU HAVE THE PERCENTAGES HERE. 62% IN THE OLD CURRICULUM, THERE WAS INSTRUCTION ON WHAT TO LOOK AT AND WHAT NOT TO LOOK AT, BUT IT'S CONFUSING AND THAT'S UNDERSTANDABLE, RIGHT? THAT WAS PART OF THE GUIDANCE THAT AARON PROVIDED EARLY ON. HERE'S WHAT YOU SHOULD BE LOOKING AT. BUT AGAIN 40 ITEMS CAME IN ABOUT WRONG INFORMATION. WHAT THAT SAYS TO ME IS IT'S A LOT TO LEARN. THESE SYSTEMS. NEVER ONCE HAS A BOARD MEMBER BEEN TOLD THEY CAN'T SEE SOMETHING. BUT OUR PROCESS FOR DECADES HAS BEEN TO DO IT WITH SOMEONE FROM THE CURRICULUM TEAM TO WALK YOU THROUGH IT SO YOU KNOW WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING AT. THAT'S NOT ENOUGH TO HIDE SOMETHING. IT'S NOT AN EFFORT TO NOT BE TRANSPARENT. IT'S AN EFFORT TO ENSURE YOU'RE LOOKING AT THE RIGHT THINGS. AND WE CAN ANSWER QUESTIONS IN CONTEXT AND THIS TEAM, PARTICULARLY THE THREE ON MY LEFT, HEATHER, ANDY, AARON HAS SPENT A GREAT DEAL OF TIME DOING THAT BECAUSE WE DO VALUE THE PERSPECTIVE THE BOARD HAS TAKEN. YOU KNOW, THE YOU KNOW, THE FOCUS ON THE CURRICULUM. AND I THINK, YOU KNOW, IN BOTH DISCUSSIONS TONIGHT, WE FOUND ITEMS THAT WHERE WE COULD MAKE MODIFICATIONS TO IMPROVE THE OUTCOME FOR STUDENTS. BUT IT'S BEEN SAID FOR MANY MEETINGS IN A ROW, AS IF THE SUPERINTENDENT OR SOMEONE IN THE ADMINISTRATION WAS TRYING TO WITHHOLD INFORMATION FROM THE BOARD MEMBERS FOR SOME PURPOSE. IT'S ABSOLUTELY NOT TRUE. I READ ONLY VERSION OF CANVAS, DOESN'T EXIST. WE CANNOT PRODUCE ONE. WE WOULD HAVE TO CHANGE A LEARNING MANAGEMENT SYSTEM. WE WOULD HAVE TO WRITE OUR CURRICULUM IN A DIFFERENT FORMAT. AND THEN SO WE ARE TRYING. TO PRODUCE CURRICULUM, TO TAKE THE CURRICULUM THAT WE'RE BUILDING FOR OUR TEACHERS AND FOR OUR STUDENTS, AND TRYING TO PUT IT INTO A FORMAT THAT MAKES IT POSSIBLE FOR YOU TO BE ABLE TO SEE IT, BUT IT'S NOT IDEAL AND IT'S NOT SOMETHING WE'VE DONE BEFORE. AND WE'LL CONTINUE TO LEARN AND WE'LL CONTINUE TO DO BETTER WITH THAT. AND BUT, YOU KNOW, WE'VE DISCUSSED THIS

[06:45:04]

BEFORE, BUT I THINK WE SHOULD PROBABLY PUT THAT OUT HERE TONIGHT. ALSO THAT I THINK WE DO NEED TO GO THROUGH A PROCESS AS A GROUP SIMILAR TO WHAT WE DID WITH THE WITH THE, LIBRARY SELECTION PROCESS THAT MISS STRAUSS HELPED WITH, BECAUSE, YES, BACK MAPPING SO THAT WE CAN PRESENT YOU WITH COMPLETELY FINISHED PRODUCTS WOULD BE LOVELY. AS YOU HEARD, THE FRAMEWORK CAME FROM MSDE IN JANUARY. THAT WOULDN'T HAVE BEEN POSSIBLE, PARTICULARLY CONSIDERING WE TABLED THIS DISCUSSION SINCE MAY, AND SO I DO THINK IT WOULD BE AN OUTSTANDING EXERCISE FOR US TO ENGAGE IN TO COME TO SOME AGREEMENT ON A PROCEDURE. IT DOESN'T NEED TO BE A POLICY, BECAUSE IT'S AN AGREEMENT THAT WE NEED TO COME TO SORT OF OPENLY. AND IF WE DON'T AGREE, THEN WE REVISIT IT. BUT TO TALK ABOUT WHAT WILL BE THE ROLE OF THE BOARD, WHAT WILL BE THE ROLE OF THE SCHOOL SYSTEM, WHAT WOULD BE THE PRODUCT WE PRODUCE AND SHARE, AND FRANKLY, I MEAN, YOU'VE YOU'VE LOOKED AT THREE VERY DIFFERENT CURRICULA TONIGHT. YOU KNOW, THE WOMEN IN PERSPECTIVE COURSE, VERY MINIMAL EXPECTATIONS FROM THE STATE FOR THAT. SOCIAL STUDIES SIX THE OPPOSITE, ADVANCED PLACEMENT, AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES. AGAIN COMPLETELY DIFFERENT BECAUSE IT'S AN OUTSIDE RESOURCE. WE'VE REALLY COVERED THE GAMUT TONIGHT ALL IN ONE CONTENT AREA. AND SO WE WILL WORK AND I THINK WE CAN DO THIS TOGETHER. WE'VE WE'VE DONE IT ONCE. IT WILL TAKE A MINUTE TO, TO PRODUCE A PLAN FOR HOW WE'RE GOING TO COME TO THESE DECISIONS, BUT I GUESS I'VE JUST HEARD THE COMMENTS TOO MANY TIMES AS IF SOMEONE IN MY ADMINISTRATION IS TRYING TO WITHHOLD INFORMATION FROM BOARD MEMBERS, AND THAT'S JUST NOT ACCURATE. AND SO WE HAVE NO INTEREST IN HIDING INFORMATION. WE WILL MAKE SURE YOU ALL GET THAT. AND WE'RE VERY COMMITTED TO FINDING IT. I MEAN, AGAIN, THE PROCESS IS GETTING BETTER.

AND, BUT THIS IS A HUGE DEPARTURE FROM WHERE WE'VE BEEN, WHERE WE'VE BEEN IN PAST YEARS.

AND THAT'S OKAY. WE'LL STRENGTHEN OUR, OUR PRODUCTS. BUT I JUST WANTED TO SORT OF CLARIFY THAT BECAUSE IT HAS BEEN BREWING FOR A LONG TIME, AND I THINK, I'VE BEEN AMAZED AT WHAT THIS TEAM'S BEEN ABLE TO DO. AND I KNOW, I MEAN, DOCTOR POINT AND YOU, WE'VE TALKED A LOT ABOUT THEY PUT A LOT OF WORK IN. WE KNOW THAT WE'RE NOT, YOU KNOW, SO EVERYONE NEEDS TO HEAR THAT.

AND THANK YOU. DISCOVER YEAH. I DO ACCEPT THAT. I DO APPRECIATE THAT. OKAY. WE CAN'T, ACCESS STUDENT RECORDS, AND I'M NOT SAYING CANVAS IS THE ONLY OPTION FOR THAT, BUT I AND I APPRECIATE YOUR SAYING THAT WE NEED TO COME TOGETHER AND AGREE ON PROCEDURE AND A PLAN FOR HOW TO COME TO A DECISION ON HOW TO SHARE THE INFORMATION SO THAT THAT THAT'S GOOD. BUT I'D LIKE TO BE A PART OF THAT. AND I STILL THINK OUR GOAL NEEDS TO BE I WANT TO HAVE A WHOLE UNDERSTANDING OF ALL THE CURRICULUM AND HOW IT'S ALL RELATED. THERE'S A LOT OF STATEMENTS MADE TONIGHT THAT THERE'S COHESIVE FLOW NOW BETWEEN, GRADE ONE THROUGH FIVE AND GRADE 11. AND, YOU KNOW, THAT'S GREAT. I'D LIKE TO UNDERSTAND IT. AND THEN THAT WAY WHEN THERE'S A NEW CURRICULUM DECISION THAT COMES OR SOMETHING'S GOING TO CHANGE, I ALREADY HAVE THAT BACKGROUND AND IT'S TOUGH TO SIT. YOU ALREADY SPENT ENOUGH TIME. I KNOW YOU DO TO SIT THERE WITH ME. IT WOULD TAKE MORE THAN TWO HOURS, BECAUSE SOCIAL STUDIES IS JUST ONE AREA. THERE'S A LOT OF AREAS. SO. AND I KNOW OTHER PEOPLE FEEL THE SAME WAY. SO, YOU KNOW, AS LONG AS WE HAVE THE GOAL TO SHARE THAT INFORMATION TO DETERMINE HOW TO BEST DO IT AND THE COMMITMENT TO DO IT, I'LL I'LL BE SATISFIED WITH THAT. THANK YOU. I JUST WANT TO SAY, ERIN, YOUR POISE AND YOUR, STATURE AND BEING ABLE TO ANSWER ALL THESE QUESTIONS AND DO THIS PRESENTATION AT 115 IN THE MORNING IS AMAZING. AND I CAN'T TELL YOU HOW MUCH I APPRECIATE ALL THE WORK YOU'VE DONE TO GET TO THIS POINT, I'M PRETTY CLEAR ON WHAT'S GOING ON. AND I THINK JUST TO KIND OF ANSWER ONE OF THE THINGS YOU WERE SAYING, MRS. COKER WOULD BE LOOKING AT THE MSDE FRAMEWORKS AND SEEING WHAT'S TAUGHT AT EACH GRADE LEVEL MIGHT HELP SOME FOR YOU TO SEE THE FLOW OF THIS FRAMEWORK.

BUT I'M JUST SAYING THE FRAMEWORKS KIND OF GIVE YOU THAT SCOPE AND SEQUENCE AS YOU GO THROUGH. SO THANK YOU. ANYBODY ELSE? THANK YOU, THANK YOU. WELL, THANKS. NO OTHER QUESTIONS. NO I THANK YOU, DOCTOR BOLTON, FOR WALKING US THROUGH THAT. I THINK THERE IS MISCOMMUNICATION ABOUT WHAT YOU'RE GETTING ACCESS TO, WHAT YOU'RE NOT ONLY FROM. I ONLY

[06:50:03]

SPEAK FROM MY FOXHOLE. RIGHT. WHAT YOU'RE GETTING THIS. YOU'RE NOT GETTING THAT. THERE'S OLD, THERE'S NEW. SO I'M A BIG BELIEVER IN HOW THE LIBRARY WORKERS WORKED. THAT WAS DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES. I THINK WE CAME OUT WITH A GOOD PRODUCT, I WOULD REALLY LIKE TO MAKE THAT A GOAL FOR THIS. YOU KNOW, WHAT DO WE EXPECT TO SEE THIS. SO. SO THERE'S A PROCESS AND A FLOW.

AND WE'RE NOT ALL FRUSTRATED WITH EACH OTHER. SO I WELCOME THAT AND LOOK TOWARDS THAT OKAY.

SO IF THERE'S NO OTHER QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS I'LL, REQUEST A MOTION AND A SECOND. THIS IS OR AGAIN, I GUESS WE COULD CALL THIS REVISED, RIGHT. BECAUSE IT WAS PREVIOUSLY PRESENTED. IT'S ALSO SOME PROPOSED CHANGES. SO REQUEST, A MOTION AND A SECOND TO APPROVE THE REVISED CURRICULUM, INCLUDING THE CURRENT AND PROPOSED CHANGES AS PRESENTED. I SO MOVE I SECOND IT. THANK YOU, ROLL CALL, PLEAS. CALVIN I HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO SEE IT, SO I'M GOING TO HAVE TO.

ABSTAIN I DON'T SEE MISS BRUCE, MISS COKER, I ABSTAIN ALSO, DOCTOR MILLER. YES, MISS BOUZOUKI. YES, MISS PERRY. YES, MR. SEWELL? YES, MISS STRAUSS. YES, PRESIDENT. BOYNTON YES, YE.

FIVE YESES AND TWO ABSTAINED. OKAY. MOTION PASSES. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. HAVE A GOOD

[F. Superintendent's Report ]

NIGHT. GOOD MORNING. GOOD MORNING. HAVE A GOOD MORNING. OKAY, MOVING ON TO THE FINAL ITEM. SUPERINTENDENT'S REPORT. I HAVE A COMMENT. YOU GOT 15 MINUTES. I'LL GET IT IN. IN A COUPLE OF MINUTES. I DID HAVE SOME PREPARED REMARKS TONIGHT. I KNOW I ALREADY SHARED A BIT, BUT I DO NEED A MINUTE. I'M SORRY IT'S SO LATE. WHEN I ARRIVED IN 2018, DURING MY ENTRY PLAN, TONIGHT'S FIRST SPEAKER, CHRISTOPHER PROVIDENCE, ASSEMBLED A GROUP OF BLACK PARENTS, STUDENTS, EDUCATORS, AND COMMUNITY LEADERS TO PROVIDE ME INFORMATION ABOUT THE EXPERIENCE OF BLACK STUDENTS AND FAMILIES IN HARFORD COUNTY. OF THE MANY TAKEAWAYS FROM THAT CONVERSATION, THE ONE THAT RESONATED MOST WAS THE FACT THAT STUDENTS DID NOT SEE ENOUGH OF THEIR CULTURES EXPERIENCE IN OUR CLASSES, AND I COMMITTED TO WORKING TO ADDRESS THIS AS SUPERINTENDENT OF HARFORD COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS, AND THIS HAS TAKEN MANY FORMS, ONE OF WHICH WE EXPERIENCED TONIGHT THROUGH THE WORK ON AFRICAN AP AFRICAN AMERICAN STUDIES AND BOARD. I APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT OF THAT. SO JUST RECENTLY HTTPS WAS CHOSEN TO PRESENT AT THE NATIONAL CONFERENCE IN DC. IT WAS A CONFERENCE ON INNOVATION, THIS PAST JUNE, WE WERE SHOWCASING OUR SUCCESS IN CHANGING THE TRAJECTORY OF SECONDARY STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT.

OUR PRESENTATION FOCUSED ON ANALYZING OUR NORTH STAR GRADUATE OUTCOMES FROM THE BASELINE YEAR OF 2018 TO THIS PAST SCHOOL YEAR. IN 2024, AS A REMINDER, WE MEASURED OUR STUDENTS ABILITY TO DEMONSTRATE SUCCESS IN BOTH HIGH SCHOOL PATHWAYS THROUGH POTENTIAL COLLEGE CREDIT FROM AP OR IB COURSEWORK, DUAL ENROLLMENT CREDIT OR TECHNICAL SKILLS THROUGH CAREER CREDENTIALS. SO I'M ENCOURAGED THAT OVERALL, WE'VE INCREASED THE NUMBER OF STUDENTS DEMONSTRATING SKILLS FOR SUCCESS AFTER HIGH SCHOOL. SO BY THE END OF 12TH GRADE, WE HAD A 7% INCREASE IN STUDENTS MEETING OUR NORTH STAR GRADUATE OUTCOMES WITH THE MOST SIGNIFICANT GAINS IN TECHNICAL SKILLS ASSESSMENT AND DUAL ENROLLMENT, AND WHILE WE SAW 7% INCREASE IN THE ALL CATEGORY, WHAT'S MOST WHAT WAS MOST INSPIRING TO ME IS WHAT WE SAW AMONG OUR SPECIAL OUR POPULATIONS THAT HAVE PREVIOUSLY SHOWN GAPS IN THESE ACHIEVEMENT MEASURES. SO FOR INSTANCE, HISPANIC STUDENTS, IN THE SAME TIME THAT THE ELL CATEGORY WENT UP BY 7, HISPANIC STUDENTS IMPROVED BY 17. AN INCREASE IN MEETING ANY NORTH STAR OUTCOME.

STUDENTS RECEIVING SPECIAL EDUCATION SHOWED A 17% INCREASE IN COMPLETING TACTICAL SKILLS ASSESSMENT, AND STUDENTS QUALIFYING FOR FREE AND REDUCED MEALS SHOW SAW AN 18% RISE IN THE SAME CATEGORY. TECHNICAL SKILLS ASSESSMENT. SO WHAT WE'RE SEEING THERE IS, YOU KNOW, I, I SOMETIMES HESITANT TO HESITATE TO USE THE WORD EQUITY BECAUSE IT'S TAKEN ON A CERTAIN CONNOTATION. BUT EQUITY IS STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT. AND THIS IS ONE OF THE WAYS WE'VE BEEN DELIVERING ON THAT. AND SO, YOU KNOW, IF THE EXPECTATION THIS YEAR IS TO FOCUS ON STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT, WE NEED TO KEEP LOOKING AT THESE DATA BECAUSE WE'RE GOING TO SEE THAT THEY'RE GOING THE RIGHT DIRECTION, GOING TO KEEP GOING THE RIGHT DIRECTION. SO ONE LAST PIECE.

OUR EFFORTS TO ESTABLISH A RIGOROUS AND VIABLE PATHWAY TO CAREER PREPARATION AND ENTRY TO CAREERS ARE PROVING SUCCESSFUL. THIS YEAR, WE ENDED WITH 210 STUDENT APPRENTICESHIPS APPRENTICES. YOU ALL KNOW THIS, LEADING THE STATE IN THAT OUTCOME AND GROWING

[06:55:06]

EXPONENTIALLY AS WE LOOK FORWARD TO THE NEW SCHOOL YEAR, WE REMAIN COMMITTED TO THIS APPROACH AND BROADENING OPPORTUNITIES FOR ALL OUR PROGRESS THUS FAR ENERGIZES OUR STAFF AND SCHOOLS TO CONTINUE OUR CAREER DRIVEN WORK, AND FOR CONTINUED IMPROVEMENT IN STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT BASED ON DEMONSTRATION OF FUTURE READY SKILLS. AND I JUST SORT OF EDITORIALIZE AT THE END OF THIS DISTRICT, I BELIEVE IS LEADING THE TRANSITION TO CAREER READY, WHICH MANY PLACES HAVE TALKED ABOUT FOR YEARS, AND IT WAS A BIG PART OF THE FEEDBACK I RECEIVED WHEN I ARRIVED HERE IN 2018. WE'RE GETTING THAT DONE AND WE'RE GETTING IT DONE IN A VERY EFFECTIVE WAY, AND I THINK WE HAVE MUCH MORE TO COME IN THIS NEXT YEAR ABOUT THAT. SO I KIND OF STAY TUNED TO THIS CHANNEL, BUT I THINK WE WILL, YOU KNOW, CONTINUE TO SEE GREAT GAINS THERE. SO VERY QUICKLY, AUGUST 15TH END OF SUMMER FESTIVAL RIPKEN STADIUM. GET YOUR TICKETS AS WE CHEER ON THE IRONBIRDS. WE HAVE OUR MUSIC CAMPERS AT HARFORD GLEN. WE KNOW WE'RE HAVING A GREAT TIME. WE ACTUALLY HAD A STUDENT THERE WHO PRODUCED A VIDEO. IT'S ON OUR FACEBOOK PAGE AND PLEASE DON'T FORGET HTTPS FOOD NUTRITION OFFICE PROVIDES FREE MEALS TO CHILDREN IN OUR COMMUNITY. DURING THE SUMMER. DETAILS ARE ON THE WEBSITE AND SOCIAL MEDIA PAGES. AND LEST WE TAKE THAT FOR GRANTED, I JUST LEARNED I WAS AT A FEDERAL ADVOCACY CONFERENCE, LAST WEEK, 15 STATES DIDN'T PICK UP THIS INITIATIVE TO PROVIDE FREE SUMMER MEALS. I DON'T KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON IN THOSE STATES, BUT I APPRECIATE THE WORK OUR TEAM DOES TO TAKE CARE OF OUR STUDENTS. AND SO I DON'T WANT TO TAKE FOR GRANTED THOSE AMAZING THINGS THAT THE TEAM PUTS IN. SO THANK YOU FOR A MARATHON NIGHT. THANK YOU FOR BEARING WITH ME FOR A SOMEWHAT EXTENDED

[Future Meetings Review ]

SUPERINTENDENT'S REPORT. I WILL SEE YOU ALL SOON SO EVERYBODY CAN TAKE OFF TOMORROW MORNING. I SAID SO, NEXT HOUR DELAY IN CENTRAL OFFICE, TWO HOUR

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.